- 1 - ! "#$$ %% &$' () %% * * * ( ) !"#" $ %& &' ( " & ) ) *+,** ,! Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - !" )) ,##-, $ % ) . " #"#+ " ( )) "-+%"( ) ) ) & #/## & " #"/ )& * *( * ) )) 0 $ % ( " - 3 - " !"#" & ) *+,** ,! !" $ %&'1& ) ". +##-# ( )) "-+%"( ) & #/## " #"/ & ) & )23 ) & 4 & # )5##+#, #+637689:;<=>9?8@6A@B=399C6BD 9B>@B?9A9B= 57 ?5AE9B3@=65B @3 @F@G:9: 6B =>9 - 4 - HI:DA9B= @F@G: :@=9: #/## E@339: 6B 5" #"/ ;< =>9 ::6=65B@8 9B65G 6J68 &I:D9 @B: @6?>IG ) 5#"-" #" 63 7689: ;< =>9 6B3IG@B?9 ?5AE@B<?>@889BD6BD6=3 86@;686=<=5E@<=>9?5AE9B3@=65B @A5IB= + 9@G: =>9 89@GB9: ?5IB398 75G =>9 @EE988@B= ?8@6A@B= @B: 89@GB9: ?5IB398 75G G93E5B:9B= 5 6B3IG@B?9?5AE@B< ! 9@GB9:?5IB39875G=>9?8@6A@B=F5I8:3I;A6= =>@= 6B =>9 5=>9G ?8@6A E9=6=65B3 @G636BD 5I= 57 =>9 3@A9 @??6:9B=6B53"/ #"/# #"/" #"/@B: #"/ =>9 6B3IG@B?9 ?5AE@B< >@3 E@6: =>9 ?5AE9B3@=65B@A5IB=@B:=>9G975G9B5F=>9@EE9@87689: ;< =>9 6B3IG@B?9 ?5AE@B< ?>@889BD6BD =>9 86@;686=< :593 B5=3IGJ6J975G?5B36:9G@=65B - 5 - 9@GB9: ?5IB398 75G =>9 6B3IG@B?9 ?5AE@B< :593B5=:63EI=9=>97@?==>@==>96B3IG@B?9?5AE@B<>@3 @:A6==9:6=386@;686=<@B:E@6:=>9?5AE9B3@=65B@A5IB=6B =>9?8@6AE9=6=65B37689:;<=>95=>9G?8@6A@B=3BJ69F57 =>9 3@A9 =>9 @EE9@8 7689: ;< =>9 6B3IG@B?9 ?5AE@B< ?>@889BD6BD=>986@;686=<:593B5=3IGJ6J975G?5B36:9G@=65B @B:@EE9@8G9KI6G93=5;9:63A6339: , 9@GB9: ?5IB398 75G =>9 @EE988@B= ?8@6A@B= F5I8: ?5B=9B: =>@= =>9 @??6:9B= >@3 =@C9B E8@?9 6B =>9 <9@G#"-@B:=>9B5=65B@86B?5A976L9:75G=>93@6:<9@G 63 3"## * @3 E9G =>9 6B?5A9 ?>@G= EG9E@G9: 75G =>9 EIGE539 57 5C :@8@=> @B: =>9 G6;IB@8 >@3 9GG9: 6B =@C6BD =>9 B5=65B@8 6B?5A9 57 =>9 ?8@6A@B= @= 3-### * E9GA5B=>>9?8@6A@B=>@33I3=@6B9:=F57G@?=IG9369 G@:6I3 @B: I8B@ @B: 897= >6E H56B= @B: >9 63 @B @DG6?I8=IG63= ?55869 >9 ?@BB5= E9G75GA >63 @J5?@=65B @B: =>9G975G9 :63@;686=< =@C9B @= "M @3 @D@6B3= :63@;686=< 3=@=9:;<=>9:5?