Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 66218 (KAR)
MALLIKARJUN S/O NAGAPPA DEAD BY LRS 1) BASAMMA AND ANR v. THE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER AND ORS
WP/202125/2022 · 2025-09-15
Jyoti Mulimani
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 66218 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 66218 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"
#!$$ !! %&'
! " #
$
%&'! %&'! (
%&'! Digitally signed by VARSHA N RASALKAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
! (
)
%&'! " #
* (+ *
* !$
* ,*
* *
* -. /012134562 1407 89:3657 ;9/ 425 <54040935/6 =43041 5>>? ;9/ /56<93>5346 49 ( 13> /0331/1?1140789:365793@5217;9;
/0 :A:6403;9/ /56<93>5349!21B51<<51/5>03<5/693
25 81<40935> /04 5404093 06 ;075> 655C03A 425 ;9779D03A/5705;6 0 /049;5/409/1/049E:1624250=<:A35>9/>5/ >145> (& 03 5B06093 5404093 9& <1665>@?425;0/64/56<93>534B0>5
- 3 -
335F:/5%13>9/>5/>145>' &<1665> @?425420/>/56<93>534B0>5335F:/5% 00 /049;13>1=:6>0/58403A425/56<93>534649 5345/42531=59;425<54040935/603425 603 /56<584 9;
?9(G =516:/03A 18/56 ( A:3416 604:145> 14 7>17 B0771A5 13B0 17:C 1082:/064/084 000 /04 9; 13>1=:6 >0/58403A 425 420/> /56<93>534 49 /5649/5 13> /54103 425 31=5 9;
>585165> 1A1==1 03 425 6 03 /56<584 9;
?9(G =5516:/03A 18/56 ( A:3416 604:145> 14 7>17 B0771A5 13B0 17:C 1082:/ 064/084 ( 25629/4;18461/5 4 06 64145> 4214 935 1=<1331 13> 161==1 1/5 425 2:6@13>13>D0;525?21>4D98207>/5331=57?/1==113> 21/131==1
21/131==1 D16 =1//05> 13> >05> 066:57566 /1==1 21> 4D9 >1:A245/6 31=57? 121341==1 13> 1A1==1 25 713> 03
?9(G =516:/03A ( 8/56 (& :3416 9/0A03177? @5793A5> 49 161==1 9 1=<1331 ;45/ 425>51429;1=<1331206D0;5161==1@581=54251@697:45
- 4 -
9D35/9;425</9<5/4? 255F58:45>1/5A0645/5>A0;4>55>93 !! & H90347? 03 ;1B9/ 9; 25/ A/13>>1:A245/6 31=57? 121341==1 13> 1A1==1 5385 121341==1 13> 1A1==1 21> @589=5 425 H9034 9D35/6 9; 425 </9<5/4? 03 E:56409313>4250/31=56D5/5=:4145>03425/5B53:5/589/>6 64203A66499>42:61A1==1>05>93 & !1;45/ A0B03A@0/42491;5=1758207>13>425/51;45/4258207>1769>05> 93 & ! 25 121607>1/ 85/40;05> 9 G 629D03A 425>0;;5/5345F45349;297>03A69;713>@?1A1==1#8/56 ( :3416$ 13> 121341==1 # 8/56 ( :3416$ 25 2:6@13> 9; 1A1==1 31=57? 1770C1/H:3 ;075> 1 6:04 03 9!!G !;9/>5871/1409313><5/=1353403H:38409313> /5840;0814093 9; 6 1770C1/H:3 @503A 425 6975 75A17 /5</56534140B5 13> 6:885669/ 9; 1A1==1 ;075> 13 1<<70814093 49 =:4145 206 31=5 03 425 /5B53:5 /589/>6 25 ;9:/42 /56<93>534 @503A 425 60645/ 9; 1A1==1 ;075> 9@H5840936 25 121607>1//5H5845>4251<<7081409393' &AA/05B5>@? 425610>9/>5/4252:6@13>9;1A1==11770C1/H:3</5;5//5> 13 1<<517 @5;9/5 425 66064134 9==0660935/ 25 66064134 9==0660935/ B0>5 9/>5/ >145> ! , >0/5845> 425 121607>1/ 49 5345/ 425 31=5 9; 1770C1/H:3 03 425 /5B53:5
- 5 -
/589/>6 503A 1AA/05B5> @? 425 610> 9/>5/ 425 ;9:/42 /56<93>534 ;075> 1 /5B06093 <5404093 @5;9/5 425 5<:4? 9==0660935/ 03 9& 25 610> 1770C1/H:3 ;075> 9@H584093649425/5B06093<54040935>05>93 ( 25 5<:4?9==0660935/B0>59/>5/>145>(& >06<965>9;
425 /5B06093 <5404093 13> 654 160>5 425 9/>5/ 9; 425 66064134 9==0660935/ 3>5/ 42565 80/8:=6413856 425 <54040935/6 1/5 @5;9/542069:/4 ! 9:3657 ;9/ 425 /56<5840B5 <1/4056 :/A5> 65B5/17 89345340936 & /012134562 1407 89:3657 ;9/ 425 <54040935/6 6:@=04642141A1==121>@589=54259D35/9;425</9<5/4?
