- 1 - ! "# $ ## # % &%'() &% (( * ! " # $ " % &$ ! " $ Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - % ' ( % " $ ' % '& % % # ) )% % % % %% "$ % % * ) " * )$ +, -,././01,2 3,/14 56678,9 0 /1 2/:, 0 0; 59/ 5/<=5> 0</6, .5./01 /8. 5<537254/ 2,4/8.,2,9 ;02 .+, 0;;,16, -71/8+53<, 719,2 ,6./018 519 2= "$0; +525./>5>5>551+/.5 ";02 8+02. ? @$ 10= -,19/14 /1 0'&01.+,;/<,0;.+,<,521,92/16/-5</A/< )794, 519 )% 5<537254/ /8 3,;02, .+/8 072. 8,,B/14 4251. 0; 35/< 719,2 ,6./01 ' 0; +525./>5 5452/B 725B8+5 51+/.5 ";02 8+02. ? @$ 01 .+, - 3 - 358/8 0; .+, ;/28. /1;02:5./01 <094,9 3> .+, /1;02:51. 5C,8+=52/0517:51.+7<</ ,5292/51.08+5./< <,521,960718,<;02.+, -,././01,2 5192/ /995</14 5./< <,521,9 99<-,6/5< 73</6208,67.02;02.+,2,8-019,1..5.,,278,9.+, :5.,2/5<8012,6029 1 A/,= 0; .+, 2/A5< 601.,1./018 724,9 3> .+, <,521,960718,<;0230.+.+,-52./,8 .+,-0/1..+5.=07<9 52/8,;02:>6018/9,25./01/8 ' > 518=,2 .0 .+, 530A, -0/1. /8 /1 .+, ?;;/2:5./A,@;02.+,;0<<0=/14 1/./5<<> 5 :/88/14 60:-<5/1. 65:, .0 3, ;/<,9 3>.+,8/8.,20;.+,9,6,58,95.,2 59,59309>0;5:5<, =58;07191,52.+,25/<=5>.256B+,/1;02:51./9,1./;/,9 - 4 - .+,9,59309>58.+5.0;+,2320.+,2519.+,%65:,.0 3, 2,4/8.,2,9 545/18. 71B10=1 -,28018 ;02 .+, 0;;,16, -71/8+53<, 719,2 ,6./01 0; 72/14 /1A,8./45./01 56678,9 08 .0 =,2, 5--2,+,19,9 519 .+,6+524,8+,,.65:,.03,;/<,98-,2.+,;/15<2,-02. /. =58 56678,9 0 =+0 +59 .+, /1.,1./01 .0 6578, .+, 9,5.+ 0;9,6,58,9 , 62,5.,95%56,300B -20;/<, /1 .+, 15:, 0; 5 4/2< 519 /1A/.,9 .+, 9,6,58,9 .0 60:, .0 5<537254/ 58 5 2,87<. 0; =+/6+ .+, 9,6,58,9 65:, .0 5<537254/ 6678,9 0 =+0 6018-/2,9 =/.+ 56678,9 08519 .00B.+,:5<014=/.++/:6678,908.0 +5A, .5B,1 .+, 9,6,58,9 1,52 .+, 25/<=5> .256B 519 .+2,5.,1,9 +/: .0 -5> .+, :01,> +, 9,6,58,9 +59 65<<,9 .+, /1;02:51. 519 58B,9 +,2 .0 .2518;,2 5 87: 0; 8 .+2074+ -+01,-5> 66029/14<> .+, /1;02:51.+59.2518;,22,98 .+2074+-+01,-5> .0.+,566071.0;.+,9,6,58,9 D ./8.+,601.,1./010;.+,-208,67./01.+5. .+, 9,6,58,9.2/,9.02715=5>;20:.+,8-0.6678,908 - 5 - 519 6+58,9 +/: 6678,9 0 8.533,9 +/: =/.+ .+, B1/;,51930.+.+,56678,9+5A,58857<.,9+/:=/.++5198 519 <,48 58 5 2,87<. 0; =+/6+ .