- 1 - ! "!#$!$ $ % !"#$$ % & '( ' ') !$# % & ( * $" * $+$ * , * , *, Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - * -, ' ./0 123/3/45 /0 6/728 9: 3.2 123/3/452; </62 022=/5> 3;?5062;464$+$1258/5>453.26/724625/4; /@/7,A8>2 ?5>?@?3/3425/4;/@/7,A8>2/5>0?>A; $ 2?;872?;528B4A502764;3.2123/3/452; 501/32 4602;@/B246543/B23.2;201458253;2C?/528?90253?58 A5;21;2025328 .2 ;201458253 .?0 6/728 3.2 123/3/45 022=/5> 8/0047A3/45 46 C?;;/?>2 /5 4$+$ ?58 /3 /0 1258/5>453.26/724625/4;/@/7,A8>2 ?5>?@?3/.2 123/3/452;<.4/0;2014582533.2;2/5/0022=/5>3;?5062;46 3.2123/3/456;4C ?5>?@?3/34/5>0?>A;.2123/3/452;/0 022=/5>3;?5062;453.2>;4A583.?30.2/0;20/8/5>?745> </3.3<4C/54;B./78;25?3/5>0?>A;?58/3/0/5B45@25/253 64;.2;34?332584A;3?3 ?5>?@?3/<./B./0?38/03?5B246 $"+ ' 6;4C /5>0?>A; .2 123/3/452; .?0 ?704 6/728 - 3 - 123/3/45022=/5>C?/5325?5B2 A582; 2B3/45 #"" 46 ?58 /3 /0 1258/5> /5 ;7/0B4#$$+$" 45 3.2 6/72 46 25/4;/@/7,A8>2/5>0?>A; " ?@/5> .2?;8 72?;528 B4A5027 3./0 4A;3 .?0 12;A028123/3/451?12;0 5 3.2 B?A02 3/372 46 3.2 123/3/45 /5 4$+$ ;20/825B2 46 3.2 ;201458253 <.4 /0 123/3/452;.2;2/5/00.4<5?0 A;A>A53?/77?>2/5>0?>A; ?7A='?7?9A;?>//03;/B3.2123/3/452;/0;20/8/5>/53.2 0?/8 @/77?>2 ?745> </3. .2; 3<4 C/54; B./78;25 3 /0 /5B45@25/25364;3.2123/3/452;343;?@276;4C.2;@/77?>234 ?5>?@?3/ <./B. /0 ?3 8/03?5B2 46 $"+ ' 34 ?33258 C?3;/C45/?7B?02 .2 45D972 12E 4A;3 /5 3.2 B?02 46 1 .?0 .278 ?0 A582;F 1 Reported in AIR 2022 SC 4318 - 4 - ! " # # #$ # " # % " & ' ! % % ( #" ) 450/82;/5> 3.2 ?94@2 ?012B3 /6 3.2 B?02 /0 543 3;?5062;;28 ?0 04A>.3 /3 </77 B?A02 /5B45@25/25B2 34 3.2 123/3/452;.2123/3/452;.?0C?824A3B?0264;3;?5062; ?004A>.3 53.2;20A733.264774</5> - 5 - /( .2123/3/45/0 //( 4$+$ 1258/5> 45 3.2 6/72 46 3.2 25/4; /@/7 ,A8>2 ?5>?@?3/ /0 4;82;28 34 92 </3.8;?<5 ?58 3;?5062;;28 34 25/4; /@/7 ,A8>2 /5>0?>A; 34 8/01402 46 3.2 B?02 /5 ?BB4;8?5B2</3.7?< &' ($!$) # /034#74