Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 66157 (KAR)
LAXMAN v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
CRL.P/201456/2025 · 2025-11-05
Sachin Shankar Magadum
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 66157 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 66157 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"
#!$!! ! %&'%()*+&%)) ,
!"#
$ %
&
'
!"#
' #"(
$ %
&
' !) '
% & ! '
%*&
+##,", % (#,", & ' ''
#"%#& ## %,& ##%#&,)%& ,#") '
,", ' '
' *
Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
-
% - &
./0 123/3/45 /0 6/728 9: 3.2 0472 ;<<=028 022>/5? ?@;53 46 @2?=7;@ 9;/7 /5
4 +##,", %;@/0/5? 4=3 46 @/A24 (#,", @2?/032@289:
;0;B;>;7:;5=@;747/<2 3;3/45
/8;@/03@/<3&1258/5?453.26/724688/3/45;7 /03@/<3;58200/450=8?2
/8;@0/33/5?;3
;0;B;>;7:;5 64@3.246625<201=5/0.;972=582@2<3/450#"%#&## %,& ##%#&,)%& ,;58#")46
.;@;3/:;:;:;;5./3; ,",
, .29@/26 6;<30 72;8/5? 34 3.2 @2?/03@;3/45 46 3.2 1@20253 <;02 ;@2 3.;33.2 123/3/452@ /0 3.2 9@43.2@ 46 3.2 82<2;028 3/0;772?283.;345#
"! ,", ;3;94=3
"" 1 A C.25 3.2 <4A17;/5;53 ;58 .2@ .=09;58 %3.2 82<2;028&C2@225?;?28/5<=33/5?020;A2<@410/53.2/@ 7;583C4?4;3092745?/5?343.282<2;02803@;:28/5343.2 ;8D4/5/5? 7;58 4C528 9: 3.2 123/3/452@ 64@ ?@;E/5? ??@/2B289:3./03.2123/3/452@/00;/834.;B21/<>28=1
- 3 -
; F=;@@27 C/3. 3.2 <4A17;/5;53 ;58 ;9=028 .2@ /5 6/73.: 7;5?=;?2 3/06=@3.2@;772?283.;38=@/5?3.2;732@<;3/45 3.2123/3/452@/5;6/346;5?2@1/<>28=1;C44825<7=9 ;58 ;00;=7328 3.2 <4A17;/5;53 45 .2@ 64@2.2;8 C/3. ;5 /53253/4534<;=02.2@82;3. *.253.282<2;028C.4/0 545243.2@3.;53.29@43.2@463.2123/3/452@;332A132834 /532@B252;581;</6:3.20/3=;3/453.2123/3/452@/0;772?28 34 .;B2 3=@528 ./0 @;?2 34C;@80 ./A ;58 ;00;=7328 ./A @212;3287: C/3. 3.2 0;A2 <7=9 6/@03 45 3.2 64@2.2;8 ;58 3.25453.29;<>0/82463.2.2;8/567/<3/5?A=73/172974C0 ;774B2@./0948: 0;@20=73463.202?@/2B4=0/5D=@/203.2 82<2;028 0=<<=A928 5 3.2 9;0/0 46 3.2 <4A17;/53 748?28 9: 3.2 C/62 46 3.2 82<2;028 ; <;02 <;A2 34 92 @2?/032@28 /5B203/?;3/45 C;0 =582@3;>25 ;58 3.2@2;632@ <.;@?20.223.;092256/728;?;/5033.2123/3/452@
.2 123/3/452@ .;0 54C ;11@4;<.28 3./0 4=@3 022>/5? 257;@?2A253 45 9;/7 3 /0 <45325828 9: 3.2 72;@528 <4=5027 64@ 3.2 123/3/452@ 3.;3 3.2 123/3/452@ C;0 ;@@20328 45 ,,
"! ,", ;58 .;0 9225 /5 D=8/</;7 <=0348:
- 4 -
0/5<2 3.25 3 /0 0=9A/3328 3.;3 3.2 123/3/452@ /0 ;
12@A;5253 @20/8253 46 3.2 B/77;?2 4C5/5? /AA4B;972 1@412@3: ;58 3.2@2 /0 54 7/>27/.448 46 ./0 ;90<458/5? 4@ 3;A12@/5? C/3. 3.2 1@402<=3/45 C/3520020 .2 72;@528 <4=5027C4=786=@3.2@0=9A/33.;33.2=564@3=5;32/5</8253 /5 F=203/45 4<<=@@28 /5 ; 0=8825 F=;@@27 ;@/0/5? 4=3 46 3@/B/;7 @2;0450 C/3.4=3 ;5: 1@2A28/3;3/45 4@/53253/45 45 3.21;@3463.2123/3/452@34<;=023.282;3.46./09@43.2@
3 /0 3.2@264@2 =@?28 3.;3 3./0 4=@3 A;: 3;>2 ; 725/253 B/2C ;58 257;@?2 3.2 123/3/452@ 45 9;/7 0=9D2<3 34 ;5: 03@/5?253<458/3/4503.;3A;:92/A14028
! 2@ <453@; 3.2 72;@528 /?. 4=@3 4B2@5A253 72;82@B2.2A2537:41140283.2123/3/45 7;</5?@27/;5<2 45 3.2 A28/<;7 2B/825<2 1;@3/<=7;@7: 3.2 1403A4@32A @214@30.20=9A/33283.;33.282<2;028.;80=03;/528;0 A;5:;0#!2G32@5;7/5D=@/20;1;@36@4A/532@5;78;A;?2 34 B/3;7 1;@30 <72;@7: /58/<;3/5? 3.2 9@=3;7 5;3=@2 46 3.2 ;00;=73 3/06=@3.2@<453258283.;33.21@402<=3/45<;02 /0 0=114@328 9: 3.@22 2:2C/3520020 /5<7=8/5?
