Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 65948 (KAR)
AMIT v. PRIYANKA
MFA/203790/2023 · 2025-12-15
H T Narendra Prasad, Tyagaraja N Inavally
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 65948 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 65948 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! " #$"
#$ $%
""
&' (
!"#$
%
&
'(
"
(
(
!"#)
%
&*++,-.,/0/,1234,+*+/,+/2.,/#$ #" )#)
Digitally signed by VARSHA N RASALKAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
5 5
"$0 5 5 (
# #! )#) 6!)#) 7
5 5
"" 5
5
#8 # )#"8 5
(
5
5
"# "" )#)
5 9
5 7 5(
:
:
&%$ :
10;2<<,2=12;2+0;,>?+*3.1,@A/B3,>.2>//,-+,, /2.,/ # #! )#) *? .1, //= +0>-0<2= A/B, 5230=C *A+. 0@2C2<A+2 ?*+ ;1*+. 9.1, 5230=C *A+.7 0> * 6!)#) D1,+,0> .1, <,.0.0*> ?0=,/ 4C .1, 2<<,==2>. A>/,+ ,-.0*> ""0204 *? 0>/A 2++02B, -."$?*+;1*+.9-.70;/0;30;;,/
&*++,-.,/0/,1234,+*+/,+/2.,/#$ #" )#)
- 3 -
) 5*+-*>E,>0,>-,.1,<2+.0,;.*.10;2<<,2=2+, 1,+,0>2?.,+ +,?,++,/ .* 0> .1,0+ +2>F; 4,?*+, .1, 5230=C *A+.0>.1,<,.0.0*>
1, <,.0.0*>,+ ?0=,/ <,.0.0*> 2B20>;. .1, +,;<*>/,>.A>/,+,-.0*>"0204*?-.4,?*+,.1, 5230=C *A+. <2C0>B ?*+ 2> *+/,+ .* B+2>. /,-+,, *? /0E*+-, 4C /0;;*=E0>B 10; 32++02B, ;*=,3>0G,/ D0.1 .1, +,;<*>/,>.*>#8 # )#"8*>.1,B+*A>/;*?-+A,=.C2>/ /,;,+.0*>
6 1, -2;, *? .1, <,.0.0*>,+ 0> 4+0,? 0; .12. .1, <,.0.0*>,+2>/+,;<*>/,>.2+,=,B2==CD,//,/1A;42>/2>/ D0?, .1,0+ 32++02B, 12E0>B 4,,> ;*=,3>0G,/ *> #8 # )#"8 2. -23<A; 0@2C2<A+2 2; <,+ .1, <+,E2=,>.+0.A2=;2>/-A;.*3;0>.1,<+,;,>-,*?+,=2.0E,;
2>/ ?+0,>/; ?.,+ .1, 32++02B, .1, +,;<*>/,>. @*0>,/ 32+0.2=-*3<2>C*?.1,<,.0.0*>,+ A..1,+,;<*>/,>./0/ >*. -**<,+2., D0.1 .1, <,.0.0*>,+ ?*+ -*>;A332.0*> *? 32++02B, *> .1, ?0+;. >0B1. 0.;,=? *> .1, B+*A>/ .12. ;1,
- 4 -
D2;3,>;.+A2.0>B/A+0>B.12..03, E,>2?.,+-*3<=,.0*> *?1,+3,>;.+A2.0*><,+0*/.1,+,;<*>/,>./0/>*.,H.,>/ 2>C -**<,+2.0*> D0.1 .1, <,.0.0*>,+ 1, ;20/ 0;;A, D2;
4+*AB1. .* .1, >*.0-, *? .1, <2+,>.; *? .1, +,;<*>/,>.;
2>/.1,C;A0.24=C2/E0;,/.1,+,;<*>/,>..*3,>/1,+;,=? A. 0> ;<0., *?;A-1 2/E0-, 4C 1,+ <2+,>.; .1,+, D2;>* -12>B, 0> .1,4,12E0*A+*? .1, +,;<*>/,>. >.1,*.1,+ 12>/ ;1, ;.2+.,/ <0-F0>B A< IA2++,= D0.1 .1, <,.0.0*>,+ 2>/10;<2+,>.;*>.+0E02=32..,+; 1,+,;<*>/,>.A;,/.* E0;0. 1,+ <2+,>.;: 1*A;, ?+,IA,>.=C D0.1*A. 0>?*+30>B .1, <,.0.0*>,+ 1, +,;<*>/,>. 4,0>B /2AB1.,+ *? .1, ?*+3,+ A;,/ .* /,32>/
; #### <,+ 3*>.1 ?+*3 .1, <,.0.0*>,+ .* ?A=?0== 1,+ /,32>/; 2>/ D1,> .1, <,.0.0*>,+ ?20=,/ *+ +,?A;,/ .* <2C .1, 23*A>. .1, +,;<*>/,>. /0/ >*.-**<,+2.,D0.11032>/;1,A;,/.*?+,IA,>.=CIA2++,= D0.1 .1, <,.0.0*>,+ *E,+ ;0==C 32..,+; 2>/ A;,/ .* .2A>. 1032>/.1,+,4C.*+.A+,103<1C;0-2==C2>/3,>.2==C 1, +,;<*>/,>.;<,>.1,+ 32@*+ .03, D2.-10>B.,=,E0;0*> 2>/
- 5 -
.2=F0>B*E,+3*40=, 1,A;,/.*0>;A=.2>/1A30=02.,.1, +,;<*>/,>.0>?+*>.*?10;?230=C3,34,+;2>/+,=2.0E,;
12.4,0>B;*0>.1,3*>.1*?,-,34,+)#"8 .1, <,.0.0*>,+ 12/ 4,,> .* ,=2B2E0 .* 2..,>/ .1, *??0-, 3,,.0>B 2>/ D1,> 1, +,.A+>,/ 1, =,2+>. .12. .1, +,;<*>/,>.D0.1*A.0>?*+30>B10312/=,?..1,32.+03*>02= 1*3,D0.11,+B*=/2>/;0=E,+*+>23,>.;2>/2=;*-=*.1,;
2>/ ;2+,,; ,.- 1,+,2?.,+ .1, <,.0.0*>,+ 2=*>B D0.1 10; <2+,>.; 2>/ ,=/,+=C <,+;*>; 2<<+*2-1,/ .1, +,;<*>/,>. 2>/ 1,+ <2+,>.; .* ;,. +0B1. .1, 32..,+ +,IA,;.0>B .1, +,;<*>/,>..*@*0>32.+03*>02=-*3<2>C*?.1,<,.0.0*>,+
A..1,+,;<*>/,>.?=2.=C+,?A;,/.*@*0>103 >.1,3*>.1 *?,<.,34,+)#"!.1,+,;<*>/,>.1,+<2+,>.;2>/1,+ ;0;.,+ -23, .* .1, 1*A;, *?