@?B0/4:59;10;455>9D5B5/93135//9359:61<</9182 425 121607>1/ 89387:>5> 4214 425 564145 9; 1A1==1 629:7> A9 49 121341==1 5 >/5D 425 144534093 9; 425 9:/4 49 584093&9;42503>:
:8856609384G&13>6:@=0464214 131<</9</01459/>5/=1?@5<1665> /0331/1?1 1407 89:3657 ;9/ /56<93>534 9! 6:@=04642141A1==1>05>066:5756613>425/5;9/525/564145 629:7> A9 49 /56<93>534 9! 425 60645/ 9; 1A1==1 13>
- 6 -
25385 425 121607>1/ D16 H:640;05> 03 <16603A 425 9/>5/ 49 =:414525/31=503/56<5849;</9<5/4?9;1A1==19:3657 425/5;9/56:@=0464214425/045404093=1?@5>06=0665> H:640;05> 425 9/>5/ 9; 121607>1/ 13> 5<:4? 9==0660935/ 13> 6:@=046 4214 13 1<</9</0145 9/>5/ =1? @5 <1665>
25 ;1846 1/5 6:;;0805347? 610> 13> >9 394 /5E:0/5 /5045/1409325066:5;1776D04203131//9D89=<16613>/571456 49 5345/03A 425 31=5 9; <54040935/6 03 425 /5B53:5 /589/>6 03 /56<5849;56414575;4@?>585165>1A1==140639403>06<:45 4214 1A1==1 13> 121341==1 21> @589=5 425 1@697:45 9D35/69;425</9<5/4?@?B0/4:59;1/5A0645/5>0;455>>145> !! &40660A30;0813449394542141A1==1A1B5@0/42 4918207>29D5B5/62513>25/8207>>05>03 ! 25</9<5/4?9;1;5=17503>:62177>5B97B5;0/647?:<93 425 6936 13> >1:A245/6 #0387:>03A 425 8207>/53 9; 13? </5% >585165>6939/>1:A245/$13>4252:6@13>40639403>06<:45 4214 1A1==1 >05> 034564145 751B03A @5203> 25/ 2:6@13> 1770C1/H:31642569756:/B0B03A250/496:8855>4925/564145 1770C1/H:3 06 1769 >51> 13> 425 <54040935/6 1/5 425 75A17
- 7 -
/5</56534140B56 9; >585165> 1770C1/H:3 3 =? B05D 425 121607>1/ 06 394 H:640;05> 03 89387:>03A 4214 1770C1/H:3 06 394 425 75A17 /5</56534140B5 9; >585165> 1A1==1 49 5345/ 425 31=59;1213421==103425/5B53:5/589/>6D042/56<58449 713>@5793A03A491A1==1259/>5/<1665>@?42566064134 9==0660935/495345/42531=59;1770C1/H:303425/5B53:5 /589/>6 06 H:64 13> </9<5/ 25/5;9/5 4206 9:/4 >55=6 04 </9<5/ 49 E:162 425 9/>5/ 9; 425 121607>1/ 13> 425 5<:4? 9==0660935/ , 25 /04 9; 5/409/1/0 06 9/>5/5> 25 9/>5/ >145> (& 03 5B06093 5404093 9& <1665> @? 425 5<:4? 9==0660935/ % ;0/64 /56<93>534 B0>5 335F:/5% 13> 425 9/>5/ >145> ' & <1665> @? 425 121607>1/ % 420/> /56<93>534 B0>5 335F:/5% 1/5 E:1625> 25 9/>5/ >145> ! , <1665> @? 425 65893> /56<93>534 % 66064134 9==0660935/06893;0/=5> 13>1=:6 06 9/>5/5> >0/58403A 425 /56<93>5346 49 /5649/542531=569;425<54040935/603425 603/56<5849;
713>03E:564093604:145>147>170771A513B017:C 1082:/ 064/084
- 8 -
' 56:741347?425/04540409306 581:65 9; >06<9617 9; 425 /04 5404093 <53>03A 0345/798:49/? 1<<708140936 0; 13? 1/5 >06<965> 9; 13> 0345/0= >0/58409360;13?6413>6>06821/A5>
(& %$ !!' $
0649
79 ,