Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 66210 (KAR)

BABUMIYAN S/O SULEMANSAB ROZEWALE v. MERAJ PATEL S/O MAHEBOOB PATEL

RSA/7123/2011 · 2025-04-24

Anant Ramanath Hegde

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - !" #$ % $ ""& '%( ) ! " # $ % AMENDMENT THE CAUSE TITLE VIDE HON’BLE COURT ORDER DATED 27.10.2021 Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - & $ #' () (# *++ ( , '+('( - .+( +( / ( ' # ()0 ( * + ( , '#'.#'( - ( ++ 1 ( 2 1 + + ( 1 3 ( 4 1( (' . ,.- ( 5 1 ( ++'. , -( ++ (( ( + . ( ( 22 5 (( . ( 4 ( ( (1. ( )( ( ++ 1 1( ( . ( ' ( 6 . ( (( - 3 - % $ ,+ 6 . ( (( - (789::";89<898=&%<>?@7"AB!&?"=@=!!"<"" 8= >4 >=@7"%8;">%!!8@8>=;8C8;.B!&" B;<&=!@7"AB!&?"=@=!!"<""8=> 2 >=@7"%8;">% "=8><8C8;.B!&"B;<& (7"9B8@89%><!";<@8>=>%@8@;"=!8=AB=@8>= 8=<"9:"@>%@7":<>:"<@D"<8=& D>/4 $?"9B<8=& <"9 / &B=@9 @ #!=8 '8;;&" (;BE =! 89@<8@ B;<&(7"9B8@89!"<""!!";<8=&@7@@7":;8=@8%%89 @7">F="<>%@7"%><"?"=@8>="!:<>:"<@D / ==::";D@7"!"%"=!=@"%><"@7"18<9@ ::";;@">B<@@7";"<="! "=8><8C8;.B!&"79;;>F"! @7"::";=!>=9"GB"=@;D79!89?899"!@7"9B8@ $ (789 ::"; F9 !?8@@"! >= 2//2 @> >=98!"<@7"%>;;>F8=&9B9@=@8;GB"9@8>=>%;F - 4 - (789 >B<@ %@"< &>8=& @7<>B&7 @7" :;8=@ C"<?"=@=!"C8!"=">=<"><!89>%@7"C8"F@7@>=" ?><"9B9@=@8;GB"9@8>=>%;F89<"GB8<"!@>"%<?"! !"!#$%&' ( $( ) * + ,- . / 0 0 !"!#$%&' "<! @7" ;"<="! >B=9"; ::"<8=& %>< @7" ::";;=@9 =! @7" ;"<="! >B=9"; ::"<8=& %>< @7" <"9:>=!"=@ 4 "<="! >B=9"; ::"<8=& %>< @7" ::";;=@9 F>B;! >=@"=! @7@ @7" :;8=@8%% ><8&8=; ::";;=@ 7! :B<79"!@7"9B8@97"!B;":<>:"<@DB=!"<@7"<"&89@"<"! - 5 - 9;" !""! !@"! /2225 =! 98=" @7"= 7" 89 8= :>99"998>= >% @7" :<>:"<@D =! !"%"=!=@ 89 B=>="<="! @>@7"%?8;D>%@7"C"=!><=!99B7@7"18<9@::";;@" >B<@ 89 =>@ AB9@8%8"! 8= <"C"<98=& @7" F";;H<"9>="! AB!&?"=@=!!"<"":99"!D@7"(<8;>B<@ @89 ;9> B<&"!>= "7;% >%@7" ::";;=@@7@ F7"= @7" :<>:"<@D F9 :B<79"! 8= @7" D"< 25 :<>:"<@D F9 =B?"<"! 9 D>/4 =! @7>B&7 >B=!<8"9 <" =>@ ?"=@8>="! 8= @7" 9;" !""! @7" :<>:"<@D 89 =>F <"=B?"<"! =! @7" :<>:"<@D 89 8!"=@8%8;" F8@7 <"%"<"=" @> ="F =B?"< 998&="! @> @7":<>:"<@D 5 @89%B<@7"<B<&"!@7@@7"!"%"=!=@"8=&@7" 9@<=&"< @> @7" %?8;D >% @7" C"=!><9 ==>@ ;8? =D <8&7@>C"<@7":<>:"<@D=!@7">?8998>=>=@7":<@>%@7" :;8=@8%%@>?"=@8>=@7">B=!<D=!