- 1 - ! "#$ %$&$$ '' (')'* + ! ( * "##$%" ! " &' #&("$% $ && #&("$% Digitally signed by KHAJAAMEEN MALAGHAN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - )& # #&("$% ) &% #&("$% & && #&("$% &" #&("$% ' $) #&("$% ( $ #&("$% * && #&("$% + ), + *, ""%$& $ ++ " & ! - 3 - + "%% + ""*$%%* $#%#$%") ! ))$%%' "#%'#$%%* + ++ + ! + + - & $ - ! ./0 122314 56 7.3 241/87/99 53/8: 1::;/3<3= 56 7.3 >?=:@387 18= =3A;33 =173= "%'$%%* 21003= /8 B))$%%' B8 7.3 9/43 /</4 ?=:3 ; 8! /8=1:/ 9B; 0.B;7 C7.3 ;/14 B?;7D! E./A. /0 AB89/;@3= 56 7.3 >?=:@387 18= =3A;33 =173= $%$%") 21003= /8 B""*$%%*B87.39/43B9 ==/7/B814 /07;/A7?=:3 />12?;9B;0.B;7C7.3+/;0722344173B?;7D! - 4 - %$ .3 15B<3 0?/7 /0 9/43= 56 7.3 241/87/99 9B; 7.3 ;34/39 B9 21;7/7/B8 18= 0321;173 2B00300/B8 /8 ;3023A7 B9 0?/7 2;B23;7/30 =30A;/53= /8 0A.3=?43# 7B 7.3 241/87 AB80/07/8: B9 9/<3 418=3= 2;B23;7/30 18= 7.;33 .B?03 2;B23;7/30 % .3A103B97.3241/87/99/07.17, " 83 101221 21003= 1E16 /8 7.3 631; "** 431</8: 53./8= ./0 E/=BE # .337151/ 18= 7.;33 0B80 56 81@3 ?441221 =3938=187 B"! 1@1221 18= B==1221.301/=1@12217.303AB8=0B821003=1E16 ?8@1;;/3= .3 41/87/99 /0 7.3 E/=BE B9 7./;= 0B8 F B=1221 .3 01/= 337151/ # E/93 B9 2;B2B0/7?0 21003= 1E16/87.3631;"*'$.301/= B=12217.3.?0518=B9 7.3241/87/9921003=1E16/87.3631;"*'&431</8:53./8= ./@7.3241/87/9910./0B846.3/;.3=3938=1870B$7B) 1;37.30B80B9=3938=187B"18==3938=187B&/07.3 =1?:.73; B9 =3938=187 B" .3 =3938=187 B /0 7.3 .?0518=B9=3938=187B& - 5 - $ .17 418= 531;/8: 6B0$%$ )"& 18= &&& E3;3BE83=18=2B003003=56101221973;./0=3@/03 81@30B9./00B80E3;3@?7173=/87.3;3<38?3;3AB;=0/8 ;3023A7B97.301/=418=0E/=3B&(").3;3E101 =/02?73/8;3023A7B9418=6B$%)537E33810122118= ./05;B7.3;1;322118=7.301@3E10=3A;33=/891<B?; B9 101221 AAB;=/8:46 7.3 01/= 418= /8 6B$%) 140B A1@37B7.32B00300/B818=BE83;0./2B9101221 1@3 B9 =3938=187 B" E10 3873;3= /8 7.3 ;3<38?3 ;3AB;=0 10 .3 E10 @181:/8: 7.3 1991/;0 B9 7.3 91@/46 .3 =3938=187 B" @?7173= 7.3 81@30 B9 =3938=1870 B$ 7B ) /8 7.3 ;3<38?3 ;3AB;=0 =?;/8: 7.3 631;"*'*.3=3938=1870B$7B)3993A73=7.321;7/7/B8 /8;3023A7B9418=/86B$%)"E/=3B'')"/87.3 631;"**(447.3037;1801A7/B80.1=71G38241A3E/7.B?7 7.3 G8BE43=:3 B9 7.3 241/87/99 