- 1 - ! "!# $%! !!## &' ( ) !"#"$ %&& ' & ( && # !"#"$ ' ) ( Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - & )) &* & )) !"#"$ %& ' )+ $"$$ & ( ) ) ,'( ) ##& () ,$$- ) ) ( ) $"$$# & ,$$- ) ) && & ) "$$$! $$$! &&) && ) . ) - 3 - % '&. )( /012334256054789:/4;520<2=:12334552=:1144>0=? 6@A4=/2=;4<4=:@6;@<34=12:0@=2A010=?@B:@6CB7?<4=: 2=72D2A772:47$"$$#0=@,$$-321147 89 :/4 770:0@=25 4=0@A 0E05 B7?4 2=7 770:0@=25 2:072A@=59@=:/4?A@B=7@6FB2=:B< /4 72:4 @6 2;;074=: 0=E@5E4<4=: @6 E4/0;54 742:/ @6 <2A @ /2=A2C 2?47 $ 942A1 1@ 251@ :/4 5028050:9:@329;@<34=12:0@=2A4=@:0=7013B:4/4@=59 7013B:4 01 D0:/ A4134;: :@ 0=274FB2:4 ;@<34=12:0@= 2D2A74789:/4A08B=25 42A7 A0 2=7443 0C29 B<2A 542A=47 ;@B=145 23342A0=? 6@A :/4 2334552=:1 ;520<2=:1 2=7 A0 B72A1/2= 542A=47 ;@B=145 23342A0=? 6@A A413@=74=: @0=1BA2=;4 ;@<32=9 074 @A74A 72:47 $"$$ =@:0;4@6:/01233425@=A413@=74=:@0170134=147D0:/ - 4 - A0 2=7443 0C29 B<2A 542A=47 ;@B=145 23342A0=? 6@A :/4 2334552=:1;520<2=:1 E4/4<4=:59 1B8<0::47:/2::/0123342501A41:A0;:47@=59D0:/A4134;::@ =@=2D2A70=?@6;@<34=12:0@=B=74A:/4605025;@=1@A:0B< 1@ 251@ $G 41;252:0@= @= :/4 1207 ;@=E4=:0@=25 /427 /4 A08B=25 /21 :2>4= :/4 0=;@<4 2=7 2D2A747 233A@3A02:4 ;@<34=12:0@= B=74A :/4 /427 5@11 @6 7434=74=;94=;4/41@B?/::@255@D:/4233425@=59:@ :/44H:4=:@65@11@6;@=1@A:0B<2=7$G41;252:0@= " 46B:0=? :/4 1B8<0110@= @6 542A=47 ;@B=145 23342A0=? 6@A :/4 2334552=: A0B72A1/2= D0:/ 255 E4/4<4=;4 1B8<0::47 :/2: :/4 A08B=25 /21 :2>4= :/4 0=;@<42::/4A2:4@61$$$$!0=1:427@61#,"$!21 34A :/4 ;/2A: 0= :/4 2814=;4 @6 2=9 3A@@6 @6 0=;@<4 /@B?/ :/4 A08B=25 /21 =@: 2D2A747 2=9 ;@<34=12:0@= B=74A:/45@11@6;@=1@A:0B</4;@<34=12:0@=2D2A747 :2>0=?/0?/4A0=;@<4<29>0=7598427CB1:47:@D2A71:/4 12<4 1 1B;/ :/4A4 01 =@ 0=:4A64A4=;4 A4FB0A47 2: :/4 - 5 - /2=71 @6 :/01 @BA: ;;@A70=? 1@B?/: :@ 701<011 :/4 233425 - 2E0=?/42A7:/4542A=47;@B=14523342A0=?6@A :/432A:04134AB147:/44=:0A42334253234A12=7251@:A025 @BA:A4;@A71 , /4 @=59 FB41:0@= :/2: D@B57 2A014 6@A ;@=1074A2:0@=846@A4:/01@BA:01 /4:/4A :/4 A08B=25 CB1:06047 0= =@: 2D2A70=? 2=9 ;@<34=12:0@= B=74A :/4 /427605025;@=1@A:0B<2=7=@:2D2A70=? $G :@D2A71 41;252:0@= @= :/4 ;@<34=12:0@= 2D2A747 B=74A :/4 ;@=E4=:0@=25/427I # 9 2=1D4A :@ :/4 28@E4 3@0=: @6 ;@=1074A2:0@= 010==4?2:0E46@A:/46@55@D0=? /@B?