- 1 - !"#"" "$$ %& %'% '' ( ! " " #$%$!& $ #$%$'!( " !) Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - " !*# " !+&,&$ - !&%$&$ #$ !*%&$ " " "" "" !%+ !+! !+!' !!%! !!% !&' '$ '** '$! !+& " &' '! . / ' 0 " " " " - !*%&$ " 1 #" 1 23 455366478 93:7; 4<<=/3> ?!& 4/ 53. @:746 .35?.8@:63>:7.:A3?!*%&$?@647> ?6:<3848:?7 4649=.4;: >:/8.:<8 B:82:7 823 C=.:/>:<8:?7 ?@ 634.73> >>:8:?746 :/8.:<8 47> 3//:?7/ =>;3 4649=.4;: .3;:/83.3> @?. 823 ?@@37<3/ 5=7:/24963 =7>3. 3<8:?7/ !%+ !+! !+!' !!%! !!% (! $$!&' - 3 - '$ '** '$! .34> B:82 3<8:?7 !+& ?@ 24.48:D4 D4D4 472:84 &' @?. /2?.8 E &'- 47> =7>3. 3<8:?7/'! . / 47>0 ?@823<23>=63>4/83/47> <23>=63>.:93/ .30378:?7?@8.?<:8:3/ <8!+%+@?. /2?.8E <8- ://33F:7;;.478?@.3;=64.94:6 34.> .: 4C3/2 ?>>4A47: 634.73> ?=7/36 @?. 823 455366478 47> .: ?546F.:/274 4>40 634.73> :;2 ?=.8 ?03.7A378 634>3. @?. .3/5?7>378 ?! # 8483 3/5?7>378 ? 82?=;2 /3.03> B:82 823 7?8:<3 24/ .3A4:73> =7#.35.3/3783> 3.=/3> 823 A483.:46/ ?7 .3<?.> ' 7 0:3B ?@ 823 .:046 <?78378:?7/ =.;3> 9D 823 634.73><?=7/36@?.9?8282354.8:3/8235?:788248B?=6> 4.:/3@?.AD<?7/:>3.48:?7:/ !"#$% - 4 - D47/B3.8?82349?035?:78:/:7823E - @?.823@?66?B:7; * 23 :7@?.A478 93:7; 823 @4823.#:7#64B ?@ 823 >3<34/3>6?>;3>@:./8:7@?.A48:?74;4:7/84<<=/3>?/!8? ' @?. 240:7; <4=/3> 823 >3482 ?@ 823 >3<34/3> 47> 4//4=68:7; 823 3D3B:873//3/ =.:7; :703/8:;48:?7 82:/ 455366478B4/455.3237>3>4..4D:7;2:A4/4<<=/3>?$ ?B823:703/8:;48:?7:/<?A56383>47><24.;3/2338<4A3 8?93@:63>47>823455366478:/4..4D3>4/4<<=/3>?!& /53.<?6=A7?!,?@823<24.;3/2338:8B4/4<<=/3> ?/!8?$B:82<?AA?7:78378:?78?<4=/3823>3482?@ >3<34/3>4//4=683>2:AB:82<6=94/4.3/=68?@B2:<223 >:3> ?7 823 /5?8 <<=/3> ?/! 8? ' 2403 4//4=683> !*B:82823/4A3B345?747><4=/3>:7C=.:3/8?2:A 23.34@83. 4<<=/3> ?/( 8? !& <4A3 8? 823 /5?8 <?7/5:.3>B:824<<=/3>?!47>4668234<<=/3>2403@63> @.?A823/5?88://8483>8248!*8?!+4.3 8233D3B:873//3/8?823:7<:>378 - 5 - $ /53.<24.;3/2338:8:/?76D4<<=/3>?/!8? $ B2? 4.3 823 4//4:6478/ B2? <4=/3> 823 >3482 ?@ 823 >3<34/3> 47> <4=/3> :7C=.:3/ 8? 823 3D3B:873//3/ ? /=<2 ?03.8#4<8 :/ 4663;3> 4;4:7/8 823 5.3/378 455366478 B2? :/ 4..4D3> 4/ 4<<=/3> ?!& :7 823 <24.;3 /2338 682?=;2 823 455366478 :/ 4 54.8D 8? 823 <?7/5:.4<D :8 :/ 7?8823<?78378:?7?@8235.?/3<=8:?7824823:/240:7;47D <.:A:746 4783<3>378/ ?7/:>3.:7; 466 823/3 @4<8/ 47> <:.<=A/847<3/ 4A ?@ 823 ?5:7:?7 8248 823 455366478 :/ 7?8.3G=:.3>8?93>384:73>:7<=/8?>D@?.47D5=.5?/347> 823/4A3B?=6>4A?=788?:7@.:7;3A378?@2:/.:;288?6:@3 47>6:93.8D34/?74963<?7>:8:?7/A4D93:A5?/3>B2:63 3764.;:7;823455366478?794:6B2:<2B:6684F3<4.3?@823 :783.3/8 ?@ 823 5.?/3<=8:?7 :7<6=>:7; 823 :783.3/8 ?@ 823 <?A564:747847>823B:873//3/<<?.>:7;6D47/B3.823 49?03 5?:78 :7 823 47> 5.?<33> 8? 54// 823 @?66?B:7; : 23455346:/ - 6 - :: 23455366478:/?.>3.3>8?933764.;3>?794:6 :7.:A3?!*%&$?@647> ?6:<3848:?74649=.4;: :/8.:<8 7?B 537>:7; ?7 823 @:63 ?@ 634.73> >>:8:?746 :/8.:<8 47> 3//:?7/ =>;3 4649=.4;: ?7 ?984:7:7; 823 9?7>:74/=A?@/&&&&&#=533/B?4F2/?76D B:828B?/=.38:3/@?.8236:F3/=A8?823/48:/@4<8:?7?@823 C=.:/>:<8:?746?=.8/=9C3<88?823@?66?B:7;<?7>:8:?7/ 4 23 455366478 /2466 7?8 <?AA:8 /:A:64. ?@@37<3/ 9 23455366478/24667?882.34837?.84A53. B:828235.?/3<=8:?7B:873//3/ < 23455366478/246645534.93@?.3823?=.84/ 47>B237.3G=:.3> ::: @ :7 <4/3 823 455366478 0:?6483/ 47D ?@ 823 <?7>:8:?7/ 4/ /8483> 49?03 823 5.?/3<=8:?7 B:66 93 48 6:93.8D 8? A?03 823 .:46 ?=.8 /33F:7; <47<36648:?7 ?@ 94:6 :0 7@=.7:/2:7;823/=.38:3/9D823455366478823 .:46?=.8:/486:93.8D8?>:.3<8823703/8:;48:7; @@:<3.8? - 7 - 03.:@D 823 <?..3<873// ?@ 823 4>>.3// 47> 4=82378:<:8D ?@ 823>?<=A378/@=.7:/23>9D82345536647847>823/=.38:3/ 47>4.35?.8A4D93<4663>@?.:78248.3;4.>B2:<2:/8? 93 /=9A:883> 9D 823 703/8:;48:7; @@:<3. B:82:7 $ >4D/ 23.:46?=.8?7/48:/@4<8:?7A4D5.?<33>8?4<<358823 /=.38:3/@?.8235=.5?/3?@.3634/:7;823455366478?794:6 )& %""' # :/8?!6?!$