- 1 - !!"# " ! $ %#!!! $ %#!% &!' ! " ## $ % ! !! "% $ % ! && ' !! % %% "% $ !%"%$ '( Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ( % %% ! ! "!%($ ! % ' )% % ! *$ % !!! + ! !! ('%( && ! , ! % # + $ % ! !! % ! ! ! !! & $! % % % %# + ! % ! - - . # ! . # % - 3 - "! -. # %$ /01 23404056 01 70839 :*8806; 06 <=314056 4/3 5>93> 9*439&&062280:*40565('(2*1139?@ 4/3*>6*4*A*4*439B06014>*40C3>0?=6*8*4*8*?=>*;0 36:/ "75> 1/5>4 D>0?=6*8E$ F/3>3?@ 901B01106; 4/3 *2280:*4056 70839 ?@ 4/3 234040563> :*8806; 06 <=314056 4/3 5>93> ?3*>06; 5)()'( 9*439 ) "663G=>3&$ 2*1139 ?@ >312569364 5 F/3>3=693> >3125693645(/*9>3H3:4394/3*2280:*405670839?@4/3 234040563> 75> :5B2*11056*43 *225064B364 56 4/3 ;>5=69 4/*41/301*B*>>0399*=;/43> ?>037 5=48063 57 7*:41 83*906; 45 70806; 57 4/01 2340405601*1=693>- ( /3 *2280:*64E1 B54/3> B4 334*?*0 F/083 F5>A06;*13:569 0C0105683>A064/3932*>4B364574/3 >3125693641 9039 56 (' 1=>C0C39 ?@ /3> /=1?*69*694/3234040563>/3>306/3*2280:*64?306;4/3 83;*8 /30> 57 4/3 3B285@33 1=?B04439 4/3 >32>31364*4056 - 4 - F04/06 563 @3*> 7>5B 4/3 9*43 57 93*4/ 57 /3> B54/3> 133A06;*225064B36456:5B2*11056*43;>5=69106:3/3> >3<=314F*1654:561093>394/3234040563>*22>5*:/394/3 >0?=6*8 06 *2280:*4056 5& F/0:/ F*1 90125139 57 56 90>3:406; 4/3 >3125693641 45 :561093> 4/3 :*13 57 4/3 *2280:*64 75> :5B2*11056*43 ;>5=69*225064B364F04/06*23>059574/>33B564/1 & =?13<=3648@ ?@ 4/3 0B2=;639 5>93> *4 663G=>3&454/3*2280:*40569*439)(4/3 :8*0B 57 4/3 234040563> F*1 >3H3:439 ?@ >312569364 5( 14*406; 4/*4 4/3 B*>>039 9*=;/43> 57 4/3 93:3*139 3B285@33 01 654 36404839 75> *225064B364 56 :5B2*11056*43 ;>5=69 /01 5>93> 01 :*8839 06 <=314056 ?375>3 4/3 >0?=6*8 06 4/3 *2280:*4056 0B2=;639 06 4/01 23404056 4 F*1 :56436939 ?@ 4/3 234040563> ?375>3 4/3 >0?=6*8 4/*4 4/3 B54/3> 57 4/3 234040563> /*9 *8>3*9@ 65B06*439 /3> *1 65B0633 06 /3> 13>C0:3 >3;0143> 9=>06; /3> 807340B3 !34040563> 01 4/3 568@ 83;*8 /30> 57 /3> - 5 - 93:3*139 B54/3> 1 23> =83 ( 57 4/3 *>6*4*A* 0C08 3>C0:31"225064B364565B2*11056*43>5=69$=831 '"75>1/5>4D'=831E$45:8*0B4/3*225064B36456 :5B2*11056*43 ;>5=691 4/3 23>156 1/5=89 ?3 932369364 56 4/3 93:3*139 5C3>6B364 13>C*64 *69 /*C06; * >38*4056*1F095F1565>=6B*>>0399*=;/43>5>F095F39 9*=;/43> /3 234040563> 01 380;0?83 06 43>B1 57 =83 ( 57 ''=8313H3:4056564/3;>5=694/*44/3234040563>01 * B*>>039 9*=;/43> *B5=641 45 4*A06; *F*@ 4/3 >0;/4 >3:5;60I39?@4/38*F ' /35C3>6B3645>*88@52251394/3*2280:*4056 14*406; 4/*4 4/3 0B2=;639 5>93> 2*1139 ?@ 4/3 5C3>6B364 ?375>3 4/3 >0?