>?8998>=>=@7":<@ >%@7":;8=@8%%@>:<>!B"@7"<"><!>%<8&7@:"<@8=8=&@> @7" 9B8@ :<>:"<@D 9 >= @7" !@" >% @7" 9B8@ 97>B;! =>@ >?" 8= @7" FD >% &<=@8=& !"<"" %>< !";<@8>= >% - 6 - @8@;" &8C"= @7" %@ @7@ ><8&8=; @8@;" !""! >% 25 89 =>@ !89:B@"! 2 "<="! >B=9"; ::"<8=& %>< @7" !"%"=!=@H <"9:>=!"=@>=@7">@7"<7=!F>B;!>=@"=!@7@@7"9B8@ 89=>@?8=@8=;"9@7">B=!<8"9>%@7"9B8@:<>:"<@8"9 <"=>@%B<=897"!;>=&F8@7@7":;8=@=!>B=!<8"9<" ;9>=>@%><@7>?8=&8=@7"<"&89@"<"!9;"!""!>%25@ 89 ;9> 789 %B<@7"< 9B?8998>= @7@ @7" <"><! >% <8&7@ :"<@8=8=&@>@7"9B8@:<>:"<@D9>=@7"!@">%@7"9B8@89 =>@ :<>!B"! @ 89 9B?8@@"! @7@ !"%"=!=@ 79 :B<79"! @7" :<>:"<@D %<>? :;8=@8%%I9 <>@7"< B=!"< <"&89@"<"! 9;" !""! !@"! 2$ 2555 =! :;8=@8%% !"%"=!=@I9 C"=!>< F9 ;9> @7" >F="< >% @7" :<>:"<@D 9 9B7 !"%"=!=@ 79 :B<79"! / <"9 &B=@98= D>/4 /J$ 22 (789 >B<@ 79 >=98!"<"! @7" >=@"=@8>=9 <89"!@@7"<=!:"<B9"!@7"<"><!9 - 7 - 2 (>9""E<";8"%>%!";<@8>=>%@8@;"8=<"9:"@>% @7" :<>:"<@D ?"9B<8=& <"9 / &B=@9 :;8=@8%% 89 <"GB8<"! @> ;"<;D ?"=@8>= @7" 9B<C"D =B?"< >% @7" :<>:"<@D98@9@>>!9>=@7"!@">%@7"9B8@=:"<B9; >% @7" :;8=@ 8@ 89 =>@8"! @7@ @7" 9B8@ :<>:"<@D 89 !"9<8"! 9 D>/4 ?"9B<8=& <"9 / &B=@9 8= :<&<:7>/>%@7":;8=@=!<"%"<"="89?!"@>@7" 9;" !""! >% 25 @> ;8? @8@;" =! :>99"998>= >% @7" :<>:"<@D >F"C"< 8= @7" :<D"< :;8=@8%% 79 9>B&7@ !";<@8>=>%@8@;"8=<"9:"@>% D>/4 $?"9B<8=& <"9 / &B=@9 #!=8 '8;;&" (;BE =! 89@<8@ B;<& 2/ (7"!89<":=D8=?"=@8>=8=&@7"9"@F>9B<C"D =B?"<9 8= @7" :;8=@ 89 =>@ "K:;8="! ><" 8?:><@=@;D @7" >B=!<8"9 >% @7" :<>:"<@D "<8=& D>/4 >< >B=!<8"9 >% @7" :<>:"<@D "<8=& D>/4 $ <" =>@ ?"=@8>="! = !!8@8>= @> @7@ 8@ 89 ;9> =>@8"! @7@ <"><!>%<8&7@:"<@8=8=&@> D>/4 $><<"><!>%<8&7@ - 8 - :"<@8=8=&@> D>/49>=@7"!@">%@7"9B8@<"=>@ :<>!B"! 2$ (789 >B<@ 79 ;9> :"<B9"! @7" 9;" !""! ?<E"!@=="KB<"H+/ 8!9;"!""!89>%@7"D"<25 =!@7":<>:"<@D>C"<"!B=!"<@7"9;"!""!89!"9<8"! 9 D>/4 F8@7 <"%"<"=" @> #9< >$ =! 9;" !""!!>"9=>@!89;>9"@7">B=!<8"9>%@7":<>:"<@D 2 @ 89 ;9> =>@8"! @7@ => 9B<C"D 9E"@7 89 :<>!B"! @> 8!"=@8%D @7" ;>@8>= >% @7" :<>:"<@D "<8=& D>/4 >< /4 $ >< /4 / $ @ 89 %B<@7"< <";"C=@ @> =>@" @7@ <"><! >% <8&7@ :<>!B"! D @7" :;8=@8%% %>< D>/4 / $%><@7"D"< H8"@7"D"<8=F787 @7" 9B8@ 89 %8;"! <"C";9 @7" "K@"=@ >% D>/4 / $ ?"9B<"9 <"9 2$ &B=@9 =! 