Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 66211 (KAR)

VAISHNAVI D/O CHANDRAKANTH AND ORS v. SUSHILABAI W/O PUNDALIKAPPA AND ORS

RSA/200086/2014 · 2025-10-15

Sachin Shankar Magadum

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - ! "#$## %% &%'%( ) !"# !"# $ % & ' !"# Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ( # !"# "' !"# " " !"# $ % " & ## ( ( ##) "## ( ( % & !##! ')## * ( +( - 3 - $# % +( & ,- ./-0-12 0-3415 6..-67 80 987-5 :; 2,- <10<33-009<7 .768128990 60068781= 2,- ><5=?-12 615 5-3/-- .600-5:;2,-8/02..-7762- 4</281 449##) ;2,-8?.<=1-5><5=?-122,-..-7762- 4</2,60.6/27; ?45898-52,-./-78?816/;5-3/--=/612-5:;2,-/867 4</2 615 ,60 580?800-5 2,- 0<82 810496/ 60 </@-; 4A ?-60</81= A 63/-0 =<1260 ,47581= 2,62 2,- 0685 ./4.-/2; 80 2,- 0-79 63B<8/-5 ./4.-/2; 49 5-9-15612 4 ==/8-@-5 :; 2,- 0685 981581= 615 ?45898362841 2,- .768128990,6@-./-9-//-52,-./-0-120-34156..-67 6?87;2/--49.768128990/-65060<15-/ <15678C6..6 <0,876:68%D89-& /68>6162,%/42,-/& % -9 4&% -9 4A& ,615/6C612% -9 4&6><% -9 4&6@8% -9 4"& --7C612,% -9 4& ,8@6?61=676%72 4& 680,16@8%72 4&680,678%72 4& - 4 - ,- 96320 7-6581= 24 2,- ./-0-12 360- 6/- 60 94774D0 768128990 40 615 6/- 2,- 56<=,2-/0 49 76812899 4615 -9-15612 4,-.7681289903412-152,622,-; 6741=D82,5-9-156120 40243410282<2-61<158@85-5 815<>481296?87;6152,622,-0<8203,-5<7-./4.-/28-0EF EF 615 E F 6/- 2,- 613-02/67 >4812 96?87; ./4.-/28-0 334/581=7; 2,-; 3768? 6 7-=828?62- 0,6/- 81 677 2,- 0<82 03,-5<7- ./4.-/28-0 2 80 9</2,-/ 677-=-5 2,62 -9-15612 4 2,- ,<0:615 49 76812899 4 62 2,- 81028=62841 49 -9-15612 4 ,60 :--1 0<:>-3281= 2,- .768128990 24 ,6/600?-12 /-0<7281= 81 02/681-5 96?87; /-7628410 410-B<-127; 2,- .768128990 ,6@- 810282<2-5 2,- ./-0-12 0<82 0--C81= .6/282841 615 0-.6/62- .400-00841 49 2,-8/ 7-=828?62-0,6/-0812,-0<8203,-5<7-./4.-/28-0 " .41 /-3-8.2 49 0<??410 2,- 5-9-156120 -12-/-5 6..-6/613- 615 3412-02-52,- 0<82 :; 98781= 2,-8/ D/822-1 0262-?-120 -9-15612 4 D,4 80 2,- ,<0:615 - 5 - 49 76812899 4 0.-38983677; 3412-15-5 2,62 0813- 2,- .7681289906/-3768?81=2,-8/0,6/-2,/4<=,,8?2,-;,6@- 14815-.-15-12/8=,2240--C.6/282841812,-0<8203,-5<7- ./4.-/28-0 ,- 743<0 026158 49 76812899 4 D60 6704 B<-02841-5412,-=/4<152,620,-D6014234?.-2-1224 ?6812681 6 0<82 94/ .6/282841 41 :-,679 49 ,-/ ?814/ 56<=,2-/0 2 D60 9</2,-/ 3412-15-5 2,62 2-? 4 49 3,-5<7- EF ./4.-/2; :-81= </@-; 4A ?-60</81= A 63/-0 =<1260 80 2,- 0-79 63B<8/-5 ./4.