=5G@=+M635B=>985F9G36:9>98533 576B?5A975G=>98@6:IEE9G65:>@3B5=;99B=@C9B;<=>9 - 6 - G6;IB@8 >9 ?5AE9B3@=65B @F@G:9: 75G @==9B:@B= ?5BJ9<@B?9 755: @B: B5IG63>A9B= ?>@GD93 6B @ 3IA 57 3!### *;<=>9G6;IB@8635B=>985F9G36:936B?9=>9 ?8@6A@B=>@3;99B@:A6==9:=5>53E6=@875G96D>=:@<3>9 ?8@6A@B=>@33I3=@6B9:=F57G@?=IG93@B:>9639B=6=89:75G ?5AE9B3@=65B =5F@G:3 E@6B @B: 3I779G6BD 6B @ 3IA 57 3#### * @3 @D@6B3= 3+#### * @F@G:9: ;< =>9 G6;IB@8>9G6;IB@8>@3B5=@F@G:9:@B<?5AE9B3@=65B =5F@G:3 8533 57 @A9B6=693 6=> =>63 89@GB9: ?5IB398 75G =>9 @EE988@B= ?8@6A@B= EG@<3 75G 9B>@B?9A9B= 57 ?5AE9B3@=65B - 9@GB9: ?5IB398 75G =>9 6B3IG@B?9 ?5AE@B< F5I8:?5B=9B:=>@==>9:63@;686=<=@C9B;<=>9G6;IB@863 EG5E9G93I;A6=3=>@==>9?5AE9B3@=65B@F@G:9:;<=>9 G6;IB@863EG5E9G@B:?5GG9?= @J6BD >9@G: =>9 89@GB9: ?5IB398 75G =>9 E@G=693 =>63 5IG= E9GI39: =>9 6AEIDB9: HI:DA9B= @B: =>9G6@85IG=G9?5G:3 - 7 - / >9 @??6:9B= >@3 =@C9B E8@?9 5B ,#"#"- @B: =>9 @D9 57 =>9 ?8@6A@B= 63,# <9@G35B36:9G6BD =>9 3@A9 =>9 B5=65B@8 6B?5A9 =@C9B ;< =>9 G6;IB@8 @= 3-### *E9GA5B=>635B=>985F9G36:9@B:=>9B5=65B@8 6B?5A9>@3=5;9=@C9B@=3"## *E9GA5B=>@3E9G =>96B?5A9?>@G=EG9E@G9:75G=>9EIGE539575C:@8@=> >9 6BHIG9: F@3 @D9: ,# <9@G3 @B: =>9G975G9 =>9 @EE86?@;89AI8=6E869G63/ "# >9 6BHIG9: F@3 @DG6?I8=IG63= ?55869 @B: :I9 =5 7G@?=IG93 57 G@:6I3 @B: I8B@ @B: 897= >6E H56B= >9 ?@BB5= E9G75GA@DG6?I8=IG@8@?=6J6=693 ?55869F5GC@B:?5B36:9G6BD =>93@A97@?==>9:5?=5G@339339::63@;686=<@=+M@B: =>9G6;IB@8>@3=@C9B:63@;686=<@="M5B36:9G6BD=>9 7@?= =>@= =>9 ?8@6A@B= F@3 :56BD @DG6?I8=IG@8 ?55869 F5GC @B::I9=5=>97G@?=IG933I3=@6B9:;<>6A>963B5=6B@ E536=65B =5 :5 @DG6?I8=IG@8 ?55869 F5GC @3 >9 F@3 :56BD 9@G869G=>9:63@;686=<>@3=5;9=@C9B@=#M9B?9=>9 - 8 - ?8@6A@B= 63 9B=6=89: 75G ?5AE9B3@=65B =5F@G:3 8533 57 7I=IG96B?5A96B@3IA573"!## *%3"## *L" L# "##L/( "" >9G6;IB@8>@3@F@G:9:3+#### *=5F@G:3 E@6B @B: 3I779G6BD 3 =>9 ?8@6A@B= >@3 3I3=@6B9: =F5 7G@?=IG93>9639B=6=89:75G?5AE9B3@=65B=5F@G:3E@6B@B: 3I779G6BD 6B @ 3IA 57 3#### * %3### * L 7G@?