<,.0.0*>,+ 2>/ <0-F,/ A< IA2++,=D0.110;3*.1,+2>/30;4,12E,/D0.11,+24A;0>B 2>/ 0>;A=.0>B 1,+ 1, <,.0.0*>,+ ?*A>/ *A. .12. .1, +,;<*>/,>. D2; 12E0>B 0==0-0. 2??20+ 2>/ .1, ;20/ ?2-. D2; -*>-,2=,/2>/;1,32++0,/.1,<,.0.0*>,+ >" ") )#)) .1,+,;<*>/,>.?0=,/?2=;,-*3<=20>.2B20>;..1,<,.0.0*>,+
- 6 -
2>/ 10; ?230=C 3,34,+; 32F0>B ?2=;, 2==,B2.0*>; *? /,32>/ *? /*D+C 2>/ 12+2;;3,>. 4,?*+, 0@2C2<A+2 (*3,>*=0-,.2.0*>2>/.1,-2;,D2;+,B0;.,+,/2B20>;. .1, <,.0.0*>,+ 2>/ 10; ?230=C 3,34,+; 0> +03, * "!$)#)) 1, 0>E,;.0B2.0*> D2; -*3<=,.,/ 2>/ .1, -12+B,;1,,.12;4,,>?0=,/2B20>;..1,<,.0.0*>,+2>/10;
?230=C3,34,+; ,>-,*>.1,;,?2-.;.1,<,.0.0*>,+?,=. .12.10;32++02B,D2;4+*F,>4,C*>/+,<20+2>/.1,+,?*+, 1, D2; -*>;.+20>,/ .* ?0=, <,.0.0*> ?*+ /0E*+-, *> .1, B+*A>/*?-+A,=.C2>//,;,+.0*>
> ;<0., *? ;,+E0-, *? >*.0-, .* .1, +,;<*>/,>. *>.1,<,.0.0*>4,?*+,.1,5230=C*A+..1,+,;<*>/,>./0/ >*.-1**;,.*2<<,2+2>/-*>.,;..1,32..,+ >;A<<*+.*? .1, -2;, *? .1, <,.0.0*>,+ 1, B*. ,H230>,/ 103;,=? 2;
( " , 2=;* ,H230>,/ .D* D0.>,;;,; 2; () 2>/ ( 2>/<+*/A-,/6/*-A3,>.;2.H; ".*6 >.1,*.1,+ 12>/ .1, +,;<*>/,>. D2; <=2-,/ ,H <2+., 2>/ 1,>-, .1,+,D2;>*-*>.,;.4C.1,+,;<*>/,>.*?.1,<,.0.0*>
- 7 -
8 ?.,+ 1,2+0>B .1, 2+BA3,>.; *? .1, =,2+>,/ -*A>;,= ?*+ .1, <,.0.0*>,+ 2>/ 2=;* *> -*>;0/,+0>B .1, +,=,E2>.32.,+02=; *> +,-*+/ .1,5230=C *A+.-*30>B .* .1, -*>-=A;0*> .12. .1, <,.0.0*>,+ 12; ?20=,/ .* <+*E, .1, B+*A>/; *? /,;,+.0*> 2>/ -+A,=.C ?*+ /0E*+-, 12;
/0;30;;,/ .1, <,.0.0*> ?0=,/ 4C 103 A>/,+ 03<AB>,/ @A/B3,>. 2>/ /,-+,, D10-1 +,;A=.,/ 0> .1, <,.0.0*>,+ 2<<+*2-10>B.10;*A+.D0.1.1,<+,;,>.2<<,2=
! 1, B+*A>/ A+B,/ 4C .1, <,.0.0*>,+ 0> .1, 2<<,2= 0; .12. .1, 03<AB>,/ @A/B3,>. 2>//,-+,, *?.1, 5230=C*A+.0;/,E*0/*?3,+0.; 1,5230=C*A+.12;>*. 2<<+,-02.,/ .1, ,E0/,>-, *? <,.0.0*>,+ 0> <+*<,+ <,+;<,-.0E, > ;<0., *? .1, ?2-. .12. 2==,B2.0*>; =,E,=,/ 2B20>;..1,+,;<*>/,>.+,320>,/A>-12==,>B,/.1,5230=C *A+. 12; ?20=,/ .* 2--,<. .1, ,E0/,>-, 2>/ 2==*D .1, <,.0.0*> > E0,D *? .1, <=,2/0>B; ,E0/,>-, 2>/ *.1,+ 32.,+02=; *> +,-*+/ .1,+, 0; -=,2+ -2;, *? 12+2;;3,>. 23*A>.0>B .* 3,>.2= 2>/ <1C;0-2= -+A,=.C 4C .1, +,;<*>/,>. .* .1, <,.0.0*>,+ D10-1 0; ;A??0-0,>. .* <2;;
- 8 -
/,-+,,*?/0E*+-,0>?2E*A+*?.1,<,.0.0*>,+ E,>.1*AB1 .1,+, 0; >*.10>B *> +,-*+/ .* 03<,2-1 .1, E,+;0*> *? .1, <,.0.0*>,+ <A. ?*+.1 0> .1, <,.0.0*> ?*+ /0E*+-, *> .1, B+*A>/ *? -+A,=.C 2>/ /,;,+.0*> .1, 5230=C *A+. 12; -*330..,/;,+0*A;,++*+0>/0;30;;0>B.1,<,.0.0*>0B>*+0>B .1, 32.,+02= ,E0/,>-, ?*+.1-*30>B *> +,-*+/ 1, +,;<*>/,>. >,E,+ ,H.,>/,/ -**<,+2.0*> ?*+ -*1240.2.0*> D0.1.1,<,.0.0*>,+2>/.1*;,?2-.;+,320>,/A>-12==,>B,/ 2; 0> ;<0., *? ;,+E0-, *? >*.0-, .1, +,;<*>/,>.
