- 1 - ! " # ! - 1 - ! " # ! $ !% $ !% & !' ( " ) Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - %' " ) *)%& ( $" % + " , $ &%)+ %$ - " ./ # # - 3 - # " 01232121451671839:;2<32=23>5930021?83%47 456212>214547591=?=8815@15A>3621452<3409309=239 % 15 =BB81?=2145 4&%)+ B=6639 :; =05=2=C= 2=23 9D151620=21E3 01:>5=8 =8=:>0@1 F<303:;2<301:>5=8=884F392<3=BB81?=2145=599103?239 2<3036B4593526 24?4561930 2<3 ?=63 47 2<3 =BB81?=52 740 03@>8=01G=2145 47 <16 630E1?3 =6 ?456193039 24 2<3 ?4!4771?1=86 =6 B30 2<3 771?1=8 3D40=59>D 9=239 *&% =59 @0=52 =88 ?4563A>3521=8 :3537126 F12<15 = B301494774>0D452<6704D2<39=234703?31B247?4B;47 2<1640930 <3 B=02136 6<=88 :3 03730039 24 =6 B30 2<310 0=5C15@6:374032<301:>5=87403=6;0373035?3 :0137 4>28153 47 2<3 7=?26 83=915@ 24 71815@ 47 2<3B036352B3212145=03=6>5930# <3 5=D3 =BB81?=52)B01E=23 036B459352 <30315 <=6 :335 6B4564039 :; 2<3 16201?2 DB84;D352 H?<=5@3 - 4 - 771?3 553H>03!" =59 9103?239 036B459352 4 24 15230E13F 740 2<3 B462 47 ./ @04>B 3DB84;D352 <3 036B459352 4& <=6 ?459>?239 15230E13F =59 =BB415239 =BB81?=52 24 2<3 B462 47 B345 =6 B30 40930 9=239 **'+ 553H>03!">:63A>3528;2<3630E1?3647 2<3 =BB81?=52 <=6 :335 ?45215>39 15 2<3 3=82< 3B=02D352 =6@04>B./ @04>B3DB84;33 459=18; F=@36 704D **'+ <3 036B459352 4 <=6 64>@<2 2<3 630E1?3 03?4096 704D 036B459352 4& 15 40930 24 03@>8=01G32<3630E1?36472<3=BB81?=52 553H>03!"5 036B4563 24 03A>1612145 :; 036B459352 4 036B459352 4& <=6 7>0516<39 2<3 15740D=2145 =845@ F12< 6=8=0; 62=23D352 704D 3B23D:30 *'+ 24 4E3D:30 + 24 036B459352 4 553H>03!%" <3 =BB81?=52 2188 <16 032103D352 <=6 :335 ?45215>39 =6 9=18; F=@3 3DB84;33 3E35 2<4>@< 2<3 15740D=2145 62=239 6>B0= F=6 6>BB8139 :>2 F=6 542 ?456193039 740 03@>8=01G=2145 <3 =BB81?=52 <=9F40C39740=242=8B3014947;3=06*D452<62188<16 032103D352=6B30 771?1=83D40=59>D9=239% - 5 - 553H>03!+" <3 =BB4152D352 47 2<3 =BB81?=52 F=6 D=93 =@=1562 = E=?=52 B462 =59 6>:63A>352 24 362=:816<D352 47 I188= =5?<=;=2 F12< 377402 704D &*'+=882<393B=02D35266244920=5673003924I188= =5?<=;=2=59=66>?<2<3630E1?3647=BB81?=52=86462449 20=5673003924I188==5?<=;=2:;4E305D352409309=239 &*'+ 24 **& 302=15 B306456 61D18=08; 612>=239 2<=2472<3=BB81?=52=BB04=?<392<164>02150123212145 4&!+)**' =59 42<30 ?4553?239 ?=636 <16 4>0245****9103?2392<3036B459352624?4561930 2<3 ?=63 47 B3212145306 15 2<3 6=19 B32121456 740 03@>8=01G=2145 <3 40930 B=6639 :; 2<3 83=0539 15@83 >9@3 47 2<164>02 F=6?=883915A>362145 15 012BB3=8 4+%!*) !36"F<1?