Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 66124 (KAR)

BANDEPPA S/O MALLAPPA GUTTEWADI v. SRI SOMSHEKHAR S/O RACHOTAYYA

MFA/201246/2019 · 2025-10-13

P Sree Sudha

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - !! ""#"$! ! %! #&#'##" # #'' ()* # #'' ()* ! ! " " ! #$%$&' " Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - '() '" * ''&&'+ &'(, ! , * ! ! $ #$%$&' " " $ " #$%$&' ! !" '() '" " &'( * " * ''&&'+ * +'&&& # +'&&&& # - 3 - * " * - * &" ' ./0123./0456.72890:6;:238<1.8 :&'+&) &<8=0.9.00.1;>23.?@/<6/72 /4/<78223.*5146.72/71/A/011/2.1''&&'+=/88.1<7 : &'( ;> 23. :2:0 ??<1.72 @/<68 0<;57/@ 567/;/1 9:0 83:02 B23. 20<;57/@C" A3.0./8 :&'D &'+ <8 9<@.1 ;> 23. :A7.0 :9 23. :99.71<74 E.3<?@.:723.40:571:9F5/7256:9?:6=.78/2<:7 ) 3. <7G50.1 ?@/<6/72 9<@.1 ?@/<6 =.2<2<:7 8..H<74 ?:6=.78/2<:7:98+'&&&& #/83.8582/<7.1<7G50<.8<7/ 0:/120/99<?/??<1.72:7&&D&'D3.20<;57/@?:78<1.0<74 23. .72<0. .E<1.7?. :7 0.?:01 /A/01.1 / 856 :9 8+'&&& # /@:74 A<23 DI <72.0.82 90:6 23. 1/2. :9 =.2<2<:7 2<@@ 0./@<J/2<:7 440<.E.1 ;> 23. 8/<1 :01.0 :&'+&) & <8 9<@.1 ;> 23. ?@/<6/72 8..H<74 - 4 - .73/7?.6.72:923.?:6=.78/2<:7/71 :&'D &'+ <8 9<@.1 ;> 23. :A7.0 :9 23. E.3<?@. ?:72.71<74 23/2 23. 1<8/;<@<2>?:78<1.0.1/223.0/2.:9)&I2:23.A3:@.;:1><8 :7 3<43.0 8<1. ?:6=/0.1 2: 23. 0.?:018 /71 .K?.88<E. ?:6=.78/2<:7<8/A/01.1571.01<99.0.723./182<882/2.1 <7 23. ?@/<6 =.2<2<:7 23/2 3. A/8 ./07<74 8+&&& # =.0 6:723/712:23/2.99.?27:0.?:018A.0.=0:15?.12:=0:E. 3<8 6:723@> <7?:6. 3.0.9:0. 23. :A7.0 :9 23. E.3<?@. 0.F5.828 2: 0.15?. 23. ?:6=.78/2<:7 /A/01.1 ;> 23. 20<;57/@ ./07.1 ?:578.@ 9:0 23. ?@/<6/72 <7 :&'+&) & 85;6<28 23/2 3. A/8 /4.1 & >./08 /71 A/8 ./07<74 8+&&& # =.0 6:723 ;> 1:<74 /40<?5@250/@ A:0H.8=.72354./6:5722:A/0186.1<?/@.K=.78.8. ?@./0@>/16<22.1<73<8.E<1.7?.23/23.<83/E<74&'/?0.'( 4572/8<7 50E.>:)D $8<25/2.1/2514<E<@@/4.5223. 20<;57/@ 3/8 .00.1 <7 2/H<74 23. <7?:6. /2 8D&&& # =.0 6:723 A3<?3 <8 :7 @:A.0 8<1. . 8582/<7.1 /;0/8<:7 :E.0 0<432H7..A<2390/?250.:9571.0@><74;:7./71A/8/16<22.1 <7 23. 3:8=<2/@ 90:6 &&D&'D 2: (&D&'D /71 A/8 - 5 - <7=/2<.72 9:0 ) 1/>8 3. ?:6=.78/2<:7 /6:572 40/72.1 571.01<99.0.723./18/0.:7@:A.08<1..A/8571.00.82 9:0 230.. 6:7238 ;52 23. 