+, 9,6,58,9 ;,<< 7160186/078,=58.+,1.+20=101.+,25/<=5>.256B519 .+,:0A/14.25/12510A,2+/8309> 5852,87<.0;=+/6++, 9/,9 . /8 .+, 601.,1./01 0; .+, -208,67./01 .+5. .+, -,././01,2 56678,9 0 =58 5. .+, 8-0. .+2074+07. .+, /16/9,1. 519 +, -52./6/-5.,9 /1 .+, 60::/88/01 0; .+, 530A,:,1./01,90;;,16, & 8 -,2 .+, 6+524, 8+,,. ;/<,9 3> .+, 1A,8./45./14 ;;/6,2 .+,2, 52, 10 ,>,=/.1,88,8 .0 .+, /16/9,1. ,/.+,2 .+, B1/;, 78,9 /1 .+, 60::/88/01 0; 0;;,16,102.+,3<0098.5/1,96<0.+,80;.+,56678,9=,2, 2,60A,2,9 A,1 58 -,2 .+, 6+524, 8+,,. .+, 5885/<51.8 52,56678,903>78/14.+,B1/;,51956678,903> 58857<./14 =/.+ .+, +5198 519 B/6B/14 =/.+ .+, <,48 0 876+ 0A,2.56. /8 5<<,4,9 545/18. .+, -2,8,1. -,././01,2 +,2,;02, 9,.,1./01 0; .+, -,././01,2 /1 678.09> =07<9 5:071. .0 /1;2/14,:,1. 0; +/8 2/4+. .0 </;, 519 </3,2.> - 6 - ,16, 5:0;.+,0-/1/01 .+5..+,-,././01,2/8,1./.<,9 .0 3, ,1<524,9 01 35/< 873C,6. .0 6019/./018 =+/6+ =/<< .5B,652,0;.+,/1.,2,8.0;.+,-208,67./01=/.1,88,8 66029/14<> 518=,2 .+, 530A, -0/1. /1 .+, 5;;/2:5./A,519-206,,9.0-588.+,;0<<0=/14 +,-,././01/8 +, -,././01,2 /8 029,2,9 .0 3, ,1<524,9 01 35/< /1 2/:, 0 0; 59/ 5/<=5> 0</6, .5./01 /8. 5<537254/ 01 03.5/1/14 .+, 3019 /1 5 87: 0; 8 "7-,,8=05B+801<>$=/.+.=0872,./,8 ;02 .+, </B,87: .0 .+, 85./8;56./01 0; .+, C72/89/6./015< 072. 873C,6..0.+,;0<<0=/146019/./018 5$ +, -,././01,2 8+5<< 10. 60::/. 8/:/<52 0;;,16,8 3$ +, -,././01,2 8+5<< 10. .+2,5.,1 02 .5:-,2=/.+.+,-208,67./01=/.1,88,8 6$ +, -,././01,2 8+5<< 5--,52 3,;02, .+, 072.58519=+,12,E7/2,9 - 7 - 9$ ; /1 658, .+, -,././01,2 A/0<5.,8 51> 0; .+, 6019/./018 58 8.5.,9 530A, .+, -208,67./01=/<<3,5.</3,2.>.0:0A,.+, 2/5<072.8,,B/146516,<<5./010;35/< 1 ;721/8+/14 .+, 872,./,8 3> .+, -,././01,2 .+,2/5<072./85.</3,2.>.09/2,6. .+, 1A,8./45./14 ;;/6,2 .0 A,2/;> .+, 6022,6.1,88 0; .+, 5992,88 519 57.+,1./6/.> 0; .+, 9067:,1.8 ;721/8+,9 3> .+, -,././01,2 519 .+, 872,./,8 519 5 2,-02. :5> 3, 65<<,9 ;02 /1 .+5. 2,4529 =+/6+ /8 .0 3, 873:/..,9 3> .+, 1A,8./45./14 ;;/6,2 =/.+/1 95>8 +, 2/5< 072. 01 85./8;56./01 :5> -206,,9 .0 566,-. .+, 872,./,8 ;02 .+, -72-08, 0; 2,<,58/14 .+, -,././01,20135/< +) %##( $ /8.0<0