<?4D3624:3916D16639 45 >:63A>3528; 2<3 @4E305D352 166>39 771?1=8 3D40=59>D 9=239 *&% =59 2<3 ?4!4771?1=86 61D18=08; 612>=239 =6 2<=2 47 =BB81?=52 <=E3 :33503@>8=01G39F<4<=E3?4DB83239;3=0647630E1?3 <3=BB81?=52B03730039=0123212145:374032<164>0215 - 6 - 4*'%) =2 =8=:>0=@1 35?< 633C15@ 03@>8=01G=2145 15 230D6 47 771?1=8 3D40=59>D 9=239 *&% <16 4>02 :; 40930 9=239 % 0383@=239 2<3 B321214530 24 2<3 =05=2=C= 9D151620=21E3 01:>5=8 15 E13F 47 =82305=21E3 =59 3771?=?14>6 03D39; =E=18=:83 24 2<3 =BB81?=52 <303=7230 2<3 B036352 =BB81?=21454&%)+?4D3624:371839F12<=B0=;30 249103?22<3036B45935262403@>8=01G32<3630E1?36472<3 =BB81?=5203593039704D**'+24%F12<=88 ?4563A>3521=8 :3537126 =59 9103?2 2<3 036B4593526 24 3H2359 2<3 630E1?36 :3537126 >5930 2<3 B04E161456 47 2<3 =05=2=C==18;=@3DB84;336387=03?2=845@ F12< =5 1523084?>240; =BB81?=2145 633C15@ 740 ?45945=2145 47938=;15=BB04=?<15@2<301:>5=8374032<301:>5=8 2<3 036B4593526)B3212145306 71839 62=23D352 47 4:J3?2145 ?45235915@ 2<=2 2<3 ?=63 47 2<3 =BB81?=52 F4>89 :3 ?456193039 >5930 3?2145 *% " 47 2<3 =05=2=C= =5?<=;=2 =J ?2 =59 2<3 630E1?3 03?4096 <=E3 :335 740F=0939242<3@4E305D35215230D64703A>1612145 - 7 - & <3 01:>5=8 =7230 ?456193015@ 01E=8 6>:D1661456 ?4594539 2<3 938=; 15 =BB04=?<15@ 2<3 01:>5=8 :; =884F15@ =BB81?=2145 4 =59 <=E15@ ?4561930392<3D=2301=84503?409=59<=E15@5421?392<=2 42<30 61D18=08; 612>=239 B306456 2<=2 47 =BB81?=52 <=E3 =803=9;:335@0=5239:35371264703@>8=01G=2145=5974>59 2<=2 2<3 =BB81?=52 16 61D18=08; 612>=239 =59 2<303 16 54 9177303521=2145 :32F335 =BB81?=52 =59 42<30 61D18=08; 612>=239 B306456 D=93 4>2 :; 2<3 2=23 =884F39 2<3 =BB81?=21459103?215@2<3036B4593526)B321214530624=??409 2<3 :353712 >5930 2<3 771?1=8 3D40=59>D 9=239 *&%=59@0=52=88?4563A>3521=8:3537126F12<2<3 21D3:4>594093071H15@2<321D34774>0D452<6704D2<3 9=234703?31B247?4B;472<3409302162<1640930B=6639 :;2<301:>5=816?=883915A>362145152<16F012B3212145 3=09 D2=;= 83=0539 1@< 4>02 4E305D35283=930740B321214530)2=23=5901199<=0=5 =E144J=0183=0539?4>5638740=BB81?=52)036B459352 - 8 - % D2=;=83=05391@<4>024E305D352 83=930 E3<3D3528; 6>:D12239 2<=2 2<3 ?<=8835@3 24 2<3 40930 B=6639 :; 2<3 01:>5=8 16 458; 45 2F4 @04>596 10628; 2<3 01:>5=8 F12<4>2 =661@515@ =5; 03=6456 ?4594539 2<3 938=; 63?4598; 2<3 =BB81?=52 =BB04=?<39 =7230 032103D352 633C15@ :3537126 @0=5239 24 2<3 42<30 61D18=08; 612>=239 B306456 <16 7=?2 <=6 542 :335 ?456193039 :; 2<3 01:>5=8 2<3 938=; 15 =BB04=?<15@ <=6 542 :335 B04B308; 3HB8=1539 =59 2<303 16 54 03=6456 7402<?4D15@ 24 ?459453 2<3 1540915=23 938=; 15 =BB04=?