Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 65945 (KAR)
ARSHAD HUSSAIN S/O MOHAMMED HUSSAIN v. KHURSHEED AHMED S/O MOHAMMED USMAN BADAL
RSA/7337/2013 · 2025-11-19
Sachin Shankar Magadum
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 65945 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 65945 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"#
$"%"" && '%( )
! "
#
$
%&'(#
'
)&
%&'(#
! "
Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
#((
* '#('(#) #( '(#' * *
) '(( #)()'(#'
*
!* "
) '((
*
+
*
%" ! +
*
"
,- ./01234-5 6-.345 /00-/7 26 89 1,- 07/2412:: /66/2724; 1,- <=5;>-41 /45 5-.?-- ?-45-?-5 89 1,- 00-77/1-3=?124 3#( '(#'@,-?-241,-00-77/1- 3=?1,/6526>266-51,-07/2412::+66=2124-412?-19 ' 3? 1,- 6/A- 3: .34B-42-4.- 1,- 0/?12-6 /?- ?-:-??-513/60-?1,-2??/4A8-:3?-1,-?2/73=?1
- 3 -
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
=1,3?219 :3? /00?3B/7 3: / ?-625-412/7 7/93=1 @,2., @/6 6/4.1234-5 34 #)#''((# /45 07316 @-?- 1,-?-/:1-? :3?>-5..3?524;131,-07/2412::1,-5-:-45/4165-6021- ,/B24;43>/44-?3:?2;,11217-3?241-?-61241,--/61-?4 ./?11?/.A?=4424; 3?1,G3=1,,/B-277-;/7793861?=.1-5/ #%:--1 ?3/5 :3?>-5 34 1,- -/61-?4 625- 3: ,26 0?30-?19 -4.-1,-0?-6-416=21./>-138-:27-5
- 4 -
034 6-?B2.- 3: 6=>>346 1,- 5-:-45/416 -41-?-5 /00-/?/4.- /45 :27-5 1,-2? @?211-4 61/1->-41 5-4924; 24 1313 1,- 07/241 /B-?>-416 ,-9 60-.2:2./779 5260=1-5 1,- 83=45/?2-6 3: 1,- 6=21 7/45 34 1,- -/61-?4 625- -:-45/41 3# .7/2>-5 1,/1 1,- 5-:-45/416 3@4 / 61?20 3: 7/45 621=/1-5 2>>-52/1-79 13 1,- -/61 3: 1,- 07/2412::H6 0?30-?19 /45 1,/1 3479 8-9345 1,26 61?20 1,- -/61-?4?3/5-D26161@/61,-?-:3?-.341-45-51,/11,- 07/2412::H6 7/45 53-6 431 -D1-45 =0 13 1,- -/61-?4 ?3/5 77-;24; 1,/1 1,- 6=21 26 / >/7/ :25- /11->01 13 -4.?3/., =034 1,-2? 0?30-?19 1,- 5-:-45/416 63=;,1 526>266/7 3: 1,-6=21
31, 0/?12-6 /55=.-5 3?/7 /45 53.=>-41/?9 -B25-4.- 24 6=003?1 3: 1,-2? ?-60-.12B- .7/2>6 4 /00?-.2/12343:1,-6/>-1,-?2/73=?10/?179/46@-?-5 66=- 3# 24 1,- /::2?>/12B- ,37524; 1,/1 1,- 07/2412:: 26 1,- 3@4-? /45 0366-663? 3: 7/45 8-/?24; 9 3#)
>-/6=?24;'/.?-6##;=41/63@-B-?21:=?1,-?,-751,/1 1,-07/2412::H67/4553-6431-D1-45=0131,--/61-?4?3/5
- 5 -
,-?2/73=?1.34.7=5-51,/1/71,3=;,1,-07/2412::26431 1,-3@4-?3:1,-5260=1-5-/61-?461?20,-26240366-66234 1,-?-3: ?-6-?B24; 728-?19 13 1,- 5-:-45/416 13 ?-.3B-?
