Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 65990 (KAR)

SRI GRAPPA v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA

WP/203915/2025 · 2025-12-10

M G S Kamal

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - !!"!#!$ % & $'"$"$ ($) ! "#$%&%' ( ) !* ! & ! #'& + ! #! #$%&'& #$%&'& Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - % ! "#$%&'& $ !, ! "!,#$+'- "#$%&%' ( ) , * ++ ++. * +/0 # ! * '&&+'+$ + ! ! # * 1 2 , ! 345 6784849/ 45 :4;70 <= 837 6784849/7> 577?4/@ :9;;9A4/@>7;47:5 - 3 - !"##!$ % & ' ( )* + 7B>/70 C9D/57; :9> 837 6784849/7> 8B?4/@ 8345 9D>8 83>9D@3 837 >7C9>05 5D<E485 83B8 >7569/07/8 9+ A34;7 6B554/@ 9>07> 9: 7F87>/E7/8 0B870 '&&+'+$ B8 //7FD>7#3B5/987/5D>7083B88376>9G4549/59:7C849/ $$9:837B>/B8B?B9;4C7C8&-):9>539>8HC81* B>7C9E6;470A48375D<E48583B8837G7>=539ACBD57 /984C7455D70B8//7FD>7#0B870''+'+$45<B5709/ 837 6>75DE6849/ B/0 5D>E4575 9: 6784849/7> CBD54/@ 0458D><B/C7 89 837 6D<;4C 67BC7 B/0 8>B/ID4;48= 7 5D<E48583B87FC768;4584/@9D8837CB575A34C33BG7<77/ :4;70B@B4/588376784849/7>/99837>078B4;5B>7:D>/45370 898376784849/7>3B8839D@3837539ACB57/984C7>7:7>5 - 4 - 89 B 6D>69>870 >769>8 455D70 <= 837 9: B0B6B/D> 9;4C7 8B849/ /9 5DC3 >769>8 45 7/C;9570 89 837 539A CBD57 /984C7 7/B<;4/@ 837 6784849/7> 89 5D<E48 345 >76;= 3B8 837 5D<J7C84G7 5B845:BC849/ 539D;0 7EB/B87 :>9E 837 >7C9>05 83B8 E7>7 ;4584/@ 9: 837 CB575 4/ A34C3 837 6784849/7> 3B5 <77/ 4E6;4CB870 CB//98 <7 837 @>9D/0 :9> 6B554/@837 9>07> 9:7F87>/E7/8 D/07> 7C849/ $$ 9: 837 C83B87G7/9>07>B8//7FD>7#0975/984/04CB87 B/= 5DC3 5D<J7C84G7 5B845:BC849/ 7FC768 >7C9>04/@ 837 B;;7@B849/5:9D/04/837C9E6;B4/85B/05:4;70B@B4/58 8376784849/7> /5D669>89:345C9/87/849/537>7;475D69/837 JD0@E7/89:8379#9>04/B87 7/C39:83459D>86B55704/ 4/ CB57 9: A37>74/8379#9>04/B87 7/C39:83459D>8D/07>54E4;B> :BC85 B/0 C4>CDE58B/C75 3B5 B;;9A70 837 A>48 6784849/ 7/C7 ;7B>/70 C9D/57; 577?5 54E4;B> <7/7:48 89 <7 7F87/070898376784849/7> - 5 - % 7B>07>D570837>7C9>05 $ 67F9D>84/837CB579:! " >769>870 4/ ## $% # B8 6B>B@>B6395&B/0&$9:837JD0@E7/83B537;0B5 :9;;9A5 +", - . #/.# 0 1 % %0 02.$ #/ 2 32 0 & % . & $" #/$# 2 4 #/.#. ) % & 5&& #6 2 $" % & 2 7 )2 % 7 & .# $" 7 4 % 8 - 6 - 2 7 2 % 2 4 2 & 8 % 2 7 )2 2% 2 & % 2 7 4 2 4 % 2 3 % 7 2 5&& #$ 3 2% #/.#. %.$ 0 #/ 2 3 4 4 29 37:BC859:8376>757/8CB57>7B04/837;4@389: 837 ,D0@E7/8 9: 837 67F 9D>8 4/ 837 CB57 9: ! )5D6>B*0975/984/04CB8783B8B/=5DC3B66;4CB849/9:E4/0 457F7>C45704/8374/58B/8CB575>4@38;=694/8709D8<= 837 ;7B>/70 C9D/57; :9> 837 6784849/7> 837 539A CBD57 - 7 - /984C7>7:7>589B6D>69>870>769>85D<E48870<=8379: B0B6B/D>9;4C78B849/<D8/95DC3>769>8457/C;9570 D>837> 837 539A CBD57 /984C7 E7>7;= 7/;4585 837 CB575 A34C3 3BG7 <77/ :4;70 B@B4/58 837 6784849/7> 37 9>07> 4E6D@/70 B8 //7FD>7# 45 >7487>B849/ 9: 837 C9/87/85 9: C9E6;B4/8:4;70<=8376784849/7>379/;=6>9<B<;7>7B59/ A34C33B5>4@38;=539A/<=837C9D/57;9:8376784849/7>45 8>BC7B<;789D//DE<7>706B>B@>B639+B86B@79-9: 8374E6D@/709>07>A34C3>7B05B5D/07> !"# $% &'( )* )* &+ , )* -./ , 0 &+ 12 2 34 5 6 7 8 9 :+;2 6; /<*+ -)* , 6 = /> ?' :, )* /5 ' 7@ . FC768 837 B<9G7 9<57>GB849/ 837>7 45 /9 045CD5549/ 9> B/B;=545 9: B/= 9837> EB87>4B; <= 837 >7569/07/89+A483>7@B>0896>757/C79:8376784849/7> CBD54/@B/=83>7B8898376D<;4C67BC7B/08>B/ID4;48=37 5B40 9>07> 4/ 837 C9/5407>70 G47A 9: 8345 9D>8 ;BC?5 - 8 - B66;4CB849/9:E4/0B/05D<J7C84G75B845:BC849/B537;0<= 83767F9D>8 3B8B6B>89>07>9:7F87>/E7/845:9>B67>490 <78A77/ '&&+'+$ B/0 ''&+'+ A34C3 3B5 B;>7B0= 567/8E9>783B/3B;:9:48587>E - CC9>04/@;=6784849/45%%& &' 37 9>07> 4E6D@/70 0B870 '&&+'+$ 6B5570 <=>7569/07/89+G407//7FD>7#45IDB5370 && 845EB07C;7B>83B8/98A48358B/04/@8379>07> 6B5570 37>74/ 837 BD839>48475 B>7 B8 ;4<7>8= 89 4/484B87 :>753 6>9C7704/@5 4: 837 548DB849/ AB>>B/85 B:87> 0D7 C9E6;4B/C7A483;BAB5/9870B<9G7 "*+ ($"$) '! &