Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 66136 (KAR)

DR. NITIN KUMAR v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA

CRL.P/200626/2025 · 2025-08-30

M G Uma

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - ! "#$## # %&' %()* '%)) + !" # $ %& !" ' ( ) * + !" Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - * + ", # - , #. " ' ( */ # ) * #*()# * % $"#"# ( $,#"#,) "##"# * $$#"#* ** ,"# #" #"# , * * 0 (0 ) 1232454567289:257;<==>92? 69 <7? 57 85@2 6$,#"#, 6A <B<7<;<8 6B5=2 4<4567 76C 327?57; 57 - 3 - 6$$#"# 67 412 A5B2 6A 412 B2<872? ??54567<B 275685D5B>?;2<7?*5E<F<3>8<82;594282?A68 4126AA27=293>7591<:B2>7?28 2=45679,"##"#"#82<? C541 2=4567 , 6A <82 922G57; 46 H><91 =85@57<B 386=22?57;957545<42?<;<5794412@ # *<=49 6A 412 =<92 57 :852A <82 41<4 829367?274 6# :257; 57A68@<74 B6?;2? 412 A5894 57A68@<4567 C541 <B<7<;<8 6B5=2 4<4567 <;<5794 <==>92? 69 46 , <BB2;57; =6@@599567 6A 412 6AA27=2 3>7591<:B2 >7?28 2=4567,"##"82<?C541 2=4567,6A45994<42? 41<4 412 ?2=2<92? 59 57A68@<74I9 3<4287<B >7=B2 <7? 12 9>932=42?41<4<==>92?6946,@5;141<D2=<>92?159 ?2<41 <7? :>852? 412 ?2<? :6?F 57 < 9>935=56>9 @<7728 29367?2746#7642?A2C57E>852967412?2<?:6?F<7? 9>932=42?41<412@5;141<D2:227@>8?282?1282A682 12 82H>2942? 412 6B5=2 46 82;59428 412 =<92 <7? 57D2945;<42412@<4428 , ==68?57;BF*=<@246:282;594282?<;<5794 <==>92? 69 46 , 12 ?2<? :6?F C<9 2J1>@2? <7? - 4 - 9>:E2=42? 46 3694 @6842@ 2J<@57<4567 9 328 412 3694 @6842@ 823684 ?2<41 6A 412 ?2=2<92? C<9 ?>2 46 <931FJ5< 829>B457; A86@ B5;<4>82 948<7;>B<4567 <996=5<42? C541 412 @<7><B 418644B57; >857; 57D2945;<4567 54 C<9 A6>7? 41<4 41282C<9 ?593>42:24C227412 ?2=2<92?<7? <==>92?6946,57412@<44286A4123863284F12B?:F 412 ?2=2<92? 9 < 829>B4 6A C15=1 <==>92? 69 46 , <99<>B42? 15@ ==>92? 69# 46 , 9<5? 46 1<D2 =<>;14 16B?6A412?2=2<92?C15B2<==>92?6948<7;>B<42?159 72=GC5413B<945=8632<7?<B96C5411<7?9C15=1829>B42? 57 159 ?2<41 ==>92? 69 46 , 386=B<5@2? 41<4 412 ?2=2<92?1<?A<BB27?6C757412:<41866@<7?C<9915A42? 46 412 169354<B 12 32454567289 :257; 412 6=4689 2J<@572? 15@ <7? ?2=B<82? 41<4 12 C<9 :86>;14 ?2<? 12 ?2<? :6?F C<9 1<7?2? 6D28 46 <==>92? 6, ==>92?6946,1<D24<G27412?2<?:6?F<7?:>852? 54 6C2D28 <==>92? 69 <7? :257; 6=4689 57 412 69354<B1<D276457A68@2?412A<=4464126B5=241<4412 ?2<? :6?F C<9 :86>;14 46 412 69354<B 1282A682 412 - 5 - A57<B823684=<@246:2A5B2?