?20=,/ .* 2<<,2+2>/-*>.,;..1,<,.0.0*> 1,5230=C*A+.*AB1..* 12E,>*.,/.1,0>.,>.0*>2>/-*>/A-.*?.1,<2+.0,;2;.1, B+*A>/ ?*+ /,;,+.0*> 2>/ -+A,=.C 2>/ *AB1. .* 12E, B+2>.,/ /0E*+-, 2; <+2C,/ ?*+ 0> .1, <,.0.0*> 1,5230=C *A+. 12; ?20=,/ .* 2<<+,-02., .1, ,E0/,>-, *> 1A32> ;,>;0.0E0.C2>/,3*.0*>; 1,5230=C*A+.12;<+*-,,/,/ 0> .1, 32..,+ 3,-12>0-2==C 2>/ 0> 2 -2;A2= 32>>,+ 2>/ 1,>-,.1,2<<+*2-1*?.1,5230=C*A+..*.1,32..,+0;
>*. -*++,-. 1,+,?*+, .1, <,.0.0*>,+ 12; <+2C,/ ?*+ 2==*D0>B.1,2<<,2=2>/.1,+,4C.*;,.2;0/,.1,03<AB>,/
- 9 -
@A/B3,>.2>//,-+,,*?.1,+02=*A+.2>/B+2>./0E*+-, *>.1,B+*A>/*?/,;,+.0*>2>/-+A,=.C2;<+2C,/?*+
$ ><A+;A2>-,*?;,+E0-,*?>*.0-,*>.10;2<<,2= .1, +,;<*>/,>. 12; 2<<,2+,/ .1+*AB1 .1, -*A>;,= 1, +02=*A+.+,-*+/;12E,4,,>-2==,/?*+
"# ,2+/.1,2+BA3,>.;*?.1,=,2+>,/-*A>;,=?*+ 4*.1.1,<2+.0,; ,+A;,/.1,+,=,E2>.32.,+02=;*>+,-*+/ *D .1, <*0>. .12. 2+0;,; ?*+ .1, -*>;0/,+2.0*> *? .10;
*A+.0;.12. "" > .1, 42;0; *? .1, <=,2/0>B; *? .1, <,.0.0*>,+ <A.?*+.10>.1,<,.0.0*>0.0;-=,2+.12..1,<,.0.0*>,+2>/ +,;<*>/,>. =,B2==C D,//,/ 1A;42>/ 2>/ D0?, .1,0+ 32++02B, 12E0>B 4,,> ;*=,3>0G,/ *> #8 # )#"8 1, 2+BA3,>.*?.1,=,2+>,/-*A>;,=<,+.1,<,.0.0*>,+0;.12. - 10 -
.1, +,;<*>/,>. /0/ >*. -**<,+2., D0.1 .1, <,.0.0*>,+ ?*+ -*>;A332.0*> *? 32++02B, ?+*3 .1, ?0+;. >0B1. *? .1, 32++02B, 0.;,=? 5A+.1,+ 0> ;<0., *? .1, 2/E0-, 4C 1,+ <2+,>.;.1,+,;<*>/,>./0/>*..+C.*3,>/1,+;,=? .0;
2=;* .1, -*>.,>.0*> *? .1, <,.0.0*>,+ .12. .1, +,;<*>/,>. A;,/.*<0-FA<IA2++,=D0.1.1,<,.0.0*>,+2>/10;<2+,>.; *E,+;0==C+,2;*>;2>/;1,4,0>B/2AB1.,+*??*+3,+ A;,/.*/,32>/
; #### <,+3*>.1?+*3103.*?A=?0== 1,+/,32>/2>/0?.1,<,.0.0*>,+?20=,/+,?A;,/.*<2C.1, 23*A>..1,+,;<*>/,>./0/>*.-**<,+2.,D0.1103
") 1,<,.0.0*>,+12;-*>.,>/,/.12.0>.1,3*>.1 *? ,-,34,+ )#"8 D1,> .1, <,.0.0*>,+ 12/ 4,,> .*
,=2B2E0.*2..,>/*??0-,3,,.0>B.1,+,;<*>/,>.=,?..1, 32.+03*>02= 1*A;, D0.1*A. 0>?*+30>B .1, <,.0.0*>,+ 1, +,;<*>/,>. .**F 1,+ B*=/ 2>/ ;0=E,+ *+>23,>.; 2>/ 2=;* -=*.1,;2>/D,>..*1,+<2+,>.;:1*A;,2>/.1,+,2?.,+0> ;<0., *? 2<<+*2-1 4C .1, <,.0.0*>,+ 2>/ 10; <2+,>.; 2>/ ,=/,+=C<,+;*>;.1,+,;<*>/,>./0/>*.@*0>.1,32.+03*>C 1*3,2>/;1,?=2.=C+,?A;,/.*@*0>.1,<,.0.0*>
- 11 -
" > ;A<<*+. *? .1, -2;, *? .1, <,.0.0*>,+ 4,?*+, .1,5230=C*A+.1,12;B*.103;,=?,H230>,/2;(" , ?0=,/10;2??0/2E0.2;,E0/,>-,0>-10,?,H230>2.0*>D1,+,0> 1, 12; +,0.,+2.,/ .1, ?2-.; 2E,++,/ 0> .1, <,.0.0*> . 0; E,+C<,+.0>,>..*>*.,.12..1,+,;<*>/,>.12;>*.-1*;,> .* 2<<,2+ 2>/ -*>.,;. .1, <,.0.0*> 0> ;<0., *? ;,+E0-, *? >*.0-, ,>-,2;;A430..,/4C.1,=,2+>,/*A>;,=?*+.1, <,.0.0*>,+ .1, <,.0.0*> 2E,+3,>.; 2>/ .1, ,E0/,>-, *? <,.0.0*>,+2;( ";.2>/;A>-12==,>B,/
"6 *+,*E,+ .1, <,.0.0*>,+ 12; <+*/A-,/ *>, 32++02B,<1*.*2>/0>E0.2.0*>+,B2+/0>B10;32++02B,D0.1 .1, +,;<*>/,>. 2; <,+ H; " 2>/ ) +,;<,-.0E,=C 1, <,.0.0*>,+12;2=;*<+*/A-,/-,+.0?0,/-*<C*?5
0>+03, * "!$)#)) *? .1, (*3,>:; *=0-, .2.0*> 0@2C2<A+2 2>/ .1, -*3<=20>. B0E,> 4C .1, +,;<*>/,>. 2B20>;. .1, <,.0.0*>,+2>/10;<2+,>.;2>/?230=C3,34,+;4,?*+,.1, (*3,>:; *=0-, .2.0*> 0@2C2<A+2 2>/ ;23, 32+F,/ 2. H; )2>/ 6+,;<,-.0E,=C 1,/*-A3,>.,/H; )2>/ 6 D*A=/ ;1*D .12. .1, +,;<*>/,>. B2E, -*3<=20>. - 12 -
2B20>;..1,<,.0.0*>,+2>/10;<2+,>.;2>/?230=C3,34,+;
2==,B0>B 12+2;;3,>.
