- 1 - ! "!# $#!%!## #&! '()'*+,'!!++ - !"#$%$ & ' ( ) !"#$%$ *+, & ' ( ) -. )' ( /-" // ) %-'( %/%%/ %" %- Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ) ) ) $-%$%- ) /%$ %$" ) )) . -- --" -%/'( ) ) ) 0 ' 0 ( 1232,4,452+62457,12899*:2;45/%$ %$" 5 ,12 <4=2 < ,12 =28+52; 254+ 4>4= *;72 85; ) 8:8>858 872?8;4 @<+ :1+, A,12 +48= *+,BC 4: 4D3*75457,12E*;7D25,;8,2;$-%$%-95>49,45714D <+,12<<2592:3*54:186=2*5;2+29,45:.----" 85;-%/<,125;485258=;2$"#%@<+:1+,A,12 BC85;:25,259457,*5;2+7:4D3=24D3+4:5D25,<+8 32+4; < # D5,1: <+ ,12 <<2592 3*54:186=2 *5;2+ 29,45.<F,*5;2+7:4D3=24D3+4:5D25,<+8 32+4; < - D5,1: <+ ,12 <<2592 3*54:186=2 *5;2+ 29,45--<F,*5;2+7:4D3=24D3+4:5D25,<+8 - 3 - 32+4; < # D5,1: <+ ,12 <<2592 3*54:186=2 *5;2+ 29,45--"<F85;,*5;2+7:4D3=24D3+4:5D25, <+ 8 32+4; < $ G28+ <+ ,12 <<2592 3*54:186=2 *5;2+ 29,45 -%/ < ?1491 ?8: 95<4+D2; 45 +4D458= 3328= " %- 5 ,12 <4=2 < ,12 =28+52; ;;4,458= 4:,+49, 85; 2::45: *;72 4E8G83*+8 @<+ :1, A)4+:, 332==8,2*+,BC>4;2E*;7D25,;8,2;%/%%/ 12 <89,: < ,12 98:2 45 6+42< 8+2 ,18, 5 $-%%$# ?125 ?8: +4;457 ,12 D,+ 9G9=2 8=57 ?4,1 14: ?4<2 85; ,? D45+ 914=;+25 5 34==45 899*:2; 62457 ,12 ;+4>2+ < ,12 6=2+ E223 628+457 27 " .$#!;+>2,12:8D2458+8:185;527=4725,D8552+ 85; 8, 1471 :322; : 8: , 25;8572+ ,12 =4<2 < 3*6=49 ;8:12;,,12D,+9G9=25,12=2<,:4;2<,12+8;8:8 +2:*=,<?1491 +4;2+85;,1234==45+4;2+:<2==;?5 85;;2928:2;62457,12:5<: $85;872;!G28+: ;42;5,128994;25,$85;85;,124+,12+914=; 8=: :*:,8452; 45E*+42: 12+26G ,12 899*:2; 18: 9DD4,,2;,128<+2D25,452;<<2592: - 4 - - 12+48=*+,,H9754I8592<,12<<2592: 85; +274:,2+2; ,12 9+4D458= 98:2 12 899*:2; 18; 83328+2; 62<+2 ,12 +48= *+, 3=28;2; 5, 7*4=,G 85; 9=84D2; , 62 ,+42; 12 3+:29*,45 2J8D452; $ , # 85; 7, D8+H2; J:$ , $- 45 :*33+, < 4,: 95,25,4512899*:2;18:;2542;8==,12459+4D458,+G D8,2+48=:8>84=86=25+29+;6*,18:5,=2;85G2>4;2592 45:*33+,<14:;2<259212+48=*+,8<,2+,8H45745, 95:4;2+8,45 8== ,12:2 D8,2+48=: 5 +29+; 98D2 , ,12 959=*:45 ,18, ,12 3+:29*,45 4: :*992::<*= 45 3+>457 ,12 7*4=, < ,12 899*:2; 62G5; +28:586=2 ;*6, 85; 