0366-6623424/..3?5/4.-@21,7/@
;;?2-B-5 89 1,- :24524;6 34 66=- 3# 1,- 5-:-45/4160?-:-??-5 3#( '(#',-2?6100-77/1- 3=?1 34 /4 245-0-45-41 ?-/66-66>-41 3: 1,- -412?- -B25-4.-526/;?--5@21,1,-?2/73=?1H6:24524;61,-75 1,/1 1,- 07/2412::H6 0?30-?19 53-6 431 -D1-45 =0 13 1,- -/61-?4./?11?/.A/451,/11,-07/2412:::/27-513-61/8726, 0366-662343B-?1,-5260=1-503?1234/6341,-5/1-3:1,- 6=21 -:-??24; 13 1,- ?2/7 3=?1H6 3@4 386-?B/1234 1,/1 1,-5-:-45/4160366-66/03?12343:1,-7/458-1@--41,- 07/2412::H6 0?30-?19 /45 1,- -/61-?4 ./?1 1?/.A 1,- 00-77/1- 3=?1 ,-75 1,/1 1,- ?2/7 3=?1H6 .34.7=6234 ?-;/?524; 1,- 07/2412::H6 0366-66234 26 .341?/?9 13 1,- 5-:-45/416H?-8=11/7-B25-4.--7924;34
D6E13## @,2.,@-?-,-7513./??90?-6=>012B-B/7=-1,-00-77/1- 3=?1.34.7=5-51,/11,-5-:-45/416,/50?3B-5831,1217-
- 6 -
/450366-662343B-?1,-241-?B-424;61?203:7/4541,-6- :24524;6 1,- 00-77/1- 3=?1 ?-B-?6-5 1,- ?2/7 3=?1H6 .34.7=6234 34 66=- 3# /45 526>266-5 1,- 6=21 24 216 -412?-19 $ ,26 3=?1 89 3?5-? 5/1-5 (E#''('( /5>211-5 1,- /00-/7/45 :?/>-5 1,- :3773@24; 6=861/412/7 C=-6123463:7/@
! "
"
#
& -/?4-5 .3=46-7 :3? 1,- /00-77/41 07/2412:: 07/.24; ?-72/4.- 34 1,- 1217- /45 83=45/?9 ?-.21/76 6=8>211-51,/11,-5-:-45/416H7/4572-6131,-43?1,3:1,- 07/2412::H6 0?30-?19 - ->0,/62I-5 1,/1 431@21,61/4524; 1,-5-:-45/416H07-/3:1217-1,-5-:-45/416525431,/B-
- 7 -
1,-2? 6/7- 5--5 >/?A-5 24 -B25-4.-J ,-4.- /4 /5B-?6- 24:-?-4.-=45-?-.1234##!;"3:1,-
B25-4.-.13=;,1 13 8- 5?/@4 /;/2461 1,-> 5B-?124; 13 1,- 5-:-45/416H 83=45/?9 5-6.?201234 !/6 07-/5-5" ,- /?;=-5 1,/1 1,- 63=1,-?4 83=45/?9 3: 1,- 5-:-45/416H ,37524; 26 1,- 07/2412::H67/45249 3#) >-/6=?24;'/.?-6##;=41/6 ,-?-:3?-1,-5-:-45/416./4431247/@3?34:/.1/66-?1 3@4-?6,20 3? 0366-66234 3B-? /49 4/??3@ 61?20 63=1, 3: 1,-2? 3@4 63=1,-?4 83=45/?9 4 1,26 0?->26- ,- .341-45-5 1,/1 1,- 2?61 00-77/1- 3=?1H6 :24524;
?-.3;42I24; 1,- 5-:-45/416H 0366-66234 3B-? 1,- 5260=1-5 61?20 26 0-?B-?6- 0/?12.=7/?79 24 1,- /86-4.- 3: 0?2>/?9 ?-8=11/7 -B25-4.- 24 1,- 4/1=?- 3: 1,- 5-:-45/416H 1217- 5--5 E $
7-/?4-5 .3=46-7 :3? 1,- ?-60345-416 5-:-45/416 5?/@24; 1,- 3=?1H6 /11-41234 13 1,- ?-8=11/7 -B25-4.- /45 13 1,- ?2/7 3=?1H6 526.=66234 =45-? 66=- 3# 6=8>211-5 1,/1 1,- ?2/7 3=?1 24.25-41/779 5-1-?>24-5 1,- 5-:-45/416H 1217- 13 1,-
- 8 -
241-?B-424; 61?20 8-1@--4 1,- 07/2412::H6 7/45 /45 1,- -/61-?4 ./?1 1?/.A 366/772 ?3/5 /45 1,/1 1,- 07/2412:: 4-21,-?/00-/7-51,/1:24524;43?:27-5.?366%38<-.12346- /?;=-5 1,/1 34.- 1217- 13 1,- 61?20 61335 24.25-41/779 ?-.3;42I-524/424<=4.12346=211,-2?6100-77/1-3=?1 ?2;,179 0?3.--5-5 13 ?-.3?5 / :24524; 34 0366-66234 24 :/B3=? 3: 1,- 5-:-45/416 1?-6624; 1,- 0?24.207- 1,/1 0366-66234 3?524/?279 :3773@6 1217- ,- >/241/24-51,/1 1,- /00-77/41 :/27-5 13 -61/8726, /.1=/7 0366-66234 3B-?