0 0?A. 7.36 1;3 8B7 5/8=/8:B8.3; - 6 - ) .3@1;;/1:3B97.3241/87/99E/7. B=1221E10 23;9B;@3=@B;37.18%631;01:BBE3<3;8BA./4=E10 5B;87B7.3@2B87.3=3@/03B9.3;.?0518=/87.3631; "*'& 7.3 =3938=1870 =/= 8B7 4BBG 1973; 7.3 241/87/99 0 0?A. 0.3 .10 5338 ;30/=/8: 17 .3; 2173;814 .B?03 17 3;?71:/ 3938=187B"E/7.18/87387/B8B9=386/8:7.3 0.1;3 B9 7.3 241/87/99 .1= 0?5@/773= 7.3 <1;1=/ 7B 7.3 </441:3 1AAB?87187 0717/8: 7.17 ./0 6B?8:3; 5;B7.3;0 # 1@1221 18= B=1221 =/3= ?8@1;;/3= AAB;=/8:46 @?717/B8/8B(")E10A3;7/9/3=E./A./09140318= AB8ABA73= .3;31973; =3938=187 B" B571/83= @?717/B8 387;6 E/=3 B("&% 18= *'*% B9 B;<1; </441:3 1443:/8: 7.17 =3938=187 B" .1= :/<38 21;7 B9 418= /8 6B$%$$ 18= B)"&" 7BE1;=0 @1/873818A3 B9 =3938=187 B& 7.B?:. 0.3 E10 8B7 387/743= 9B; 0?A. ;/:.70 .3 241/87/99 B8 431;8/8: 15B?7 7.3 /443:14/7/30 =3@18=3= 9B; 21;7/7/B8 18= 0321;17/B8 B9 .3; 0.1;30 =38/14B9E./A..10AB807;1/83=.3;7B9/437.30?/7 - 7 - %) .3 =3938=187 B" 9/43= E;/7738 07173@387 E./A. /0 1=B273= 56 =3938=1870 B) & 18= .3 =3938=1870 B$ 7B =/= 8B7 9/43 E;/7738 07173@387 .3 =3938=1870B7B*91/43=7B12231;100?A.7.36E3;3 241A3=3H#21;73 %& 8 7.3 E;/7738 07173@387 7.3 =3938=187 B" AB8738=3=7.17 &" .177.3 B==1221./06B?8:3;5;B7.3;21003= 1E16?8@1;;/3=/87.3631;"*'&.3241/87/99E.BA41/@0 7B 53 ./0 E/=BE E10 .1;=46 "& 7B " 631;0 B9 1:3 .3 241/87/99/07.323;@18387;30/=387B93;?71:/</441:3.3 E104/</8:E/7.B83/8:1221.3;@173;814?8A4318=E.B /08B@B;3.30/073;B97.3241/87/99/0:/<38/8@1;;/1:3 7B 7.3 0B8 B9 7.3 =3938=187 B" 81@346 10.1221 7.3 =3938=187B$ &$ 0 0?A. 7.3 A41/@ B9 7.3 241/87/99 53/8: 7.3 E/=BE B9 =3A3103= # B==1221 /0 91403 18= 0.3 /0 8B7 .1</8: 186 0.1;3 /8 7.3 0?/7 2;B23;7/30 .3 A41/@B9 7.3 241/87/997.170.3.1</8:5338@1;;/3=7B B==122115B?7 %631;01:B/09140318=?87381543 - 8 - & .3 241/87/99 9/43= 7.3 0?/7 B846 E/7. 7.3 0B43 /87387/B8B92;300?;/I/8:=3938=187B"7B0377437.3B7.3; 0?/77.17/0238=/8:/8 B"$%$%%9/43=56=3938=187 B.3=3938=187B$#10.122118==3938=187B 1=/E1412211;37.30B80B9=3938=187B"E.B.1=9/43= 7.3 01/= 0?/7 /8 B"$%$%% 7B ;3B238 7.3 31;4/3; 21;7/7/B8 81AAB?87B901/==/02?7307.3;3417/B80./2E/7. =3938=187 B" E10 02B/43= .17 /8 </3E B9 7.3 01/= ;3417/B80./2=3938=1870B$7B.1<3037?27.3241/87/99 7B9/437.32;303870?