Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 66172 (KAR)

SHAMBU BHEEMASHANKAR S/O LATE SHAMBU VENKATASWAMY v. K. NARASIMHALU S/O K MUNIYAPPA AND ORS

MFA/200707/2022 · 2025-10-30

P Sree Sudha

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - !"# ## $%& ' ! " # $ !! % &' %() ! !* Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - %) * ! ) %+ , %) " # *- '! )(!)!! $ (*#$ *(!)! !.!)!) / " 012345012678094:;<=;45:>30: ! 5>:1??01@>:<>@03=A450B@1>8194161>9:4450 C7368094 193 1D123 31403 *)(!)! ?1::03 =A 450 2>9B>?1@ >:42>B4 193 0::>;9: 7360 193 - 3 - 1>B572E<;2:5;24F2>=791@GH>9 ;!.!)!):00I>96 09519B08094;<B;8?09:14>;9 * 50 >9C7203 B@1>8194 1603 * A012: 804 D>45 19 1BB>3094 ;9 ))+!)+ 193 :7:41>903 62>0J;7: >9C72>0: 09B0 50 <>@03 1 B@1>8 ?04>4>;9 =0<;20 450 2>=791@ :00I>96 B;8?09:14>;9 ;< :!+()))) 50 2>=791@ 1<402 B;9:>302>96 450 094>20 0J>309B0 ;9 20B;23 1D12303 450 B;8?09:14>;9 ;< :**))) D>45 >94020:4 14.K?0219978<2;84503140;<?04>4>;94>@@201@>L14>;9 1933>20B40320:?;93094 ;* 9:7219B0 ;8?19A 4; ?1A 450 B;8?09:14>;9 662>0J03 =A 450 :1>3 1D123 450 1??0@@194 B@1>819451:?20<0220345>:1??01@ 012903 B;79:0@ <;2 450 B@1>8194 81>9@A B;94093>964514450B;8?09:14>;91D12303=A4502>=791@ 79302 1@@ 5013: >: 801620 4 >: B;9409303 4514 450 B@1>8194 513 :7:41>903 <21B4720 ;< @0<4 B@1J>B@0 B27:5 >9C72>0:4;2>654620144;0193>4D1:18?7414031931@:; :7:41>903 5013 >9C72A 193 50 :?094 :*))))) <;2 803>B1@ 0M?09:0: =74 2>=791@ 51: 1D12303 ;9@A - 4 - :%)))) D5>B5 >: ;9 450 @;D02 :>30 4 >: 1@:; B;9409303 4514 450 B@1>8194 D1: 2;?2>04;2 ;< : 518=7 09I141:D18A D>45 978=02 193 0129>96 :*++! ?02 19978 9 :7??;24 ;< 5>: B1:0 50 ?2;37B03204729:4;:5;D451450D1:6044>96>9B;80;< :*++! =74 450 2>=791@ 02203 >9 9;4 B;9:>302>96 450 :180 193 457: 20N70:403 <;2 09519B>96 450 B;8?09:14>;9>95>:<1J;72 4 >: :7=8>4403 =A 450 @012903 B;79:0@ <;2 20:?;93094 ;* O 9:7219B0 ;8?19A 4514 450 B;8?09:14>;91D12303=A4502>=791@>:C7:4193?2;?02 1939003:9;>9402<0209B0 . 501??0@@194:4140:451450D1:3;>96=7:>90:: 1930129>96 :))))) ?0219978 9 :7??;24 ;<5>: B;94094>;950?2;37B03M!O204729:<;2450A012 !)% !)