1,- 5260=1-5 61?20 34 1,- 5/1- 3: 6=21J .346-C=-4179 1,- 6=861/412/7C=-6123463:7/@:?/>-5891,263=?15-6-?B- 138-/46@-?-5/;/24611,-07/2412:: #( -/?5 7-/?4-5 .3=46-7 :3? 1,- 0/?12-6 -?=6-5 1,- 07-/524;6 3?/7 /45 53.=>-41/?9 -B25-4.- /45 1,- .34.=??-41 /6 @-77 /6 52B-?;-41 :24524;6 ?-.3?5-5 89 1,- 3=?168-73@ ## 3 -61/8726, 1217- /45 0366-66234 3B-? 9 3#) >-/6=?24; ' /.?-6 ## ;=41/6 1,- 07/2412::
0?35=.-5 1,- ?-;261-?-5 6/7- 5--5 /1
D& /734; @21,
- 9 -
-B25-4.- 3: .34B-?6234 /45 5-B-730>-41 3: / ?-625-412/7 7/93=1 B2I 7/4424; =1,3?219 /00?3B/7 /1
D 1,- /00?3B-5 7/93=1 07/4 /1
D /45 1,- >/0 /1
D$ -.3?5 3: 2;,16 -41?2-6 /?- /763 07/.-5 34 ?-.3?5 6,3@24;1,-07/2412::/61,-A,/1-5/?3:9 3#) 131,- 6/25-D1-41 #' 4 ?-8=11/7 1,- 5-:-45/416 0?35=.-5 6=?B-9 6A-1.,-6/1
D6E13##J,3@-B-?1,-2?6/7-5--51,- 8-61 -B25-4.- 3: 1,-2? 1217- /45 83=45/?2-6 @/6 431 1-45-?-5 /45 >/?A-5
B-4 34 1,- 5-:-45/416H 3@4 83=45/?95-6.?201234/607-/5-51,--/61-?483=45/?93:
1,-2? 7/45 /8=16 1,- ./?1 1?/.A 366/772 ?3/5 /45 1,- 63=1,-?483=45/?9/8=161,-07/2412::H69 3#) 41,- /86-4.- 3: 1,- 5-:-45/416H 1217- 5--5 24 -B25-4.- 1,-2? /11->0113./?B-3=1/4/??3@61?2063=1,3:1,-2?63=1,-?4 83=45/?926=46=003?1-5890?2>/?953.=>-41/?90?33: #)
,372612. -D/>24/1234 3: 1,- 1303;?/0,9 ->-?;24;:?3>1,-07/2412::H6/00?3B-57/93=1! D"/45 1,- 5-:-45/416H 6A-1.,-6 ! D6E 13 ##" 2452./1-6 1,/1
- 10 -
1,-5-:-45/416H7/4572-6131,-43?1,@,27-1,-07/2412::H6 7/45249 3#) 72-6131,-63=1,41,--/61-?4625- 3:831,,37524;6?=461,- 3?1,G3=1,K366/772H?3/5 ./?1 1?/.A 31/879
DE 5-02.16 63>-@,/1 /43>/73=679 / 67-45-?134;=-%72A-0?3<-.12345-6.-4524;63=1,@/?5:?3> 1,- 5-:-45/416H 43?1,-?4 ,37524; 1,-?-89 241?=524; 2413 1,- -/61-?4 03?1234 3: 1,- 07/2412::H6 0?30-?19 ,26 5-02.1234 .34:72.16 @21, 1,- 83=45/?9 ?-.21/76 ?-72-5 =034 89 1,- 07/2412:: =45-? D& @,2., 6,3@ 9 3#)
