- 1 - ! "#$## #%% &' &(%)* &)) + ! " # $ % " # $ & '(#)$& & & !))) ) !!) )!& (#$ !#$ #$ & ) %& Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - & & % * $# # * $ +, -..,//-01 2,304 1+, 56/, -7785,9 30 6!))) ) 60 1+, :3/, 6: 1+, /,-;0,9 9931360-/ 351;371-09,553605894,-/-28;-43<:6;5+6;11+,;3-/ 68;1=> 35 3?.840304 1+, @894?,01 6: 760A371360 9-1,9 !!) )! -09 6;9,; 6: 5,01,07, 9-1,9 !!!!) )! 760A371304 1+, -7785,9 :6; 1+, 6::,07,5 .8035+-2/, 809,; ,71360 ( -;1 6: 1+, 093-0 ,0-/ 69, !B <:6; 5+6;1 C1+, => -09 809,; ,71360 ! #!$ #-$ 6: 1+, 093-0/,71;3731D71) <:6;5+6;1C1+,/,71;3731D71=> -095,01,07304+3?16809,;46;346;6853?.;3560?,01:6; :3A,D,-;5-0916.-D:30,-?68016:5) :6;1+, 6::,07,.8035+-2/, 809,; ,71360 ( -;1 6:E -09 16809,;4653?./,3?.;3560?,01:6;60,D,-;-0916.-D :30, 6: 5) :6; 1+, 6::,07, .8035+-2/, 809,; - 3 - ,71360 ! #!$ #-$ 6: 1+, /,71;3731D 71 F31+ 9,:-8/1 5,01,07,5 ) +, :-715 6: 1+, 7-5, 30 2;3,: -;, 1+-1 1+, 9-84+1,;6:1+,9,7,-5,9/694,9:3;5130:6;?-1360-//,4304 76??355360 6: 1+, 6::,07, .8035+-2/, 809,; ,71360 ( -;16:-09,71360!#!$#-$6:1+,/,71;3731D71 -4-3051 1+, -..,//-01 -09 1+, 6::373-/ :1,; 30A,5134-1360 7+-;4, 5+,,1 7-?, 16 2, :3/,9 :6; 1+, 5-39 6::,07,5 +, ;3-/ 68;1 -:1,; 1-G304 3016 760539,;-1360 1+,?-1,;3-/5 60 ;,76;9 166G 76403H-07, 58??60,91+, -7785,9 +, -7785,9 -..,-;,9 2,:6;, 1+, ;3-/ 68;1 ./,-9,9 061 483/1D -09 7/-3?,9 16 2, 1;3,9 +, .;65,781360,I-?30,9%5!16!461?-;G,9I5!16 !( -09 39,013:3,9 5! 16 ! 30 58..6;1 6: 315 7601,01360+,-7785,9+-59,03,9-//1+,307;3?30-1304 ?-1,;3-/5 -A-3/-2/, 60 ;,76;9 30 +35 51-1,?,01 809,; ,71360 ! 6: ; 281 +-5 061 7+65,0 16 /,-9 -0D ,A39,07,3058..6;16:+359,:,07,+,;3-/68;1-:1,; 1-G304 3016 760539,;-1360 -// 1+,5, ?-1,;3-/5 60 ;,76;9 - 4 - 7-?, 16 1+, 7607/85360 1+-1 1+,.;65,781360 35 5877,55:8/ 30 .;6A304 1+, 483/1 6: 1+, -7785,9 :6; 1+, 6::,07,5 .8035+-2/, 809,; ,71360 ( -;1 6: -09 ,71360 !#!$#-$6:1+,/,71;3731D71776;9304/D.-55,91+, 3?.840,9 @894?,01 6: 760A371360 -09 6;9,; 6: 5,01,07, ,304 -44;3,A,9 2D 1+, 5-?, 1+, -7785,9 35 2,:6;, 1+35 68;1 ,-;9 ;3 -09G35+6;, 662 /,-;0,9 76805,/ :6; 1+, -..,//-01 -09 ;3 6.-/G;35+0- -9-A /,-;0,9 34+68;16A,;0?,01/,-9,;:6;1+,;,5.609,011-1, ,;85,91+,?