- 1 - !"#$ %& ' !"#$ (% ) &) ) #* ) #+ , ! " $ % ® Digitally signed by NIJAMUDDIN JAMKHANDI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ) &"-& & #* % & #'+%# -"#* ' ' % ) ) & #'+%#** #* * -" , !" $ %'!$ " " +% . & ' " +% . % / ('% ) &) % ) &"-& &% ) #* , ! " $ - 3 - % ) ) & #'+%# % -)") #* ' % ) & #'+%#** -)" ) #* ' ' #* , ! " '. "% 0 &$ % '!$ " ** & & ' 0 " (+% &" ) ) - 4 - !) $ 1232 4552463 472 89 :12 4552664;: < =;3>74;?2 ?(@54;943A266434552664;:%?64=@4;:?466=;B=;C>23:=(; :12 D>EB@2;: 4;E 4A47E E4:2E ' =; " (+%54332E89:12EE6=3:7=?:4;E233=(;3 >EB2 4;E (:(7 ??=E2;: 64=@3 7=8>;46 4: 4=?1>7 !F(731(7:G:127=8>;46/$(;:12B7(>;E(F6=48=6=:943A266 43C>4;:>@ 12 E4:2 (F 4??=E2;: =;H(6H2@2;: (F H21=?62 =;D>7=233>FF272E89>7>6=;B4994472;(:=;E=35>:212 E=35>:2=3:(A47E36=48=6=:943527:124552664;:%;3>74;?2 ?(@54;9:(549:12?(@52;34:=(;(;:12B7(>;E:14::12 =;D>72E 7(E2 :12 @(:(7?9?62 =; 4 7431 4;E ;2B6=B2;: @4;;274;E7235(;3=862F(7:124??=E2;:.3(463(?466=;B=; C>23:=(;:12C>4;:>@F(7=;D>7=23=2F74?:>72(F:=8=44;E F=8>64 :12 7=8>;46 143 4A47E2E 4; 2I(78=:4;: ?(@52;34:=(; (F 3**%# 4;E :12 ?(@52;34:=(; - 5 - 4A47E2E>;E27466124E34722I:72@269(;:121=B1273=E2 4;E72C>=72372E>?:=(; ' (F4743:124552664;:%?64=@4;:=3?(;?27;2E=: =3F(7:12=;4E2C>4:2?(@52;34:=(;43:127=8>;46143;(: 57(52769 4332332E :12 E=348=6=:9 3>FF272E 89 :12 4552664;:%=;D>72E 247E 7= >E47314; 6247;2E ?(>;326 455247=;B F(7 :12 4552664;: < ;3>74;?2 ?(@54;9 =; (% 4;E @: 4:=6 14;:484= >81431 6247;2E ?(>;326 455247=;B F(7 :12 4552664;:%?64=@4;: =; ('% 1(>B1:124552664;:<=;3>74;?2?(@54;9F=62E :12455246(;:12B7(>;E(F6=48=6=:943 A26643C>4;:>@ E>7=;B:1252;E2;?9(F:124552467235(;E2;::12(A;27 (F:12H21=?62725(7:2E:(82E24E43527:12E4:2E + ;+A12;:12@4::27A436=3:2E F(7 :4J=;B 3:253 :12 4552664;: < =;3>74;?2 ?(@54;9 A43 B74;:2E4A22J/3:=@2:(:4J23:253=;72352?:(FE2?2432E - 6 - 7235(;E2;:((A2H27;(3:25314H2822;:4J2;F(7 @(72 :14; :A( @(;:13 12 @4::27 A43 4B4=; 6=3:2E (; * B74;:=;B 4 A22J/3 :=@2 :( :4J2 3:253 4;E @4::27A436=3:2E(;*3;(3:253472:4J2; (; * :1=3 (>7: 14H=;B ;( (:127 (5:=(; E=3@=332E:12455246434B4=;3::12(A;27(F:12(FF2;E=;B H21=?6243484:2E;:1232?=7?>@3:4;?23:12B7(>;E(F 6=48=6=:92H2;F(7?