- 1 - !!" !# $ "%"&""! ""&& '() ""&& '() !" " ## !$ % & # ' ! $ # ( )) Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ( !*!$) ) ( # +)*,+ ( !*!$) % & # $- )' ( $,+&$' # $+$))$ # !)$()$* " # . # ( )) / ( . % &# ' ! $ ( - 3 - # +)*,+ ( . !*!)$$ ) !*!$) % & $- # )' ($,+&$' 0' # # $+$))$ # !)$()$* # . # 1 1 " # %! $ 23 45670483 89:;04< 205 ;73=3773> 9)$*)())) 0?0@45A A23 #6>?:34A 04> 0B07> >0A3> $+$))$;0553>@4 9!)$()$*C<A2334@97 @D@E #6>?3 04> 2@AA0;67 &=97 5297A FA23 A7@C640EG' - 4 - B237305 A23 8E0@:04A 205 ;73=3773> 9)$$**())) 533H@4?3420483:34A9=A2389:;3450A@94 ) 23 8E0@:04A :3A B@A2 0 790> A70==@8 088@>34A 94 ,$)$! 23 8E0@:04A B05 >9@4? :@EH D34>@4? C65@4355 04>23B050?3>$*<30750AA23A@:39=A23088@>34A 63A9 A23@4I67@35565A0@43>@4A23088@>34A23B050>:@AA3>@4A23 295;@A0E 04> A0H34 A730A:34A 23 8E0@:04A =@E3> 8E0@: ;3A@A@94533H@4?89:;3450A@94 9= 5)+( 0E94?B@A2 @4A3735A 0A A23 70A3 9= J ;37 0446: 23 A7@C640E 0=A37 8945@>37@4? A23 34A@73 3D@>3483 94 73897> 0B07>3> A23 89:;3450A@94 9= 5( 0E94? B@A2 @4A3735A 0A A23 70A39=J;370446:=79:A23>0A39=;3A@A@94A@EEA23>0A3 9=730E@K0A@9423735;94>34A9)4567048389:;04<B05 >@738A3> A9 >3;95@A A23 0B07> 0:964A 0E94? B@A2 @4A3735A B@A2@40;37@9>9=A2733:94A253@4?0??7@3D3>C<A2350@> 97>37A234567048389:;04<05B3EE05A238E0@:04A20D3 ;73=3773>A23;73534A0;;30E5 + 30743> 896453E =97 A23 45670483 89:;04< 56C:@A5A20A@45;@A39=537D@839=49A@83A239B437>@>49A - 5 - ;79>683 A23 >7@D@4? E@83483 C6A A23 A7@C640E 377943965E< 52@=A3>C67>3494A23456737(@4567048389:;04<@483A23 >7@D3720549>7@D@4?E@83483A234567048389:;04<@549A E@0CE3 A9 ;0< A23 89:;3450A@94 23483 73L635A3> A9 3M94370A3 A23 45670483 89:;04< =79: ;0<@4? A23 89:;3450A@94 67A237 23 0E59 894A34>3> A20A A23 @489:3 9=A238E0@:04AB05A0H3405 5(;37:94A2B@A296A 04< C05@5 04> A23 >@50C@E@A< 0A )!J A9 A23 B29E3 C9>< M$+@5A23>@50C@E@A<837A@=@80A323 98A97B293M0:@43> 04>0553553>A23>@50C@E@A<@50?34370E;2<5@8@04C6A49A0 67?394 3483 A23 >@50C@E@A< 0553553> C< 2@: 80449A C3 8945@>373> 04> A265 73L635A5 A9 73>683 A23 89:;3450A@94 238E0@:04A205565A0@43>AB95@:;E3@4I67@3505;37M! 4 A23 B964> 837A@=@80A3 @A @5 5;38@=@80EE< 5A0A3> A20A A23 @4I67@35 073 5@:;E3 @4 40A673 3 205 C334 A730A3> @4 A23 295;@A0E=79:,$)$!A9$!$)$!