-1,;3-/560;,76;9307/893041+,;3-/68;1 ;,76;95 ( 0 A3,F 6: 1+, ;3A-/ 7601,013605 8;4,9 2D /,-;0,976805,/:6;261+1+,.-;13,51+,.63011+-1F68/9 -;35,:6;?D760539,;-136035 - 5 - D -05F,; 16 1+, -26A, .6301 35 C =:6;1+,:6//6F304 1351+,7601,013606:1+,.;65,7813601+-11+, -7785,9 2,304 1+, 6F0,; 6: 1+, /-09 30 J8,51360 +-5 9;-F0 3//,4-/ ,/,71;3731D 7600,71360 2D 85304 1+, 2309304 F3;, ! :;6? 1+, ,/,71;37 .6/, 16 .;61,71 +35 7;6. ,7,-5,97-?,307601-71F31+1+,5-39F3;,/D304601+, 4;6809 -09 98, 16 ,/,71;6781360 5+, 93,9 +,;,2D 1+, -7785,9 +-5 76??311,9 1+, 6::,07,5 -5 51-1,9 -26A, 6 .;6A, 1+35 7601,01360 1+, .;65,781360 ,I-?30,9 %5! -09)%!351+,9-84+1,;6:1+,9,7,-5,9-095+,35 1+,30:6;?-01%)351+,+852-096:%!61+1+,5, F310,55,5 +-A, 58..6;1,9 1+, 7-5, 6: 1+, .;65,781360 16 51-1,1+-11+,9,7,-5,9+-9460,161+,/-092,/60430416 1+,-7785,916;,18;01+,5.;-D304?-7+30,-095+,7-?, 307601-71F31+1+,F3;,9;-F0:6;1-G3043//,4-/,/,71;3731D 7600,713602D1+,-7785,9-5-;,58/16:F+37+5+,93,9 1355844,51,916%!1+-11+,,/,71;37F3;,F-5781-09 - 6 - F-5+-04304+,9,7,-5,97-?,307601-71F31+587+/3A, F3;, -5 - ;,58/1 6: F+37+ 5+, 93,9 +, F310,55 7-1,46;37-//D 9,03,9 1+35 5844,51360 01,;,51304/D 1+,;, 35 06 587+ 5844,51360 ?-9, 16 %) 6; ,A,0 16 1+, 0A,5134-1304::37,;K%! B %! 5.,-G5 -2681 1+, 9;-F304 6: 5.61 ?-+-H-;-5.,;IB-095,3H304 ! 1+,2309304 F3;, F+37+ F-5 85,9 2D 1+, -7785,9 :6; 9;-F304 1+, ,/,71;3731D 7600,71360 3//,4-//D % 2,304 1+, /,71;37-/ 05.,716;,I-?30,91+,F3;,-099,.65,92,:6;,1+,68;1 1+-1 1+,,/,71;3731D768/9 .-55 1+;684+ 1+, F3;, 61+304 +-52,,0,/3731,9:;6?,31+,;%5!)6;2D1+,/,-;0,9 76805,/:6;1+,-7785,9 ' %B351+,6716;F+67609871,9.651?6;1,? ,I-?30-1360 6: 1+, 9,-9 269D -09 3558,9 .651?6;1,? ,I-?30-1360;,.6;1-5.,;IL+,7-85,6:9,-1+-5 .,;1+35;,.6;13598,16,/,71;678136001,;,51304/D1+,;, F-5067;655,I-?30-1360,31+,;16%B6;%'+,;, - 7 - 35065844,51360F31+;,4-;9161+,:-711+-11+,9,7,-5,9 +-993,998,16,/,71;6781360301+,/-092,/604304161+, -7785,9+,-7785,9+-50611-G,0-0D5.,73:379,:,07, 16 .;62-2/3H, 1+, 5-?, 60539,;304 1+, 6;-/ -09 9678?,01-;D ,A39,07, -09 -/56 1+, ?-1,;3-/ 62@,715 .;6987,9 2,:6;, 1+, 68;1 -? 6: 1+, 6.30360 1+-1 1+, .;65,781360 35 5877,55:8/ 30 .;6A304 1+, 483/1 6: 1+, -7785,9 :6; 1+, 6::,07,5 .8035+-2/, 809,; ,71360 ( -;16:-09,71360!#!