899+;457=G38::2;,124D3*752;E*;7D25,<95>49,45 85; +;2+ < :25,2592 2457 877+42>2; 6G ,12 :8D2 899*:2; 18; 3+2<2++2; +4D458= 3328= " %- 12 )4+:,332==8,2*+,5+2 833+2948,45<,12D8,2+48=:5 +29+;;4:D4::2;,1283328=6G95<4+D457,124D3*752; E*;7D25, < 95>49,45 85; +;2+ < :25,2592 38::2; 6G ,12+48=*+,2457877+42>2;6G,12:8D2,12899*:2; 4:62<+2,14:*+, - 5 - / 28+; +4 14>8585; 8,,858:12,,G =28+52; 9*5:2=<+,12+2>4:4532,4,452+85;+4 38=H+4:158 8;8> =28+52; 471 *+, >2+5D25, =28;2+ <+ ,12 +2:35;25, ,8,2 2+*:2; ,12 D8,2+48=: 5 +29+; 459=*;457,12+48=*+,+29+;: ! 5 >42? < ,12 +4>8= :*6D4::45: D8;2 6G ,12 =28+52;9*5:2=<+6,1,1238+,42:,12345,,18,?*=; 8+4:2<+DG95:4;2+8,454: G 85:?2+ , ,12 86>2 345, 4: <+,12<==?457 !! # >25 ,1*71 ,12 32,4,452+ 18: +84:2; :2>2+8= 7+*5;: 45 ,12 +2>4:45 32,4,45 =28+52; 9*5:2= <+ ,12 32,4,452+ 18: +2:,+49,2; 14: 8+7*D25, 5=G , :22H - 6 - =254259G ?14=2 :25,259457 ,12 899*:2; 32,4,452+ <+ ,12 <<2592 3*54:186=2 *5;2+ 29,45 -%/ < 28+52; 9*5:2= :3294<498==G :*6D4,,2; ,18, ,12 32,4,452+ 4: 5, +84:457 85G ,12+ 7+*5; , :22H 89K*4,,8= 99+;457=G 3+8G:<+38::457833+3+48,2+;2+: 28+52; 471 *+, >2+5D25, =28;2+ 33:457 ,12 3=28 <+ :1?457 85G =254259G 45 <8>*+ < ,12 899*:2; 32,4,452+ :*6D4,,2; ,18, ,12 D45+ 914=; 872;<4>2G28+:;42;;*2,,128994;25,$85; 18>2 :*:,8452; 45E*+42: 5;2+ :*91 94+9*D:,8592: 5 =254259G9*=;62:1?545<8>*+<,1232,4,452+ " 5 32+*:8= < ,12 D8,2+48=: 5 +29+; 4, 4: 5,492; ,18, $ L D,12+ < ,12 ;2928:2; 4: ,12 45<+D85,85;:124:,1245E*+2;2G2?4,52::4:,12 <8,12+ < ,12 ;2928:2; 85; ,12 +4;2+ < ,12 D,+9G9=2 24:8=:8545E*+2;2G2?4,52::,4::,8,2;,18, ?8:+4;457,12D,+9G9=28=57?4,114:?4<2L$85; ,? 914=;+25 $ 85; 18>2 ;23:2; +278+;457 +8:1 85; 527=4725, ;+4>457 < ,12 6=2+ E223 6G ,12 - 7 - 899*:2; 12 :3, D818I8+ L J 85; :3, :H2,91 L J$$ ;4:9=:2 ,18, ,12 899*:2; ?8: ;+4>457 ,12 6=2+ E223<+D8:8>85872?8;485;18;7525,12?+57 :4;2 < ,12 +8; 85; ;8:12; , ,12 D,+9G9=2 ?1491 +2:*=,2; 45 ,12 ;28,1 < ,12 ;2928:2; 872; <4>2 G28+: 5;2+ :*91 94+9*D:,8592: 8D < ,12 34545 ,18, ,12 3+:29*,45 4: :*992::<*= 45 3+>457 ,12 7*4=, < ,12 899*:2;62G5;+28:586=2;*6,85;,12899*:2;4:=486=2 <+95>49,45 . ,4:5,492;,18,,12+48=*+,18::25,2592; ,12 899*:2; 32,4,452+ <+ 6,1 ,12 <<2592: 3*54:186=2 *5;2+29,45:.85;-%/<29,45.