(;:7=8>:(79;2B6=B2;?2=3;(:4H4=64862=; :124832;?2(F547:9??(7E=;B69:12455246(;B7(>;E (F6=48=6=:9=3E=3@=332E(A2H278(:1:124552463A272 1247E(;C>4;:>@ + 7= >E47314; H212@2;:69 3>8@=::2E :14: :12 7=8>;46 143 ?(@@=::2E 327=(>3 277(7 =; :4J=;B :12 =;?(@2 4: :12 74:2 (F 3%# 527 @(;:1 =; :12 4832;?2(F57((F(F=;?(@2124??=E2;:14E(??>772E(; ' 3 527:12 147: 5725472E89:12 47;4:4J4 :4:2 2B46 27H=?23 >:1(7=:9 :12 =;?(@2 F(7 :12 9247 =3 3'%# 5@ :12 7=8>;46 143 F4=62E :( ?(;3=E27 :12 34=E 4352?: (F :12 @4::27 (A2H27 143 - 7 - :4J2; :12 =;?(@2 4: 3%# 527 @(;:1 (; :12 572@=32:14::12=;D>72E?64=@4;:=34147@4?=3:7>;;=;B 4@2E=?4631(5:14::(((;69(;:12843=3(F31(56=?2;32 =;:124832;?2(F4;9@4:27=46:(:14:2FF2?:12=;D>72E# ?64=@4;: 143 ?64=@2E =;?(@2 4: :12 74:2 (F 3 %# 527 @(;:1 A1=?1 ?(@23 :( 3 *%# 527 4;;>@ A1=?1 =3 829(;E :12 =;?(@2 :4I 3648 F=I2E F(7 :12 9247 12=;D>72E#?64=@4;:143;(:57(E>?2E4;9=;?(@2 :4I72:>7;3:(31(A1=3=;?(@2B2;274:2E5274;;>@12 7=8>;46 =; :12 4832;?2 (F 4;9 ?(B2;: 2H=E2;?2 (;69 (; :12843=3(F31(56=?2;?24;E?27:=F=?4:2=33>2EF(77>;;=;B :12147@4?9143:4J2;:12=;?(@24:3%#5@ A1=?1=3>;3>3:4=;4862=;64A4;E6=4862:(82@(E=F=2E4;E 723:7=?:2E:(3'%#43F=I2E89:12 47;4:4J4:4:2 2B4627H=?23>:1(7=:9F(7:129247 126247;2E?(>;326F>7:1273>8@=::2E:14::12 =;D>72E1433>FF272EF74?:>72(F:=8=44;EF=8>64(E(>8: 12 A43 (5274:2E :A=?2 43 :12 564:2 F=I2E :( :12 F74?:>72 3=:2 A43 87(J2; >: :12 E(?:(7 143 ?624769 3:4:2E :12 - 8 - 8724J=;B(F=@564;:=3E>2:(;2B6=B2;?2(;:12547:(F:12 =;D>72E 4;E ;(: E>2 =@57(527 F=I4:=(; 89 1=@ 12 2H=E2;?2 (F :12 E(?:(7 =3 2I:74?:2E 4: 54B2 (' (F :12 D>EB@2;:127=8>;46143:4J2;:12E=348=6=:94:K=; :124832;?2(F4;9@4:27=46:(:14:2FF2?:12E(?:(7143 3:4:2EE=348=6=:9:(:122I:2;:(F'K:(:12A1(628(E9 (A2H27 E(?:(7 143 ;(: 3:4:2E A14: =3 :12 E=348=6=:9 :( :12 547:=?>647 6=@8 3 3>?1 :12 34@2 ?(>6E ;(: 82 4332332E:(:12A1(628(E9;:1232?=7?>@3:4;?23:12 E=348=6=:9 :4J2; 4: K =3 (; 1=B127 3=E2 4;E 72C>=723 72E>?:=(; * 12 7=8>;46 143 4A47E2E 2I(78=:4;: ?(@52;34:=(; >;E27 24?1 124E 3( 463( 52;46 =;:2723: (F E26492E 549@2;: (F ?(@52;34:=(; :12 34@2 72C>=723 @(E=F=?4:=(;(76(33(F=;?(@2E>7=;B:1264=E>5527=(E :12 7=8>;46 143:4J2;3%#43 =;?