+>9D5>B55>:>9B;80>::5;D91::**))) 1:03 ;9 450 :1>3 3;B78094 450 2>=791@ 41I09 5>: >9B;801::!)))) ?028;94519345>:;724<>93:9; 201:;94;>9402<020D>45450:1>3;2302 - 5 - ( : ?02 M* O ;793 024><>B140 450 >9C72>0: :7:41>903=A450B@1>819412062>0J;7:>9914720! ;B4;2>::703M+O>:1=>@>4A024><>B1401::0::>96!)K 3>:1=>@>4A 4; 450 D5;@0 =;3A ;9 1BB;794 ;< 18?7414>;9 ;< 62014024;0=744502>=791@;=:02J03451418?7414>;9;< 62014024;0D>@@9;41<<0B45>:>9B;801939;41D1230319A B;8?09:14>;9<;2@;::;<<747200129>96B1?1B>4A7445>: ;724<>93:>4C7:4193201:;91=@04;41I0!)K3>:1=>@>4A1: 1::0::03 =A 450 ;B4;2 BB;23>96@A 450 B@1>8194 >: 094>4@03<;2@;::;<<747200129>96B1?1B>4A1:79302 :!)))) M!MM!)KP:!%))) % 50B@1>8194D1:138>4403>94505;:?>41@<2;8 ))+!)+ 4; ))+!)+ 193 :7=:0N7094@A <2;8 )+)+!)+4;!)+!)+1:?02>:B51260123:812I03 1: M:( 193 % 5020<;20 B;9:>302>96 450 ?02>;3 ;< 5;:?>41@>L14>;9 914720 ;< >9C72>0: 193 ;4502 20@0J194 <1B4;2:45>:;724<>93:>4201:;91=@04;1D1231918;794 ;< :))))) <;2 ?1>9 193 :7<<02>96 :%)))) <;2 @;::;<1809>4>0:193:*)))) <;24219:?;2414>;90M421 - 6 - 9;72>:58094 193 144093194 B51260: ;D0J02 450 B;8?09:14>;9 ;< :%+))) <;2 803>B1@ 0M?09:0: 193 :%)))) <;2 @;:: ;< >9B;80 372>96 @1>3 7? ?02>;3 1D12303=A4502>=791@9003:9;>9402<0209B0 + 50 B;8?09:14>;9 1D12303 =A 450 2>=791@ >: 8;3><>031:79302 @ ; 013: D123=A450 2>=791@ D123=A45>: ;724 1>9 193 :7<<02>96 :%)))) :))))) ! 03>B1@ M?09:0: :%+))) :%+))) * ;:: ;< <74720 0129>96B1?1B>4A :!%))) 219:?;2414>;9 0M421 9;72>:58094 193 144093194 B51260: :))) :*)))) ;:: ;< 1809>4>0: :()))) :%)))) . ;:: ;< >9B;80 372>96 @1>3 7? :%)))) :%)))) - 7 - ?02>;3 ;41@ :**))) :+)())) 5020D>@@=009519B08094;<:(*))) ) 0:?;93094 ;* O 9:7219B0 ;8?19A 51: 1@2013A 30?;:>403 450 B;8?09:14>;9 18;794 1D12303 =A 4502>=791@ 945020:7@4450<;@@;D>96;2302>:?1::03 #>$ ??01@>: #>>$ 50 B@1>8194 >: 094>4@03 <;2 450 09519B03 B;8?09:14>;9 ;< :(*))) D>45 >94020:4 14 .K ?02 19978 <2;8 450 3140 ;< ?04>4>;94>@@4503140;<201@>L14>;9 #>>>$ 0:?;93094 ;* O 9:7219B0 ;8?19A >: 3>20B403 4; 30?;:>4 450 1<;20:1>3 B;8?09:14>;918;7941@;96D>45>94020:4D>45>9 ;908;945<2;84503140;<45>:C7368094 - 8 - #>J$ 9 :7B5 30?;:>4 450 B@1>8194 >: ?028>44034;D>45321D450094>2018;7941@;96 D>45>94020:41BB2703;9>4 ;79:0@<;220:?;93094 ;*O9:7219B0;8?19A>: ?028>44034;<>@01I1@14D>45>94D;D00I:<2;84;31A ()* $#& " >:4 ;@ ;%.