- 1 - !! ""##"$! ! %! &'#&#& (##) (# &) ! ! " # $%! & ' ( % "! $!"& Digitally signed by SACHIN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - " $ ! $) ! )* % &$ )* ' !! $$ ) " $ ) $) * $ + $$ ) ) '$ - 3 - !,, ) + - " ! ! $$ ) " ! ! ' $.$$ ! $.$$ ( % "! " !$& # $ * + $ $ ! & - 4 - # $ # ! .) + ! .) * ")+ *%& ) * + & # $ # ! .) ' $ %&!) ) * %&!) ) * $" ! "" " * ) ' ( % "! $ ! !& - 5 - " $ $) ! ) $ ) * ' " $ ) $ ) ) " $.$$ * !! ) '$ !/0 * + + $$ ! - 6 - # ) $.$$ ( % "! " ! $ *& # $ * +$ $ ! &# $ * + $$ ' .)1 & # $ * *%& $ -- ' .) 1 & # $ " $ ! ' %!) .) ! $ #! - 7 - CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE M.G.S.KAMAL ORAL ORDER (PER: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE M.G.S.KAMAL) 2343456278 46 39282 3:5 ;23434568 <72 =2>572 3948 5?73<@@742A2B=C39257B278B<32B' ;75B?D2B <3 662E?728) <6B 728;2D34A2FC 46 <6B =C :94D9 392 728;56B263 5 9<8 B2DF462B 35 ><A5?7 392 463274G <;;F4D<3456>4F2B=C392;2343456278?6B278?=)82D3456%'&5> 2D3456 * 5> 392 <76<3<H< 5)5;27<34A2 5D423428 D3 --%927246<>32772>2772B35<8/D3--0>5789573& 92;234345627846# 5 ''' <72392 472D3578 5> 728;56B263 5 )5)5;27<34A2 5D423C <6B 392 ;2343456278 46 # 5 ''* <72 392 472D3578 5> 728;56B263 5 85D423C 728;2D34A2FC 75D22B46@8 ?6B27 2D3456 * 5> 392 D3 -- :272 46434<32B 273<46F5<68:272@7<632B=C392728;56B263)D55;27<34A2 =<6H 35 562 74 <D946 9<7<39D9<6B7< <G<F<;?7H<7 35 392 2E3263 5> 8 D75728 <6B 35 562 74 46@<7<I - 8 - "2:<7@4 35 392 2E3263 5> 8 D757278 :272 8?=I2D3 G<33275>3928<4B;75D22B46@8?746@392D5?7825>8<4B ;75D22B46@8 43 48 5=827A2B 39<3 392 ;2343456278 927246 <F56@:4395392789<B6535=I2D32B>57@7<6346@5>3928<4B F5<68 <6B 39<3 392C :272 653 A4@4F<63 46 268?746@ 392 8<>23C <6B 82D?743C 5> 392 8<4B F5<6 <G5?638 28?F3<63 728;56B263 D55;27<34A2 <6H 9<B 46D?772B D273<46 >46<6D4<F F58828 ?78?<63 35 :94D9 392 "5463 2@4837<7 5> 55;27<34A25D423C;<882B57B278?6B272D3456*5>392 D3 -- A4B2 662E?728) <6B 728;2D34A2FC 662E?728 35 392 8<4B 57B27 ?6B27 2D3456 * D3 -- 46B4D<32 39<3 < 72D5GG26B<34568 <72 G<B2 35 72D5A27 392 <G5?638 :94D9 :272 ;<C<=F2 =C <>5728<4B =5775:278 <6B :94D9 9<A2 72G<462B ?6;<4B 46 A42: 5> <FF2@2B B272F4D3456 5> B?3C 56 392 ;<73 5> 392 ;2343456278 95FB46@ 392G ;27856<FFC F4<=F2 =C 46434<346@ 26J?47C ?6B27 2D3456*-5>392D3-- ' 348394857B27?6B272D3456*5>392D3 -- 39<3 9<8 @4A26 <;;729268456 46 392 G46B8 5> 392 - 9 - ;2343456278 D56837<4646@ 392G 35 H65DH 392 B5578 5> 3948 5?73 ;<734D?F<7FC 56 392 ;72G482 39<3 392 8<4B 5=827A<34568 :5?FB =2 ?82B =C 728;56B263 5) 23?7646@>>4D2735B26C392;2343456278<65;;573?643C5> ;<734D4;<346@46392268?46@2F2D34568 9226457D5?682F<;;2<746@>57392;2343456278 3<H46@39485?733975?