Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 65910 (KAR)

ANJALI D/O PANDURANG @ PANDU KSHATRI v. THE DIVISIONAL CONTROLLER

MFA/201284/2021 · 2025-08-29

Shivashankar Amarannavar

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - ! "# $ $ %% &$' ( ! "# # $ ! "#% % $ %& & '("$ & % ) % % % #% & %) ( * # & %%#%+ % &, Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - %& % & %) % -#% % # ./0122314/05/436789.31223441:9;41/<1:9033=/:> 3:.1:;3<3:9 ?5 ;?<23:019/?: 1@1A636 /: 9.3 BC6><3:9 1:6 1@1A6 61936 ( * 210036 /: % ? 789.366/9/?:143:/?A/D/4C6>31:6 9.3%3<73A%?9?A;;/63:941/<0A/7C:14+/B1812CA &1;90 4316/:> 9? 5/4/:> ?5 9.3 ;41/< 239/9/?: 1A3 10C:63A .19 ?: 19 17?C9 +( .?CA0 :31A #1::/;A?00?:E141=/+?A9/A?169.363;31036 1:6CA1:> 14?:> @/9. 9.3 1223441:9;41/<1:9 @3A3 A/6/:> 9.3 <?9?A;8;43 731A/:> A3>/09A19/?: ? + +*'' >?/:> 9?@1A60 E141=/ 5A?< ?A9/ 0/63 ).3: 9.38 ;1<3 :31A #1::/ ;A?00 ?: E141=/+?A9/ A?16 19 9.19 9/<3 9.3 - 3 - 1A:191=1 9193 ?16 A1:02?A9 ?A2?A19/?: #C0 731A/:> A3>/09A19/?:? +&+'*6A/D3:78/906A/D3A/:1./>. 02336 1:6 /: 1 A10. 1:6 :3>4/>3:9 <1::3A ;1<3 5A?< ?22?0/930/631:69.36A/D3A?59.301/67C0@10C:17439? ;?:9A?4 ?D3A 9.3 7C0 610.36 1>1/:09 9.3 <?9?A;8;43 A30C49/:>/:9.31;;/63:9 1:6CA1:>6/36?:9.302?91:6 9.3239/9/?:3A:B14/9.32/44/?:A/63A?59.37/=3@.?/09.3 61C>.93A ?5 9.3 63;31036 1:6CA1:> 0C091/:36 /:BCA/30 .3 A/7C:14 1593A A3;?A6/:> 3D/63:;3 .10 10030036 ;?<23:019/?:1:61@1A6360 (+@/9./:93A30919 9.3 A193 ?5 F 23A 1::C< .3 239/9/?:3A 73/:> :?9 019/05/36 @/9. 9.3 1@1A6 ?5 ;?<23:019/?: 78 9.3 A/7C:14 .105/4369./0122314033=/:>3:.1:;3<3:9 ( 31A69.3431A:36;?C:0345?A9.31223441:91:6 431A:36;?C:0345?A9.3A302?:63:9;?A2?A19/?: G 31A:36 ;?C:034 5?A 9.3 1223441:9 @?C46 ;?:93:6 9.19 9.3 1223441:9;41/<1:9 6C3 9? 9.3 1;;/63:9 0C091/:366/017/4/98C29?F9?(F1:60.3@101>36 - 4 - G 831A0 10 ?: 9.3 6193 ?5 9.3 1;;/63:9 1:6 ;?:0/63A/:> 9.3 63;/0/?: ?5 9.3 ?:H743 23I ?CA9 /: 9.3 ;103 ?5 A32?A936 /: !"#$%& $% ' ()* 9.3 ;?<23:019/?: A3JC/A30 9? 73 3:.1:;36 3 5CA9.3A 0C7</90 9.19 9.3 1223441:9;41/<1:9 0C091/:36 /:BCA/30 1:6 16</9936 /: .?02/9145?A5?CA933:6180 3:;3?:3?59.321A3:909??= ;1A3 ?5 9.3 /:BCA365?A @./;. 9.38 4?09/:;?<3 5?A9.A33 <?:9.0 35CA9.3A0C7</909.19/: + ;1039.31;;/63:9.1091=3:241;3/:9.3831A1:6/: 9.32A303:9;1039.31;;/63:9.1091=3:241;3/:9.3831A 1:69.3A3/01>12?593:831A09.3A35?A330;1419/?: 19FA3JC/A309?731@1A636 31A:36;?C:0345?A9.3A302?:63:9;?A2?A19/?: @?C46 ;?:93:6 9.19 9.3 ;?<23:019/?: 1@1A636 78 9.3 A/7C:14 /0 BC09 1:6 2A?23A 1:6 9.3A3 1A3 :? >A?C:60 5?A 3:.1:;3<3:9?5;?