(@2 527 @(;:1 4;E B74;:2E ?(@52;34:=(; F(7 4 527=(E (F @(;:13 4: :12 74:2 (F 3'%# 12 =;D>72E#?64=@4;: 3:=66 7>;;=;B:1231(54;E82=;B48>3=;233@4;:12=;D>79143 - 9 - ;(: ?(@2 =; :12 247;=;B (F :12 =;D>72E 12 6247;2E ?(>;326143463(3>8@=::2E:14::12@2E=?468=66357(E>?2E 472 ;(: 3>8@=::2E A=:1 5723?7=5:=(;3 12 7=8>;46 143 ?(;3=E272E:1234@24;E4A47E2E43>@(F3 '*%# :(A47E3 @2E=?46 2I52;323 4;E 34@2 72C>=723 72# ?(;3=E274:=(;??(7E=;B693(>B1::(466(A:124552464;E @(E=F9:1234@2A=:172352?::(:12=;D>7=233>FF272E4;E :12 ?(@52;34:=(; 2;:=:62E :( 82F=: A=:1=; :12 :27@ D>3: ?(@52;34:=(; 2F>:=;B :12 3>8@=33=(;3 (F 6247;2E ?(>;326 455247=;B F(7 :12 4552664;: < ;3>74;?2 ?(@54;9 @: 4:=6 14;:484= >81431 A=:1 466 H212@2;?2 3>8@=::2E :14: :12 =;D>72E%?64=@4;: =3 4 147@4?=3: 12 143 3>FF272E F74?:>72 :( 8(:1 8(;23 2 14E >;E27B(;2 (5274:=(; :A=?2 43 :12 =@564;:3 =;327:2E 87(J2; E>2 :( =@57(527 F=I4:=(; ?4>3=;B 54=; 4;E 4B(;9 4;E 463( F=;4;?=462I52;323F(732?(;E:=@2:(4557(4?1:121=B127 1(35=:46 F(7 F=I4:=(; (F :12 34@2 2 A43 (>: (F D(8 F(7 46@(3:(;2924712E(?:(7143?6247693:4:2EE=348=6=:9 - 10 - 3>FF272E :( :12 2;:=72 8(E9 :( :12 2I:2;: (F 'K 4;E 7=8>;46 143 F4=62E :( ?(;3=E27 :12 34@2 4;E 143 :4J2; KA1=?1(>B1::(14H2822;'K12=;?(@2(>B1: :( 14H2 822; :4J2; 4: :12 74:2 (F 3 %# 43 :12 =;D>72EA43A(7J=;B43147@43?=3:14H=;B431(54;E12 ?4;;(: 82 2C>4:2E A=:1 4; >;3J=662E 648(>7 4;E 4??(7E=;B69 3(>B1: :( 466(A :12 455246 2;14;?2 :12 ?(@52;34:=(; 4;E ?(;32C>2;:69 E=3@=33 :12 455246 F=62E 89:124552664;:<=;3>74;?2?(@54;9 4H=;B 1247E :12 6247;2E ?(>;326 F(7 :12 547:=23 527>32E :12 2;:=72 455246 545273 43 A266 43 :12 :7=46(>7:72?(7E3564?2E896247;2E?(>;326455247=;BF(7 :12 4552664;:%?64=@4;: 12 72?(7E3 564?2E 472 :12 ?27:=F=2E?(5=23(F2I1=8=:3564?2E82F(72:127=8>;4612 34@2 =3 ;(: E=35>:2E 89 :12 6247;2E ?(>;326 F(7 :12 4552664;:#=;3>74;?2 ?(@54;9 12 (;69 5(=;: :14: A(>6E 47=32F(7(>7?(;3=E274:=(;=3) &12:127:12?(@52;34:=(;4A47E2E89:12 7=8>;46 82F=: A=:1=; :12 2I57233=(; D>3: - 11 - ?(@52;34:=(; 3( 463( :12 52;46 =;:2723: E=72?:2E 89 :12 7=8>;46 =F :12 4;3A27 =3 (:127A=32 A12:1274;9=;:27F272;?24::12 14;E3 (F :1=3 (>7: =3 72C>=72E 43 527 :12 ?