Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 66301 (KAR)
YALLAPPA v. THE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER
WP/202888/2025 · 2025-11-12
M G S Kamal
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 66301 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 66301 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!" #$%
&%'!%!%
(!!)
!! "
#$ %
& '
$' ' &&
! ''( ((
(( )
!! "
#)'
( &%
' ( !!* !! ( '
(
' ( ' '
$ $
Digitally signed by SACHIN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
! !!!! ! &!!! ' ! #+'% '
'
' ()
'
(
'
' '
' ,)
#' ,)
%
-././01-2/34-502-.6/3072.4-/189882/-:-;4<.6- -1;023-=-1.;9.-;!&!!/337-;4<2-3>01;-1.0! ;-?@/1/18 .0 ?013/;-2 .6- 9>>@/?9./01 05 .6- >-././01-2 502 9>>0/1.=-1. 01 ?0=>933/019.- 82071; 01 .6- >2-=/3- .69..6->-././01-2A9398-;4-<01;.6-@/=/.3>2-3?2/4-;
71;-2 .6- 27@-3 93 01 .6- ;9.- A6-1 6- =9;- 91 9>>@/?9./01 ! 6- ?93- 05 .6- >-././01-2 /3 .69. 6/3 =0.6-2 =.9=9::9A 092->>9A93A02B/18939A-->-2/1 9;/ 71/?/>9@/.< 9@947298/ /3.2/?. 91; 36- >933-;
9A9< ;72/18 .6- 3-2:/?- 01 !!& 69. .6- >-././01-2 =9;- 91 9>>@/?9./01 3--B/18 9>>0/1.=-1. 01
- 3 -
?0=>933/019.-82071;01!&!!!93>-211-C72-
69. 101?013/;-29./01 05 .6- 39/; 9>>@/?9./01 69; ?013.29/1-;.6->-././01-2.09>>209?6.6/3072.01-92@/-2 0??93/01 /1 0! & !! A6/?6 A93 ;/3>03-; 05 01 & !! ;/2-?./18 2-3>01;-1. 0! .0 ?013/;-2 .6- 39=- 6-2-95.-2 .6- 2-3>01;-1. 0! /13.-9; 05 ?013/;-2/18 .6- 9>>@/?9./01 693 /337-; .6- -1;023-=-1. ;9.-; !&!! 2-D-?./18 .6- 2-E7-3. 05 .6- >-././01-2 01.6->2-=/3-056-69:/18-C?--;-;.6-98-@/=/. -921-;?0713-@502.6->-././01-2374=/.3.69. .6-=0.6-205.6->-././01-2>933-;9A9<01!!& 6- ;9.- 05 4/2.6 05 .6- >-././01-2 93 >-2 .6- 3?600@ 2-?02;3/3& &F &69.9301.6-;9.-05.6-;-9.605 .6- =0.6-2 >-././01-2 A93 D73. F <-923 =01.63 6-2-502-6-374=/.3.69..6-2-D-?./0105.6-9>>@/?9./01 502 ?0=>933/019.- 82071; 4< 2-3>01;-1. 0! /3 71373.9/194@-'-1?-.6->-././01
-921-; ;;/./019@
0:-21=-1. ;:0?9.- 01 .6-0.6-2691;;29A/18.6-9..-1./0105.6/3072..0.6-
- 4 -
/2?7@92 ;9.-; !& >20;7?-; 4< .6- >-././01-2 11-C72-)9.@0374=/.3.69..6-=/1/=7=91;.6- =9C/=7= 98- 05 .6- 9>>@/?91. /3 .0 4- .9B-1 /1.0 ?013/;-29./01 93 01 .6- ;9.- 01 A6/?6 .6- 9>>@/?9./01 /3 5/@-; '- 374=/.3 .69. ;9.- 05 4/2.6 05 >-././01-2 /3 & &F & 91; .6- 9>>@/?9./01 3--B/18 ?0=>933/019.- 82071;A935/@-;01!&!!!69.93>-2?01;/./019. @005.6-/2?7@929.@09301.6-;9.-A6-1.6- 9>>@/?9./01A93=9;->-././01-269;?2033-;.6-98-@/=/. 05<-9236-2-502-.6-9>>@/?9./016934--12-D-?.-; '-1?-3--B35022-D-?./0105.6->-././01
'-92;-273-;.6-2-?02;3 * 6-2-/310;/3>7.-05.6-59?..69..6-=0.6-2 05 .6- >-././01-2 >933-; 9A9< 01 !!& -././01-2 693 5/@-; 91 9>>@/?9./01 3--B/18 ?0=>933/019.- 9>>0/1.=-1. 01 !&!!! 93 >-2 11-C72- 6- 3?600@ .29135-2 ?-2./5/?9.- >20;7?-; 4< .6- >-././01-2 9. >98-0!05.6->-././01/1;/?9.-36/3;9.-054/2.6.04- & &F &
- 5 -
@973- 05 .6- ?/2?7@92 ;9.-; !& >20;7?-;9.11-C72-)2-9;39371;-2
! "#$ %& '$( ) * +,! - !. /
0/%
'$( ) %& '$( )
1 %+
23%+
4 -!5 6%%+
%+
2 %+
2 07)00%,0/% %+
%+
%(8&% 9%' (: &% $8, %
%;0<= %& '$( ) %& = (> . - !. = (> . '$
?"= @A=B@AC 9%' %(8! 0/ D 0!/ ,E F ! GH
@-92@<9301.6-;9.-A6-1.6-9>>@/?9./01A93 5/@-;>-././01-269;?2033-;.6-98-@/=/.05<-923 F 1.6-943-1?-0591<>20:/3/015022-@9C9./0105 98- @/=/.
10 -2202 ?91 4- 5071; ??02;/18@< >-././01 /3
!*+ (%!%) ' 31 /3.0&@0 .>B