@3=970;37@9>9= 4@43>0<5 945@>37@4?A2340A67394@4I67@3504>A23;37@9> 9= 295;@A0E@K0A@94 A2@5 967A =@4>5 @A 7305940CE3 A9 ?704A 0 56:9= 5!(A9B07>5@4I67@35 5!(=97;0@404> 56==37@4? 04> E955 9= 0:34@A@35 5!( A9B07>5 - 6 - A7045;97A0A@943MA704967@52:34A523B05295;@A0E@K3>=97 4@43>0<523@50E5934A@AE3>=97E9559=@489:3>67@4?E0@>6; ;37@9> =97 943 :94A2 @3 5*( 3483 A23 A9A0E 89:;3450A@9489:35A9 5)+( 4 5;@A3 9= 537D@83 9= 49A@83 A23 9B437 04> A23 >7@D37 9= A23 D32@8E3 20D3 49A 0;;3073> 23 9B437 9= A23 D32@8E320549A;79>683>A23>7@D@4?E@834839=A23>7@D379= A23 9==34>@4? D32@8E3 5 A2373 @5 49 >7@D@4? E@83483 @A 0:964A5 A9 D@9E0A@94 9= A37:5 04> 894>@A@945 9= A23 ;9E@8< 04> A265 A23 45670483 89:;04< @5 0A E@C37A< A9 ;0< 04> 7389D37A2389:;3450A@94=79:A239B4379=A23D32@8E305 ;37 A23 8@A0A@94 73;97A3> @4 73;97A3> @4 ! AA2@55A0A3A238E0@:04A@5@4A34>@4?A9;79>683 A23 >7@D@4? E@83483 C3=973 A2@5 967A 23 088@>34A @5 9= A23 <307)$!238E0@:;3A@A@945=@E3>@4A23<307)$*04>073 >@5;953> 9= @4 A23 <307 ))$ 23 ;73534A 0;;30E5 073 ;73=3773> @4 A23<307 ))) 23 8E0@:04A :@?2A 20D3 A0H34 - 7 - @4A3735AA9;79>683A23>7@D@4?E@834830AA23307E@35A;9@4A9= A@:3 C6A =0@E3> A9 >9 59 23483 0A A2@5 5A0?3 L635A@94 9= 8945@>37@4? A23 >7@D@4? E@83483 97 73:04>@4? A23 :0AA37 A9 A23A7@C640E>93549A07@53 2389:;3450A@940B07>3>C<A23A7@C640E@4 9!)$()$* @4 0 56: 9= 5( @5 73>683> A9 5)+(0E94?B@A2@4A3735A0AA2370A39=J;370446: =79:A23>0A39=;3A@A@94A@EEA23>0A39=730E@K0A@94 , 30743> 896453E =97 A23 45670483 89:;04< 56C:@A5 A20A A23 89:;3450A@94 0:964A 0B07>3> C< A23 A7@C640E205C334>3;95@A3> * 8897>@4?E<A23=9EE9B@4?1 ! &@' 23 0;;30E =@E3> C< A23 45670483 89:;04< @3 9)$*)())) @5 0EE9B3> @4 ;07A- &@@' 23 0;;30E =@E3> C< A23 8E0@:04A @4 9)$$**()))@5>@5:@553>- - 8 - &@@@' 23 89:;3450A@94 0:964A 0B07>3> C< A23A7@C640E@4056:9= 5(@573>683>A9 5)+(0E94?B@A2@4A3735A0AA2370A39=J;37 0446: =79: A23 >0A3 9= ;3A@A@94 A@EE A23 >0A3 9= 730E@K0A@94- &@D' 23 8E0@:04A @5 34A@AE3> A9 5)+( 0E94? B@A2 @4A3735A 0A A23 70A3 9= J @4A3735A =79: A23>0A39=;3A@A@94A@EEA23>0A39=730E@K0A@94- &D' 23 3M8355 0:964A >3;95@A3> C< A23 45670483 89:;04< 520EE C3 73=64>3> A9 A23 4567048389:;04<0E94?B@A2@4A3735A- &D@' 4 D@3B 9= ;0< 04> 7389D37< A23 45670483 89:;04< @5 0A E@C37A< A9 7389D37 A23 89:;3450A@940:964A=79:A239B4379=A23D32@8E3 >63;7983559=E0B *+ '&""!) %! @5A91$E91*