/7 &) .177.3=3938=187B".105338/82B00300/B8 18=38>B6@387B97.30?/72;B23;769B;@B;37.18%631;0 3<382;/B;7B9/4/8:B97.30?/7E/7.B?7186B5>3A7/B809;B@ 186B83 E.B@0B3<3; 10 0?A. .3 .10 23;93A73= ./0 387/743@3877B7.32;B23;76B<3;123;/B=B97/@338A3 0B?:.79B;=/0@/0014B97.30?/7 - 9 - % .3 ;/14 B?;7 5103= B8 7.3 2431=/8: 9;1@3= 7.39B44BE/8:/00?30# ! %' 41/87/99 3H1@/83= .3;0349 10 " 18= 3H1@/83= 7EB @B;3 E/7830030 10 $ 18= 18= 3H./5/73= $& =BA?@3870 10 23; H" 7B $& EB E/7830030 .1<3 5338 3H1@/83= B8 53.149 B9 7.3 =3938=187010 "18=$18=@1;G3=$%=BA?@387010 23;H "7B$% %( 8 122;3A/17/B8 B9 3</=38A3 7.3 ;/14 AB?;7 180E3;3= /00?30 B " 7B ) /8 7.3 83:17/<3 18= AB803J?38746 =/0@/003= 7.3 0?/7 .B4=/8: 7.17 7.3 241/87/99 .1=91/43=7B2;B<3.3;03497B537.3E/93B97.3=3A3103=# B==1221 - 10 - %* 3/8:1::;/3<3=241/87/999/43=3:?41;22314/8 B""*$%%* .3 01/= 122314 E10 71G38 ?2 56 7.3 +/;0722344173B?;79B;AB80/=3;17/B8B99B44BE/8:2B/870# " # # # $ # "% .3 +/;07 22344173 B?;7 B8 ;3#122;3A/17/B8 B9 3</=38A3 180E3;3= 2B/870 B" 7B /8 7.3 83:17/<3 18= AB803J?38746 =/0@/003= 7.3 122314 18= AB89/;@3= 7.3 >?=:@38718==3A;3321003=567.3;/14B?;7 "" 3/8: 1::;/3<3= 7.3 2;30387 122314 /0 9/43= 56 7.3241/87/99 - 11 - "$ 31;83= AB?8034 9B; 7.3 241/87/99#122344187 ;3/73;17/8: 7.3 :;B?8=0 ?;:3= /8 7.3 @3@B;18=?@ B9 122314 0?5@/773= 7.17 7.3 ;/14 B?;7 18= 7.3 +/;07 22344173 B?;7 3;;3= /8 8B7 1AA327/8: 7.3 B;14 18= =BA?@3871;6 3</=38A3 2;B=?A3= 56 7.3 241/87/99 7B 2;B<3 .3;@1;;/1:3E/7.4173F B==1221.3241/87/99.1=3<38 3H1@/83= 7EB /8=3238=387 E/7830030 E.B .1<3 02BG38 15B?77.3@1;/7140717?0B97.3241/87/99E/7.7.3=3A3103=# B==1221.177.3241/87/99.1=2;B=?A3=E/=BE2380/B8 A1;=18=7.3;17/B8A1;=7B307154/0..3;;3417/B80./2E/7. 7.3 =3A3103= .3 01/= =BA?@3870 1;3 7.3 2?54/A =BA?@3870AB?4=8B7.1<3533883:173=567.3;/14B?;7 18= 7.3 +/;07 22344173 B?;7 .17 AB80/=3;/8: 7.3 1:3 18= 7.3 51AG:;B?8= B9 7.3 241/87/99 /7 EB?4= 53 536B8= AB@2;3.380/B87B3H23A77.17241/87/99EB?4=:B18=033G =3A41;17/B8 B9 .3;0349 53/8: 1 E/93 B9 0B@3B83 3403 ./0 1023A7 B9 7.3 @1773; .10 5338 4B07 0/:.7 B9 56 7.3 B?;7 :/</8: ;/03 7B 0?507187/14 J?307/B8 B9 41E /8 7.3 @1773; 38A3033G09B;144BE/8:7.3122314 - 12 - " % 7.3 431;83= AB?8034 12231;/8: 9B; 7.3 ;302B8=387 # =3938=187 0?5@/70 7.17 7.3 <3;6 =30A;/27/B8B97.321;7/309B?8=/87.3241/8710E34410/8 7.3 3</=38A3#199/=1</70 EB?4= /8=/A173 7.17 7.3 241/87/99 E.BA41/@07B.1<3@1;;/3=7B B==122115B?7%7B& 631;0 2;/B; 7B 9/4/8: B9 7.3 0?