8= @7" 9?" <"><! >% <8&7@@7"<"<""=@<8"9=""=@<D8=@7"=?">%""<A "7>> @> @7" "K@"=@ >% / <"9 &B=@9 =! =>@7"< "=@<D 8= @7" =?" >% :;8=@8%%H7C9 @> @7" "K@"=@ >% <"9 / &B=@9 % >@7 "K@"=@9 <" !!"! @>@; "K@"=@ "K""!9 5 <"9 >F"C"< @>@; "K@"=@ - 9 - C8;;"8=@7":<>:"<@D"<8=& D>/4 / $8@9";%89 <"92$&B=@9 2 =!"<@7"9"8<B?9@="9@789>B<@89>%@7" C8"F @7@ @7" (<8; >B<@ "<<"! 8= &<=@8=& <";8"% >% !";<@8>=>%@8@;"=!8=AB=@8>= 24 1<>? @7"<"><!9:;"!"%><"@7" >B<@ 8@89 =>@8"! @7@ @7"<" <" @>> ?=D 7=&"9 8= @7" 9B<C"D =B?"< >% ><8&8=; D>/4 (7>9" 7=&"9 <" =>@ "K:;8="! 9@89%@><8;D "8@7"< 8= @7" :;8=@ >< 8= @7" "C8!"="><8=@7"%><?>%=""99<D<"C"=B"<"><!9 2 1><@7"%><"?"=@8>="!<"9>=9@7"9B8@>%@7" :;8=@8%% F>B;! %8; >F"C"< 8@ 89 ;9> =>@8"! @7@ @7" :;8=@8%% ;8?9 @> 7C" :B<79"! @7" :<>:"<@D "<8=& D>/4 ?"9B<8=& <"9 / &B=@9 B=!"< @7" <"&89@"<"! 9;" !""! >% 25 "<";D "B9" @7"<" <" !89<":=8"9 8= <"><!8=& @7" 9B<C"D =B?"< =! "K@"=@ >%;=!8=@7"<"C"=B"<"><!98@==>@"98!@7@@7" :;8=@8%%79=>@8@;">C"<@7":<>:"<@D@@7"9?"@8?" - 10 - !"%"=!=@9;9>;8?@8@;">C"<@7":<>:"<@D>=@7"989 >% @7" <"&89@"<"! 9;" !""! >% 2555 ;"8@ @> ;"99"< "K@"=@ "%"=!=@ ;8?9 @> 7C" :B<79"! @7" :<>:"<@D "<8=& D>/4 /J$ 25 =!"<@7"9"8<B?9@="9@789>B<@89>%@7" C8"F@7@@7"8?:B&="!AB!&?"=@9=!!"<""97C"@>" 9"@H98!" =! @7" ?@@"< 79 @> " <"?8@@"! @> @7" (<8; >B<@&8C8=&;8"<@D@>@7":;8=@8%%@>?"=!@7":;8=@@> 8=><:><@" ;; @7" =""99<D :<@8B;<9 @> "9@;897 789 ;8? 8= <"9:"@ >% @7" 9B8@ :<>:"<@D F8@7 :<>:"< !"9<8:@8>= =" @7" 98! ?"=!?"=@ 89 <<8"! >B@ :B<9B=@ @> = ?"=!?"=@ ::;8@8>= @7" !"%"=!=@9 97>B;! " &8C"= = >::><@B=8@D @> %8;" !!8@8>=; F<8@@"= 9@@"?"=@@>@7"?"=!"!:;8=@=!@7"<"%@"<?@@"<79 @>"!AB!8@"!%<"978=><!="F8@7;F "="@7"%>;;>F8=& - 11 - ,8- (7"::";89 ,88- (7" AB!&?"=@ =! !"<"" !@"! 22 8= > 5 >= @7" %8;" >% "=8>< 8C8; .B!&" B;<& <" 9"@H 98!" ,888- (7"?@@"<89<"?8@@"!@>@7"(<8;>B<@%>< %<"97>=98!"<@8>=8=><!="F8@7;F E"":8=& 8= ?8=! @7" >9"<C@8>=9 ?!" >C" F7"<"8= @789 >B<@ 79 &<=@"! ;8"<@D @> :;8=@8%% @> ?"=! @7" :;8=@ @> 8=><:><@" ;; =""99<D :<@8B;<9 =! ;8"<@D89;9>&<=@"!@>@7"!"%"=!=@9@> %8;" !!8@8>=; F<8@@"= 9@@"?"=@ @> @7" ?"=!"!:;8=@ ,8C- +<@8"997;;::"<"%><"@7"(<8;>B<@ >= F8@7>B@=D%B<@7"<=>@8" %<>?@7">B<@ - 12 - ,C- @ 89 ?!" ;"< @7@ @789 >B<@ 79 =>@ "K:<"99"! =D >:8=8>= >= @7" ;8? >% "8@7"<>%@7":<@8"9 ,C8- ;;>=@"=@8>=9<"E":@>:"= *' & $ ( % '+ 89@>2 ;>$$