<15@ 2<3 01:>5=8 <3 771?1=8 3D40=59>DF=6 472<3;3=0%2<3=BB81?=52=BB04=?<3901:>5=87402<3 03813715+24?4561930<16?=6374003@>8=01G=214547<16 630E1?36 ??40915@8; 64>@<2 24 =884F 2<3 B3212145 =59 916D166392<3=BB81?=2145 + 37>215@2<36>:D16614564783=05391@<4>02 4E305D352 83=930 01199<=0=5 =E1 44J=01 83=0539 ?4>5638 F12< =88 E3<3D35?3 6>:D12239 2<=2 2<3 61D18=08; 612>=239 B306456 <=E3 :335 @0=5239 :3537126 =59 - 9 - 03@>8=01G39 F<4 <=E3 =BB04=?<39 2<16 4>02 15 2<3 ;3=0 :; 166>15@ 771?1=8 3D40=59>D 9=239 *&% <3 2=23 <=6 542 D=93 4>2 =5; ?=63 24 6<4F 2<=2 2<3 =BB81?=52169177303528;B8=?392<=52<=2472<3B306456F<4 =03?4E3039>59302<3 771?1=83D40=59>D62=2396>B0= 2<3 =BB81?=52 F=6 B3061623528; 15 24>?< F12< 2<3 036B4593526740<1603@>8=01G=214521654215916B>232<=2 2<3=BB81?=52F40C39152<393B=02D352740=B3014947 ;3=06 * D452<6 <3 ?=63 47 2<3 B3212145306)036B4593526 :37403 2<301:>5=8 162<3?=63 47 2<3=BB81?=52 F4>89 :3 ?456193039 >5930 3?2145 *% " 47 =05=2=C= =5?<=;=2 =J ?2 <4F3E30 54 623B6 64 7=0 <=6 :335 2=C35 740 03@>8=01G=2145<3=BB81?=5216=BB415239=@=1562=E=?=52 B462 ?45215>39 15 630E1?3 2188 032103D352 =59 2<3 =BB4152D352 16 2<04>@< 3DB84;D352 3H?<=5@3 4771?3 6 2<3 03A>362 47 2<3 =BB81?=52 F=6 542 ?456193039 <3 71839 F012 B3212145 15 =59 <=6 :335 0383@=239 24 2<3 01:>5=8 15 E13F 47 =82305=21E3 03D39; <3 =BB81?=52 =6 452<39=234740930B=6639152<3F012B32121450383@=215@ - 10 - <1D 24 01:>5=8 F=6 =@39 % ;3=06 =59 0321039 5 2<3 ?10?>D62=5?362<301:>5=82=C15@1524?4561930=214547=88 2<3 7=?26 =884F39 2<3 =BB81?=2145 15 =BB04=?<15@ 2<3 01:>5=8 =59 @0=5239 2<3 038137 64>@<2 9103?215@ 2<3 036B4593526)B3212145306<3031524?45619302<3?=63472<3 =BB81?=52 740 03@>8=01G=2145 15 230D6 47 771?1=8 3D40=59>D9=239*&%F<1?<16=F38803=64539 40930=599436542?=88740=5;1523073035?3=22<3<=596 472<164>02 ' 4 :>220366 <16 =0@>D352 <3 <=6 038139 45 2<3 J>9@D352 47 2<3 ?440915=23 47 2<16 4>02 15 2<3 ?=63 47 24 ?4523592<=2 2<3 ?440915=23 35?< 15 = 61D18=08; 612>=239 ?=63 916D16639 2<3 B3212145 71839 :; 2<3 5145 =59 ?45710D39 2<3 40930 B=6639 :; 3520=8 9D151620=21E301:>5=89103?215@2<3=>2<40121362<3031524 ?4561930 2<3 ?=63 15 230D6 47 2<3 40930 B=6639 :; 2<3 01:>5=8??40915@8;64>@<224916D1662<3B3212145 1 !9=239*% - 11 - * =E15@ <3=09 83=0539 ?4>5638 740 2<3 B=02136 B30>6392<3352103B3212145B=B306<3458;A>3621452<=2 F4>89=01637404>0?4561930=214516=674884F6# "#$%#$&%#$&'$&()$'*+%#$ &,*-.)/, 0-%,,$',.%#$)1%).'1,&1-2%).1$%#$ (&$$.