/,32>/0>B /*D+C 2>/ .1, -2;, D2;
+,B0;.,+,/ 2B20>;. <,.0.0*>,+ 2>/ *.1,+; ?*+ .1, *??,>-,; <A>0;124=,A>/,+,-.0*>;6$!"#$)#6#+,2/ D0.1,-.0*>6*?.1,>/02>,>2=*/,?*+;1*+.97 2>/,-.0*>6*?*D+C+*1040.0*>-.?*+;1*+.9-.7
" > .1, -*3<=20>. 2. H 6 .1, +,;<*>/,>. 32/, ;*3, 2==,B2.0*>; 2B20>;. .1, <,.0.0*>,+ 2>/ 10; ?230=C3,34,+; A.2;;A430..,/4C.1,=,2+>,/-*A>;,= .*.1,<,.0.0*>,+.1,+,;<*>/,>./0/>*.-1**;,.*2<<,2+ 2>/ -*>.,;. .1, <,.0.0*> 4,?*+, .1, 5230=C *A+. 2>/ .1,+,?*+, .1, ,E0/,>-, *? <,.0.0*>,+ 2; (" 2>/ .1, /*-A3,>.; 2. H; " .* 6 ;.**/ A>-12==,>B,/ ,>-, .1, 2+BA3,>. *? .1, =,2+>,/ -*A>;,= ?*+ .1, <,.0.0*>,+ 0; .12..1,+02=*A+.12;-*330..,/,++*+0>/0;30;;0>B.1, <,.0.0*>?*+/0E*+-,>*.2<<+,-02.0>B.1,A>-12==,>B,/*+2= 2>//*-A3,>.2+C,E0/,>-,?*+.1-*30>B*>+,-*+/
- 13 -
" .1,2+BA3,>.*?.1,=,2+>,/-*A>;,= 4C .1, +,;<*>/,>. 0; .12. .1, <,.0.0*>,+ 12; ?0=,/ .1, <,.0.0*> 4,?*+, .1, 5230=C *A+. *> ?2=;, 2==,B2.0*>;
*D,E,+ .1, +,;<*>/,>. 12; >*. -1*;,> .* 2<<,2+ 2>/ ?0=, 2>C ?0=, 2>C *4@,-.0*>; .* .1, <,.0.0*> /,>C0>B .1, <,.0.0*>2E,+3,>.; ,>-,2;;A430..,/.*=,2/232+0.2= =0?, 2>/ 1,>-, .1, 32++02B, 4,.D,,> .1, 4C .1, =,2+>,/ -*A>;,= ?*+ .1, <,.0.0*>,+ .1, <,.0.0*> 2E,+3,>.; ;.2>/ >*./0;<A.,/ ;/0;-A;;,/1,+,0>24*E,.1,<,.0.0*>,+2;
(" 0> 10; ,E0/,>-, 0> -10,? ,H230>2.0*> 12; +,0.,+2.,/ .1, ?2-.; 2E,++,/0>.1, <,.0.0*> 1, ,E0/,>-,*?(" 0> -10,? ,H230>2.0*>0;0>2--*+/2>-,D0.1<=20>.2E,+3,>.;
. 0; E,+C <,+.0>,>. .* >*., .12. 2; <,+ .1, <,.0.0*> 2E,+3,>.;2>/.1,,E0/,>-,*?("?+*3.1,?0+;.>0B1.*? .1,32++02B,0.;,=?.1,+,;<*>/,>./0/>*.-**<,+2.,D0.1 .1,<,.0.0*>,+2>/.1,+,;<*>/,>.D2;>*.-*>;A332.,/
"8 5A+.1,+ .1, -*>.,>.0*> *? .1, <,.0.0*>,+ .12. .1,+,;<*>/,>.0;/2AB1.,+*?H 2>/;1,D2;12E0>B 2> 0==0-0. +,=2.0*>;10< D0.1 ;*3, *.1,+ <,+;*> ;.2>/; >*. - 14 -
-*>.+*E,+.,/ *+,*E,+0.0;E,+C0>.,+,;.0>B.*>*.,.12. .1,+,;<*>/,>.=*/B,/-*3<=20>.2B20>;..1,<,.0.0*>,+10;
<2+,>.; 2>/ 10; +,=2.0E,; 4,?*+, (*3,> *=0-, .2.0*> 0@2C2<A+2 2; <,+ H 6 2>/ .1, 5
D2; 0;;A,/ 4C .1, -*>-,+>,/<*=0-,2;<,+H >.1,-*3<=20>.2.H 6 .1, +,;<*>/,>. 12; ;.2.,/ .12. 1,+ 32++02B, D0.1 .1, <,.0.0*>,+D2;;*=,3>0G,/*>#8 # )#"82. -*==,B, <+,30;,; 0@2C2<A+2 1, 2==,B2.0*> 2B20>;. .1, <,.0.0*>,+10;<2+,>.;2>/+,=2.0E,;0;.12..1,C;A4@,-.,/ .1, +,;<*>/,>. .* 0== .+,2.3,>. 2>/ /+*E, 1,+ *A. *? .1, 32.+03*>C1*3, .0;2=;*3,>.0*>,/0>.1,-*3<=20>.2. H 6 .12. 2--A;,/ * 6 D1* 0; .1, C*A>B,+ 4+*.1,+ *? .1,<,.0.0*>,+D2;=**F0>B2.1,+2;?*==*D;
6
!"
#$ % &
"! 5A+.1,+0>.1,-*3<=20>.2.H 60.0;;.2.,/ .12. .1, <2+,>.; *? +,;<*>/,>. .**F 1,+ .* .1, 1*A;, *? <,.0.0*>,+2>/.1,<,.0.0*>,+7;<2+,>.;2>/+,=2.0E,;=**F,/ 2?.,+1,+*>=C?*+?*A+.*?0E,/2C; B20>*>) #! )#"8
- 15 -
.1, <,.0.0*>,+ 10; <2+,>.; 2>/ +,=2.0E,; /+*E, .1, +,;<*>/,>. *A. *? .1, 32.+03*>02= 1*3, 1, +,=,E2>. <*+.0*>0>H 6+,2/;.1A;
' ()#!)#"8
)
**+ ,* *
"
-
.