<4: ,12 D45+ <<2592 ?1491 D2+72: ?4,1 ,12 D8E+ <<2592 *5;2+29,45-%/<85;12592:238+8,2:25,2592 522;5,624D3:2;<+6,1,12<<2592:5,12899*:2; 45 ,12 =471, < ,12 ;294:45 < ,12 5B6=2 32J *+, 45 1 12+2<+2 ,12 +;2+ < :25,2592 <+ ,12 1 (2012) 8 SCC 734 - 8 - <<25923*54:186=2*5;2+29,45.<4:=486=2,62 :2, 8:4;2 ?2>2+ ,12 +48= *+, 18: :25,2592; ,12 899*:2; , *5;2+7 , :4D3=2 4D3+4:5D25, <+ 52 G28+ <+,12<<25923*54:186=2*5;2+29,45-%/<6*, 5<452?8:4D3:2;5,12899*:2;5:4;2+457,12<89, ,18, ?8: 8=: +4;457 ,12 D,+9G9=2 8=57 ?4,1 14: ?4<2 85; ,? 914=;+25 85; :4592 ,12 ;8,2 < 8994;25, 4: ;8,2;$-%%$#8D<,1234545,18,=254259GD8G 62:1?545<8>*+<,1232,4,452+?14=2:25,25945714D <+ ,12 <<2592: 3*54:186=2 *5;2+ 29,45: -- --" 85; -%/< $%5>42?<,1286>285:?2+,1286>2345, 85; 3+922; , 38:: ,12 <==?457 4( +4D458=+2>4:4532,4,454: 44( 12 E*;7D25, < 95>49,45 ;8,2; $-%$%- 38::2; 45 /%$ %$" 5 ,12 <4=2 < - 9 - =28+52;;;4,458=254+4>4=*;7285;) 8:8>858 872?8;4 85; ,12 E*;7D25, ;8,2; %/%%/ 38::2; 45 +4D458= 3328= %" %-5,12<4=2<=28+52;;;4,458= 4:,+49, 85; 2::45: *;72 4E8G83*+ 95<4+D457 ,12 E*;7D25, < 95>49,45 8+2 12+26G 95<4+D2; 45 +2:329, < <<2592: *5;2+ 29,45:.----"85;-%/< 444( ?2>2+ ,12 +;2+ < :25,2592 38::2; 6G ,12 +48= *+, <+ ,12 <<2592: 3*54:186=2 *5;2+ 29,45:----"85;-%/<4:D;4<42; 8:*5;2+ 8( 12 +2>4:45 32,4,452+ 899*:2; 4: :25,2592; , *5;2+7 +47+*: 4D3+4:5D25, <+ ,1+22 D5,1: <+ ,12 <<2592 3*54:186=2 *5;2+29,45-%/<85;,38G8<452< :$%%%% 5 ;2<8*=, , 38G <452 12 :18== *5;2+7:4D3=24D3+4:5D25,<+52D5,1 - 10 - 6( 12 +2>4:45 32,4,452+ 899*:2; 4: :25,2592;,*5;2+7:4D3=24D3+4:5D25,<+ ,? D5,1: 2891 <+ ,12 <<2592: 3*54:186=2 *5;2+29,45--85;--"< 4>( ==,12:25,2592::18==+*5959*++25,=G >( 12+;2+<:25,259238::2;6G,12+48=*+, <+,12<<25923*54:186=2*5;2+29,45.< 4:12+26G:2,8:4;2 274:,+G 4: ;4+29,2; , :25; 689H ,12 +48= *+, +29+;: 8=57 ?4,1 ,12 93G < ,14: E*;7D25, <+ 45<+D8,4585;522;<*=89,45 !., '##+ % +, 4:,$=-$