<;<5794<==>92?6946,A68 4126AA27=293>7591<:B2>7?28 2=45679,"#<7?#"82<? C541 2=4567 , 6A <7? <;<5794 <==>92? 69 <7? A68 412 6AA27=2 3>7591<:B2 >7?28 2=4567 #"# 6A ==>92? 69 <7? <82 :2A682 4159 6>84 922G57; 46 H><91412=85@57<B386=22?57;57545<42?<;<5794412@ 2<8? 85 <7E<F <45B B2<872? =6>792B A68 412 32454567289 <7? 85 <@<?<8 1<1<:>??57 B2<872? 5;1 6>84 6D287@274 B2<?28 A68 412 829367?274 4<4228>92?412@<4285<B96782=68? 7 D52C 6A 412 85D<B =6742745679 >8;2? :F 412 B2<872?=6>792B9A68:6414123<845294123657441<4C6>B? <8592A68@F=6795?28<456759 !"#$% - 6 - ! F <79C28 46 412 <:6D2 36574 59 57 A68412A6BB6C57; . 4 59 412 932=5A5= =674274567 6A 412 38692=>4567 41<4 <==>92? 69 46 , 1<D2 =<>92? 412 ?2<41 6A ?2=2<92? :F 948<7;>B<457; 159 72=G C541 412 3B<945= 8632 <7?<B96@<7><BBF418644B57;15@12F1<D2<B96=<>92? ?59<332<8<7=26A4122D5?27=26A=6@@54457;4126AA27=2 12 ?2<? :6?F C<9 :86>;14 46 412 69354<B C541 < A<B92 159468F 41<4 12 1<? A<BB27 ?6C7 57 412 :<41866@ 7 2J<@57<4567 <==>92? 69 <7? ?2=B<82? 15@ <9 :86>;14?2<?<7?1<7?2?6D28412?2<?:6?F46<==>92? 6,>367C15=1<==>92?6946,1<D2:>852?412?2<? :6?F 57 F?28<:<? 1282A682 412 6AA27=29 <BB2;2? <;<5794 <==>92? 69 46 , <82 >7?28 2=45679 ,"# <7? #" 82<? C541 2=4567 , 6A C15B2 412 <BB2;<4567 <;<5794<==>92?69<7?5967BF>7?28 2=4567#"#6A 6C2D28 <=6@@67 =1<8;291224 =<@2 46 :2A5B2? <7?B2<872?<;5948<42466G=6;75K<7=26A4126AA27=29 - 7 - 6C5459412=6742745676A412B2<872?=6>792B A68 412 32454567289 41<4 2=4567 #"# 6A C15=1 59 <33B5=<:B2 46 412 3829274 32454567289 59 < 767=6;75K<:B2 <7?:<5B<:B26AA27=2459?59457=4A86@4126AA27=29>7?28 2=45679,"#<7?#"6A<BB2;2?<;<5794<==>92?69 46,12386=2?>82<9=6742@3B<42?>7?28 2=45676A 8C<9764A6BB6C2?:F4127D2945;<457;AA5=28<7? 41282A682412=85@57<B386=22?57;957545<42?<;<579441292 32454567289 722?9 46 :2 H><912? 2 3B<=2? 82B5<7=2 67 412 ?2=59567 6A 412 67I:B2 32J 6>84 57 C128241267I:B232J6>84 =6795?282? 412 =<92 C15=1 1<9 27?2? 57 <=H>544<B <A428 < A>BBAB2?;2?485<B<7?12B?573<8<;8<316<9>7?28/ &'( ) *"+ ,! &-( ! &( &#( 1 $.$ #,# - 8 - * " + , * " + ,* ) .* ! ! *"+ ,*/ " + ,! * ) * #"' &+ //( *##-+ , ! *"+ ,*) 0 , 11 * " + , *) * ) *"+ , *) * - 9 - A428 41292 6:928D<45679 412 67I:B2 32J 6>84 <=H>5442? 412 <==>92? A68 412 6AA27=2 3>7591<:B2 >7?28 2=4567#"#6A $ 2<872?