/ 0 12 3
4,
' %5. 6
678
2
"
-
&
"$ 10; 32.,+02= *> +,-*+/ D*A=/ ;1*D .12. ?+*3) #! )#"8.1,+,;<*>/,>.12;>*.4,,>+,;0/0>B D0.1 .1, <,.0.0*>,+ 0> .1, 32.+03*>02= 1*3, ;
/0;-A;;,/ 1,+,0> 24*E, 0. 0; >*. 0> /0;<A., .12. .1, 32++02B, *? .1, <,.0.0*>,+ 2>/ +,;<*>/,>. D2;
;*=,3>0G,/*>#8 # )#"8 ,>-,0?.1,-*>.,>.0*>*? .1,+,;<*>/,>.0>.1,-*3<=20>.2.H 60;.2F,>0>.* -*>;0/,+2.0*>0.D*A=/4,-=,2+.12.;1,+,;0/,/D0.1 .1,<,.0.0*>,+0>.1,32.+03*>02=1*3,*>=C?*+24*A. J3*>.1;?+*3.1,/2.,*?.1,0+32++02B,
- 16 -
)# 5A+.1,+ 0> .1, -*3<=20>. 2. H 6 .1, -*>.,>.0*> *? .1, +,;<*>/,>. 0; .12. ?2.1,+ *? <,.0.0*>,+ .*=/ 1,+ ?2.1,+ *E,+ <1*>, .* -*>E,>, 2 <2>-12C2.0>.1,<+,;,>-,*?,=/,+; 10;D*A=/;1*D .12..1,<,.0.0*>,+:;?2.1,+.+0,/.*+,-*>-0=,32++02B, *?.1,<,.0.0*>,+ 2>/+,;<*>/,>. 4A. .1, +,;<*>/,>. /0/>*.32F,2>C2..,3<.?*+;,..=,3,>. )" 5A+.1,+0.0;2E,++,/0>.1,-*3<=20>.2.H 6 .12. 9
: 2 ; :<=
><
:
9
0
#
9 - ? $
? 9
"<
@3 'AB 'C
#$%5
D
0
*%&
)) 10; D*A=/ 2=;* ;1*D .12. .1, ;,..=,3,>. D2;
2..,3<.,/ .* 4,32/, 4C .1, -*==,2BA,; *? .1, ?2.1,+ *? <,.0.0*>,+ A. .1,+, D2; >* 2..,3<. 32/, 4C .1,
- 17 -
+,;<*>/,>.7; ?2.1,+ .* ;,..=, .1, 32..,+ 4,.D,,> .1, <,.0.0*>,+2>/.1,+,;<*>/,>. ) *+,*E,+2;;A430..,/4C.1,=,2+>,/-*A>;,= ?*+.1,<,.0.0*>,+0?.1,2E,+3,>.;*?.1,5
2.H 2+, .2F,> 0>.* -*>;0/,+2.0*> .1, 2==,B,/ *??,>-, .**F <=2-, 4,.D,,> ) #8 )#"8 .* ) #! )#"8 A. .1, -*3<=20>. D2; B0E,> 4C .1, +,;<*>/,>. .* .1, *=0-, .2.0*> *>
" ") )#))0 , 2?.,+3*+,.12>C,2+;?+*3.1,/2.,*? .1,2==,B,/0>-0/,>. )6 >;<0.,*?;,+E0-,*?>*.0-,0>.1,<,.0.0*>.1, +,;<*>/,>. 12; >*. -1*;,> .* 2<<,2+ 2>/ -*>.,;. .1, <,.0.0*> 1,+,?*+, .1, <,.0.0*> 2E,+3,>.; 2>/ .1, ,E0/,>-,?*+.1-*30>B*>+,-*+/;.2>/>*.-*>.+*E,+.,/4C .1, +,;<*>/,>. 1,+, 0; 24;*=A.,=C >* 32.,+02= ?*+.1-*30>B ?+*3.1,+,;<*>/,>..* ;1*D D1C .1,+,D2;
0>*+/0>2., /,=2C *? 3*+, .12> C,2+; 0> =*/B0>B .1, -*3<=20>.0?2.2==;1,D2;;A4@,-.,/.*0== .+,2.3,>.2>/ 12+2;;3,>. 2. .1, 12>/; *? .1, <,.0.0*>,+ 2>/ 10; ?230=C
- 18 -
3,34,+; /,32>/0>B /*D+C ,>-, .1, ,E0/,>-, *> +,-*+/D*A=/;1*D.12..1,+,;<*>/,>.D0==?A==C>,B=,-.,/ .1, <,.0.0*>,+ 2>/ ;1, /,;,+.,/ .1, 32.+03*>02= 1*3, 2?.,+.1+,,3*>.1;*?32++02B, ;*>.1,/2.,*??0=0>B.1, <,.0.0*>.1,+,;<*>/,>.12;/,;,+.,/.1,<,.0.0*>,+?*+2 <,+0*/*?3*+,.12>.D*C,2+;
) 1, <,.0.0*> D2; ?0=,/ 4,?*+, .1, 5230=C *A+. *> # #) )#) ,>-, 2; *> .1, /2., *? ?0=0>B *? .1, <,.0.0*> .1, +,;<*>/,>. =,?. .1, 32.+03*>02= 1*3, 2>/ /,;,+.,/.1,<,.0.0*>,+?*+.1,<,+0*/*?24*A.6JC,2+;
; .1,+, 0; >* ,E0/,>-, *> +,-*+/ .* ;1*D .12. .1, +,;<*>/,>.