-/2; 49 -9-15612 46152,-/-94/-2,-0<8294/.6/28284180142 ?68126816:7- 81 /-0.-32 49 2,- 0685 ./4.-/2; 1 2,-0- =/4<1502,-5-9-15612004<=,2580?80067492,-0<82987-5 :;2,-.76812899094/.6/2828416150-.6/62-.400-00841 ,- /867 4</2 <.41 6../-3862841 49 2,- 4/67 615543<?-126/;-@85-13-41/-34/55-3/--52,-0<8281 .6/2 :; =/61281= 2,- .768128990 6 #2, 0,6/- 81 2,- 0<82 3,-5<7- EF 615 EF ./4.-/28-0 -G37<581= 61 -G2-12 49 ' 63/-0 81 2-? 4 :-6/81= </@-; 4!) D,83, 81 24267 ?-60</-0 # 63/-0 615 ) =<1260 ,- 0<82 ,4D-@-/ - 6 - 36?- 24 :- 580?800-5 810496/ 60 3,-5<7- E F ./4.-/2; 80 3413-/1-5==/8-@-5:;2,-./-78?816/;5-3/--.600-581 4') 49 ## 2,- 5-9-156120 ./-9-//-5 6 /-=<76/ 6..-67:-94/-2,-8/02..-7762- 4</2 A ,- ..-7762- 4</2 41 /-6../-3862841 49 2,- -128/- -@85-13- /-@-/0-5 2,- 981581= 49 2,- /867 4</2 810496/602-? 4493,-5<7-EF:-81=</@-; 4A ?-60</81= A 63/-0 615 =<1260 1 61 815-.-15-12 -@67<62841 49 2,- ?62-/867 -@85-13- :42, 4/67 615 543<?-126/; 2,- ..-7762- 4</2 /-34/5-5 6 362-=4/8367 981581=2,62 -9-15612 42,-D854D492,-./4.4082<0 <22678C6..6615?42,-/49 -9-15612 4 ,615/6C612 ,65 63B<8/-5 2,- 0685 ./4.-/2; 81 ,-/ 8158@85<67 36.6382; <15-/ 6 /-=802-/-5 067- 5--5 ?6/C-5 60 G,8:82 2 2,-/-94/-,-752,622-? 4493,-5<7-EF802,-0-79 63B<8/-5 ./4.-/2; 49 -9-15612 4 615 142 .6/2 49 2,- >481296?87;-0262- 410-B<-127;2,-6..-67D606774D-5 6152,-.768128990F0<82D60580?800-5810496/602-? 4 49 3,-5<7- EF16?-7;</@-; 4A?-60</81= A63/-0 - 7 - 615 =<1260 80 3413-/1-5 -13- 2,- ./-0-12 0-3415 6..-6780341981-5417;242,-0685./4.-/2; ' -6/1-5 34<10-7 94/ 2,- .768128990 /-82-/6281= 2,-?-?4/615<?49=/4<150@-,-?-127;3412-15-52,62 2,-..-7762- 4</2F0981581=2,62</@-; 4A%3,-5<7- EF& 80 2,- 0-79 63B<8/-5 ./4.-/2; 49 -9-15612 4 80 .67.6:7;-//41-4<06153412/6/;242,--@85-1286/;/-34/5 5@-/281=242,-.7-6581=06152,-4/67615543<?-126/; -@85-13- ,- 0<:?822-5 2,62 -9-15612 4 ,65 14 815-.-15-12 04</3- 49 8134?-H ,-13- 2,- ./4.-/2; 0261581= 81 ,-/ 16?- .6/26C-0 2,- 3,6/632-/ 49 >4812 96?87;613-02/67./4.-/2;-2,-/-94/-</=-52,80 4</224 610D-/ <:02612867 *<-02841 4 81 2,- 6998/?628@- 615 /-024/-2,-/867 4</2F05-3/--:;8137<581=</@-; 4A 94/.6/28284160D-77 ! - 9</2,-/ 6/=<-5 2,62 :42, 34</20 -//-5 81 -G37<581= 61 -G2-12 49 ' 63/-0 9/4? 2-? 4 %</@-; 4!)&41 2,- ./-?80- 2,62 2,- ./4.4082<0 <1578C6..6 - 8 - ,65 0475 2,62 .4/2841 24 2,- 0043862841 <15-/ 6 /-=802-/-5 067- 5--5 /-7;81= 812-/ 6786 41 G,8:82 334/581= 24 ,8? 