- 1 - ! " # $%&$'()%*&$(( + !"#$%$ !"$%& ' ' (&) ("& * $ $" % ' "$ % $%"""% *& !%& ( * $)#$ Digitally signed by NIJAMUDDIN JAMKHANDI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ' *' ' +' '' ,-./01234-50-12123426728-59:/..;6-53$<,326 1,-,;69/45371,-5-.-/6-56--=24>>?/4137?->;8/?9/28 ;45-?-.1234("&37,/?/12://>/?2=;?/=6,//4,21/ %&243$" %/?2624>3;137?2@-3" % 73? 1,- 377-4.-6 0;426,/98- ;45-? -.12346 $%" " "% ?-/5 <21, & 37 ,/?/12:/ :/:/ /4,21/ %& /45 ;45-?-.1234(373<?:?3,2921234.1$)#$ ?2-78: 61/1-5 1,- ./6- 37 1,- 0?36-.;1234 26 1,/134$A%A%/1/93;1#%%0@1,-7/1,-?371,- 5-.-/6-5 835>-5 / .3@08/241 /88->24> 1,/1 ,26 5/;>,1-? </6 >2B-4 24 @/??2/>- 13 /..;6-5 3$ /45 1,/1 1,- @/??2/>-</6638-@42C-534$%(%(126/88->-51,/1 /..;6-5 3$ ?-.-2B-5 53<?: 24 1,- 73?@ 37 ./6, /@3;4124>13%%%%% !/834><21,>3853?4/@-416,- - 3 - .3@08/2417;?1,-?/88->-61,/11,-5-.-/6-5</66;9D-.1-5 13 .?;-81: 24 .344-.1234 <21, 0-?6261-41 5-@/45 73? /5521234/8 53<?: 1 26 61/1-5 1,/1 1,3;>, 1,- 5-.-/6-5 ,/5.34.-2B-56,-</6/88->-58:73?.-5131-?@24/1-1,- 0?->4/4.: 1 26 7;?1,-? /88->-5 1,/1 34 $#%A% /1 /93;1%%0@1,-5-.-/6-5.341/.1-5,-?@31,-?;624> 1,-@3928- 0,34- 37 /..;6-53$/45 2473?@-5 ,-?1,/1 6,- </6 9-24> ,/?/66-5 9: ,-? ,;69/45 /45 @31,-?!24! 8/< 34 /..3;41 37 /5521234/8 53<?: 5-@/456 ;96-E;-418: /..;6-5 3$ 2473?@-5 1,- .3@08/24/41 1,/11,-5-.-/6-5,/5.3@@211-56;2.25-9:,/4>24> & 034 ?;6,24> 13 1,- @/1?2@342/8 ,3@- 1,- .3@08/24/4173;451,-935:37,265/;>,1-?,/4>24>7?3@ /4--@1?--;45-?6;602.23;6.2?.;@61/4.-6/6-5341,- 6/25 .3@08/241 ?2@- 3"$ % </6 ?->261-?-5 /45 ;034 .3@08-1234 37 24B-612>/1234 .,/?>- 6,--1 ,/6 9--4 8/25 - 4 - ( -/?4-5 .3;46-8 73? 1,- 0-121234-? ?-21-?/124> 1,->?3;456;?>-5241,-0-121234/4508/.24>?-82/4.-34 1,- .,/?>- 6,--1 @/1-?2/86 0/?12.;8/?8: 1,- 7;?1,-? 61/1-@-41 37 1,- .3@08/24/41F7/1,-? 37 1,- 5-.-/6-5 <3;85 6;9@21 1,/1 1,- .3@08/24/41 ,/6 ./1->3?2./88: /5@211-5 1,/1 ,26 5/;>,1-? </6 431 73?.-5 13 ;45-?>3 /93?1234 -7-??24>131,-6-@/1-?2/86,-6;9@2161,/11,- 0-121234-? </6 /00?-,-45-5 34 $"%A% /45 1,/1 1,- 24B-612>/1234 ,/B24> 9--4 .3@08-1-5 /45 .,/?>- 6,--1 728-5.34124;-524./?.-?/1234371,-0-121234-?<3;856-?B- 43;6-7;80;?036-/45<3;85247?24>-,26?2>,113827-/45 0-?634/8 829-?1: >;/?/41--5 ;45-? ?12.8- $ 37 1,- 346121;1234 37 452/ - <3;85 7;?1,-? .341-45 1,/1 1,- .,/?>- 6,--1 @/1-?2/86 53 431 526.836- 1,- -66-412/824>?-52-41637377-4.-60;426,/98-;45-?-.12346 &%# /45 &%(! 37 1,- 452/4 -4/8 35- $"#% - 6;9@216 1,/1 1,- 0-121234-? 26 <28824> 13 /925- 9: /4: 61?24>-41 .345212346 1,/1 @/: 9- 2@036-5 9: 1,26 3;?1 /451,-?-73?-6--=6-48/?>-@-41371,-0-121234-?349/28 - 5 - 8-/?4-5 2>, 3;?1 3B-?4@-41 8-/5-? ?-7-??24> 13 1,- .,/?>- 6,--1 @/1-?2/86 ,/6 B-,-@-418:30036-51,-0-121234/456;9@211-51,/11,-?- 266;772.2-41 @/1-?2/82452./124>1,-24B38B-@-41 371,-0-121234-?241,-/88->-5377-4.-6/451,-?-73?-1,26 26431/721./6-73?>?/41379/28 # /B24>,-/?51,-8-/?4-5.3;46-8/00-/?24>73? 1,-0/?12-6/45340-?;6/8371,-.,/?>-6,--1@/1-?2/86 1,263;?1,/6>2B-4216/4G23;6.34625-?