-D1-4524; =0 13 1,- -/61-?4 3?1,G3=1, ?3/5 ,- ?2/7 3=?1 @,27- 24.25-41/779 4-;/12B24; 1,- 07/2412::H6 1217- 13 1,-# :--1 -/61-?4 61?20 4-B-?1,-7-66 :3=45 1,- 07/2412:: 24 0366-66234 3: 1,/1 61?20 /6 34 1,- 5/1- 3: 6=21 /45 ;?/41-5/424<=4.1234?-6-?B24;728-?19131,-5-:-45/416 13?-.3B-?0366-66234245=-.3=?6-3:7/@ # ,26 ./6- 1=?46 34 1@3 241-?73.A24; :/.-16 !2" 1,-7-;/7-::-.13:1,-5-:-45/416H:/27=?-13>/?A1,-2?3@4 6/7- 5--5 /45 !22" 1,- 0?30-? /00?/26/7 3: 83=45/?9 ?-.21/76B26%L%B261,-0,962./75-02.123424
D6E13##
- 11 -
2B-41,/11,-5-:-45/416H6/7-5--51,-8-61-B25-4.-3: 1,-2?83=45/?9.7/2>@/6@21,,-75:?3>0?33:/4/5B-?6- 24:-?-4.-26/11?/.1-5,-41,-83=45/?9?-.21/7624
D& !1217- 3: 1,- 07/2412::" /?- ?-/5 @21, 1,- 6/4.1234-5 7/93=1 ! D" /45 ?-B-4=- -41?2-6 1,-9 .3;-4179 6=003?1 1,- 07/2412::H60366-66234 =013 1,--/61-?4 ./?11?/.A 366/772 ?3/5 ,- 2?61 00-77/1- 3=?1 ,3@-B-?
0?-6=>-5831, 1217- /45 0366-66234 24 :/B3=? 3: 1,- 5-:-45/416 34 1,- 61?-4;1,3:1,-6=?B-96A-1.,-6/734-@21,3=1/55?-6624;
!/"1,-/5B-?6-24:-?-4.-!8"1,-83=45/?9?-.21/76=45-? D& /45 !." 1,- ?2/7 3=?1H6 60-.2:2. :24524; 3: /.1=/7 0366-66234 @21, 1,- 07/2412:: /6 34 1,- 5/1- 3: 6=21 ,26 /00?3/.,26.7-/?79:7/@-5/456=::-?6:?3>0-?B-?6219 # ,- 07/2412:: 24 3?5-? 13 -61/8726, ,26 7/@:=7 0366-66234 3B-? 1,- 6=21 0?30-?19 ,/6 0?35=.-5 1,- ?-;261-?-5 6/7- 5--5 /1 D& /734; @21, .3;-41 53.=>-41/?9 -B25-4.- 5->3461?/124; .34B-?6234 /45 5-B-730>-41 3: / ?-625-412/7 7/93=1 4/>-79 1,- 7/4424;
=1,3?219H6 /00?3B/7 /1
D 1,- 6/4.1234-5 7/93=1 07/4
- 12 -
/1
D/451,-.3??-6034524;>/0/1
D$,--.3?5 3:2;,16-41?2-607/.-534?-.3?5/7636,3@1,-07/2412::/6 1,- A,/1-5/? 24 ?-60-.1 3: 9 3#) 13 1,- -D1-41 3: ' /.?-6 ## ;=41/6 ,-6- 53.=>-416 1/A-4 .=>=7/12B-79 =4>261/A/879 5-02.1 1,- 07/2412::H6 .34124=3=6 /45 /.1=/7 0366-66234 3B-? 1,- 6=21 0?30-?19 -D1-4524; =0 13 1,- -/61-?4 366/772 ?3/5
B-4 1,3=;, 1,- ?2/7 3=?1 @,27- /46@-?24; 66=- 3# 24.25-41/779 ?-.3?5-5 / :24524;
/5B-?6- 13 1,- 07/2412:: 34 1,- C=-61234 3: 1217- 13 1,- 4/??3@ -/61-?4 61?20 1,- 6/>- 3=?1 62>=71/4-3=679 /45 =4-C=2B3./779 ,-75 1,/1 1,- 07/2412:: @/6 24 0366-66234 3: 1,- 6/25 03?1234 /6 34 1,- 5/1- 3: 6=21 /45 1,-?-:3?- -41217-5 13 0?31-.1234 3: ,26 0366-66234 89 @/9 3: 24<=4.1234 ,26 :24524; 34 0366-66234 :3=45-5 34 53.=>-41/?9 -B25-4.- ->/4/124; :?3> 0=872. 3::2.-6 /45 341,-07/2412::H6/00?3B-57/93=16,3@24;/..-66=0131,- -/61-?4 ?3/5 ?->/24-5 @,3779 =46,/A-4 24 .?366% -D/>24/1234