%1)$34 >0=56F30242<3=:4E3B4152740?4561930=2145 16.15=7710D=21E3/7402<374884F15@# 21654215916B>232<=242<3061D18=08;612>=239 B306456<=E3:3353H2359392<3:35371264703@>8=01G=2145 15 230D6 47 771?1=8 3D40=59>D 9=239 *&% <3 2=23 <=6 7=1839 24 D=C3 =5; 9177303521=2145 :32F335 2<3 =BB81?=52 =59 2<3 B306456 ?4E3039 >5930 2<3 771?1=8 3D40=59>D 62=239 6>B0= <3 45:83 B3H 4>02 15 = 03?352J>9@D352152<3?=63475 5 5 <389 2<=2 2<3 1591E19>=8 F<4 =03 61D18=08;612>=239242<463F<4<=E3=803=9;:335@0=5239 038137 :; 2<3 4>02 5339 542 :3 03A>1039 24 15121=23 2 1E18BB3=84*&)9=239*& - 12 - 63B=0=23 B04?33915@6 740 2<3 6=D3 :353712 <3 45:83 B3H 4>02 =2 B=0=@0=B< 46 & ' =59 * =7230 03730015@ 2<3 J>9@D352 15 2<3 ?=6347 5 67 55 5 8 9 5 <389 2<=2 15 2<3 =:635?3 47 =5; 9177303521=2145 :32F335 2<3 B30645 =59 2<3 453 F<4 <=6 =803=9; :335 @0=5239 :353712 2<303 16 54 03=645 740 2<3 =>2<4012136 15 542?456193015@2<3?8=1D4761D18=08;612>=239B306456=6 2<3 6=19 916?01D15=2145 16 F12<4>2 =5; 03=645 =59 45 2<3 B015?1B832<=281E36:3203=239=81C3 <31E1614535?<472<164>02152<3?=6347 : & <389 2<=2 12 16 542 53?366=0; 740 3E30; B30645 24 =BB04=?< 2<16 4>02 740 = 61D18=0 038137 24 2<3 453 =803=9; @0=5239 :; 2<3 4>02 15 2<33=0813093?1614567=93?16145<=6:33503593039:; 2<34>0212F4>89:3B04B307402<3=>2<40121362474884F =59 3H2359 2<3 :353712 47 2<=2 93?16145 15 81C3 ?=636 ?4D15@:374032<3D<=26<4>89:32<3@>1915@B015?1B83 3 *+"&+& 4 012BB3=84'%47*'%9=239'*'% - 13 - 24:3:405315D159152<3=9D151620=2145216542B04B30 24 901E3 3E30; B30645 24 633C 038137 15 2<3 4>02 2 16 1593392<39>2;472<3=>2<4012136243H23592<3:353712647 2<3 ?45?8>939 93?16145 47 2<3 4>026 24 =88 42<30 61D18=0 ?=636 <3?440915=2335?<472<164>0215 -(&)!=7230?456193015@2<383@=8B0454>5?3D3526 472<345:83B3H4>02=6F388=62<164>02<=6?4D36 242<3?45?8>61452<=22<3B3212145302<30315F30354215= B4612145 24 9177303521=23 :32F335 2<3 =BB81?=526 =59 036B4593524624':374032<301:>5=8152<36=19?=63 <389 2<=2 2<3 916?01D15=2145 =D4>526 24 >57=10 =59 2<3 6=D316=@=15622<36B101247.8=F473A>=812;/=??40915@8; 916D1662<3B3212145 & <16 4>02 15 40930 24 =6?302=15 F<32<30 2<3 =BB81?=52 16 B8=?39 =6 2<=2 47 2<3 B306456 ?4E3039 >5930 771?1=83D40=59>D9=239*&%35A>10392<31@< 4>02 4E305D352 83=930 15 2<=2 03@=09 4 2<3 4>02 A>30; 2<3 83=0539 1@< 4>02 4E305D352 83=930 16 - 14 - >5=:83 24 D=C3 4>2 =5; 9177303521=2145 E35 :37403 2<3 01:>5=81216542916B>2392<=22<3=BB81?=521654261D18=08; 612>=239 24 2<=2 47 2<3 B306456 ?4E3039 >5930 771?1=8 3D40=59>D9=239*&%<3458;4:J3?21452=C35 15 2<16 B3212145 16 938=; 15 =BB04=?