$#-$6:1+,/,71;3731D71 2,D609;,-560-2/,96821+,;,:6;,1+,-7785,935/3-2/, :6;760A371360 11+3551-4,/,-;0,976805,/:6;1+,-..,//-01 7601,09,91+-11+,-..,//-01-7785,9F-530785169D:6;- .,;3696:53I?601+5-091+,;,:6;,+,?-D2,5,01,07,9 :6;1+,.,;369F+37++,+-5-/;,-9D809,;460,98;3041;3-/ -09.;-D5:6;5+6F304/,03,07D30:-A68;6:1+,-..,//-01 ,-;0,9 34+ 68;1 6A,;0?,01 /,-9,; 6..65,5 587+ 582?355360 6F,A,; +, 7601,095 1+-1 31 35 /,:1 16 1+, 9357;,13606:1+,68;1 - 8 - L +, ;3-/ 68;1 +-5 5,01,07,9 1+, -7785,9 16 809,;46 ;346;685 3?.;3560?,01 :6; - .,;369 6: :3A, D,-;5 -0916.-D:30,6:5) :6;1+,6::,07,.8035+-2/, 809,;,71360 (-;16:F+3/,760A371304+3?16 809,;4653?./,3?.;3560?,01:6;-.,;3696:60,D,-;-09 16.-D:30,6:5) :6;1+,6::,07,.8035+-2/,809,; ,71360 ! #!$ #-$ 6: 1+, /,71;3731D 71 F31+ 9,:-8/1 5,01,07,560539,;3041+,:-715-0973;78?51-07,56:1+, 7-5,F+,;,1+,9,7,-5,9+-9460,161+,/-092,/604304 16 1+, -7785,9 98;304 034+1 +68;5 7-?, 30 7601-71 F31+ 1+,/3A,F3;,-0993,9-11+,5.61-?6:1+,6.303601+-1 /,03,07D ?-D 2, 5+6F0 30 :-A68; 6: 1+, -7785,9 F+3/, 5,01,07304+3? ,07,-05F,;1+,-26A,.6301C.-;1/D 301+,-::3;?-13A,=-09.;67,,916.-551+,:6//6F304 #3$ +,-..,-/35 #33$ +, @894?,01 6: 760A371360 9-1,9 !!) )! .-55,9 2D 1+, 9931360-/ 351;371 -09 ,553605 894, -/-28;-43 30 - 9 - 6!))) ) 760A371304 1+, -7785,9 :6; 1+, 6::,07,5 .8035+-2/, 809,; ,71360 ( -;16:-09,71360!#!$#-$6:1+, /,71;3731D7135+,;,2D #333$ +, 6;9,; 6: 5,01,07, 9-1,9 !!!!) )! .-55,9 2D 1+, ;3-/ 68;1 35 ?693:3,9 -5 809,; #-$ +, -7785,9 35 5,01,07,9 16 809,;46 53?./, 3?.;3560?,01 :6; - .,;369 6: -09 16 .-D :30, 6: 5) <8.,,5 F6 -G+ 60/D> :6; 1+, 6::,07, .8035+-2/, 809,; 30 9,:-8/116.-D:30,16809,;4653?./, 3?.;3560?,01 :6; - .,;369 6: 1+;,, ?601+5 #2$ +, -7785,9 35 5,01,07,9 16 809,;46 53?./, 3?.;3560?,01 :6; - .,;369 6: 1F6 ?601+5 -09 16 .-D :30, 6: - 10 - 5) <8.,,5 F,01D &3A, +685-09 60/D> :6; 1+, 6::,07, .8035+-2/,809,; ! ! ! "#309,:-8/116.-D :30, 16 809,;46 53?./, 3?.;3560?,01 :6;!9-D5 #3A$ +, 58251-013A, 5,01,07,5 5+-// ;80 76078;;,01/D #A$ +, -7785,9 35 ,0131/,9 :6; 5,1 6:: -5 .,; ,71360()6:; #A3$ +,6;9,;;,4-;930476?.,05-1360.-55,92D 1+,;3-/68;135+,;,2D760:3;?,9 ,4351;D 35 93;,71,9 16 5,09 2-7G 1+, ;3-/ 68;1 ;,76;95 -/604 F31+ 76.D 6: 1+35 @894?,01 :6; 30:6;?-1360 -090,,9:8/-71360 ,* &##) $ % 351 6!/ 6