(;:2;:=(;3 4EH4;?2E 89 8(:1 :12 6247;2E ?(>;3263 F(7 :12 4552664;:#=;3>74;?2 ?(@54;943A26643:124552664;:#=;D>72EL >7 4;3A27 :( :12 48(H2 5(=;:3 F(7 ?(;3=E274:=(; =3 =; 547:69 4FF=7@4:=H2 4;E =; F4H(>7 (F 4552664;:#=;3>74;?2 ?(@54;9 4;E 4B4=;3: :12 ?64=@4;:# =;D>72EF(7:12F(66(A=;B) :=3;(:=;E=35>:2:14::124??=E2;:14E(??>772E=; :12 9247 3 527 :12 =;?(@2 F=I2E >;E27 :12 147: 5725472E89:12 47;4:4J4:4:22B4627H=?23>:1(7=:9 :12=;?(@2F=I2EF(74;>;3J=662E648(>7=33'%#5@ 1(>B1 :12 4552664;: 143 57(E>?2E 31(5 6=?2;?2 :( 31(A :14:12A437>;;=;B4147@4?931(54;E12=341(6E27=; =56(@4147@4?9I?25::1=3?27:=F=?4:24;E6=?2;?212 143 ;(: 57(E>?2E 4;9 E(?>@2;: :( 31(A :12 247;=;B3 - 12 - F7(@:1231(54;E3=;?212=314H=;B4147@4?931(512 143;(:57(E>?2E4;9E(?>@2;:4312=3?(@=;BA=:1=;:12 ?::(31(A:12=;?(@2B2;274:2EF7(@:1231(54;E A14::4I1214354=E:(:12(H27;@2;:4;EA14:=3:12 =;?(@2 F7(@ :12 31(5 :( 349 :12 =;?(@2 (F :12 =;D>72E# 4552664;: 14: 4547: 12 143 ;(: 57(E>?2E 4;9 =;?(@2 :4I 72:>7;3 2=:127 572H=(>3 (7 ?>772;: :( 433233 :12 =;?(@2 ; :1232 ?=7?>@3:4;?23 :12 7=8>;46 143 ?(@@=::2E 4 327=(>3 277(7 =; :4J=;B :12 =;?(@2 4: 3%# 5@ (;69 (; :12 843=3 (F ?27:=F=?4:2 (F =56(@4 4;E 31(5 6=?2;?2 : :12 H279 34@2 :=@2 =: ?4;;(:826(3:3=B1::14::12=;?(@2F=I2E>;E27:12?147: =3=;72352?:(F>;3J=662E648(>7(A2H27=;:124832;?2 (F4;9E(?>@2;::(:122FF2?::(31(A:12=;?(@2(F:12 4552664;:#=;D>72E :1=3 (>7: F2263 =: 4557(57=4:2 :( ?(;3=E27:12=;?(@24::1274:23+%#527@(;:1 3527:122H=E2;?2(F:12E(?:(7:128724J=;B (F=@564;:=3E>2:(;2B6=B2;?2(;:12547:(F:12=;D>72E 4;E ;(: E>2 :( =;4E2C>4:2 F=I4:=(; 89 :12 E(?:(7 1=3 - 13 - 3:4:2@2;: (F :12 E(?:(7 143 ;(: 822; ?14662;B2E 89 :12 =;D>72E#?64=@4;: 3 ?(>6E 82 322; F7(@ :12 72?(7E :12 2I4@=;4:=(;#=;#?1=2F (F :12 E(?:(7 143 822; 5725472E 89 :12 6247;2E ?(>;326 455247=;B F(7 :12 ?64=@4;:#=;D>72E (A2H27 :12 4;3A27 (F :12 E(?:(7 =; :12 ?7(33# 2I4@=;4:=(;B(232;:=72694B4=;3::122I4@=;4:=(;#=;#?1=2F 72B47E=;B :12 E=348=6=:9 3>FF272E 43 :12 E(?:(7 143 352?=F=?46693:4:2E:14::128724J=;B(F=@564;:3=3E>2:( ;2B6=B2;?2 (; :12 547: (F :12 =;D>72E 1=@326F (F47 43 E=348=6=:9 =3 ?(;?27;2E :12 E(?:(7 143 E=72?:69 3:4:2E 4: 'K:(:12A1(628(E9A=:1(>:3:4:=;BA14:=3:12=;D>79 3>FF272E :( :12 547:=?