/7 EB?4= .1<3 5338 >?07 1 @/8B;.171=@/773=460/073;B97.3241/87/99E10:/<38/8 @1;;/1:3 7B =3938=187 B$#10.1221 7.3 0B8 B9 =3938=187 B" 0 0?A. 7.B?:. 7.3;3 /0 8B 0717?7B;6 2;B./5/7/B8 9B; 0?A. 1 @1;;/1:3 /7 /0 ?81AA3271543 7.17 =3938=187 B$#10.1221 53/8: 1 832.3E B9 B==1221 EB?4=@1;;60/073;B9./0E/93E./A.;3417/B871871@B?877B 7.17B91@B7.3;3140B;393;07B7.3;3<38?3=BA?@3870 2;B=?A3= 56 7.3 =3938=1870 17 H 7B "% 7B 2B/87 B?7 7.177.301/=;3<38?3387;/30.1<3AB@3/87B3H/0738A317 18 ?8=/02?73= 2B/87 /8 7/@3 E.3;3 /8 B==1221 18= 1@12217.30B80B91012211;30.BE87B.1<321003= 1E16 E.38 7.36 E3;3 @/8B;0 17 7.3 1:3 B9 "% 18= %& ;3023A7/<346 0 0?A. 7.3 J?307/B8 B9 B==1221 53/8: - 13 - 14/<3 7B @1;;6 241/87/99 % 7B & 631;0 1:B 10 A41/@3= /0 ?87381543 .17 7.3 =BA?@3870 0B?:.7 7B 53 ;34/3= ?2B8 56 7.3 241/87/99 81@346 7.3 E/=BE 2380/B8 A3;7/9/A173 /0 ?8;34/1543 /810@?A. 10 7.3 241/87/99 E.B A41/@0 7B 53 BE8/8: /@@B<1543 2;B23;76 A188B7 53 /00?3= E/7. 7.3 E/=BE 2380/B8 A3;7/9/A173 .17 1 23;?014 B9 7.3 01/= =BA?@387 .3 0?5@/70 /8=/A173 B<3; E;/7/8: B8 7.3 01/= =BA?@3873;393;0 7B7.3;17/B8A1;= 53/8: ;34/3=?2B8 56 7.3 241/87/99 7B AB8738= 7.17 7.3 01/= =BA?@387 .10 AB@3 ?2 B846 >?07 2;/B; 7B 9/4/8: B9 7.3 0?/7 3 140B 0?5@/707.177.3;3/0AB87;1=/A7/B8/87.3=32B0/7/B8B97.3 241/87/99 /8 7.17 /8 B83 5;317. E./43 0.3 A41/@0 7.3 @1;;/1:3A3;3@B867BBG241A3/8173@24318=/87.3B7.3; 0.3 A41/@0 7.3 01@3 .1</8: 71G38 241A3 /8 9;B87 B9 7.3 .B?03.?0.30?5@/707.177.3;/14B?;718=7.3+/;07 22344173 B?;7 .1</8: 122;3A/173= 7.303 @173;/14 3</=38A3 241A3= B8 ;3AB;= .1<3 AB@3 7B >?07 AB8A4?0/B8 18= =3A4/8/8: 7B 1AA327 7.3 A41/@ B9 7.3 241/87/99 B9 0.3 53/8:7.3E/=BEB9 B==1221.17E.387.3;3417/B80./2 - 14 - /70349 .10 8B7 5338 2;B<3= 7.3 J?307/B8 B9 0.3 53/8: 387/743= 9B; 0.1;/8: 7.3 91@/46 2;B23;76 EB?4= 8B7 1;/03 .?08B0?507187/14J?307/B8EB?4=1;/039B;AB80/=3;17/B8 18=033G09B;=/0@/0014 ") 31;=3;?03=7.3;3AB;=0 "& .3 241/87/99 E.B A41/@0 7B 53 7.3 E/=BE B9 B==1221 7.3 7./;= 0B8 B9 101221 /0 ;3J?