- 1 - ! " # $%& $'() &$(( * !"! # $ % ! &'' !"! &'' ' (!" ) *) + ) * ' , , *! Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - - ) . !" +* !! , +) ' !) * !+ + !* ' +) ' ! *) ! ! * ' ! - 3 - !. ' ( !"! )" ' )! ' ' ( !"! )) ', ) ' ' !"! # $ & !% & ) &$% *) & ).")") "))")* & / ' - 4 - $ / '% 012134345617489::741;1<=>30157<175?3015@73 =1A5B29881<56921343456?4A1<@6<171C3456*"5?301 5<15?74D469A75C1<@71!.+71E@18346:3015@7335 B430<79B18845689815!")")!216<46:=1?571301 <<434569A 48374C3 96< 1884568 @<:1 4F9>92@7 96< CA@=B43018845689815!)")+216<46:=1?571301 <<434569A48374C396<1884568@<:14F9>92@7 ) 01 A19761< 746C429A 48374C3 96< 1884568 @<:1 4F9>92@7 @256 1G9D4693456 5? 301 D931749A8 56 71C57<098C56CA@<1<30933012718163D933179748185@35? 9 C981 96< C5@6317C981843@93456 3 48 6531< 309374D1 5+)"!+96<74D15*)"!+B17171:483171<=>301 4F9>92@7 @79A 5A4C1 46 71821C3 5? 301 89D1 46C4<163 9AA1:1< 35 09;1 5CC@771< 56 )"+)"!+ 93 9=5@3 !)+" 2D 6 3048 =9CH:75@6< 2A9C46: 71A496C1 56 301 A9B A94< <5B6 => 301 56I=A1 21G 5@73 46 3931 5? ; 48074A9A301A19761<746C429A48374C396<1884568@<:1 - 5 - 01A<3093=530301C9818=146:46317A46H1<96<974846:?75D 30189D146C4<16397171E@471<35=13741<84D@A39615@8A> => 301 89D1 7184<46: ??4C17 35 168@71 C56848316C> 5? ?46<46:8 96< 35 9;54< C56?A4C346: F@<:D1638 CC57<46:A> 30121343456?4A1<@6<171C3456*"5?3015<15?74D469A 75C1<@71 !.+ B98 9AA5B1< 96< 1884568 981 5!")")!216<46:=1?571301<<434569A48374C396< 1884568@<:14F9>92@7B98B430<79B696<37968?1771< 35301<<434569A48374C396<1884568@<:14F9>92@7 35=13741<9A56:B43018845689815!)")+ + 01 A19761< C5@681A ?57 301 2134345617 7143179346: 301:75@6<8 @7:1<46301 21343456;101D163A> C56316<1< 3093 301 4D2@:61< 57<17 8@??178 ?75D 81745@8 46?47D43418 4698D@C0 98 301 37968?17 098 =116 1??1C31< B4305@3 9??57<46: 96> 6534C1 57 522573@643> 5? 019746: 35 301 21343456179CC@81< 3 48 @7:1< 3093 8@C0 @64A93179A 1G17C481 5? 25B17 => 301 A19761< 746C429A 48374C3 96< 1884568@<:1B4305@3C5D2A496C1B4303012746C42A185? - 6 - 693@79AF@834C1716<1783014D2@:61<57<17@68@839469=A1 46A9B96<A49=A135=1813984<1 * 301A19761< 4:05@735;176D163 A19<178@225731<3014D2@:61<57<17=>C56316<46:3093 @=81C3456 $)% 5? 1C3456 *" 5? 301 5<1 5? 74D469A 75C1<@71 1G27188A> 1D25B178 301 1884568 @<:1 35 37968?17 96> C981 57 92219A 216<46: =1?571 9 5@73 8@=57<46931 35 04D 96< 3093 301 8393@31 <518 653 C5631D2A931 488@96C1 5? 6534C1 35 301 9CC@81< 27457 35 8@C0 37968?17 16C1 301 57<17 4D2@:61< 48 B1AA B43046 301 F@748<4C34569A C5D21316C1 5? 301 A19761< 746C429A 48374C396<1884568@<:196<C9AA8?576546317?1716C1 048 5@73 098 C971?@AA> C5684<171< 301 74;9A 8@=D48845689<;96C1<5614301784<196<098D134C@A5@8A> 217@81< 301 4D2@:61< 57<17 9A56: B430 301 D931749A 2A9C1<5671C57< 3048 5@73 48 89348?41< 3093 74D1 5+)"!+96<74D15*)"!+974815@35?9C98196< - 7 - C5@6317C981843@93456530301C9818B17171:483171<=> 30189D15A4C13934564F9>92@7@79A5A4C14671A93456 359646C4<1639AA1:1<3509;15CC@771<56)"+)"!+93 9=5@3 !)+" 2D 01 A19761< 746C429A 48374C3 96< 1884568 @<:1 B04A1 16317394646: 301 21343456 @6<17 1C3456*"5?3015<15?74D469A75C1<@71!.