/:/4A08B=25/21:2>4=1$$$$!21 2?20=1:1#,"$!@D4E4A2134A:/4;@=:4=:0@=1@6:/4 ;520<2=:846@A4:/4A08B=25:/474;42147D217A0E4A2=7 - 6 - /40121>0554734A1@=:/2=2=B=1>05547528@BA4A:@D/@< :/4 0=;@<4 60H47 B=74A :/4 ;/2A?4 D21 1#,"$! /4 0=1BA2=;4 ;@<32=9 01 =@: 0= 233425 ;;@A70=?59 :/4 ;@=:4=:0@=@6542A=47;@B=14523342A0=?6@A:/40=1BA2=;4 ;@<32=9:/2::/4A08B=25/21:2>4=/0?/4A0=;@<4;2==@: 84 ;@B=:4=2=;47 /4 A08B=25 /21 =@: 2D2A747 2=9 ;@<34=12:0@= B=74A :/4 /427 5@11 @6 605025 ;@=1@A:0B< 1@ 251@$G41;252:0@=21/45789:/4@=J85434H@BA:0= :/4;214@6 12=7 = E04D @6 2D2A70=? :/4 605025 ;@<34=12:0@= 21 D455 21 $G 41;252:0@= :/4 ;@<34=12:0@= 2D2A747 89 :/4 A08B=25 A4FB0A41 A4;@=1074A2:0@= 2=7 A4!74:4A<0=2:0@= = A4! 74:4A<0=2:0@=:/4;@<34=12:0@=;@<41:@ 1 '$,(--#$ 2'$(,-, - 7 - 5 @ 4271@6@<34=12:0@= <@B=:1 @11 @6 0=;@<4 7B4 :@ 7434=74=;9 1 "$$$! @D2A715@11@641:2:4 1 "$$$! @D2A716B=4A254H34=141 1 "$$$! @11@6605025;@=1@A:0B< 'H$$$$!( 1 1-$$$$! " $G41;252:0@=6@A:D@:4A<1@6 :/A44942A16A@<$,:@$" 04$G 1#$$$! 1 ,$$$$! $ ;;@A70=?59 :/4 ;520<2=:1 2334552=:1 2A4 4=:0:547 6@A 2 1B< @6 1,$$$$! 21 2?20=1: 1"$$$! 2D2A747 89 :/4 A08B=25 /4 4=/2=;47 ;@<34=12:0@=D@A>1@B::@1#$$$!/42<@B=:@6 ;@<34=12:0@= 1/255 ;2AA9 0=:4A41: 2: :/4 A2:4 @6 -G 34A 2==B< 2=7 :/4 72:4 @6 34:0:0@= :055 A4250K2:0@= ;;@A70=?59:/01@BA:3A@;447:@3211:/46@55@D0=? 0 3342501 00 /4 0<3B?=47 CB7?<4=: 2=7 2D2A7 72:47 $"$$# 321147 0= @,$$- 89:/47754=0@A0E05B7?42=7 072A01/4A489<@706047+ - 8 - 000 /4 2334552=: 01 4=:0:547 6@A :@:25 ;@<34=12:0@=@61,$$$$!212?20=1: 1"$$$! 2D2A747 89 :/4 A08B=25 2=7 4=/2=;47 ;@<34=12:0@= @6 1#$$$! 25@=? D0:/ 0=:4A41: 2: -G 34A 2==B< 6A@< :/4 72:4 @6 6050=? @6 :/4 34:0:0@=:055A4250K2:0@=0=2770:0@=:@D/2: /2125A4279844=2D2A74789:/4A08B=25 0E /4 A413@=74=: @ ! 0=1BA2=;4 1/255 743@10: :/4 4=:0A4 ;@<34=12:0@= 2<@B=: 25@=? D0:/ 2;;AB47 0=:4A41: 1:2:47 846@A4 :/4 ;@=;4A=47 A08B=25 D0:/0= 2 34A0@7 @6 10H D44>1 6A@< :/4 72:4 @6 A4;403: @6 ;4A:06047;@39:/01CB7?<4=: E = 743@10: 4=:0A4 ;@<34=12:0@= 2<@B=: 25@=? D0:/ 2;;AB47 0=:4A41: 1/255 84 A4542147 0= 62E@BA @6 255 :/4 2334552=:1 4FB2559@=3A@34A074=:060;2:0@= E0 @@A74A21:@;@1:1 !*+ & ( % & 01:@5@