/;3= 17 7.3 B?70377B 307154/0. .3;;3417/B80./2 B9 0.353/8:1 43:1446 E3==3=E/93B9 B==1221/8B;=3;7B0?AA33=/8.3;A41/@ 9B;21;7/7/B8B97.32;B23;76534B8:/8:7B7.3=3938=1870 .3 3</=38A3 ;34/3= ?2B8 56 7.3 241/87/99 /0 .3; BE8 B;14 A41/@B90.3.1</8:@1;;/3=7B B==122115B?7%7B& 631;02;/B;7B9/4/8:B97.30?/7 87.3199/=1</79/43=/84/3? B9 .3; 3</=38A3 241/87/99 .10 =32B03= 7.17 .3; @1;;/1:3 E10 23;9B;@3= /8 9;B87 B9 .3; .B?03 B9 B==1221 .3 140B 1=@/70 7.17 .3; 6B?8:3; 0/073; .1:1<1 /0 :/<38 /8 @1;;/1:37B10.12217.3=3938=187B$E.B/07.30B8 B9 =3938=187 B" .3 9?;7.3; =32B030 7.17 E.38 - 15 - B==122121003=1E16E.38.3E101:3=15B?7$&631;0 18= 0.3 E10 1:3= 15B?7 " 631;0 .3 9?;7.3; =32B030 7.17 B=1221E101:3=$&631;018=0.3E10B9"$631;0 E.38 7.36 @1;;/3= .3 2431=0 /:8B;18A3 B9 ;3<38?3 387;/30 ;3943A7/8: 7.3 =317. B9 B==1221 18= ./0 5;B7.3; E./437.36E3;307/44@/8B;0 " /7830030 $ 18= E.B .1<3 5338 3H1@/83= 56 7.3 241/87/99 7B 2;B<3 .3; @1;;/1:3 /8 7.3 A;B00#3H1@/817/B8 .1<3 2431=3= /:8B;18A3 15B?7 7.3 E1@/>/ E.B 23;9B;@3= 7.3 @1;;/1:3 .36 .1<3 140B 2431=3= /:8B;18A3 15B?7 7.3 23;9B;@18A3 B9 ?;1:/ 9?8A7/B8 .36 .1<3 140B 1=@/773= 7.17 0/073; B9 7.3 241/87/99 81@346 .1:1<<1 .1= :/<38 /8 @1;;/1:3 7B =3938=187B$ "' .3 =BA?@387 9?;8/0.3= 56 7.3 241/87/99 @B;3 21;7/A?41;46 7.3 317. 3;7/9/A173 B9 B==1221 10 23; H"' /8=/A17/8: ./0 173 B9 317. 10 $%""*'& .3 .10 140B 2;B=?A3= H$) 1 A3;7/9/A173 /00?3= 56 7.3 - 16 - 31=@1073;B9B=34;/@1;6A.BB4B;1E1;/8=/A17/8: 7.3 173 B9 /;7. B9 B==1221 10 %"%"*&% BE3<3; 7.31?7.B;B97.301/==BA?@38717H$)/08B73H1@/83= 7B 2;B<3 7.3 173 B9 /;7. B9 B==1221 10 0B?:.7 7B 53 @1=3B?7567.3241/87/99 "( .3/=BE380/B8 =387/9/A17/B81;=2;B=?A3= 17H$10;/:.74671G388B73B9567.3;/14B?;7.10 B<3; E;/7/8: .3 43A7/B8 1;= 17 H$$ .10 5338 /00?3=/87.3631;$%%18=7.3/8071870?/7.10140B5338 9/43= /8 7.3 631; $%% .3 17/B8 1;= 2;B=?A3= 17 H$&=B308B7.1<37.3=173B9/70/00?18A3 "* 8 1==/7/B8 7.3 241/87/99 .3;0349 .10 2;B=?A3= 7.3 ?717/B8 3:/073; H7;1A7 10 23; H E./A. /0 140B @1;G3= 56 7.3 =3938=1870 10 H 3;?014 B9 7.3 01/= =BA?