>647 6=@8 43 :12 =;D>79 3>FF272E 472 (;69F74?:>72(F:=8=44;EF=8>64;:1232?=7?>@3:4;?23=: 82?(@23H279147EF(7:1=3(>7::(4??25::12?(;:2;:=(; (F :12 6247;2E ?(>;326 455247=;B F(7 :12 4552664;: =; :12 455246572F2772E89:12?64=@4;::(?(;3=E27:12E=348=6=:9 4::1274:2(F'K:(:12A1(628(E93(463(:12E=348=6=:9 ?(;3=E272E89:127=8>;464:K;H=2A(F:12=;D>7=23 3>FF272E89:12=;D>72E:(8(:1:128(;23:12E=348=6=:9=3 - 14 - 723:7=?:2E :( K :( :12 A1(62 8(E9 ??(7E=;B69 :12 4@(>;:4A47E2E>;E27:12124E6(33(FF>:>72247;=;B43 A26643:12=;?(@2E>7=;B:1264=E>5527=(E72C>=72372# ?(;3=E274:=(; ' (F4743@2E=?462I52;323=3?(;?27;2EA2F=;E ;(?14662;B289:124552664;:<=;3>74;?2?(@54;9:(:12 2H=E2;?262E89:12=;D>72E<?64=@4;:H2;:1272=3;( 3>?1 E2;=46 (F @2E=?46 8=663 ; :1232 ?=7?>@3:4;?23 A2 F=;E ;( =;F=7@=:9 =; :12 4A47E 54332E 89 :12 7=8>;46 B74;:=;B@2E=?462I52;323:(:122I:2;:(F3 '*%# 1234@2=372@4=;2E=;:4?: ((J=;B :( :12 ?(@52;34:=(; 4A47E2E >;E27 24?1 124E 2I?25: @2E=?46 2I52;323 :12 34@2 322@3 :( 822I(78=:4;:?(@5472E:(:12=;D>7=233>FF272E:724:@2;: >;E27B(;2 89 :12 4552664;:#=;D>72E 12 7=8>;46 143 B74;:2E43>@(F3%#>;E27:1722E=FF272;:124E3 =2 ?(;H294;?2 ?147B23 4::2;E4;: ?147B23 4;E ;(>7=31@2;:?147B23.3%#:(A47E36(33(FF>:>72 - 15 - 4@2;=:=23. 3%# :(A47E3 F>:>72 @2E=?46 2I52;323 3%# :(A47E3 54=; 4;E 3>FF27=;B 66 :1232 ?(@52;34:=(; >;E27 :12 72352?:=H2 124E3 72C>=723 72# ?(;3=E274:=(; :=3:7=:264A:14::12?(@52;34:=(;31(>6E824 D>3:?(@52;34:=(;::1234@2:=@2=:31(>6E;(:824 8((:9(7>;D>3:2;7=?1@2;:4;E?4;;(:8245=::4;?212 (;/86252I(>7::=@24;E4B4=;143?4>:=(;2E:14::12 ?(@52;34:=(;:(824D>3:?(@52;34:=(;;2=:127@(72;(7 623327;:12?432(;14;E:12?(@52;34:=(;322@=;B69 2I(78=:4;: A12; ?(@5472E :( :12 =;D>7=23 3>FF272E 4;E :724:@2;::4J2; + 1=3 (>7: ;(:=?2E :14: =;H47=4869 =; 466 :12 ?4323 :12 7=8>;463 472 E=72?:=;B E2F4>6: =;:2723: F(7 F4=6>72:(E25(3=::124@(>;:A=:1=;4:=@28(>;E@4;;27 : :1=3 D>;?:>72 =: =3 7262H4;: :( 72F27 2?:=(; (F:12(:(7"21=?623?:**!F(731(7:G:12?:/$ A1=?13524J348(>:4A47E=;B(F=;:2723:A12724;9?64=@ - 16 - =3466(A2E(7243972F272;?22?:=(;(F:12?:=3 7257(E>?2E43>;E27) M!"#$%&'(#()'!*(#("&+,-"%.%) "--!