3.2
- 5 -
<4A17;/5;53C.4.;0 <450/032537: 8214028@2?;@8/5?3.2 4B2@3;<30<4AA/33289:3.2123/3/452@ .272;@528 C4=78 14/53 4=3 3.;3 3.2 <4A17;/5;53 .2@0276 C;0 6/@03 ;00;=7328 9: 3.2 123/3/452@ ;58 C.25 .2@ .=09;58 /532@B2528 .2 C;0 6;3;77: ;33;<>28 3 /0 3.2@264@2 ;@?=283.;33./0/0;<;02466@;3@/</822G./9/3/5?2G3@2A2 ;??@200/45;58<@=273:;583.;3@272;0/5?3.2123/3/452@;3 3./003;?2C4=781402;02@/4=03.@2;3343.20;623:463.2 <4A17;/5;53;5843.2@1@402<=3/45C/3520020 25<2/3/0 1@;:283.;33.2123/3/45928/0A/0028
.;B2.2;@83.272;@528<4=502764@3.2123/3/452@ ;583.272;@528/?.4=@34B2@5A25372;82@;3725?3. .;B2 ;704 <;@26=77: 12@=028 3.2 @2<4@80 A;82 ;B;/7;972 ;745?C/3.3.2<.;@?20.223
+ .2 F=203/45 3.;3 ;@/020 64@ <450/82@;3/45 9264@2 3./04=@3/0 C.23.2@3.2123/3/452@.;0A;824=3;<;02 64@?@;5346@2?=7;@9;/7/5
4 +##,", %;@/0/5?4=3 46@/A24 (#,", 46
;0;B;>;7:;5=@;747/<23;3/45
- 6 -
/8;@ /03@/<3& 1258/5? 45 3.2 6/72 46 3.2 88/3/45;7 /03@/<3 ;58 200/450 =8?2 /8;@ 0/33/5? ;3 ;0;B;>;7:;564@3.246625<201=5/0.;972=582@2<3/450 #"%#& ## %,& ##%#& ,)%& , ;58 #") 46 3.2 .;@;3/:;:;:;;5./3;,",
( 5 A23/<=74=0 12@=0;7 46 3.2 <.;@?2 0.223 A;32@/;7/32A2@?203.;33.2123/3/452@/0;772?2834.;B2 ;00;=73283.2<4A17;/5;53;58=145/532@B253/459@=3;77:
;33;<>28 ./0 4C5 9@43.2@ @20=73/5? /5 ./0 82;3. .2 1403A4@32A@214@38/0<74020;343;746#!8/03/5<3/5D=@/20 64=58 45 3.2 948: 46 3.2 82<2;028 /5<7=8/5? ;9@;0/450 4B2@3.2@/?.30/82463.29@/8?2463.254024B2@3.2.27/G 463.2@/?.32;@;58<453=0/4504B2@B;@/4=01;@3046943. ;@A0 ;58 64@2;@A0 5 ;88/3/45 A=73/172 7/52;@ ;9@;0/450 C2@2 4902@B28 45 3.2 =112@ 9;<> 3.2 7;@?203 A2;0=@/5? #+ <A G # <A .2 5;3=@2 5=A92@ ;58 8/03@/9=3/45 46 /5D=@/20 <72;@7: 82A4503@;32 @212;328 ;58 64@<26=7 974C0 /567/<328 45 B/3;7 ;58 545B/3;7 1;@30 ;7/>2 52?;3/5? ;5: 0=??203/453.;33.2;00;=73C;0;<</8253;74@7/A/32834;
- 7 -
0/5?72 974C .4=?. /3 /0 3@/32 3.;33.29=@825 461@4B/5? ?=/7392:458@2;045;97284=93@2030C/3.3.21@402<=3/45 ;33./003;?23.21@/A;6;</2A;32@/;745@2<4@88/0<74020 3.2 123/3/452@H0 8/@2<3 /5B47B2A253 /5 ; 9@=3;7 ;00;=73 @20=73/5?/53.282;3.46./04C59@43.2@ /B253.2?@;B/3: 463.246625<23.202@/4=05200463.2;772?;3/450;583.2 7/>27/.448 46 3.2 123/3/452@ /567=25</5? C/3520020 3./0 4=@3 6/580 54 D=03/6/<;3/45 34 2G2@</02 /30 8/0<@23/45 /5 6;B4=@463.2123/3/452@64@?@;53469;/7
<<4@8/5?7:C/3.4=32G1@200/5?;5:41/5/45453.2 A2@/30463.2A;332@3./04=@3/0463.2<450/82@28B/2C 3.;33.2123/3/452@.;06;/72834A;>24=3;5:?@4=58064@ ?@;53 46 @2?=7;@9;/7 .2123/3/45 92/5?82B4/846A2@/3 03;5808/0A/0028
-* %!!) $
/034 #74 #"