@387 /8=/A173 7.17 101221 21003= 1E16 B8 $%%)"** 431</8: 53./8= ./0 0B80 81@346 ?441221 1@1221 B==1221 18= 7.3 01/= 7.;33 0B80 1;3 ;32;303873= 56 7.3/; @B7.3; 10 7.3/; @/8B; :?1;=/18 H;31=010?8=3; - 17 - !"#$%"&'()*+),)-./ -0'.123$-451236+ .7 8 9 ' 0 - 3$%),)-./-30 8 9 '. 0 - * :;$% !< = - *:;$-% $% 8B7.3; ?717/B8 3:/073; H7;1A7 2;B=?A3=56 7.3 241/87/990 10 H"% 10 E344 10 56 7.3 =3938=1870 @1;G3= 10 H " 3;?014 B9 7.3 01/= =BA?@387 EB?4= /8=/A1737.177.381@30B9?4412211@1221 B==1221 E3;3 @?7173= /87.3 ;3<38?3 ;3AB;=010 <1;10?=1;0.3 01/==BA?@387;31=010?8=3; ,(>9?1-?@ A()*+) ,)-./-%A,0 8 9 0 3-B %, $ -./ 3C *'D '- "# ( E<#- $ 0 8 9 3 "#-B " F - - () *+ 3 3-B - 3C ; :; D - * :.* *+ 3 !< G = :;% $" 3;?014 B9 7.3 19B;301/= =BA?@3870 81@346 H140B@1;G3=10H A173:B;/A1446307154/0.3=7.17 3<38 10 B8 $%%)"** 7.3 =16 E.38 101221 7.3/; 917.3;21003=1E16 B==1221E10@/8B; - 18 - $$ H"% 140B @1;G3= 10 H " 10 3H7;1A73= 15B<3 /0 1 =BA?@387 =173= %"$"*(* E./A. .10 AB@3 /87B 3H/0738A3 0?503J?387 7B 7.3 =3@/03 B9 B==1221 /8=/A1737.17 B==1221.1=21003=1E16E.38.3E1007/44 1@/8B;18=?8@1;;/3= $ .38 7.3 B;14 18= =BA?@3871;6 3</=38A3 2;B=?A3=567.3241/87/99/0>?H712B03=E/7.7.3=BA?@3870 2;B=?A3= 17 H 18= H"% 56 8B83 B7.3; 7.18 7.3 241/87/997.32/A7?;3E./A.3@3;:30/07.17 B==1221E.B 1=@/773=4621003=1E16/87.3631;"*'&E10@/8B;177.3 7/@3 E.38 ./0 917.3; 21003= 1E16 18= ;3@1/83= ?8@1;;/3=7/44./0=317..3;3/08B;310B88B77B1AA327 7.3 19B;301/= =BA?@3871;6 3</=38A3 E./A. .1<3 AB@3 /87B 3H/0738A3 17 18 ?8=/02?73= 2B/87 B9 7/@3 E./A. A4/8A.30 7.3 A103 B9 7.3 =3938=1870 B9 241/87/99 8B7 53/8: 7.3E/=BEB9 B==1221 - 19 - $) .3 ;/14 B?;7 18= 7.3 +/;07 22344173 B?;7 71G/8:8B73B97.303B;1418==BA?@3871;63</=38A3.1<3 AB@37B>?07AB8A4?0/B87B.B4=7.177.3241/87/99.1091/43= 7B2;B<3.3;;3417/B80./2B90.353/8:1E/93B9 B==1221 .387.3241/87/99.1091/43=7B2;B<37.3;3417/B80./27.3 9?;7.3;J?307/B8E.37.3;B;8B70.3/0387/743=7B0.1;3/8 2;B23;7653AB@30;3=?8=187 $& B 23;<3;0/76 /443:14/76 B; /;;3:?41;/76 A18 53 9B?8= /8 7.3 9/8=/8: 18= AB8A4?0/B8 1;;/<3= 56 7.3 ;/14 B?;7 18= AB89/;@3= 56 7.3 +/;07 22344173 B?;7 B 0?507187/14 J?307/B8 B9 41E EB?4= 7.3;39B;3 1;;/<3 17 9B; AB80/=3;17/B822314/01AAB;=/8:46 ,) ($$* & "