($#&12724;964=@37=8>;46466(A34?64=@ F(7?(@52;34:=(;@4E2>;E27:1=3?:3>?17=8>;46 @49 E=72?: :14: =; 4EE=:=(; :( :12 4@(>;: (F ?(@52;34:=(; 3=@562 =;:2723: 31466 463( 82 54=E 4: 3>?1 74:2 4;E F7(@ 3>?1 E4:2 ;(: 2476=27 :14; :12 E4:2 (F @4J=;B :12 ?64=@ 43 =: @49 352?=F9 =; :1=3 82146FN * 3 527 :12 A(7E=;B3 >32E =; :12 34=E 32?:=(; :12 7=8>;46 @49 E=72?: =; 4EE=:=(; :( :12 ?(@52;34:=(; 4A47E2E 4 3=@562 =;:2723: :( 82 54=E (; 3>?1 74:2 F7(@ :12 E4:2 (F 52:=:=(; :=66 :12 34@2 =3 34:=3F=2E ;?2 :12 7=8>;46 2I27?=32E =:3 5(A27 (F 4A47E=;B =;:2723: :1272 72@4=;3 ;(:1=;B F(7 :12 7=8>;46 F(7 72:7(352?:=H2 2;14;?2@2;: (F :12 =;:2723: F(7 E2F4>6: =; 549@2;: (F ?(@52;34:=(; 12 7243(; 82=;B :12 E=3?72:=(; B74;:2E >;E27 :12 34=E 57(H=3=(; :( :12 7=8>;46 F(7 4A47E=;B =;:2723:(;:12?64=@A12;=:=3466(A2E4;E(;?22I27?=32E ?4;;(:72H=3=::1234@2:?4;;(:826(3:3=B1::14::12 - 17 - E=3?72:=(; =3 46A493 ?(>562E A=:1 E>:=23 12 A(7E G@49/ >32E=;:1232?:=(;3>BB23:34E=3?72:=(;12E=3?72:=(; B74;:2E >;E27 4;9 57(H=3=(; =3 (;69 A=:1 72352?: :( A12:127 :( 2I27?=32 :12 5(A27 =; :12 @4;;27 J;(A; :( 64A>:=:?4;;(:82=;:2;E2E:(3>BB23:43:(:12@(E23 :(2I27?=3243:12E=3?72:=(;43527:12A(7E3>32E=;:12 34=E32?:=(;E(;(:483(6>:212A(7E3>32E=;:1232?:=(; ?6247693>BB23::14::127=8>;46@49E=72?:=;4EE=:=(;:( :12 ?(@52;34:=(; 3=@562 =;:2723: 5494862 4: 3>?1 74:2 A127243:1272=3;(E=3?72:=(;?(;:4=;2E=;:1257(H=3=(; :(4A47E52;46=;:2723:&2F226:14::1234=E2I27?=3289 :12 7=8>;46 =3 4B4=;3: :12 H279 57(H=3=(; 4;E >;3>3:4=;486212E=3?72:=(;:(822I27?=32E31466;(:82 478=:74798>:B>=E2E89D>E=?=4657=;?=56234;E31(>6E824 D>E=?=46 E=3?72:=(; 12 7=8>;46 A1=62 2I27?=3=;B D>E=?=46 F>;?:=(;8246A493J225=;@=;E:12D>7=3E=?:=(;57=;?=5623 43 :12 E=3?72:=(; =; 2?:=(; (F :12 2A ?: =3 ;(: 483(6>:24;E=F4;9H=(64:=(;4@(>;:3:(478=:74792I27?=32 (F :12 34=E D>7=3E=?:=(; 4@2;4862 F(7 D>E=?=46 72H=2A ; - 18 - :1232 ?=7?>@3:4;?23 A12; :12 57(H=3=(; B74;:3 4 E=3?72:=(;A2F226=:4557(57=4:2:(1(6E:14::12E=3?72:=(; =3 4 D>E=?=46 E=3?72:=(; 4;E =: =3 :( 82 2I27?=32E =; 4 D>E=?=(>3 @4;;27 4;E ;(: 4??(7E=;B :( :12 A1=@3 4;E F4;?=23(F:125273(;2I27?=3=;B:1234@2 127=8>;46=;:12?432(;14;E1434A47E2E 3=@562 =;:2723: 4: :12 74:2 (F +K 527 4;;>@ (; :12 ?