=IG93( " >9?8@6A@B=F@3@:A6==9:6B>53E6=@875G96D>= :@<3 @B: >9 >@3 3I779G9: =F5 7G@?=IG93 >9G975G9 >9 63 9B=6=89: 75G ?5AE9B3@=65B =5F@G:3 8533 57 6B?5A9 :IG6BD 8@6: IE E9G65: 6B @ 3IA 57 3+#-# * %3"## * L + A5B=>3( "+ )IG=>9G =>9 ?8@6A@B= 63 9B=6=89: 75G ?5AE9B3@=65B =5F@G:3 @==9B:@B= ?5BJ9<@B?9 755: @B: B5IG63>A9B= ?>@GD93 6B @ 3IA 57 3 ### * @3 @D@6B3= 3!### *@F@G:9:;<=>9G6;IB@8 - 9 - "! >9 G6;IB@8 >@3 G6D>=8< @F@G:9: A9:6?@8 9LE9B393 57 3,,+! * @B: 7I=IG9 A9:6?@8 9LE9B393 57 3" #### * " 3 =>9 ?8@6A@B= >@3 3I779G9: =F5 7G@?=IG93 >9 639B=6=89:75G?5AE9B3@=65B=5F@G:3853357@A9B6=6936B@ 3IA573!#### * ", 5B36:9G6BD @88 @;5J9 @3E9?=3 =>9 @EE988@B= ?8@6A@B= 63 9B=6=89: 75G =5=@8 ?5AE9B3@=65B @3 IB:9G 85 9@:3 A5IB= " 533577I=IG96B?5A9 3"!## * @6B@B:I779G6BD 3#### * + 533 57 6B?5A9 :IG6BD 8@6: IE E9G65: 3+#-# * ! ==9B:@B= ?5BJ9<@B?9 755: @B:B5IG63>A9B=?>@GD93 3 ### * 9:6?@89LE9B393 3,,+! * , )I=IG9A9:6?@89LE9B393 3" #### * - 53357@A9B6=693 3!#### * +,- ./ /0( "- >9G975G9=>9@EE988@B= ?8@6A@B=639B=6=89:75G =5=@8 ?5AE9B3@=65B 57 3/,!/ * @3 @D@6B3= 3+/+-! *@F@G:9:;<=>9G6;IB@8 - 10 - " B=>9G93I8==>975885F6BD %"( >9 @EE9@8 7689: ;< =>9 B3IG@B?9 5AE@B< 6B )5#"-" #"63:63A6339: %( >9 @EE9@8 7689: ;< =>9 ?8@6A@B= 6B ) 5##+#, #+63@885F9:6BE@G= %+( >9 @EE988@B= ?8@6A@B= 63 9B=6=89: 75G ?5AE9B3@=65B 57 3/,!/ * @3 @D@6B3= 3+/+-! *@F@G:9:;<=>9G6;IB@8 %!( >9 6B=9G93= @3 @F@G:9: ;< =>9 G6;IB@8 G9A@6B9:IB@8=9G9: %( >9 ?8@6A@B= 63 B5= 9B=6=89: =5 6B=9G93= 75G =>9 E9G65:57:98@<57"/:@<36B7686BD=>9@EE9@8 %,( >9 6B3IG@B?9 ?5AE@B< 63 :6G9?=9: =5 :9E536= 9B>@B?9:?5AE9B3@=65BF6=>6B@E9G65:5796D>= F99C37G5A=>63:@<7@686BDF>6?>=>9?8@6A@B= 63 9B=6=89: 75G 6B=9G93= @= =>9 G@=9 57 /M E9G - 11 - @BBIA 5B =>9 9B>@B?9: ?5AE9B3@=65B =688 E@<A9B= %-( >9 3=@=I=5G< :9E536= A@:9 ;< =>9 6B3IG@B?9 ?5AE@B< 63 5G:9G9: =5 ;9 =G@B3A6==9: =5 =>9 G6;IB@8 % ( 776?9 63 :6G9?=9: =5 G9=IGB =>9 G6@8 5IG= G9?5G:3@85BDF6=>@?5E<57=>63HI:DA9B= 1( &$$' # 63=5"85! =