=6*8 14*406; 4/*4 4/3 0B2=;6395>93>2*11390106*::5>9*6:3F04/8*F*69*815 >38039 56 4/3 5>93> 9*439 ) 2*1139 06 *2280:*4056 5&( F/3>306 4/3 >0?=6*8 /*1 /389 4/*4 4/3 B*>>039 9*=;/43>1 *>3 654 36404839 75> *225064B36456:5B2361*4056;>5=691 - 6 - ) /3 >0?=6*8 *743> :561093>06; 4/3 >0C*8 1=?B0110561 *69 4/3 3*>803> 5>93> 57 4/3 >0?=6*8 06 *2280:*40565&(>38039?@4/35C3>6B364/389 4/*4 4/3 *B369B364 45 4/3 "$ "B369B364$ =83101654*2280:*?83454/3:*13574/3234040563> *14/3*2280:*4056574/3234040563>012>5123:40C3066*4=>3 *69>3H3:4394/3*2280:*40564014/015>93>57>3H3:405601 =693>:/*8836;3064/32>3136423404056 3*>9B4334**HH*61/344@83*>639:5=6138 *223*>06; 75>4/3 234040563> *69 B4 *@* 83*>639 0;/5=>45C3>6B364!83*93>75>>3125693645145( !3>=1394/33640>3B*43>0*8156>3:5>9 B4 334* *HH*61/344@ C3/3B3648@ 1=?B041 4/*44/3B54/3>574/3234040563>F*1F5>A06;*1 *69 9039 F/083 06 13>C0:3 56 (' BB390*438@ 4/3>3*743> 06 43>B1 57 ' =831 4/3 234040563> 1=?B04439 *6 *2280:*4056 >3<=31406; 45 :561093> /3> :*13 75> *225064B364 56 :5B2*11056*43 ;>5=69 4 4/3 3*>803> 25064 57 40B3 *1 /3> :8*0B F*1 654 :561093>39 1/3 /*9 - 7 - *22>5*:/39 4/3 >0?=6*8 *69 >0?=6*8 /*1 90>3:439 4/3 >3125693641 45 :561093> 4/3 :8*0B 57 4/3 234040563> 06 * 40B3 ?5=69 B*663> =?13<=3648@ /3> >3<=314 :*B3 45 ?3>3H3:439?@3695>13B3649*439)(564/3 ;>5=694/*41/301*B*>>0399*=;/43>*6901654380;0?83 75>*225064B36456:5B2*11056*43;>5=69 /383*>639:5=6138F5=891=?B044/*40643>B1 57 B369B364 45 =831 ' 4/3 234040563> 01 380;0?83 75> *225064B364 56 :5B2*11056*43 ;>5=69 /3 F5=89 *815 1=?B04 4/*4 *1 4/3 *B369B364 01 ?@ F*@ 57 1=?1404=4056 4/3 *B369B364 F5=89 ?3 >34>5123:40C3 *69 4/3234040563>F5=89?33640483975>4/3?36370457*B36939 =8315?=44>311/3>*>;=B3644/383*>639:5=6138 >38039 56 4/3 H=9;B364 57 4/3 55>906*43 36:/ 57 4/01 5=>4064/3:*1357 *69 1=?B041 4/*4 4/3 5 5>906*43 36:/ /*1 /389 4/*4 4/3 B369B364 45 '=831/*1>34>5123:40C33773:406:34/3*B369B364 1 !5'&"$ ()& - 8 - 01?@F*@571=?1404=405636:31/315=;/445*885F4/3 234040560643>B1574/35>93>2*1139?@4/355>906*4357 4/015=>4064/3F>042340405614*439 B4 *@* >37=406; 4/3 1=?B0110561 57 83*>639 :5=6138 75> 4/3 234040563> F5=89 1=225>4 4/3 5>93> 2*1139 ?@ 4/3 >0?=6*8 F/083 15 1=225>406; 4/3 5>93> 2*1139 ?@ 4/3 >0?