0813- 2,- -.<2; 4??800841-/ ,60 3613-77-52,-341@-/08414/5-/2,--128/-2;492-? 4 ?-60</81= # 63/-0 ) =<1260 /-?6810 6@6876:7- 94/ .6/282841H 2,- 3412/6/; 981581= ,- 0<:?822-5 80 .-/@-/0- 615D6//6120812-/9-/-13- ) 6027; ,- .4812-5 4<2 2,62 2-? 4 %</@-; 4&819632?-60</-0!63/-0=<126060/-97-32-581 2,- 4/8=8167 .76812 615 2,62 2,- 98=</- I =<1260J 6..-6/81= 81 2,- 6?-15-5 .76812 80 6 ?-/- 2;.4=/6.,8367 -//4/-2,-/-94/-/-B<-02-50<826:7-?45898362841492,- 5-3/--24/-97-322,-34//-32-G2-12 # ,-5-9-156120,6@-1423,40-1243412-022,- ./-0-120-34156..-676@81=,-6/52,-7-6/1-534<10-7 6..-6/81= 94/ 2,- .768128990 2,80 4</2 ,60 36/-9<77; 65@-/2-5 24 2,- 0<:02612867 B<-028410 49 76D 9/6?-5 94/ 341085-/62841-94/-./43--581=24-G6?81-2,-?622-/41 - 9 - ?-/820 82 D4<75 :- 6../4./862- 24 /-./45<3- 2,- 0<:02612867 B<-028410 49 76D 9/6?-5 :; 2,80 4</2 D,83, /-656094774D0 !" " # $ !"" % &' & % ( ) " " * ( " # $ !"" + " ( ) ) " # - 10 - ( %,'- " #. *+,*+-.+./0.12+1*234/5.1*+326* 15-/ 2,80 .4812 2,- 800<- 9/6?-5 94/ 341085-/62841 80 D,-2,-/ :42, 2,- 4</20 :-74D D-/- ><02898-581-G37<581=61-G2-1249'63/-081</@-; 4!) D,83, 94/?0 2-? 4 49 3,-5<7- EF ./4.-/2; 9/4? .6/282841 ,- /867 4</2 692-/ 65@-/281= 24 2,- /-=802-/-5 067- 5--5 -G-3<2-5 :; 2,- ./4.4082<0 762- <1578C6..65-3781-524=/61261;0,6/-81/-0.-32492,- 678-162-5.4/2841615341981-52,-.768128990F-12827-?-1224 2,- /-?68181= -G2-12 49 63/-0 ) =<1260 ,- 8/02 ..-7762- 4</2D,87-6998/?81=2,80981581=4:0-/@-52,62 2,4<=, 2,- .768128990 D-/- 142 -12827-5 24 6 0,6/- 81 2,- 678-162-5 7615 2,-; D-/- 62 78:-/2; 24 D4/C 4<2 2,-8/ /8=,208961;816334/5613-D82,76D6=681022,-678-1--0 - 11 - -94/- 2,80 4</2 2,- 7-6/1-5 34<10-7 94/ 2,- .768128990 04<=,2 24 3412-15 2,62 0813- 2,- -.<2; 4??800841-/ ,60 0<:0-B<-127; 5-3781-5 24 =/612 341@-/0841.-/?800841242,- 004386284124D,4? ' 63/-0 D-/- 0475 2,- 0685 678-162841 026150 9/<02/62-5 6152,-./4.-/2;/-@-/20242,-96?87;2,-/-:;?6C81=2,- -128/--G2-1249#63/-0)=<12606@6876:7-94/.6/282841 " ,80 3412-12841 81 2,- 341085-/-5 @8-D 49 2,80 4</280D,477;<12-16:7-:42,8196326158176D12,- 98/02 .763- 14 543<?-126/; -@85-13- ,60 :--1 ./45<3-5 :;2,-.76812899024-026:780,2,622,- -.<2; 4??800841-/ ,60 81 9632 /-9<0-5 2,- 341@-/0841 6..78362841 @-1 600<?81= 0<3, /-9<067 2,- 06?- D4<75 142 81 61; ?611-/ 699-32 2,- 2827- 67/-65; 341@-;-5 <15-/ 6 5<7; -G-3<2-5615/-=802-/-5067-5--5 280D-770-227-5<15-/-32841!492,-/6109-/ 49 /4.-/2; 32 !! 