=6>792B1<9<B963B<=2?82B5<7=267412 ?2=59567 6A 57 ! #C1282412=1<8;291224=<@246:2A5B2?<;<5794 412 <==>92? A68 412 6AA27=29 3>7591<:B2 >7?28 2=45679 ,"!,.!#"<7?#"#82<?C541 2=4567$6A<7? 4126AA27=29>7?28 2=45679,.!,"!<7?#"C<9<;<5794 412@<57<==>92?C15B24126AA27=2>7?28 2=4567#"#6A C<9 <;<5794 412 32454567289 :2A682 412 =668?57<42 27=1 6A 412 28<B< 5;1 6>84 C16 1<D2 96>;14 A68 H><9157; 412 =85@57<B 386=22?57;9 12 6>84 12B? 41<4 412 6AA27=2 <BB2;2? >7?28 2=4567 #"# 6A <;<5794 412 3245456728412825759<923<8<42<7??59457=4767=6;75K<:B2 6AA27=2 485<:B2 :F 412 <;5948<42 1282A682 412 57D2945;<45676A4129<5?6AA27=2=<7:2=67?>=42?:F412 6B5=267BF<A428;24457;328@599567A86@412<;5948<42<9 2 #"# .,#. - 10 - 386D5?2?>7?28 2=4567(#)6A8<7?<==68?57;BF 412=85@57<B386=22?57;9C<9H><912? " 7412A<=496A4123829274=<925459=B2<841<4 4126AA27=2<BB2;2?<;<5794<==>92?6946,<82>7?28 2=4567,"#<7?#"82<?C541 2=4567,6AC15B2412 6AA27=2 <BB2;2? <;<5794 412 3829274 32454567289 :257; <==>92? 69 <7? 59 >7?28 2=4567 #"# 6A 1282A682 412 6AA27=2 <BB2;2? <;<5794 412 32454567289 59 ?59457=4 <7? 923<8<42 <7? >7=6772=42? C541 412 6AA27=2 <BB2;2? <;<5794 <==>92? 69 46 , 5@5B<8BF <==>92? 69 46 , <82 <B96 764 =6772=42? 46 412 6AA27=2 >7?28 2=4567 #"# 6A 7?28 9>=1 =58=>@94<7=29 <@ 6A 412635756741<4923<8<42*916>B?1<D2:22782;594282? <;<5794412382927432454567289A684126AA27=23>7591<:B2 >7?28 2=4567#"#6A<A428A6BB6C57;412386=2?>82<9 =6742@3B<42? >7?28 2=4567 (#) 6A 8 57=2 41282 59 < 92856>9 B<392 57 412 386=2?>82 <?6342? :F 412 7D2945;<457;AA5=28<@6A412635756741<4412=85@57<B 386=22?57;957545<42?<;<57944123245456728959B5<:B246:2 - 11 - H><912?6C2D285741227?96AE>945=2B5:284F@<F:2 82928D2? 57 A<D6>8 6A 412 38692=>4567 46 A6BB6C 412 386=2?>82 <7? 46 82;59428 < 923<8<42 * <A8291 <;<5794 412923245456728957<==68?<7=2C541B<C 7D52C6A412<:6D2<79C28412<:6D236574 57412 <7?386=22?463<99412A6BB6C57; 5) 123245456759 " 55) 85@57<B 386=22?57;9 57545<42? <;<5794 412 32454567289<==>92? 69 <7? 57 6$$#"# 67 412 A5B2 6A 412 B2<872? ??B 27568 5D5B >?;2 <7? * 6>84 5E<F<3>8< 57 85@2 6$,#"#, 6A <B<7<;<8 6B5=2 4<4567 82;594282? A68 412 6AA27=2 3>7591<:B2 >7?28 2=4567 6A 59 1282:F H><912? 555) 5:284F 59 82928D2? 57 A<D6>8 6A 412 38692=>4567 46 82;59428 < 923<8<42 * <;<5794 412 3829274 - 12 - 3245456728957<==68?<7=2C541B<C5A4129<@259 328@5995:B2 ? %##) $ 5946 B6,"