32/, 2>C 2..,3<. .* @*0> .1, -*3<2>C *? <,.0.0*>,+0.D*A=/-=,2+=CB*.*;1*D.12..1,+,;<*>/,>. 12; D0==?A==C /,;,+.,/ .1, <,.0.0*>,+ *+,*E,+ .1, ?2-. .12..1,+,;<*>/,>./0/>*.-**<,+2.,D0.1.1,<,.0.0*>,+ .* -*>;A332., 32++02B, ?+*3 .1, ?0+;. >0B1. *? .1, 32++02B, 0.;,=? D*A=/ ;1*D .12. .1, <,.0.0*>,+ D2;
;A4@,-.,/.*3,>.2=-+A,=.C4C.1,+,;<*>/,>. - 19 -
) 5A+.1,+ .1, <,.0.0*> 2E,+3,>.; +,B2+/0>B .1, 12+2;;3,>. 2. .1, 12>/; *? .1, +,;<*>/,>. ;.2>/ >*. -*>.+*E,+.,/ 1,+,0;>*+,2;*>.*/0;4,=0,E,.1,<,.0.0*> 2E,+3,>.; 2>/ .1, ,E0/,>-, *? (" 1, <,.0.0*>,+ 12;
,H230>,/ 10; ?2.1,+ 1,,32+2@ * 2==2<<2 ,==A440 2;
() 2>/ *>, 0//2=0>B2<<2 * 2;2>2<<22/032>0 2 +,.0+,/ B*E,+>3,>. ;,+E2>. 2>/ ,=/,+ *? .1, ?230=C 2;
( 1, () 2>/ ( 12E, ?0=,/ .1,0+ 2??0/2E0. 2;
,E0/,>-, 0> -10,? ,H230>2.0*> +,0.,+2.0>B .1, <,.0.0*> 2E,+3,>.; +,B2+/0>B *> .1, B+*A>/ *? /,;,+.0*> 2>/ -+A,=.C <A. ?*+.1 4C .1, <,.0.0*>,+ 0> .1, <,.0.0*> 1, ,E0/,>-,*?()2>/(2=;*;.2>/;>*.-*>.+*E,+.,/4C .1,+,;<*>/,>. )8 1, () 0> 10; ,E0/,>-, 12; ;.2.,/ .12. 1, 2=*>BD0.1,=/,+;*?.1,?230=C.+0,/.*;,..=,.1,32..,+ 4A..1,+,;<*>/,>./0/>*.1,,/.*.1,0++,IA,;. (0> 10; ,E0/,>-, 12; /,<*;,/ .12. .1, 3*.1,+ *? +,;<*>/,>. A;,/ .* -*3, .* .1, 1*A;, *? <,.0.0*>,+ 2>/ .2F, 1,+ /2AB1.,++,;<*>/,>. *A.;0/, D0.1*A. 0>?*+30>B .1,
- 20 -
<2+,>.;*?<,.0.0*>,+2>/.1,+,;<*>/,>.A;,/.*B**A.*? 32.+03*>02= 1*3, D0.1*A. 0>?*+30>B .1, ?230=C 3,34,+; 2>/;1,D2;4,12E0>B2/232>.=C0>.1,?230=C
)! 1, E,+C ?2-. .12. 0> ;<0., *? ;,+E0-, *? >*.0-, .1,+,;<*>/,>.12;>*.-1*;,>.*2<<,2+2>/-*>.,;..1, <,.0.0*>D*A=/;1*D.12..1,<,.0.0*>2E,+3,>.;2>/.1, ,E0/,>-, *? (" .* ( ;.2>/ >*. -*>.+*E,+.,/ 4C .1, +,;<*>/,>. 1,+,0;24;*=A.,=C>*+,2;*>.*/0;4,=0,E,.1, ,E0/,>-, ?*+.1-*30>B *> +,-*+/ ?+*3 .1, <,.0.0*>,+ *D,E,+.1,5230=C*A+.0>;.,2/*?2<<=C0>B.1,=2D.* .1, ?2-.; *? .1, -2;, 12; /0;-A;;,/ 3*+, 24*A. .1, <+0>-0<=,; *? =2D D0.1*A. .2F0>B 0>.* -*>;0/,+2.0*> .1, <,.0.0*> 2E,+3,>.; 2>/ .1, ,E0/,>-, ?*+.1-*30>B *> +,-*+/ ; 2+BA,/ 4C .1, =,2+>,/ -*A>;,= ?*+ .1, <,.0.0*>,+ >* +,2;*> 0; ?*+.1-*30>B 0> .1, 03<AB>,/ @A/B3,>.*?;1*D2;.*D1C.1,,E0/,>-,*?(".*( -2>>*.4,4,=0,E24=,
- 21 -
)$ 5A+.1,+ 0. 0; ;.+2>B, .12. .1, 5230=C *A+. 0> .1, 03<AB>,/ @A/B3,>. 12; /0;-A;;,/ .12. .1, B,>,+2= +A=,0>2==-2;,;*?-+A,=.C0;.12. K
! "
!L
# 1, 5230=C *A+. 12; >*. ;.2.,/ 2; .* D12. ;1*A=/4,.1,2/,IA2.,,E0/,>-,.*<+*E,.1,B+*A>/;*? /,;,+.0*>2>/-+A,=.C?*+/0E*+-, 1,+,0;>*3,>.0*>4C .1,5230=C*A+.0>.1,03<AB>,/@A/B3,>.2;.*D1C.1, ,E0/,>-,*?(".*(0;>*.4,=0,E24=,D1,>0.;.2>/;
>*.-*>.+*E,+.,/4C.1,+,;<*>/,>. " . 0; .+A, .12. .1, ,-.0*> *? ""0 2 *?