2,62 6 2/6109-/ 49 8??4@6:7- ./4.-/2; .600-0 94/2,D82, 24 2,- 2/6109-/-- 677 2,- - 12 - 812-/-020D,83,2,-2/6109-/4/802,-136.6:7-49.60081=81 2,- ./4.-/2; 24=-2,-/ D82, 820 7-=67 81385-120 <17-00 6 3412/6/; 812-12841 80 -G./-00-5 13- 2,- ./4.4082<0 <1578C6..6-G-3<2-56/-=802-/-5067-5--5341@-;81=' 63/-0 49 7615 81 </@-; 4!) 81 96@4</ 49 2,- 0043862841 94/ @67<6:7- 341085-/62841 2,-4D1-/0,8. 615 677./4./8-26/;812-/-0200244558@-02-59/4?2,-2/6109-/4/ 615@-02-56:047<2-7;812,-2/6109-/-- A </2,-/ <15-/ -32841 " 49 2,- /6109-/ 49 /4.-/2;326067-498??4@6:7-./4.-/2;8062/6109-/49 4D1-/0,8.81-G3,61=-94/6./83-.6854/./4?80-5.41 -G-3<2841615/-=802/62841492,-067-5--52827-.600-024 2,- .</3,60-/ ,- 0<:0-B<-12 5-1867 49 341@-/0841 .-/?800841 <15-/ 2,- 6/1626C6 615 -@-1<- 32 80 ?-/-7; 61 65?81802/628@- 5-380841 /-=<76281= 2,- <0-/ 49 7615H8254-0142699-324/611<72,-2/6109-/494D1-/0,8. 67/-65;.-/9-32-5:;6/-=802-/-5341@-;613- - 13 - ' -/-/->-3284149341@-/0841.-/?800841361142 :;61;7-=6798328414.-/62-60/-@-0281=492827-8196@4</ 49 2,- 2/6109-/4/F0 96?87; ,- /8=,2 2827- 615 812-/-02 ,6@81= 76D9<77; .600-5 24 2,- 0043862841 2,- .768128990 361142 3768? 2,62 2,- 678-162-5 ./4.-/2; ,60 /-@-/2-5242,->481296?87;-0262-4/-4@-/2,-..-7762- 4</2 ,60 6704 4:0-/@-5 2,62 2,- 0043862841 ,60 94/?-5 /-085-12867 .7420 615 678-162-5 2,- 06?- 24 2,8/5 .6/28-0 2,-/-:; 3/-6281= ?<728.7- 5-/8@628@- /8=,20 <3, 2,8/5 .6/2; 812-/-020 9</2,-/ ?878262- 6=68102 61; 3768? 94/ .6/28284181/-0.-32492,-678-162-5.4/2841 ! 1@8-D492,-6:4@-7-=676159632<67.4082841 2,80 4</2 ,4750 2,62 2,- 067- -99-32-5 :; <1578C6..6 80 @6785615:81581=412,->481296?87;17-00615<12872,- 0685 067- 5--5 80 0-2 6085- 81 6../4./862- ./43--581=0 810282<2-5 81 6334/5613- D82, 76D 2,- .768128990 361142 0--C.6/28284181/-0.-32492,-678-162-5'63/-049761581 </@-; 4!) - 14 - ) 334/581=7;2,80 4</298150148198/?82;812,- 3413<//-12981581=0/-34/5-5:;:42,2,- 4</20:-74D 81 5-378181=24=/61260,6/-812,-0685.4/284142, 4</20 ,6@-/8=,27;341981-52,-.768128990F0,6/-242,-/-?68181= -G2-124963/-0)=<1260812-? 4493,-5<7-EF # -13-2,-0<:02612867B<-028414976D 4%8&80 610D-/-5 81 2,- 615 6=68102 2,- .768128990 <.,47581=2,-3413<//-12981581=0492,- 4</20:-74D *+,*+-.+./0.12+1*234/5.1*+326** 15-/ 2,80 .4812 2,- 0<:02612867 B<-02841 94/?<762-594/341085-/6284180D,-2,-/2,-981581=492,- 8/02..-7762- 4</2,47581=2,622-? 4493,-5<7- EF ./4.-/2; 16?-7; </@-; 4A 80 2,- -G37<08@- ./4.