20<;57/@ 3/8 7:2 40/72.1 /7> ?:6=.78/2<:7 571.0 23. 3./1 :9@:88 :9 ./07<74150<74 @/<1 5= =.0<:1 3.0.9:0. 0.F5.82.1 9:0 .73/7?.6.72 :9 23. ?:6=.78/2<:7 $ 8 23. :A7.0 :9 23. E.3<?@. 3/8 7: E/@<1 7850/7?. =:@<?> .K<82<74 /8 :7 23. 1/2. :9 23. /??<1.72 @</;<@<2>A/89<K.1:723.:A7.0/7123.:A7.0:923.E.3<?@. ?:72.71.123/223.?@/<6/728582/<7.1:7.90/?250.;5223. /88.88.1 23. 1<8/;<@<2> .K?.88<E.@> /2 D&I 3. 20<;57/@ 3/8 2/H.7 23. 8/6. /8 )&I A<23:52 /7> ;/8<8 : /@8: 23. <7?:6. /88.88.1 ;> 23. 20<;57/@ <8 6:0. 3. ?@/<6/72 .K/6<7.1 23. :?2:0 A3: 20./2.1 3<6 3. ?@/<6/72 8582/<7.1 <7G50<.8 :7 &&D&'D /16<22.1 <7 23. 3:8=<2/@ :7 &$&D&'D :=.0/2.1 :7 'D&D&'D /71 1<8?3/04.1:7(&D&'D7+&)&'%3./==0:/?3.19:0 1<8/;<@<2>?.02<9<?/2.4/E.1<8/;<@<2>?.02<9<?/2.A3<?3<8 6/0H.1 /8 K(( /71 /@8: <1.72<9<.1 3<8 8<47/250. 571.0 K((# . 95023.0 82/2.1 23/2 ?@/<6/72 0.F5<0.8 95250. - 6 - 6.1<?/@.K=.78.8:98D&&&& #2:8(&&&& #9:00.6:E/@ :0 <6=@/728 . <885.1 1<8/;<@<2> ?.02<9<?/2. <7 A3<?3 <2 A/8 :;8.0E.1/89:@@:A8 D 2 A/8 95023.0 82/2.1 23/2 23.0. <8 6/@57<2.1 90/?250.:9@/2.?:71>@.2<;</A<231.=0.88<:7.?/77:2 8<2 ?0:88 @.44.1 8F5/2 ?@<6; 82/<08 3. ?/77:2 1: 3./E> A:0H?/77:2@<923./E>A.<432@<6=<74=0.8.7215.2:=/<7 /71 6/@57<:7 /71 /??:01<74@> /88.88.1 23. 1<8/;<@<2> /2 D&I 2: 23. A3:@. ;:1> 8 3. @:82 8<432 :9 .<23.0 .>. /71 /@8: @:82 3./0<74 :9 .<23.0 ./0 /71 23.0. A/8 =.06/7.72 <6=/<06.72 :9 23. =:A.08 :9 /7> 6.6;.0 :9 G:<72 /71 =.06/7.72 1<89<450/2<:7 :9 23. 3./1 :0 :9 23. 9/?. 23. :?2:0 A3: 20./2.1 23. =.2<2<:7.0 3/8 0<432@> /88.88.1 23. 1<8/;<@<2>/2D&I/71<2?/77:2;.20./2.1/8.K?.88<E.3. 20<;57/@?:78<1.0<7423.7/250.:9<7G50<.8/7123.=.0<:1:9 - 7 - 3:8=<2/@<J/2<:7 0<432@> 2/H.7 23. 1<8/;<@<2> /2 )&I /71 <2 7..18 7: <72.09.0.7?. 3. =.2<2<:7.0 A/8 /4.1 & >./08 3:543 <2 <8 82/2.1 23/2 3. A/8 ./07<74 8+&&& # =.0 6:723 3. 3/8 7:2 9<@.1 /7> <7?:6. =0::9 8 3. 6.2 A<23 23. /??<1.72 :7 &&D&'D 3<8 <7?:6. <8 2: ;. 2/H.7 /2 8%($& #=.06:723/8=.023.45<1.@<7.8:923.!/07/2/H/ 2/2..4/@ .0E<?.8523:0<2>3.65@2<=@<.0?:6.82:B'$C /71@:88:995250.<7?:6.A:5@1;./8571.0 8%($& #,','$,)&IL8($&& # ( 3. ?@/<6/72 A/8 3:8=<2/@<J.1 9:0 ) 1/>8 :78<1.0<74 23. 7/250. :9 23. <7G50<.8 /71 =.0<:1 :9 3:8=<2/@<J/2<:723<8:5029<718<20./8:7/;@.2:40/72/856 :9 8$&&& # 9:0 =/<7 /71 8599.0<748 8'$&&& # 9:0 @:88 :9/6.7<2<.83.6.1<?