=6*8 1/3 F5=89 :564369 4/*4 4/3 *225064B364 56 :5B2*11056*43 ;>5=69 :*6654?3:8*0B39*1*B*443>57>0;/423>156F5=89;34 *>0;/445133A*225064B364564/3:5B2*11056*43;>5=691 568@ 07 /31/3 01 75=69 380;0?83 06 43>B1 57 ' =831 F/0:/ F3>3 3G01406; *1 56 4/3 9*43 57 93*4/ 57 4/3 5C3>6B36413>C*64 ( 64/30614*64:*134/3B54/3>574/3234040563> 9039F/0830613>C0:356('*1564/31*099*43 4/3>3 01 65 2>5C01056 45 :561093> 4/3 *2280:*4056 57 * B*>>039 9*=;/43> :8*0B06; 45 ?3 4/3 932369364 57 4/3 93:3*1395C3>6B36413>C*6464/3*?136:357*6@1=:/ 2>5C01056 06 4/3 =83 4/3 234040563> ?306; 4/3 B*>>039 - 9 - 9*=;/43> 01 654380;0?83 45?3 :561093>39 75>*225064B364 56 :5B2*11056*43 ;>5=69 /3 >0?=6*8 01 H=1407039 06 >3H3:406;4/3*2280:*4056*6975885F06;4/33*>803>5>93>57 4/3>0?=6*806*2280:*40565&(F/3>306>380*6:3 F*128*:39564/3H=9;B364574/356.?8323G5=>406 4/3 :*13 57 ! "#!$ % &! % /58906; 4/*4 4/3 *B369B364 01 2>5123:40C3 06 6*4=>3 *69 654 >34>5123:40C3 ::5>906;8@ 15=;/4 45 901B0114/323404056 & *C06;/3*>94/383*>639:5=613875>4/32*>4031 *695623>=1*8574/33640>3F>04234040562*23>14/3568@ 250644/*4*>51375>5=>:561093>*405601*175885F- ! "!" #$ %& =>*61F3>454/3*?5C32506475>:561093>*4056 010663;*40C3/58906;4/*44/3>0?=6*801654H=140703906 901B01106;4/3*2280:*4056:5670>B06;4/35>93>2*1139?@ 2 ($)) - 10 - >312569364 14*439 06 4/3 25064 75> :561093>*4056 75> 4/3 75885F06;- !! ' 4014>=34/*4*:8*0B75>:5B2*11056*43;>5=69 01654*B*443>57>0;/4?=44/39323693641574/313>C*64 :5=89 133A 75> *225064B364 56 :5B2*11056*43 ;>5=69 =693> 4/3 3G01406; :/3B3 5> 3G01406; =831 >38*406; 45 1=:/ *225064B364 6 4/3 4*43 57 *>6*4*A* 1=:/ :/3B301>3;=8*439=693>'=8311:5=89?31336 7>5B4/3>3:5>912>05>45B369B3644/325104056 *1 14559 =693> =831 ' 4/3>3 F*1 65 2>5C01056 75> :561093>*4056 57 *2280:*4056 75> *225064B364 56 :5B2*11056*43 ;>5=69 ?@ * B*>>039 9*=;/43> 57 4/3 93:3*139 5C3>6B364 13>C*64 /3 83*>639 06;83 #=9;3 57 4/01 5=>4 06 4/3:*13 57 4/3% '! # ! (/*1/389 4/*4 4/3 =83 14*431 4/*4 4/3 B*>>039 9*=;/43>1 *>3 654 ?306; 36404839 75> :5B2*11056*43 *225064B364 45 ?3 =6:561404=4056*8=?13<=3648@4/393:01056574/383*>639 3 "' - 11 - 06;83H=9;314*439"$F*1:*883906<=314056?375>3 4/3 0C01056 36:/ 57 4/01 5=>4 *69 4/3 1*09 2>525104056 /*1 ?336 :5670>B39 ?@ 4/3 0C01056 36:/ F/0:/ F*1 =840B*438@4*A36454/356.?8323G5=>4*69*770>B39*1 F388 ) 6 4/*4 C03F 57 4/3 B*443> 4/3 4*43 5C3>6B364 =693> 654070:*4056 9*439 & ?>5=;/4 *B369B364 45 =831 ' 45 3G2*69 4/3 9370604056 57 * 93:3*139 5C3>6B364 13>C*64 45 06:8=93 9*=;/43> "=6B*>>039B*>>03990C5>:39F095F39$ F/5 *>3 93236906; =256 /0B 5> /3> /3 *B369B364 ?>5=;/4 45 =83"$57=831'>3*91*175885F1- )! * & )+ ' () *+ + ,- * . / 0 112 , / ' 0 3, / , / ,/ # $43 5,/ 5 . + +5 $ . ++# #+ # . + + # 6 3 , / 7!5 - 12 - ,/ ,/ # $43 5,/5$5 3 ,/ . + + # # , + # #/ # # #+#8 ,/ . + + ,+ # #/ # # # # # +# 8 ,/ . + + # # #+#8 ,+/ . + + # # #+# ,+/ . ++# # # +#) + +#!5 - 13 - 3*906;57*?5C3*B369B364:83*>*19*@80;/4 4/*4 4/3 B369B364 45 4/3 =831 ' 01 ?