-/2;49 -9-15612 480-//41-4<0 1 6 36/-9<7 -G6?8162841 49 2,- .7-6581=0 49 :42, .6/28-0 615 2,- 4/67 615 543<?-126/; -@85-13- 41 /-34/5 82 80 -@85-12 9/4? G,8:82 6 /-=802-/-5 067- - 15 - 5--5 562-5 '#)!' 2,62 -9-15612 4 .</3,60-5 2-? 4493,-5<7-EF./4.-/2;81,-/8158@85<6716?- ,- .768128990 ,4D-@-/ ,6@- 3412-15-5 2,62 2,- 067- 341085-/62841 94/ 2,- 0685 .</3,60- D60 .685 :; 2,- ./4.4082<0 762- <1578C6..6 615 ,-13- 2,- ./4.-/2; 0,4<75 :- 2/-62-5 60 .6/2 49 2,- >4812 96?87; -0262- 41@-/0-7; -9-15612 4 600-/2-5 2,62 2,- 341085-/62841 D60 .685 :; ,-/ 962,-/ 615 -G6?81-5 -9-15612 4A ,-/ :/42,-/ 60 81 0<..4/2 49 ,-/ 3768? 4D-@-/ 2,- .7-6581=0 81 2,- .76812 /-=6/581= 2,80 82-? 6/- @6=<- =-1-/67 615 4?18:<0 763C81= 61; 0.-389836@-/?-126024,4D4/D,-12,->481296?87;9<150 D-/- <2878K-5 94/ 2,- .</3,60- 49 2,- 0685 ./4.-/2; ,- 76D 80 D-77 0-227-5 2,62 ?-/- .</3,60- 49 ./4.-/2; 81 2,- 16?-4969-?67-?-?:-/492,-96?87;54-0142:;820-79 7-65242,-./-0<?.28412,628280>481296?87;./4.-/2; - 16 - " 12,80/-=6/52,-./8138.7--?:458-581-32841 "%& 49 2,- 815< <33-00841 32 )A 80 49 @8267 08=18983613-,-0685./4@808415-376/-02,6261;./4.-/2; .400-00-5:;6815<9-?67-D,-2,-/63B<8/-5:-94/-4/ 692-/2,-34??-13-?-12492,-320,677:-,-75:;,-/ 60 6:047<2- ./4.-/2; 615 0,- 0,677 :- 2,- 9<77 4D1-/ 2,-/-49 ,- 7-=807628@- 812-12 60 /-.-62-57; -?.,608K-5 :; 2,- 41F:7- <./-?- 4</2 81 !! " 615 ## 80 24 -78?8162- 2,- 3413-.2 49 6 78?82-5 -0262- 49 6 815< D4?61 615 24 3419-/ <.41 ,-/ 34?.7-2- 4D1-/0,8. 615 6<2414?; 4@-/ ./4.-/2; ,-75 81 ,-/16?- 2 80 -B<677; D-77 0-227-5 2,62 D,-/- ./4.-/2; 026150 81 2,- 16?- 49 6 815< 9-?67- 2,- ./-0<?.2841 <15-/ 76D 80 2,62 82 80 ,-/ 6:047<2- ./4.-/2; 615 2,- :</5-1 49 ./4@81= 2,62 82 80 81 9632 6 >4812 96?87; 600-2 .</3,60-5 9/4? >4812 96?87; 9<150 78-0 0B<6/-7; 41 2,- - 17 - .-/041600-/281=0<3,3768?12,-./-0-12360-2,-/-80 14543<?-126/;-@85-13-0<3,60./449493412/8:<284149 >4812 96?87; 9<150 /-382670 81 2,- 067- 5--5 4/ 3412-?.4/61-4<0 /-@-1<- /-34/50 24 8158362- 2,62 2,- .</3,60- D60 ?65- 94/ 2,- :-1-982 49 2,- >4812 96?87; 4/ 2,62 -9-15612 4-@-/,-7582816985<386/;36.6382; A ,- /867 4</2F0 981581= 2,62 2-? 4 3410282<2-5>481296?87;./4.-/2;?-/-7;:-36<0-2,-962,-/ 49 -9-15612 4D60142608=1624/;242,-067-5--580 ?6189-027; .-/@-/0- 615 <10<026816:7- 81 76D ,- -G-3<2841 49 6 /-=802-/-5 067- 5--5 81 2,- 047- 16?- 49 -9-15612 4 34<.7-5 D82, 2,- 9632 2,62 2,- /-@-1<- /-34/50 ,6@- 3410802-127; 02445 81 ,-/ 16?