/@.K=.78.840/72.1;>23.20<;57/@ <7 / 856 :9 8')$&&& # 7..18 7: <72.09.0.7?. /71 23. /6:572 40/72.1 571.0 23. 3./1 :9 .K20/ 7:50<836.72 20/78=:02/2<:7 /71 /22.71/72 ?3/04.8 <8 .73/7?.1 2: 8)&&&& #3.?@/<6/726<4323/E.7:2/22.71.1/7>A:0H 9:0 230.. 6:7238 15. 2: 23. <7G50<.8 8582/<7.1 <7 23. - 8 - /??<1.723.0.9:0.3.<8.72<2@.19:0/856:98%($& #, ) 6:7238 A3<?3 ?:6.8 2: 8D$& # 571.0 23. 3./1 :9 @:88 :9 <7?:6. 150<74 @/<1 5= =.0<:1 3:543 3/8 82/2.1 23/2 3. 0.F5<0.8 8D&&&& # 2: 8(&&&& # 9:0 0.6:E/@:9<6=@/72@./07.1?:578.@9:023.?@/<6/7285;6<28 23/2 23. ?@/<6/72 3/8 /@0./1> 571.04:7. 0.6:E/@ :9 <6=@/72;527:0.?:01<89<@.10.4/01<7423.8/6.:A.E.0 23<8:5029<718<20./8:7/;@.2:/A/01/856:98&&&& # 571.023.3./19:00.6:E/@:9<6=@/728 % :2/@ ?:6=.78/2<:7 /A/01.1 ;> 23<8 :502 <8 /8 571.0 #+ ,-./012,3/-453 1634 ' :88:995250.<7?:6. 8($&& # /<7/718599.0<74 8$&&& # ) 0/78=:02/2<:7 .K20/# 7:50<836.72 9::1 /71 /22.71/72?3/04.8 8)&&&& # .1<?/@.K=.78.8 8')$&&& # $ .6:E/@:9<6=@/728 8&&&& # D :88:9/6.7<2<.8 8'$&&& # ( :88 :9 <7?:6. 150<74 @/<1 5==.0<:1 8D$& # 4-+ /7 7 + ./07.1 ?:578.@ 9:0 23. :A7.0 :9 23. E.3<?@. 85;6<28 23/2 23. :A7.0 :9 23. E.3<?@. 1.=:8<2.1 / 856 :9 - 9 - 8+'&&& # ;.9:0. 23. 20<;57/@ /71 /@8: 8$&&& # /8 82/252:0>1.=:8<2;.9:0.23<8:502 '& ??:01<74@>23.9:@@:A<74:01.0 " <" :&'+&) & 9<@.1 ;> 23. ?@/<6/72<8/@@:A.1<7=/02M <<" :&'D &'+ 9<@.1 ;> 23. :A7.0:923.:99.71<74E.3<?@.<81<86<88.1M <<<" 3. ?@/<6/72 <8 .72<2@. 2: 2:2/@ ?:6=.78/2<:7:98()($& #/@:74A<23<72.0.82 /2 23. 0/2. :9 DI =.0 /7756 /8 /4/<782 8+'&&& #/A/01.1;>23.20<;57/@M <E" <7?. @./07.1?:578.@ 9:0 23. :A7.0 :9 23. E.3<?@. 85;6<22.1 23/2 / 856 :9 8+'&&& # ;.9:0. 23. 20<;57/@ /71 / 856 :9 8$&&& # ;.9:0. 23<8 :502 2:A/018 82/252:0> /6:572 <8 /@0./1> 1.=:8<2.1 23. :A7.0 :9 23. E.3<?@. 83/@@ 1.=:8<2 23. .73/7?.1 ?:6=.78/2<:7 :9 8D&(($& # /@:74 A<23 DI <72.0.82 A<23<7 / =.0<:1:9:7.6:72390:623.1/2.:923<8:01.0M - 10 - E" 3. 82/252:0> 1.=:8<2 /6:572 :9 8$&&& #1.=:8<2.1;>23.:A7.0:923.E.3<?@. ;.9:0.23<8:502<8:01.0.12:;.8.72;/?H2:23. 20<;57/@9:023A<23M E<" 7 85?3 1.=:8<2 ;> 23. :A7.0 :9 23. E.3<?@.23.?@/<6/72<8=.06<22.12:A<2310/A23. .72<0./6:572/@:74A<23/??05.1<72.0.8223.0.:7 #. ('##"* &" <82:' @:+' *