(@52;34:=(;:(824A47E2E(A2H27F>7:127(8327H2E :14:=;:122H2;::12?(@52;34:=(;=3;(:E25(3=:2EA=:1=; :A(@(;:13F7(@:12E4:2(F(7E27F>:>72=;:2723:3146682 4::1274:2(FK5274;;>@F7(@:12E4:2(FE2F4>6:3 3:4:2E48(H2(;?2:12E=3?72:=(;=32I27?=32E:1272=3;( 5(A27 >;E27 2?:=(; (F :12 ?: A1=?1 2;48623 :12 7=8>;46:(2I27?=32:125(A27:((7E27F(7E2F4>6:=;:2723: >7H=2AB4=;33:72;B:1F7(@:1264A64=EE(A; 89 :12 (;/862 52I (>7: =; :12 ?432 (F !" #$%&$!! - 19 - '$12(;/86252I(>7:4:5474B7451(3*:(' A1=6272F277=;B:(:12273:A1=622?:=(;#(F:12?: !?(77235(;E=;B :( 2?:=(; (F :12 ;2A ?:$ 126E :14: (;?2:12E=3?72:=(;143822;2I27?=32E89:127=8>;46:( 4A47E 3=@562 =;:2723: (; :12 4@(>;: (F ?(@52;34:=(; :( 824A47E2E4:4547:=?>64774:24;EF7(@4547:=?>647E4:2 :1272 =3 ;( 4A47E F(7 72:7(352?:=H2 2;14;?2@2;: F(7 E2F4>6: =; 549@2;: (F ?(@52;34:=(; ( 2I57233 (7 =@56=2E5(A27=;:1=372B47E?4;82?>662E(>:F7(@2?:=(; # (F :12 ?: (7 2?:=(; (F :12 2A ?: 12 (;/862 52I (>7: =; :12 4F(7234=E D>EB@2;: 2352?=4669 4: 5474B7451 ( 2I564=;2E :12 A(7E ME=3?72:=(;N 72F277=;B:(D>EB@2;:=;=;E3(;4;E 27329=;:12A(7E3 (F(7E4@E2;M 1 !"#$$%& 2 '() ")*#+& - 20 - N(7243972F272;?2A27257(E>?25474B7451(3* :('A1=?1724E343F(66(A3) ,( -+ . * $ # # '' /$$ 0 # '&' 1 2 0 '3)) , 0 4" 5 . # '' 0 # '(( 0 # %! $ $ 6 '3 ) ,$6$4" . 7 5 ,4 . 8 $ 8$ 9 : ;5<')) "+0$'!=!389>:+&&= !8+!(*8"?= ,: - 21 - 5 5 4 . $ #$ 6 @ : <'3+'#$$' ))=0- '3+#$'(? #6@A <'3)' # #$$ )& = 0- '3) #$ '!3? " *B 8 7 ! 7 2 = ,)C DEEE 0 = . 5 . 1 5 5 C 4 ) C . F - 22 - 0 5 6 8*8$ #F <')3'0$ '&% = '))(/3 " 0 7- - (+' *8"? " 0 #@ 9 A <0- '3(& #$ '!&? , 4 5 , 4 8 $ 8$9 * G <'() ")*#+&? 5 5 - 23 - # 5 F F 9 8 : - $ <')&'" ( $6 +&( = ! 8 )&? 1 1 <')(3"'6H1(!!?" # '' /$$ 0 # '&' 0 " 5 ; 5 I 5 # '' /$$ 0 # '&' 0 # * $ 4 - 24 - ; H=2A (F :12 64A 64=E E(A; 89 :12 (;/862 52I (>7: (; 52;46:9 =;:2723: 4;E F(7 :12 48(H2 E=3?>33=(; :12 E=72?:=(; (F 52;46 =;:2723: =2 E2F4>6: =;:2723: =3 >;3>3:4=;4862 =; 64A 4??(7E=;B69 34@2 =3 32: 43=E2 3 3:4:2E =; :12 F(72B(=;B 5474B74513 (; 72# ?(;3=E274:=(; 4;E 72#E2:27@=;4:=(; :12 ?(@52;34:=(; A(7J3(>:43>;E27) ("$),./(&)"'%& .0&' 4=;4;E3>FF27=;B 3 %# 2E=?462I52;323 3 '*%# (;H294;?2?147B23 ::2;E4;:/3?147B23 (>7=31@2;: 3 %# (33 (F =;?