- 0813- )!' 37-6/7; -026:780,-0 ,-/ 815-.-15-12 615 -G37<08@- 4D1-/0,8.4@-/2,-0685./4.-/2; ' ,- 8/02 ..-7762- 4</2 41 6 ./4.-/ 615 815-.-15-12 /-6../68067 49 2,- -@85-13- ,60 /8=,27; 34137<5-52,622-? 4493,-5<7-EF./4.-/2;16?-7; - 18 - </@-; 4A ?-60</81= A 63/-0 615 =<1260 80 2,- 0-79 63B<8/-5 615 6:047<2- ./4.-/2; 49 -9-15612 4 6152,-/-94/-2,-06?-801426@6876:7-94/.6/282841 ! 1 @8-D 49 2,- 0-227-5 7-=67 .4082841 2,62 6 ./4.-/2;0261581=812,-16?-496815<9-?67-?<02:; @8/2<- 49 -32841 "%& 49 2,- 815< <33-00841 32 :- ./-0<?-524:-,-/6:047<2-./4.-/2;<17-00/-:<22-5:; 34=-12615341@81381=-@85-13-D,83,80D,477;763C81=81 2,- ./-0-12 360- 2,80 4</2 98150 14 /-6041 24 812-/9-/- D82,2,-D-77 /-6041-5981581=492,-..-7762- 4</2 ) 334/581=7;2,80 4</2,47502,622-? 449 3,-5<7-EF./4.-/2;%</@-; 4A&802,--G37<08@-615 0-79 63B<8/-5./4.-/2;49 -9-15612 46152,-981581= /-34/5-5:;2,-..-7762- 4</2809<77;816334/5613-D82, 76D ,- 0<:02612867 B<-02841 49 76D 4%88& 80 2,-/-94/- 610D-/-5812,-$%6156=681022,-.768128990 - 19 - *+,*+-.+./0.12+1*234/5.1*+326.***2+,*7 # 813-<:02612867 *<-028410496D 40615 "6/-812-//-762-52,-;6/-341085-/-524=-2,-/,-/867 4</2,60=/612-52,-.7681289906#2,0,6/-812,-0<82 03,-5<7-./4.-/28-0-G37<581=82-? 4812,-03,-5<7-EF ./4.-/2; 4D-@-/ 41 6 3740-/ -G6?8162841 2,80 4</2 98150 2,62 2,- B<612898362841 49 0,6/-0 ?65- :; 2,- /867 4</2 80 37-6/7; -//41-4<0 615 3412/6/; 24 0-227-5 ./8138.7-0 49 815< 76D 6..7836:7- 24 .6/28-0 =4@-/1-5 :; 2,- 826C0,6/6 3,447 60 ./-@68781= 81 2,- ;5-/6:65 6/1626C6/-=841 28060-227-5.40828412,62<15-/2,-826C0,6/6 76D606..78-5812,-;5-/6:65 6/1626C6/-=8416D89- 54-0 142 63B<8/- 61 815-.-15-12 0,6/- 81 >4812 96?87; ./4.-/2;5</81=2,-789-28?-49,-/,<0:615,808058028132 9/4?2,-.4082841<15-/2,-4?:6;3,44749815<6D D,-/- 2,- D89- 41 .6/282841 :-2D--1 ,-/ ,<0:615 615 041080-12827-524/-3-8@-60,6/--B<67242,62496041 -13- 2,- 981581= 49 2,- /867 4</2 81 =/61281= 61 - 20 - 815-.-15-120,6/-2476812899 42,-D89-49 -9-15612 4 5</81= 2,- 789-28?- 49 ,-/ ,<0:615 80 7-=677; <10<026816:7- ,- 65?822-5 =-1-674=; 5803740-0 2,62 <1578C6..6 %2,- ./4.4082<0& 615 -9-15612 4 L ?2 <0,--76:68,6594</041016?-7; -9-156120 40 " 615 .41 2,- 5-62, 49 <1578C6..6 6 14284167 .6/282841,6024:--99-32-560.