<15@ 2<3 01:>5=8 =59 6>:63A>352 24 032103D352 =59 938=; 16 542 B04B308; 3HB8=1539 <35 2<16 4>02 F=; :=?C 15 2<3 ;3=0 *'% <=6 0>839 2<=2 12 16 542 53?366=0; 740 61D18=08; 612>=239 B3064562421D3=59=@=15=BB04=?<2<34>027402<3E30; 6=D3038137F<1?<<=6=803=9;:335@0=5239:;2<34>02 152<33=08130B321214562162<39>2;472<3=>2<401213624 3H23592<3:3537126472<3?45?8>93993?16145472<34>02 24=8842<3061D18=08;612>=239B306456 6?4>89:36335704D03?4096036B4593524 ?=8839 740 630E1?3 B=021?>8=06 47 2<3 B321214530 740 03@>8=01G=214545&'=6B30553H>03!=592<3 6=D3F=66352=6B30553H>03!%9=239+'=59 2<3 6=D3 F303 740F=0939 :; 036B459352 4& 45 +' =6 B30 553H>03!% 36B123 2<3 6=D3 2<3 - 15 - ?=63 47 2<3 =BB81?=52 F=6 542 ?456193039 <=E15@ C54F839@3 47 771?1=8 3D40=59>D 9=239 *&% 4F 12 16 542 4B35 740 2<3 2=23 24?452359 2<=2 2<30316 938=; 15 =BB04=?<15@ 2<3 01:>5=8 =59 2<3 =BB81?=52 <=6 =BB04=?<39 6>:63A>352 24 032103D352 <3 62=59 47 2<3 2=2316>5:3?4D15@452<3B=02472<3D49383DB84;3015 E13F472<383@=8B0454>5?3D35262<3=>2<40121364>@<224 <=E3?4561930392<3?=63472<3=BB81?=52F12<4>2F=1215@ 740=5;9103?2145704D2<34>0245:3<=87472<3=BB81?=52 5?3 = J>9@D352 <=6 =22=1539 715=812; @0=5215@ =5; :3537126 2<3 6=D3 =BB8136 24 =88 2<3 B306456 B8=?39 61D18=08;<3=>2<4012;152<3?=6345<=59<=E37=183924 916?<=0@3 2<310 9>2; 15 230D6 47 8=F =59 J>91?1=8 B0454>5?3D352 62=239 6>B0= <303 16 453 D403 @04>59 7402<164>0224916D1662<16F012B3212145132<34093016 B=6639 15 2<3 ;3=0 2<3 B3212145 F=6 71839 15 2<3 ;3=0 12 6<4F6 2<3 ?83=0 =B=2<; 45 2<3 B=02 47 2<3 036B459352)=>2<4012136 15 ?4DB8;15@ 2<3 40930 B=6639 :; 2<3 01:>5=8 <3 40930 B=6639 15 F12< 2<3 21D3 - 16 - 6?<39>83F12<4>22<303:315@=5;152301D409302<32=23 >2<4012136F=1239740;3=06=592<35718392<3B3212145 2<16=D4>52624=0:120=0;=59>503=645=:83452<3B=0247 2<32=23371595415710D12136152<340930B=6639:;2<3 01:>5=8 40 2<3 03=6456 62=239 6>B0= F3 B=66 2<3 74884F15@# 1" <3 F012 B3212145 71839 ?<=8835@15@ 2<3 40930 9=239 % 15 BB81?=2145 4&%)+ B=6639 :; 2<3 =05=2=C= 2=23 9D151620=21E301:>5=8 =8=:>0=@1).D30126 =59=??40915@8;',2,$' 11" <3 01:>5=8 B=6639 40930 15 24 ?4561930 2<3?=63472<3=BB388=52F12<15=B301494774>0 D452<6 F3 =03 54F 63315@ 2<3 359 47 2<3 =BB81?=52)B01E=23 036B459352 54F =@39 + 621880>5515@=04>594>02740<1601@<27>8?8=1D ??40915@8; F3 9103?2 2<3 B321214530)2=23 24 ?4DB8;F12<2<340930B=6639:;2<301:>5=8=6 - 17 - 3HB391214>68;=6B4661:83F12<15=54>23081D1247 2F4 D452<6 F12<4>2 F=1215@ 740 = ?4B; 47 2<3 40930=62<3;=03B=02136152<3B3212145=1815@ 24 ?4DB8; F4>89 0>5 =>2<4012136 E>8530=:83 24 7>02<30?4563A>35?36 !" #$% !&'(" #$% 1624#84#&* #