-.+,2/;.1A;
#$%&
&
'
- 22 -
$#%((((((
$# % )
*
$#%(((
) 1,,H<=2>2.0*>.*,-.0*>""+,2/;.1A;
“+( '"
'
( ,,
( ! ; ;A430..,/ 4C .1, =,2+>,/ -*A>;,= ?*+ .1, <,.0.0*>,+ 2; <,+ ,-.0*> ""0 2 *? -. 0? *>, <,+;*> .* .1, 32++02B, D*A=/ .+,2. *.1,+ <,+;*> D0.1 -+A,=.C0.D*A=/4,2B+*A>/.*.2F,/0E*+-, A.0.0;E,+C ;.+2>B, .* >*., .12. ,E,> .1*AB1 .1, 5230=C *A+. 12;
-*3, .* .1, -*>-=A;0*> .12. 3,>.2= -+A,=.C -2>>*. 4, ,;.24=0;1,/4C/0+,-.,E0/,>-, .0;?A+.1,+*4;,+E,/.12. .1, <,.0.0*>,+ 12; 30;,+24=C ?20=,/ .* 32F, *A. 2>C -2;, 2;<,+.1,=2D2>/.*<+*/A-,,E0/,>-,D10-1D*A=/=,2/
- 23 -
.*/+2D2>0>?,+,>-,.12..1,<,.0.0*>,+D2;;A4@,-.,/.* -+A,=.C4C.1,+,;<*>/,>. 6 5A+.1,+ .1, 5230=C *A+. 12; *4;,+E,/ 0> .1, 03<AB>,/@A/B3,>..12.>*2/,IA2.,,E0/,>-,0;2//A-,/ 4C.1,<,.0.0*>,+.*<+*E,.12..1,32++02B,4,.D,,>103 2>/ +,;<*>/,>. 4+*F, /*D> 0++,.+0,E24=C 2>/ .1,+, 0; >* -12>-,*?.1,3-*30>B.*B,.1,+ A.2;;A430..,/4C.1, =,2+>,/-*A>;,=?*+.1,<,.0.0*>,+;A-1*4;,+E2.0*>*?.1, 5230=C *A+. 0; D0.1*A. -*>;0/,+0>B .1, ,E0/,>-, *? <,.0.0*>,+ D10-1 ;.**/ >*. -*>.+*E,+.,/ 4C .1, +,;<*>/,>. 1,+,0;24;*=A.,=C>*32.,+02=?*+.1-*30>B0> .1, 03<AB>,/ @A/B3,>. .* ;1*D D1C .1, ,E0/,>-, *? <,.0.0*>,+ 12; >*. 4,,> 4,=0,E,/ 4C .1, 5230=C *A+. D1,> ;A-1 ,E0/,>-, ;.2>/; >*. -*>.+*E,+.,/ 4C .1, +,;<*>/,>. *+,*E,+ ,E,> .1*AB1 .1, 5230=C *A+. 12;
+,?,++,/ .* ;*3, @A/B3,>.; *? .1, *>:4=, <,H *A+. +,B2+/0>B.1,B+*A>/;*?-+A,=.C2>//,;,+.0*>.1,5230=C
- 24 -
*A+.12;?20=,/.**4;,+E,2;.*D1,.1,+.1*;,/,-0;0*>;
2+,2<<=0-24=,.*.1,?2-.;*?.1,-2;,*>12>/ .0;D,== ;,..=,/ <+0>-0<=, *? =2D .12. ,E,+C -2;, ;1*A=/ 4, -*>;0/,+,/*>.1,?2-.;*?,2-1-2;, ;/0;-A;;,/1,+,0> 24*E,0>.1,-2;,*>12>/.1,2..0.A/,*?.1,+,;<*>/,>. 2;2E,++,/4C.1,<,.0.0*>,+D10-10;>*.-*>.+2E,+.,/4C .1, +,;<*>/,>. D*A=/ -=,2+=C ;1*D .12. .1, +,;<*>/,>. /0/>*.-**<,+2.,D0.1.1,<,.0.0*>,+?+*3.1,?0+;./2C*? .1,32++02B,0.;,=?2>//A,.*.1,-*>/A-.*?+,;<*>/,>. .1, 32++02B, *? <,.0.0*>,+ D0.1 .1, +,;<*>/,>. D2; >*. -*>;A332.,/
5A+.1,+ ,E,> .1*AB1 .1, <,.0.0*>,+ 2>/ .1,0+ ?230=C 3,34,+; .+0,/ .* ;,..=, .1, 32..,+ 4C -*>E,>0>B <2>-12C2. D0.1 .1, 1,=< *? ,=/,+; 0> .1, ?230=C .1, +,;<*>/,>. /0/ >*. 1,,/ .* .1, 2/E0-, *? .1, <2+,>.; *? .1,<,.0.0*>,+2>/.1,,=/,+;*?.1,?230=C2>/.1,+,4C;1, ?20=,/.*@*0>.1,32.+03*>02=1*3,*?.1,<,.0.0*>,+
8 ; /0;-A;;,/ 1,+,0>24*E, .1, 32++02B, *? .1, <,.0.0*>,+D0.1+,;<*>/,>.D2;;*=,3>0G,/*>#8 # )#"8
- 25 -
5+*3 .1, -*3<=20>. 2E,+3,>.; *? .1, +,;<*>/,>. 2; <,+ H 6 0. D*A=/ 4, -=,2+ .12. ?+*3 ) #! )#"8 .1, +,;<*>/,>.12;>*.4,,>+,;0/0>BD0.1.1,<,.0.0*>,+0>.1, 32.+03*>02=1*3,0 , ;1,+,;0/,/D0.1.1,<,.0.0*>,+*>=C ?*+.1,<,+0*/*?J3*>.1;2>/.1,+,2?.,+.1,+,;<*>/,>. 12;>*.+,;0/,/D0.1.1,<,.0.0*>,+
! 1,<,.0.0*>2E,+3,>.;.12..1,+,;<*>/,>.=,?. .1,32.+03*>02=1*3,D0.1*A.0>?*+30>B*+0>.032.0>B.1, <,.0.0*>,+ 2>/ 10; ?230=C 3,34,+; 2>/ 10; <2+,>.; ;.2>/ >*.-*>.+*E,+.,/ 1,2==,B2.0*>32/,4C.1,+,;<*>/,>. 0> .1, -*3<=20>. 2. H 6 .12. ?*+ 3*+, .12> ?0E, C,2+;
;1, 12; 4,,> +,;0/0>B ;,<2+2.,=C ?+*3 .1, <,.0.0*>,+ D*A=/;1*D.12.;1,0;>*.D0==0>B.*@*0>.1,32.+03*>02= 1*3, *? <,.0.0*>,+ 5A+.1,+ 0> ;<0., *? ;,+E0-, *? >*.0-, .1, +,;<*>/,>. 12; >*.