-/2,-./8138.7-0768554D1 <15-/-32841A492,-815<<33-0084132)A ,-./4.4082<0<1578C6..6615,8094</0410 -9-156120 40"61526C-2,0,6/--63,,<0 622,-98/02026=--63,D4<7526C-2,0,6/- " <2 49 2,- 2, 0,6/- 49 762- <1578C6..6 :; @8/2<-4914284167.6/282841 -9-1561214615,8094</ 0410D4<75-63,26C-61-B<670,6/-15-/0-32841!49 815< <33-00841 32 ,-/-94/- -9-15612 4 D4<75 /-3-8@- 2, 0,6/- %8- 2, M 2,& 615 -63, 041 D4<75 /-3-8@- 2, 0,6/- 81 65582841 24 2,-8/ 4/8=8167 - 21 - 2, 0,6/- /-0<7281= 81 -63, 041 ,47581= A2, 0,6/- %2,N2,& 2 80 14D /-.4/2-5 2,62 -9-15612 4 L ,615/6C612 2,- ,<0:615 49 76812899 4 ,60 .600-5 6D6; .41 ,80 5-?80- ,80 A2, 0,6/- 5-@47@-0 :; 0<33-00841<.41,803,875/-116?-7;768128990 40615 ;D6;4914284167.6/2828410,6/-,6024:-677422-524 -9-15612 14768128990 615 615 -9-15612 14 -63, :-81= -12827-5 24 41- 2,8/5 0,6/- 4<2 49 A2, 81 6334/5613- D82, -32841 A 49 2,- 815< <33-00841 32 )A 410-B<-127;768128990 406150,677-63,26C- 2,0,6/- A ,- 142841672,0,6/-,-75 :; ,615/6C612 80 9</2,-/ /-B<8/-5 24 :- 5802/8:<2-5 6?41= ,80 7600 ,-8/0O768128990 4024615 -9-15612 463,49 2,-94</,-8/0D8772,-/-94/-:--12827-52461-B<67#2, 0,6/-81 ,615/6C612F02,.4/2841 - 22 - '165582841 -9-15612 4L?2<0,--76:68 D,467/-65;,47502,0,6/-60,-/81,-/82613-9/4?,-/ ,<0:615F0 -0262- D877 6704 :- -12827-5 24 6 9</2,-/ #2, 0,6/- 9/4? 2,- -0262- 49 ,-/ 5-3-60-5 041 ,615/6C612 60 41- 49 ,80 7600 ,-8/0 <15-/ -32841 ! 49 2,- 815< <33-0084132 ! 334/581=7; 2,- 34//-32 34?.<262841 49 0,6/-0 0,677:-6094774D0 • -9-15612 4 %?2 <0,--76:68& ,4750 #2, 0,6/-%8-2,N#2,&H • 76812899 4 615 76812899 4 -63, ,475 #2, 0,6/-%8-2,N#2,&H615 • 76812899 4,4750#2,0,6/- ) -13- 2,- 34?.<262841 49 #2, 0,6/- 60 5-2-/?81-5 :; 2,- /867 4</2 80 94<15 24 :- :42, ?62,-?6283677; 615 7-=677; <10<026816:7- ,- 0,6/-0 2,-/-94/- /-B<8/- /-34?.<262841 81 6334/5613- D82, 2,- 6:4@- ./8138.7-0 3410802-12 D82, 2,- 826C0,6/6 76D 6..7836:7-242,-;5-/6:65L6/1626C6/-=841 - 23 - "# 334/581=7;0<:02612867B<-028414976D 4%888& 80610D-/-5812,-$%6150<:02612867B<-0284149 76D 4%8@&80610D-/-5812,- " 1 @8-D 49 2,- 6:4@- 5803<00841 615 981581=0 2,80 4</2./43--5024.6002,-94774D81= %8& ,-6..-6780.6/27;6774D-5 %88& ,-0<82492,-.768128990810496/6082-? 4 8103,-5<7-EF./4.-/2;80580?800-5 %888& ,-0,6/-0492,-.6/28-0-G37<581='63/-0 81 82-? 4 49 03,-5<7- EF ./4.-/2; 6/- ?45898-56094774D0 %6& -9-15612 4 %?2 <0,--76:68& ,4750 #2,0,6/-%8-2,N#2,H %:& 76812899 4 615 76812899 4 -63, ,475 #2,0,6/-%8-2,N#2,&H615 %3& 76812899 4,4750#2,0,6/- - 24 - %8@& /6D5-3/--6334/581=7; %@& 77.-1581=812-/743<24/;6..7836284108961; 02615580.40-549 ,' &##( $ 802 47 4