Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 66099 (KAR)

NARASAPPA v. KALIMUDDIN AND ANR

MFA/202521/2023 · 2025-12-08

P Sree Sudha

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - !" # $!%!&!! !!&& '() * ! ! !" # $ %&'( ) * ! '+! %,((', "! # - !"! #) Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - !# # .+ # ! ! # " ! ()())()+ " $ "!# ! ! + ,)( ! ! # * ) ! ! # ! " ! ! / !" % 01230 405 677568 9: 89:45; <1= 6;>9::91? @940 405 A1?:5?4 1< 856=?5; A12?:58 <1= 405 76=495: 94 9: 46B5? 27 <1=<9?68;9:71:68 ) 09: 677568 9: <985; 6369?:4 405 C2;3>5?4 6?; 6@6=;;645;()())()+76::5;DE405II ;;85?1=9F98 "2;35$"!#6?;;;8!649;6=9?!1+ ,1< )( + 05 A869>6?4 635; E56=: ;19?3 86D12= @1=B >54 @940 6? 6AA9;5?4 1? )) ))( . 6?; :2:469?5; - 3 - 3=95F12: 9?C2=95: 05=5<1=5 05 <985; 6 A869> 7549491? D5<1=5 405 =9D2?68 A869>9?3 A1>75?:6491? 1< :((((% 05 =9D2?68 A1?:9;5=9?3 405 5?49=5 5F9;5?A5 1? =5A1=; 6@6=;5; 6 381D68 A1>75?:6491? 1< :,((((% @940 9?45=5:4 64 G 76 <=1> 405 ;645 1< 7549491?4988=5689:6491?6?;;9=5A45;=5:71?;5?41 %1@?5= 41;571:94405:6>5 ' 33=95F5;DE405:69;C2;3>5?46?;6@6=;405 9?C2=5; A869>6?4 06: 7=5<5==5; 409: 677568 9? @09A0 94 9: A1?45?;5; 4064 05 @6: 56=?9?3 :)((((% 75= >1?40 6?; ?1 6>12?4: 6=5 6@6=;5; 2?;5= 405 056;: 81:: 1< 6>5?9495: >5;9A68 5H75?:5: 81:: 1< A1?F5E6?A5 6?; ?12=9:0>5?4769?6?;:2<<5=9?36?;81::1<9?A1>5;2=9?3 869; 27 75=91; 5 :2:469?5; >2849785 9?C2=95: 41 85<4 097 85<44093089<5B?55=9304409306?;=9304@=9:405=5<1=5 A1?:9;5=9?3 405 ?642=5 1< 9?C2=95: 6?; ;9:6D9894E 405 =9D2?68 12304 41 06F5 6@6=;5; A1>75?:6491? 41@6=;: 81::1<<242=556=?9?3:02:=5I25:45;<1=5?06?A5>5?4 1<A1>75?:6491? - 4 - 56=;4056=32>5?4:1<D140:9;5: , 056775886?406::2:469?5;<9F5:9>7859?C2=95: 6:75= H+%@12?;A5=49<9A64505=5<1=5405=9D2?6806: 6@6=;5; 381D68 A1>75?:6491? 1< :,((((% 6?; 409: 12=4<9?;:?1=56:1?419?45=<5=5@940405:6>51@5F5= 6: 405 ;=9F5= 1< 405 1<<5?;9?3 F509A85 9: 06F9?3 F689; ;=9F9?3 89A5?A5 =5:71?;5?4 1) % ?:2=6?A5 1>76?E 681?59:;9=5A45;4176E405A1>75?:6491?6@6=;5;DE405 =9D2?6895:,((((%@9409?45=5:464G76<=1>405 ;645 1< 7549491? 4988 405 ;645 1< 6@6=; 6?; =5:71?;5?4 1 %1@?5=1<405F509A859:;9=5A45;4176E4059?45=5:464 G761?4056>12?46@6=;5;DE405=9D2?68<=1>405 ;645 1< 6@6=; 95 ()())()+ 4988 ( ))() @9409? 1?5 >1?40<=1>405;6451<409:C2;3>5?4 . ? :2A0 ;571:94 405 6775886?4 9: 75=>9445; 41 @940;=6@4055?49=56>12?4681?3@9409?45=5:46AA=25;1? 94 - 5 - & AA1=;9?38E4056775689:76=48E6881@5; +,- '&!! ) % LG List No.: 1 Sl No.: 61 - 6 - ( ))() # ! / !" .!&/ 05 C2;3>5?4 9? 409: A6:5 @6: 7=1?12?A5; 1? (& ))()>5>1<1=D59?3:71B5?419:<985;1?( ))() DE=5:71?;5?41 %1@?5=1<405F509A85=5I25:49?340512=4 41=5A59F5405;=9F9?389A5?A5 ?<6A46:405=5@6:?1;=9F9?389A5?A51=;5=1<76E6?; =5A1F5=E @6: 76::5; DE 409: 12=4 5:71?;5?4 1 06: ?14 7=1;2A5; ;=9F9?3 89A5?A5 D5<1=5 405 =9D2?68 6?; 68:1 D5<1=5 409:12=4;2=9?340575?;5?AE1<409:6775681@5F5=6:405 =5:71?;5?4 1)% ?:2=6?A5 1>76?E 06: ?1 1DC5A491? <1= =5A59F9?3 405 ;=9F9?3 895?A5 409: 12=4 <9?;: 94 =56:1?6D85 41 =5A59F5 405 :6>5 D24 @940 6 A1?;9491? 4064 9?45=5:4 9: 41 D5 769; DE 405 1@?5= 1< 405 F509A85 <=1> 405 ;645 1< 6@6=; 4988 41;6E95 ( ))() : 405 ;=9F5= 1< 405 1<<5?;9?3 F509A85 9: 06F9?3 F689; ;=9F9?389A5?A5=5:71?;5?41)% ?:2=6?A51>76?E681?59: ;9=5A45;4176E405A1>75?:6491?6@6=;5;DE405=9D2?6895 - 7 - :,((((%@9409?45=5:464G76<=1>405;6451<7549491? 4988405;6451<6@6=;6?;=5:71?;5?41 %1@?5=1<405F509A85 9: ;9=5A45; 41 76E 405 9?45=5:4 64 G 76 1? 405 6>12?4 6@6=;5;DE405=9D2?68<=1>405;6451<6@6=;95()())()+ 4988 41;6E 95 ( ))() @9409? 1?5 >1?40 <=1> 405 ;645 1< 409:1=;5= 6=6 1, 1< 405 C2;3>5?4;645;(& ))() 9: 1=;5=5; 41D5>1;9<95;6AA1=;9?38E !,- '&!! ) % 9:41 81