-1*;,> .* 2<<,2+ 4,?*+, .1, 5230=C*A+.2>/-*>.,;..1,<,.0.0*> E,>0>.1,2<<,2= *> 12>/ .1,+, 0; >* 2>C B+*A>/ 32/, *A. 4C .1, +,;<*>/,>..*32F,.1,<=,2/0>B;2>/.1,,E0/,>-,*?.1,
- 26 -
<,.0.0*>,+4,?*+,.1,5230=C*A+.+,B2+/0>B.1,B+*A>/*? -+A,=.C2>//,;,+.0*>?*+/0E*+-,/0;4,=0,E24=,
$ 5A+.1,+.1,+,;<*>/,>./0/>*..2F,>2>C;.,<;
.* ;1*D .12. ;1, 0; D0==0>B .* @*0> .1, <,.0.0*>,+ 2>/ .1,+,4C >*. .* B+2>. *? /0E*+-, 0> ?2E*A+ *? <,.0.0*>,+ /0;;*=E0>B 1,+ 32++02B, D0.1 .1, <,.0.0*>,+ *D 0. 0;
>,-,;;2+C .* +,?,+ .* .1, /,-0;0*> *? .1, *>:4=, <,H *A+. 0> .1, -2;, *? +,<*+.,/ 0> /,-0/,/ *> ,<.,34,+ )#) D1,+,0> 0> .1, <,.0.0*> ?*+ /0E*+-, ?0=,/ A>/,+ ,-.0*> ""0 2 *? -. A>/,+ .1, B+*A>/*?-+A,=.C0.0;1,=/.12. - ! . ! / $0#$%#' % (
(
! ! "
1
! *
- 27 -
! ! 6# *+,*E,+.1,*>:4=,<,H*A+.0>.1,-2;,*? !" # $ +,<*+.,/ 0> % &&'/,-0/,/*>,-,34,+"$)#)612; 1,=/.12. 2
! &
!. & ! 6" 1, ?2-.; *? .1, 24*E, +,?,++,/ -2;, ;IA2+,=C 2<<=C .* .1, ?2-.; *? .1, -2;, *> 12>/ . 0; .+A, .12. 4A+/,>*?<+**?=0,;*><,+;*>D1*2<<+*2-1,;.1,*A+. D0.12/,?0>0.,-2;, *D,E,+.1,<,.0.0*>2E,+3,>.;2>/ .1,,E0/,>-,*?(".*(0>.1,-2;,*>12>/;.2>/>*. -12==,>B,/ 4C .1, +,;<*>/,>. 4C -*>.,;.0>B .1, <,.0.0*> 2>/ 1,>-, .1, <=,2/0>B; 2>/ ,E0/,>-, *? .1, <,.0.0*>,+
- 28 -
12E, +,320>,/ A>/0;<A.,/ 1, 4A+/,> *? <+**? 2+0;,; *>=C0?.1,*.1,+;0/,/,>0,;.1,-*>.,>.0*>;*?.1,<,+;*> D1* 2<<+*2-1,/ .1, *A+. > <+,;,>. -2;, .1, +,;<*>/,>.12;>*.-1*;,>.*-*>.,;..1,<,.0.0*>
6) *+,*E,+ 2; /0;-A;;,/ 1,+,0>24*E, .1, -*3<=20>2>. 2E,+3,>.; *? .1, +,;<*>/,>. 2; <,+ H 6 D*A=/-=,2+=C;1*D.12.;1,+,;0/,/D0.1.1,<,.0.0*>,+0> 32.+03*>02=1*3,*>=C?*+.1,<,+0*/*?.1+,,3*>.1;2>/ .1,+,2?.,+ ;1, =,?. .1, 32.+03*>02= 1*3, 2>/ ;1, 12;
4,,> +,;0/0>B 0> 1,+ <2+,>.;: 1*A;, ?*+ 2 <,+0*/ *? 3*+, .12> C,2+; 2; *> .1, /2., *? ?0=0>B *? .1, <,.0.0*> 1, 2..,3<.32/,4C.1,<,.0.0*>,+.*@*0>.1,+,;<*>/,>..* 32.+03*>02= 1*3, +,320>,/ A>;A--,;;?A= ,>-, .1, 32.,+02=;*>+,-*+/D*A=/-=,2+=C;1*D.12..1,+,0;-=,2+ B+*A>/*?/,;,+.0*>0>?2E*A+*?.1,<,.0.0*>,+?*+B+2>.0>B /0E*+-,2;<+2C,/?*+
6 1, <,.0.0*>,+ 12; 2=;* <+*E,/ .12. 1, D2;
;A4@,-.,/.*-+A,=.C4C.1,+,;<*>/,>. A-1-+A,=.C32C
- 29 -
>*. 4, <1C;0-2= -+A,=.C ; 1,=/ 0> .1, 24*E, +,?,++,/ /,-0;0*>; *? .1, *>:4=, <,H *A+. 0. 0; -=,2+ .12. .1, -+A,=.C12;>*?0H,/3,2>0>B2>/.1,+,0;D0/,/0;-+,.0*> .* .1, *A+. .* 2<<=C 0. =04,+2==C 2>/ -*>.,H.A2==C > .1, -2;,*>12>/A>/,+.1,-0+-A3;.2>-,;0.D*A=/4,-=,2+ .12..1,+,;<*>/,>.12;;A4@,-.,/.1,<,.0.0*>,+.*3,>.2= -+A,=.C 1, 12; >* D0==0>B>,;; .* @*0> .1, 32.+03*>02= 1*3,*?.1,<,.0.0*>,+
66 1,+,?*+,2;2+BA,/4C.1,=,2+>,/-*A>;,=?*+ .1, <,.0.0*>,+ .1, <,.0.0*>,+ 12; 32/, *A. ;A??0-0,>. B+*A>/ .* ;,.
2;0/, .1, 03<AB>,/ @A/B3,>. 2>/ /,-+,, 2>/ .1,+,4C .* B+2>. 2 /,-+,, *? /0E*+-, 0> 10; ?2E*A+ /0;;*=E0>B10;32++02B,;*=,3>0G,/D0.1.1,+,;<*>/,>.*> .1, B+*A>/; *? -+A,=.C 2>/ /,;,+.0*> *>;,IA,>.=C .1, <,.0.0*> ?0=,/ 4C .1, <,.0.0*>,+ 4,?*+, .1, 5230=C *A+. /,;,+E,; .* 4, 2==*D,/ ,>-, D, 2+, *? .1,-*>;0/,+,/ E0,D.12..1,2<<,2=*>12>//,;,+E,;.*4,2==*D,/
6 >.1,+,;A=.2>;D,+0>B.1,24*E,<*0>.0>.1, 2??0+32.0E,D,<+*-,,/.*<2;;.1,?*==*D0>B
- 30 -
0 1,2<<,2=0;1,+,4C())*+ 00 *>;,IA,>.=C .1, @A/B3,>. 2>/ /,-+,, /2.,/ # #! )#) *? .1, //= +0>-0<2= A/B,5230=C*A+.0@2C2<A+20> * 6!)#)0;1,+,4C;,.2;0/,
000 1,<,.0.0*>?0=,/4C.1,<,.0.0*>,+4,?*+,.1, +02= *A+. A>/,+ ,-.0*>
""0204 *? 0>/A 2++02B, -. "$ ;.2>/; 2==*D,/ 2>/ 2 /,-+,, *? /0E*+-, 0; B+2>.,//0;;*=E0>B.1,32++02B,*?<,.0.0*>,+ D0.1+,;<*>/,>.;*=,3>0G,/*>#8 # )#"8 0E **+/,+2;.*-*;. E ,-+,,*?/0E*+-,;12==4,/+2D>2--*+/0>B=C
)* &"' $
)* & $% ' $ 0;.* "=* !