/1234131,-?2B/8 6;9@2662346,-73883<24>03241/?26-673?.34625-?/1234 A ,- 0?36-.;1234 ./6- /6 4312.-5 6;0?/ 0?3.--56 34 1,- /88->/1234 1,/1 1,- 5-.-/6-5 </6 6;9D-.1-513.?;-81:/45,/?/66@-419:,-?,;69/45/45 24!8/<624.344-.1234<21,5-@/4573?53<?:/451,/16,- </6 /88->-58: 73?.-5 13 1-?@24/1- ,-? 0?->4/4.: <,2., - 6 - ;812@/1-8: 5?3B- ,-? 13 1/=- 1,- -G1?-@- 61-0 3<-B-? 1,- 7;?1,-? 61/1-@-41 37 1,- .3@08/24/41 ?-.3?5-5 34 $A%A%/66;@-6?-8-B/4.-/11,2661/>-24637/?/6,- ,/661/1-51,-?-241,/143935:.3@0-88-51,-5-.-/6-513 ;45-?>3 /93?1234 /45 1,/1 1,- 6/@- </6 34 /..3;41 37 -G.-662B-98--524> " 11,26D;4.1;?-1,263;?126371,-.34625-?-5 B2-<1,/1<,-1,-?1,-.345;.1/11?29;1-5131,-0-121234-? 4/@-8:/88->-5.?;-81:/45,/?/66@-4124.344-.1234<21, 53<?: 5-@/45 </6 37 6;., 241-4621: /6 13 5?2B- 1,- 5-.-/6-5 13 .3@@21 6;2.25- 26 / @/11-? 1,/1 ?-E;2?-6 /5D;52./12345;?24>1,-.3;?6-37/7;88!78-5>-51?2/8 ) ,- 34H98- 0-G 3;?1 24 / ./1-4/ 37 5-.262346,/6.346261-418:,-851,/1136;61/24/.34B2.1234 ;45-?-.1234&%#371,-?-@;619-.3>-41@/1-?2/8 2452./124> 1,/1 1,- /..;6-5 ,/5 9: ,26 /.16 3? .345;.1 .?-/1-5.2?.;@61/4.-68-/B24>1,-5-.-/6-5<21,43301234 9;1 13 .3@@21 6;2.25- 1 ,/6 7;?1,-? 9--4 ,-85 1,/1 1,- - 7 - 377-4.-?-E;2?-60?33737 /45/52?-.13?/.12B- /.1 37 24612>/1234 4 1,- 0?-6-41 ./6- 24B-612>/1234 26 .3@08-1-/45.,/?>-6,--1,/69--4728-5,-0-121234-? ,/69--424D;52.2/8.;6135:624.-$"%A%34625-?24> 1,/1 .?2@24/8 1?2/86 24B/?2/98: 1/=- .34625-?/98- 12@- 1,26 3;?1 26 37 1,- B2-< 1,/1 .34124;-5 5-1-41234 37 1,- 0-121234-? /1 1,26 61/>- 26 431 </??/41-5 ,- /00?-,-462346 -G0?-66-5 9: 1,- 0?36-.;1234 ./4 9- /5-E;/1-8:6/7->;/?5-59:2@03624>61?24>-41.345212346 ..3?524>8:1,-0324173?.34625-?/123426/46<-?-5241,- /772?@/12B- $% 3? 1,- 73?->324> ?-/6346 1,26 3;?1 0?3.--56 130/661,-73883<24> 2 ,-?2@24/8-12123426/883<-5 22 ,- 0-121234-? /..;6-5 3$ 6,/88 9- -48/?>-5 34 ?->;8/? 9/28 24 3$" % /?2624> 3;1 37 ?2@- - 8 - 3"$ %?->261-?-573?1,-377-4.-60;426,/98-;45-? -.12346 $%" " /45 "% ?-/5 <21, -.1234 & 37 1,- ,/?/12:/:/://4,21/%&/45-.1234(371,-3<?: ?3,2921234 .1 $)#$ 0-4524> 34 1,- 728- 37 1,- 8-/?4-5 ?24.20/8 -662346 ;5>- 2D/:/0;? 6;9D-.1 13 1,- 73883<24>.345212346 / ,- 0-121234-? 6,/88 -G-.;1- / 0-?634/8 9345 73? / 6;@ 37 6$%%%%% ! ;0--6 4- /=, 348: <21, 1<3 6;?-12-6 73? 1,- 82=- 6;@ 13 1,- 6/1267/.1234371,-D;?2652.1234/83;?1I 9 ,- 0-121234-? 6,/88 431 1/@0-? <21, 1,- 0?36-.;1234 <214-66-6 3? ,/@0-? 1,- .3;?6- 37 24B-612>/12343?1?2/824/4:@/44-?I . ,- 0-121234-? 6,/88 /00-/? 9-73?- 1,- ?2/8 3;?1 34 /88 5/1-6 37 ,-/?24> ;48-66 -G-@01-5 9:1,-3;?173?B/825?-/6346I - 9 - 5,-0-121234-?6,/8843124B38B-,2@6-8724/4: .?2@24/8 /.12B21: 3? 24 /4: 377-4.- 37 / 62@28/? 4/1;?-5;?24>1,-0-45-4.:371,-1?2/8I - ,-0-121234-? 6,/88 431 8-/B- 1,- D;?2652.1234 37 1,- ?2/8 3;?1 <21,3;1 391/2424> 0?23? 0-?@266234 7?3@ 1,- 6/25 3;?1 ;4128 .34.8;6234 371,-1?2/8 222 238/1234 37 /4: 37 1,- /93B- .345212346 6,/88 -41218-1,-0?36-.;1234136--=./4.-88/1234379/28 ,) $ ( # 2613$83$