@ F*@ 57 1=?1404=4056 6C03F5713448392>525104056578*F4/*407*6@ *B369B364 01 ?>5=;/4 *1 * 1=?1404=4056 45 4/3 3G01406; =831 04 F5=89 ?3 >34>5123:40C3 06 6*4=>3 03 7>5B 4/3 9*43574/35>0;06*8=831?>5=;/4064575>:3 1 :5=89 ?3 1336 7>5B 4/3 >3:5>91 4/3 568@ >3*156 75> >3H3:4056 57 4/3 :8*0B 57 4/3 234040563> 01 4/*4 1/3 01 * B*>>039 9*=;/43> *69 01 654 380;0?83 =693> 4/3 =8313G0406; 4/3>3 2>05>454/3 *B369B364 /325104056 578*F/*1*8>3*9@?336:83*>39?@4/355>906*4336:/ 57 4/01 5=>4 06 ,/ F/3>306 123:070:*88@ *4 2*>*;>*2/ 51 ' J ) 4/=1 4/01 5=>4 /*1 /389*175885F1- 2! 9+ + $ # $ + ! - 14 - : $ ++!' + 0 $ ) ) # ! 0 + # 55# # 55! ! ' + +# +# 0 $ # $ !& /38*F0165F1344839157*>*1*2280:*?0804@57 *B36939=83145*2280:*4056?@*B*>>0399*=;/43> 57 * 93:3*139 5C3>6B36413>C*64 F/5 9039 2>05>454/3 *B369B364 /3 H=9;B364 57 "/ 1=?13<=3648@ 75885F39 ?@ * 55>906*43 36:/ 57 4/01 5=>4 06 >04 !3404056 5'"$ 9*439 (& 6 C03F 57 4/3 :561014364 H=90:0*8 2>565=6:3B3641 57 4/3 55>906*43 36:/ 57 4/01 5=>4 - 15 - *69 06 C03F 57 4/3 1344839 25104056 57 8*F 4/*4 F/363C3> *6@ *B369B364 01 ?>5=;/4 ?@ F*@ 57 1=?1404=4056 4/3 1*B31/5=89?3>3*9*1074/3@F3>34/3>3564/39*@4/3 =831:*B3064575>:30304>38*431?*:A45=831'' 4/39*@56F/0:/04F*1?>5=;/4064575>:3 6 4/*4 C03F 57 4/3 B*443> F3 /*C3 65 /3104*405645/5894/*44/3>0?=6*8=693>*B01:56:324056 574/32>525104056578*F/3894/*44/3*B369B364?>5=;/4 012>5123:40C3066*4=>3*69654*2280:*?83454/3:*1357 4/3 234040563> 1 1=:/ 4/3 706906; 57 4/3 >0?=6*8 01 B0128*:39*11=:/:*6654?3*::32439 ( 64/380;/4574/3*?5C3>3*1561 F32*114/3 75885F06;- 0 /3>04!340405601&&' 00 >93> 9*439 && 06 *2280:*4056 5('( 2*1139 ?@ 4/3 >0?=6*8 01 134 *1093 5613<=3648@ *2280:*4056 - 16 - 5('(70839?@4/3234040563>?375>3 4/3>0?=6*801*885F39 000 695>13B3645>93> ?3*>06; 5) ()'( 9*439 )"663G=>3&$ 2*1139 ?@ >312569364 5( 01 /3>3?@ <=*1/39 0C 312569364 51 45 ( *>3 90>3:439 45 :561093> 4/3 *2280:*4056 57 4/3 234040563> 9*439 75> *225064B364 56 :5B2*11056*43 ;>5=691 06 43>B1 57 ' =831 2*>40:=8*>8@ 4*A06; 6543 57 *B369B364 =693> 654070:*4056 9*439 & F04/5=4 >*0106; 4/3 5?H3:40561 4/*44/3234040563>01*B*>>0399*=;/43> C 8854/3>011=31*>3A324523645?393:0939 ?@4/3>312569364106*::5>9*6:3F04/8*F C0 0B375>:5B280*6:3014F5B564/17>5B4/3 9*4357>3:302457:3>407039:52@574/015>93> - 17 - C00 55>93>*145:5141 !() &!!' # !() &%' # ! 0145-85-&& -#