(@2 E>7=;B 64=E >5 527=(E !3+I $ + %# (33 (F =;?(@2 E>2 :( E=348=6=:9 %# - 25 - 3+II'I% (33(FF>:>724@2;=:=23=;6=F2 %# >:>72@2E=?462I52;323 '%# ) 1123 ' 12 :(:46 ?(@52;34:=(; 72#E2:27@=;2E 89 :1=3 (>7: A(7J3 (>: :( 3+'%# 43 4B4=;3: 3**%# 4A47E2E 89 :12 7=8>;46 46(;B A=:1 =;:2723: 4: +K 527 4;;>@ F7(@ :12 E4:2 (F F=6=;B (F :12 52:=:=(;:=667246=O4:=(; (7:12F(72B(=;B7243(;3A24;3A27:125(=;: 74=32E F(7 ?(;3=E274:=(; 4;E A2 57(?22E :( 5433 :12 F(66(A=;B) =$ 12455246=;('% F=62E89 :124552664;:%=;D>72E=3127289E=3@=332E43 34;3@27=:. - 26 - ==$ 12455246=;(% F=62E89 :124552664;:%=;3>74;?2?(@54;9=3466(A2E =;547: ===$ 12 D>EB@2;: 4;E 4A47E 54332E 89 :12 7=8>;46 =; 4A47E E4:2E ' =; " (+% 54332E 89 :12 EE6 =3:7=?: 4;E 233=(;3 >EB2 4;E 4=?1>7=3@(E=F=2E4;E72E>?2E. =H$ 12?(@52;34:=(;4A47E2E89:127=8>;46 F7(@ 3**%# =3 72E>?2E :( 3+'%# 12 72#E2:27@=;2E ?(@52;34:=(; 31466 ?4779 =;:2723: 4: :12 74:2 (F +K 527 4;;>@ F7(@ :12 E4:2 (F F=6=;B(F:1252:=:=(;:=667246=O4:=(;. H$ 12 4@(>;: =; E25(3=: 82F(72 :1=3 (>7: 31466 82 :74;3@=::2E 82F(72 :12 ?(;?27;2E 7=8>;46F(7E=38>732@2;:F(7:1A=:1 - 27 - H=$ 12 8464;?2 72#E2:27@=;2E ?(@52;34:=(; 4@(>;: 82 E25(3=:2E 46(;B A=:1 4??7>2E =;:2723: 89 :12 4552664;: < =;3>74;?2 ?(@54;9 82F(72 :12 ?(;?27;2E 7=8>;46 A=:1=;3=IA22J3F7(@:12E4:2(F72?2=5:(F ?(59(F:1=3(7E27 H==$ F4;94@(>;:=3E25(3=:2EA1=62(8:4=;=;B =;:27=@ (7E27 4;E :12 34@2 =3 =; 2I?233 :14;:124@(>;:72#E2:27@=;2E:122I?233 4@(>;: =F 4;9 4F:27 4ED>3:=;B :( :12 72# E2:27@=;2E ?(@52;34:=(; 46(;B A=:1 4??7>2E =;:2723: 82 72:>7;2E :( :12 4552664;: < =;3>74;?2 ?(@54;9 (; 57(527 =E2;:=F=?4:=(; ; :12 2H2;: :12 4@(>;: E25(3=:2E F4663 31(7: :( :12 4@(>;: 72# E2:27@=;2E 46(;B A=:1 4??7>2E =;:2723: 8464;?28254=E433:4:2E3>574 - 28 - H===$ 2B47E=;B:12E25(3=:43A266437262432=3 43527:12(7E2754332E89:127=8>;46 =I$ 2B=3:79=3127289E=72?:2E:(=7?>64:2:12 ?(59 (F :1=3 D>EB@2;: (; 466 :12 (:(7 ??=E2;:64=@37=8>;463=;:12:4:2(;69 (;:125(=;:(FE2F4>6:=;:2723:=;:27@3(F 64A 64=E E(A; 89 :12 (;/862 52I (>7: 72F2772E :( 48(H2 4;E :12 (8327H4:=(;3 @4E21272=;48(H2 I$ ((7E2743:(?(3: $3 45 6 $3 46 =3:()6()+ )