- 1 - !" # $%# $% ## &'( ) ! " # $%& ' ( ) Digitally signed by SACHIN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - * # * + $% * # ! " *,,--. + $% " $%& * # * + $% ' (* " / " / &&/ "") " " -() " . " # &. # () - 3 - %&- " . %& &&&, " &&&, " " "#+ " # 0# 0#" % ( 0#") 123 455647 23 89 :16 ;742<4=:34556774=:3 ;4772=> 2= ?@63:2A= :16 B@C><6=: 4=C 4D4EC C4:6C &. 2= A%&- 54336C89:16A@E:AF E2=;254723:E2;: 4=C 6332A=3 #@C>6 4=C 42;1@E (GE28@=47H FAE 31AE:) :16 7248272:9 23 F43:6=6C A=:16 2=3@E6C 3A 473A FAE 6=14=;6<6=: 16 C4:6 AF 4;;2C6=: 2=IA7I6<6=: AF I612;76 4=C C64:1 AF @>@E4994 D4<9 4E6 =A: 2= C235@:6 16 A=79 C235@:6 23 D2:1 E6>4EC :A 7248272:9 F43:6=6C A= :16 - 4 - 2=3@E6C E4:16E :16 2=3@E6E 4=C :16 ?@4=:@< AF ;A<56=34:2A= 64EC <: 4:27 14=:4842 @8431 764E=6C ;A@=367 45564E2=> FAE :16 ;742<4=:34556774=:3 4=C E2 E@=J@<4E <4E>@=C4554 764E=6C ;A@=367 45564E2=> FAE E635A=C6=: A 43 D677 43 E2 4=I6=CE4 6CC9 764E=6C ;A@=367 45564E2=> FAE E635A=C6=: A$=3@E4=;6 A<54=9AF4E43E635A=C6=:A23;A=;6E=6C=A:2;623 167C3@FF2;26=: 1A@>1:1645564723F276CA=:DA>EA@=C326 A= 7248272:9 43 D677 43 6=14=;6<6=: AF ;A<56=34:2A= 64E=6C ;A@=367 45564E2=> FAE :16 ;742<4=:34556774=:3 23 E63:E2;:6CA=792=E6356;:AF7248272:9A=:16>EA@=C:14::16 E28@=47 143 =A: FE4<6C 455EA5E24:6 233@6 2= E6356;: AF 7248272:9 43 :A D1A 23 724876 :A 549 :16 ;A<56=34:2A= 1AD6I6E 6KA=6E4:6C:16=3@E4=;6A<54=9 % <: 4:27 14=:4842 @81431 764E=6C ;A@=367 FAE :16 ;742<4=:34556774=:3 3@8<2:3 :14: :16 F272=> AF - 5 - ;14E>6,3166: 4>42=3: :16 CE2I6E AF :16 I612;76 @=C6E 6;:2A=-. &,4=CAF 4=C6;:2A=E64CD2:1 6;:2A=3&4=CAF ;:4>42=3::16AD=6EAF:16 I612;76 D277 =A: 89 2:367F >2I63 4 >EA@=C :A E236 4 5E63@<5:2A=:14::16AD=6E;A=3;2A@37914I2=>J=AD76C>6 :14::16CE2I6E23=A:14I2=>4=9I472C4=C6FF6;:2I6CE2I2=> 72;6=36 C6352:66=:E@3:6C:16I612;76:A3@;156E3A==:16 4836=;6AF4=93@;15EAAF F43:6=2=>7248272:9A=:162=3@E6C 23@=;4776CFAE 16 143 F@E:16E 3@8<2::6C :14: :16 =3@E4=;6 A<54=9:1A@>16K4<2=6C2:3AFF2;6E4=C5EAC@;6C;6E:42= CA;@<6=:3 AD6I6E :16E6 23 =A 6I2C6=;6 ;A=:E4 5EAC@;6C 89 :16 =3@E4=;6 A<54=9 :A 31AD :14: :16 AD=6E AF :16 I612;76 ;A=3;2A@379 14I2=> J=AD76C>6 6=:E@3:6C:16I612;76:A456E3A=D1A23=A:14I2=>I472C 4=C 6FF6;:2I6 CE2I2=> 72;6=36 = :1636 ;2E;@<3:4=;63 :16 F2=C2=>AF:16E28@=47F43:6=2=>7248272:9A=:16=3@E6C23 6EEA=6A@3 4=C E6?@2E63 :A 86 36: 432C6 4=C :16 <4::6E E6?@2E63E6<4=C86FAE6:16E28@=47:AFE4<6455EA5E24:6 - 6 - 233@6 4=C 5@: :16 ;436 A= E247 :A 67@;2C4:6 D16:16E :16 AD=6E;A=3;2A@37914I2=>J=AD76C>66=:E@3:6C:16I612;76 :A456E3A=14I2=>=ACE2I2=>72;6=36;;AEC2=>79 3A@>1: :A 477AD :16 455647 36: 432C6 :16 AEC6E 4=C E6<4=C :16 <4::6E :A :16 :E28@=47 FAE FE631 :E247 A= :16 5A2=: AF 7248272:9 - E2 E@=J@<4E <4E>@=C4554 764E=6C ;A@=367 45564E2=> FAE E635A=C6=: A,CE2I6E A= 2=3:E@;:2A= 3@8<2:3 :14: :16 ;E2<2=47 ;436 D12;1 D43 ;A=:63:6C 89 :16 4;;@36C 6=C6C 2= 4;?