<23:019/?: - 5 - 1D/:> .31A6 9.3 431A:36 ;?C:034 5?A 9.3 21A9/30 9./0 ?CA9 23AC036 9.3 /<2C>:36 BC6><3:9 1:6 ?9.3A<193A/14241;36?:A3;?A6 ' .3 1;;/63:9 .10 91=3: 241;3 ?: 1:6 19 9.3 9/<3 ?5 9.3 1;;/63:9 9.3 1223441:9;41/<1:9 @10 1>36 G 831A0 .3 6/017/4/98 0C091/:36 78 9.3 1223441:9;41/<1:9 /0 F 9? (F 0 9.3 1223441:9 .10 0C091/:36 6/017/4/98 <?A3 9.1: F 1:6 @/9./: (F 9.3 ;41/<1:9 /0 3:9/9436 9? ;?<23:019/?: ?5 0 (+ 5?A 21/:1:60C553A/:>14A3168C:63A>?:31:69?730C553A36/: 5C9CA3 <3:914 1:6 2.80/;14 0.?;= .1A60./2 /:;?:D3:/3:;31:66/0;?<5?A9039; 1:64?00?51<3:/9/30 /: 4/53 ?: 1;;?C:9 ?5 23A<1:3:9 6/017/4/98 : +;1039.31;;/63:9.10?;;CAA36/:9.3831A 1:6/:9.32A303:9;1039.31;;/63:9.1091=3:241;3 /:9.3831A .3A35?A3/9/0122A?2A/1939?166F 30;1419/?: 9? 9.3 01/6 0 (+ 3:;3 9.3 1223441:9;41/<1:9 /0 3:9/9436 9? 0 (+ "0 (+IFK0 +$ - 6 - .3;41/<1:9.10733:16</9936/:9.3.?02/914 5?A5?CA933:61801:60C091/:365A1;9CA3?54359;41D/;431:6 A/>.9 53<CA 6/55/;C498 /: 0JC199/:> 0/99/:> ;A?00 43> 1:6 =:334/:> ?: A/>.9 4?@3A 4/<7 <?D3<3:9 ?5 A/>.9 ./2 1:6 =:33 1A3 21/:5C4 1:6 A309A/;936 :3 ?5 9.3 21A3:90 .10 4?09./0/:;?<35?A123A/?6?59.A33<?9.05?A91=/:>;1A3 ?59.31223441:9;41/<1:9@.?@10</:?A1>36G831A0 .3A35?A3 9.3 1223441:9;41/<1:9 /0 3:9/9436 9? ;?<23:019/?: /: 1 0C< ?5 0 G+ "0 + I ( <?:9.0$ 9?@1A60 6/0;?<5?A9 /:;?:D3:/3:;3 1:6 4?00 ?5 31A:/:>0 9? 9.3 21A3:90 6CA/:> 9.3 23A/?6 ?5 .?02/914/L19/?: .3 A/7C:14 .10 A/>.948 1@1A636 <36/;14 3I23:030/:10C<?50 + * :D/3@?59.317?D39.3;41/<1:9/03:9/94365?A 9?914;?<23:019/?:10C:63A 316 ?<23:019/?:<?C:9 1/: 1:6 0C553A/:> 14A3168 C:63A>?:3 1:6 9? 73 0C553A36 /: 5C9CA3 <3:914 1:6 2.80/;14 0.?;= .1A60./2 /:;?:D3:/3:;3 1:6 6/0;?<5?A90 39; 1:6 4?00 ?5 1<3:/9/30 /: 4/53 ?: 1;;?C:9 ?5 23A<1:3:96/017/4/98 0 (+ "0 (MF$ - 7 - /0;?<5?A9 /:;?:D3:/3:;3 1:6 4?00 ?531A:/:>09?9.321A3:906CA/:>9.3 23A/?6?5.?02/914/L19/?: 0 G+ %36/;143I23:030 0 + )*+ ,- . :D/3@?59.317?D39.31223441:9;41/<1:9/0 3:9/94365?A9?914;?<23:019/?:?50 (G+101>1/:09 0 (+1@1A636789.3A/7C:14 :D/3@?59.317?D39.35?44?@/:> "$ .3 %/0;3441:3?C0 &/A09 22314 /0 144?@36 /: 21A9 "$ .3 1223441:9;41/<1:9 /0 3:9/9436 5?A 9?914 ;?<23:019/?: ?5 0 (G+ 14?:> @/9. /:93A309199.3A193?5F23A1::C<5A?<9.3 6193?5239/9/?:9/44A314/L19/?: "($ .3 A302?:63:9;?A2?A19/?: 0.144 632?0/9 9.3 3:9/A3 ;?<23:019/?: 1<?C:9 735?A3 9.3 A/7C:14@/9./:0/I@33=05A?<9./061851/4/:> - 8 - @./;. /9 /0 4/1743 9? 218 /:93A309 19 *F 23A 1::C< "G$ 0 9.3 1223441:9;41/<1:9 .10 :?@ 1991/:36 9.3 1>3 ?5 <1B?A/98 0.3 /0 3:9/9436 9? >39 A343103?59.33:9/A31<?C:9?5;?<23:019/?: "$ .3 1223441:9;41/<1:9 /0 :?9 3:9/9436 9? /:93A309?:9.33:.1:;36;?<23:019/?:5?A9.3 63418 23A/?6 ?5 '( 6180 /: 5/4/:> 9.3 122314 "1023A9.3?A63A61936 $ Sd/- & $ $' # /09? 4?