- 13 -
# 4 .341?/61 1,- 2?61 00-77/1- 3=?1 ?-B-?6-5 1,- :24524; 34 0366-66234 637-79 34 1,- 8/626 3: 1,- 5-:-45/416H 6=?B-9 6A-1.,-6 /1
D6E 13 ## @21,3=1 -D/>2424; 1,- 07/2412::H6 0?2>/?9 1217- /45 83=45/?9 53.=>-41/1
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
- 14 -
0366-66234341,-5/1-3:6=21/45241-?:-?-4.-1,-?-@21, ,/1 8=?5-4 61335 526.,/?;-5 34 1,- 61?-4;1, 3:
D& ?-/5@21,
D613$/451,-.341->03?/4-3=6?-B-4=- >/1-?2/7 ,- 5-:-45/416H 434%0?35=.1234 3: 1,-2? 6/7- 5--5 =45-?>24-6 1,-2?
07-/ 13 1,- .341?/?9 ..3?524;79 1,- 6=861/412/7 C=-61234 3: 7/@ 3# 26 /46@-?-5 24 1,- /45 6=861/412/7 C=-61234 3: 7/@ 3' 26 /46@-?-5241,-,37524;1,/11,-2?6100-77/1- 3=?1 -??-5 24 ?-B-?624; 1,- 5-.?-- 3: 24<=4.1234 ;?/41-5 891,-?2/73=?1,-?-B-?6/726B212/1-589>2652?-.1234 /450-?B-?6219/45@/??/416241-?:-?-4.- #& ,- 00-77/1- 3=?1H6 .34.7=6234 1,/1 1,- 5-:-45/416 @-?- 24 0366-66234 26 1,-?-:3?- :3=45-5 34 0?-6=>012346 .341?/?9 13 1,- -B25-412/?9 ?-.3?5 /45 52?-.179 24.346261-41 @21, 1,- /5>211-5 1303;?/0,9 ?-:7-.1-5241,-07/2412::H67/93=153.=>-416=.,/:24524;
26 >/42:-6179 0-?B-?6- 8-24; 8/6-5 34 >26?-/524; 3:
-B25-4.- 3>266234 13 .34625-? >/1-?2/7 53.=>-416 /45 24B-?62343:1,-8=?5-43:0?33:
- 15 -
#E ..3?524;791,263=?1,37561,/11,-07/2412::H6 0366-66234 3B-? 1,- 6=21 0?30-?19 24.7=524; 1,- -/61-?4 61?20 =0 131,- 366/772 ?3/5 61/456 5=79 0?3B-5 1,?3=;, D&/45/772-553.=>-416J1,-00-77/1-3=?1H6.341?/?9 :24524; 8-24; 0-?B-?6- /45 =46=61/24/87- 1,- 6/>- 5-6-?B-6138-6-1/625-/451,-?2/73=?1H6:24524;34 0366-66234@/??/416?-2461/1->-41 '( 3?1,-:3?-;324;?-/63461,263=?10/66-61,- :3773@24;
/" ,- -;=7/? -.345 00-/7 26 /773@-5 24 0/?1 8" ,- <=5;>-41 /45 5-.?-- 3: 1,- 2?61 00-77/1- 3=?1 24 3#( '(#' 26 ?-B-?6-5 346-C=-4179 1,- <=5;>-41/45 5-.?-- ?-45-?-5 89 1,- ?2/7 3=?1 24 3) '(( ;?/4124; 0-?0-1=/7 24<=4.123426/::2?>-5
- 16 -
." 28-?19 26 ?-6-?B-5 13 1,- 5-:-45/416 13 6--A/00?30?2/1-?-72-:24/>/44-?A43@4 137/@ 5" ?/@-.?--/..3?524;79
*+ '""( %
261 3)7 3#