@2::47 A= 477 :16 ;14E>63D12;1;764E7931AD3:14::16;14E>63@8<2::6C89 :165A72;62=;14E>6,3166:4=C:16;14E>6376I6776C89:16 E247A@E: =A:5EAI6C=:1636;2E;@<3:4=;63:16F2=C2=> AF:16E28@=474=C7248272:9236EEA=6A@34=CE6?@2E63:A86 36:432C616E643E24=I6=CE46CC9 764E=6C;A@=367 45564E2=> FAE =3@E4=;6 A<54=9 I616<6=:79 3@8<2:3 :14::1A@>14356;2F2;233@6143=A:866=FE4<6C 8@::16 E28@=47 :4J2=> 2=:A ;A=32C6E4:2A= AF :16 F4;: :14: :16 5A72;6 2= :16 ;14E>6 3166: 14I6 473A F276C ;14E>63 @=C6E - 7 - 6;:2A= E64C D2:1 6;:2A=3 & 4=C AF ;: 4>42=3::16CE2I6EAF:16<A:AEI612;7643D677434>42=3: :16AD=6EAF:16<A:AEI612;76123;764E7931AD3:14::16 AD=6E 14I2=> J=AD76C>6 6=:E@3:6C :16 I612;76 4;;AEC2=>79 :16 E28@=47 5EA;66C6C :A 5433 :16 AEC6E F43:6=2=> :16 7248272:9 A= :16 2=3@E6C D12;1 CA63 =A: ;477 FAE4=92=:6EF6E6=;64::1614=C3AF:123A@E: 4I2=>164EC:16764E=6C;A@=36745564E2=>FAE :1654E:263 56E@36C:166=:2E64556475456E34=CE28@=47 E6;AEC :16 A=79 5A2=: :14: DA@7C 4E236 FAE A@E ;A=32C6E4:2A=23 . @E 4=3D6E FAE :16 48AI6 5A2=: FAE ;A=32C6E4:2A=232==6>4:2I6FAE:16FA77AD2=> - 8 - & C<2::6C79 :16 E28@=47 143 FE4<6C :1E66 233@63 2=;7@C2=> :16 233@6 2= E6356;: AF 4;:2A=4876 =6>72>6=;6 A= :16 54E: AF :16 CE2I6E AF :16 I612;76 4=C E6>4EC2=>:16;A<56=34:2A=AD6I6E 2=:16342C233@62: 233:4:6C:14:2F3A 4:D14:E4:64=CFEA<D1A<AD6I6E =A356;2F2;233@623FE4<6CA=7248272:9A=:1654E:9 43:A D1A 23 E635A=32876 :A 549 :16 ;A<56=34:2A= 16 233@63 4E6 :A 86 FE4<6C 6=4872=> :16 54E:263 :A <4J6 A@: :162E ;4363E6356;:2I67986FAE6:16A@E:A=:16C235@:6AEA= D12;1:1694E6C235@:2=> 1234356;:AF:16<4::6E23I6E9;764E@=C6E:16 5EAI232A=3 AF EC6E @76 % AF = 4836=;6 AF 356;2F2; 233@66I6=43143866=A836EI6C89:16E28@=47 2= :16 8AC9 AF :16 B@C><6=: :14: =A 356;2F2; 233@6 23 FE4<6C 2: ;764E79 31AD3 :14: :16 54E:263 4E6 =A: >2I6= 4<576A55AE:@=2:9:A<66::16;4364=CC67286E4:6A=:16 342C 233@6 89 4CC@;2=> 455EA5E24:6 6I2C6=;6 86FAE6 :16 E28@=47 - 9 - = :1636 ;2E;@<3:4=;63 :16 F2=C2=> AF :16 E28@=47E6?@2E63E6;A=32C6E4:2A=;;AEC2=>79 D64=3D6E :165A2=:FAE;A=32C6E4:2A=2=:16=6>4:2I6FAE:16FAE>A2=> E643A=3 D65433:16FA77AD2=> 2) 1645564723 22) 16F2=C2=>AF:16E28@=47F43:6=2=>:167248272:9 A=:162=3@E6C2316E68936:432C6 222) 16<4::6E23E6<2::6C84;J:A:16E28@=47FAE FE4<2=>455EA5E24:6233@6A=:167248272:94=C:A 5EAI2C6 455EA5E24:6 A55AE:@=2:9 :A 8A:1 :16 32C63:A749:162E;43643D67743C6F6=;6 2I) 77;A=:6=:2A=34E6J65:A56=A=792=E6356;:AF 7248272:9 I) 2=;6 :16 <4::6E 23 AF :16 964E &- :16 E28@=47 23 C2E6;:6C :A ;A=;7@C6 2:3 :E247 D2:12= 32K <A=:13 FEA< :16 C4:6 D12;1 23 =AD 866= F2K6C89:123A@E:26 A=&.&% - 10 - I2) 16 54E:263 4E6 C2E6;:6C :A 45564E 86FAE6 :16 ;A=;6E=6C E28@=47 A= &.&% D2:1A@: 4D42:2=> FAE 4=9 F@E:16E =A:2;6 FEA< :16 E28@=474=C;A,A56E4:6D2:1:16;436 I22) AAEC6E43;A3: I222) 6>23:E9 23 C2E6;:6C :A 36=C :16 E6;AEC3 FAE:1D2:1:A6=4876:16E28@=47:A:4J6,@5:16 <4::6EA=&.&% *+ &#( % *+ &( % 23:A7A