+098 74:03A>6534C1<3093<182431=530C98181D969346:?75D301 89D146C4<16346;5A;46:;45A1639C38301>B171=146:3741< 46<1216<163A>=1?5713B5<4??171635@738@C09C5@781 4?217D4331<35C56346@1B5@A<65356A>=1C563797>35301 B1AA8133A1<F@<4C49A279C34C1=@39A855??16<3012746C42A18 5??94796<C5684831639<F@<4C93456 34865B98133A1<258434565?A9B98A94<<5B6 =>301&@AA16C05?30485@7346 3093B016301719713B5C9818561=146:301 D946C98196<301530179C5@6317C981974846:5@35?301 89D146C4<163=5308@C0C9818D@83=13741<=>30189D1 1 )"!)'".. - 8 - @<:1 561 9?317 301 53017 01 &@AA 16C0 098 9@305743934;1A> 16@6C4931< 3093 84D@A39615@8 3749A8 => <4??17163 @<:18 971 4D217D4884=A1 98 301> D9> A19< 35 C56?A4C346:?46<46:85630189D18135??9C3896<1;4<16C1 30171=>718@A346:46D48C97749:15?F@834C101&@AA16C0 098?@730172718C74=1<301275C1<@7135=19<5231<468@C0 C47C@D8396C18 301 89D1 7184<46: ??4C17 809AA C56<@C3 =530 3749A8 71C57< 1;4<16C1 81297931A> 46 19C0 C981 96< <1A4;17 3B5 <48346C3 F@<:D1638 56 301 89D1 <9> 39H46: C971 653 35 71?17 35 301 1;4<16C1 71C57<1< 46 561 C981 B04A1<1C4<46:3015301704889A@397>275C1<@71168@718 29743>C56848316C>96<275C1<@79A?9476188469<F@<4C93456 5?46317A46H1<C74D469AC9818 6 301 2718163 C981 301 A19761< 746C429A 48374C3 96< 1884568 @<:1 1G17C4846: 25B178 @6<17 1C3456 *" 5? 301 5<1 098 <471C31< B430<79B9A 5? 1884568 981 5!")")! ?75D 301 ?4A1 5? 301 <<434569A 48374C3 96< 1884568 @<:1 4F9>92@7 96< 438 37968?17 35 301 5@73 5? 301 <<434569A 48374C3 96< - 9 - 1884568 @<:1 4F9>92@7 B0171 1884568 981 5!)")+$301C5@6317C981%48216<46:012134345617I8 2746C429A :741;96C1 48 3093 301 894< 37968?17 098 =116 1??1C31< B4305@3 9??57<46: 04D 96 522573@643> 5? =146: 0197< 5B1;17 @=81C3456 $)% 5? 1C3456 *" 5? 301 5<15?74D469A75C1<@71<5186534D258196>8393@357> 5=A4:93456@2563011884568@<:135488@16534C135301 9CC@81< =1?571 1G17C4846: 301 25B17 5? B430<79B9A 96< 37968?17 01 25B17 @6<17 1C3456 *"$)% 7 48 9<D464837934;1 46 693@71 C56?1771< 35 168@71 275217 <48374=@345696<C5685A4<934565?C981835?9C4A439311??1C34;1 9<F@<4C9345696<35@205A<3014631718385?F@834C1 . 3482173461633565313093=53018845685@738 463012718163D93317971843@931<B4304630189D1F@<4C49A 271D4818 93 4F9>92@7 96< 65 271F@<4C1 275C1<@79A 57 53017B481 C96 =1 894< 35 09;1 =116 C9@81< 35 301 2134345617 => 8@C0 37968?17 6 9 821C4?4C E@17> => 3048 5@73 A19761< C5@681A ?57 301 2134345617 B98 @69=A1 35 <1D56837931 96> 275;48456 5? 301 5<1 3093 D96<9318 - 10 - 27457 6534C1 35 301 9CC@81< =1?571 1G17C481 5? 25B178 @6<17 1C3456 *" 7 01 9=816C1 5? 8@C0 6534C1 30171?571 <518 653 716<17 301 57<17 4D2@:61< 4AA1:9A 57 ;45A934;15?96>8393@357>D96<931 !" 41B1< 30@8 3048 5@73 48 5? 301 C5684<171< 5246456 3093 301 4D2@:61< 57<17 29881< => 301 A19761< 746C429A 48374C3 96< 1884568 @<:1 4F9>92@7 48 46 C5685696C1B4303012746C42A1816@6C4931<=>301 56I=A1 @271D1 5@73 46 ) 96< => 301 &@AA 16C0 5? 3048 5@73 46 $8@279%01<471C34563509;1=530301C98196<C5@6317 C9813741<=>30189D1@<:14865356A>A1:9AA>85@6<=@3 9A85 61C18897> 35 168@71 C56848316C> 5? ?46<46:8 9;54<96C1 5? C56?A4C346: ;17<4C38 96< 9<;96C1D163 5? 8@=8396349AF@834C1 !! 46C1 301 8393@357> ?79D1B57H @6<17 1C3456 *"$)%7<51865316;489:1488@96C15?6534C135301 2 $)""+%.*) - 11 - 9CC@81< =1?571 1??1C346: 37968?17 96< 846C1 65 <1D568379=A1271F@<4C1098=116C9@81<353012134345617 => 301 894< 57<17 301 C09AA16:1 D5@631< 9:94683 43 48 <1;54<5?D1743CC57<46:A>304821343456?94A896<8396<8 <48D4881< AA 216<46: 46317A5C@357> 922A4C934568 4? 96> 8396< <482581<5? 01 A19761< 4:0 5@73 5;176D163 A19<17 48 :79631<3B5B11H8I34D135?4A1D1D55?92219796C1 +) $ ( # 4835)A5!!