@9392;75A4845685>2D34568** <6B*-5>392D3--<6B392;75D22B46@872>2772B 35 <=5A2 8?=G43 39<3 ?6F288 <6B ?634F 8?7D9<7@2 ;75D22B46@8 ?6B27 2D3456 *- 5> 392 D3 -- <72 46434<32BD56B?D32B<6BD56DF?B2B46392G<6627H65:35 F<: 392 728;56B263 ) <?395743428 D<6653 95FB 392 ;2343456278F4<=F2>57392<G5?63<FF2@2BFCB?2<6B;<C<=F2 35392728;56B263D55;27<34A2=<6H?D9<;75D2B?7248 562:4395?3<?395743C5>F<:9<3B28;4323928<G29<A46@ =226=75?@93353926534D25>728;56B263 5 BB43456<F 2@4837<7 %72B43 2D3456& 46 392 <;;2<F >4F2B =C 392 ;2343456278929<8><4F2B352E27D482I?748B4D3456A2832B46 94G9<3395?@9<F3276<3272G2BC48;75A4B2B392488?2 - 10 - 7<482B ;?72FC =246@ 562 46A5FA46@ J?283456 5> F<: 92 8?=G43839<3392:7438<72G<463<46<=F226D2822H8>57 46B?F@26D2 6728;5682744I<CH?G<7BB43456<FBA5D<32 2627<F<;;2<746@3975?@9A4B25D56>2726D28?=G43839<3 392<;;7292684565>392;234345627848G48;F<D2B23<H28 3948 5?73 56D2 <@<46 3975?@9 392 D5632638 5> 392 72;573 ?6B272D3456*5>392D3--<6B392B5D?G2638 <662E2B 3927235 <6B 8?=G438 <FF 39<3 392 8<4B 57B27 46B4D<32483546434<32;75D22B46@8?6B272D3456*-5>392 D3--<6B3928<G2D<6653=2D5684B272B35=2< D56DF?84565>392F4<=4F43C5>392;23434562789272>57292 8?=G438 39<3 392 ;2343456278 9<A2 65 @75?6B8 35 ?7@2 46 3948G<33272>?739278?=G43846<8G?D9<8>?73927<;;2<F 48;75A4B2B392;2343456278G<C:2FF=272F2@<32B35<A<4F 392 8<4B 72G2BC <6B :926 392 <;;2<F >4F2B =C 392 ;2343456278 ?6B27 2D3456 * 5> 392 D3-- 48 ;26B46@ D5684B27<3456 392C D<6653 8?=A273 <6B <;;75<D9 39485?7326D2822H8>57B48G488<F5>392;24334568 - 11 - * <A46@92<7B392F2<762B26457D5?682F>57392 ;2343456278 <6B F2<762B BB43456<F BA5D<32 2627<F <;;2<746@ >57 392 728;56B2638 43 48 DF2<7 39<3 392 57B278 ;<882B =C 728;56B2638 <72 ?6B27 2D34568 * <6B * 5> 392D3--928<4B57B278<728?=I2D3G<33275> 392 ;26B46@ <;;2<F8 ?6B27 2D3456 * 5> 392 D3 -- BG4332BFC 65 8?7D9<7@2 ;75D22B46@8 9<A2 =226 46434<32B?6B272D3456*-5>392D3-- + 639<3A42:5>392G<332739485?73485>392 D5684B272B A42: 39<3 39282 ;23434568 D<6 =2 B48;582B 5> :439<DF<74>4D<345639<339257B278;<882B?6B272D3456* 5> 392 D3 -- <6B 392 5=827A<3456 G<B2 46 392 662E?728 35 392 8<4B 57B278 89<FF 653 =2 D56837?2B <6B 372<32B <8 <6 46B4D3G263 <6B >4E46@ 5> F4<=4F43C 56 392 ;2343456278 948 48 ;<734D?F<7FC >57 392 72<8568 39<3 65 8?7D9<7@2;75D22B46@8 <8 D5632G;F<32B ?6B27 2D3456*- 5>392D3--9<A2=22646434<32BC23 3 48 G<B2 DF2<7 65 57B27 57 5;46456 48 2E;72882B 56 392 G27438 57 53927:482 5> 392 D5632634568 - 12 - 7<482B=C392;<734282ED2;372D57B46@3928?=G4884568<6B DF<74>4D<345656392<=5A2<8;2D3 - #439 392 <=5A2 5=827A<34568 ;23434568 <72 B48;582B5> #* (&#& ) '" SN List No.: 2 Sl No.: 2