- 1 - ! " #$!# " %!&$"&&&' %!&"$""&! (") ! " #$ % & ' ( $ ) )' ( #* $ % ) Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - #* $ #* $ ' ( & ' )$+%, )( ) %%* + %%-) ) ) . /%% $/ % %% %% 0# . ) $ $% $* -% $/0##* )1 . ) % -% % ) ) 2 1 3 2 1 - 3 - * ' 2 1 ( 4 567 897:745 ;9<5 875<5<=4 567 875<5<=479 6>: ?6>@@74A7B 567 =9B79 B>57B % %% %% <4 88@<?>5<=4 =/%% $/ 8>::7B CD 567 >94>5>E> 5>57 BF<4<:59>5<G79<CH4>@>5>@>CH9>A<'6797<4>I57997I7997B 5= >: J9<CH4>@K I=9 :6=95( ;6797CD 567 875<5<=479K: >88@<?>5<=4?6>@@74A<4A567=9B79B>57B -% $/8>::7B CD 97:8=4B745 =$ 5>57 <F8=:<4A 567 874>@5D =I ?=F8H@:=9D975<97F745=46<F;>:97L7?57B % +,- ./01 67 >88@<?>45 '875<5<=479( ;6<@7 :79G<4A>:>>44>B> 7?5H979>5567)<9:59>B7=@@7A7 >:>G>E>@D>4> <:59<?5 <B>9 ;>: :HCL7?57B 5= B78>95F745>@74MH<9D<4<5<>57BCD567 =E>DHE5>C>:7B=4 > ?=F8@><45 I<@7B CD 6<: ;<I7 =47 F5 >G<569>F> 67 ?=F8@><4>45 >@@7A7B 56>5 567 875<5<=479 6>B ?=459>?57B > :7?=4BF>99<>A7;<56=4791>D>B7G<><E;>BBH9<4A 567:HC:<:574?7=I6<:I<9:5F>99<>A75;>:IH95679>@@7A7B 56>5 <4 567 :?6==@ 97?=9B: =I 567 ?6<@B974 C=94 I9=F 567 - 4 - :7?=4B F>99<>A7 567<9 ?>:57 ;>: 745797B >: J=@7D>K <4:57>B=IJH9HC>K;6<?6<:567875<5<=4792:?>:57 H9:H>45 5= 567 ?=F8@><45 B78>95F745>@ 74MH<9D;>:?=4BH?57B674MH<9DII<?79:HCF<557B6<: 978=956=@B<4A567875<5<=479AH<@5D=I?6>9A7:67:>F7 ;>:I=9;>9B7B5=567 =E>DHE5>67 =E>DHE5>I=9;>9B7B 567 978=95 ;<56 <5: 97?=FF74B>5<=4: 5= 567 5>57 =G794F745 5= <F8=:7 567 874>@5D =I ?=F8H@:=9D 975<97F745 I9=F :79G<?7 7:8=4B745 =$ 5>57 H8=4 97?7<G<4A567978=95<::H7B>:7?=4B:6=;?>H:74=5<?75= 567 875<5<=479 :77E<4A 6<: 7N8@>4>5<=4 67 7N8@>4>5<=4 :HCF<557BCD567875<5<=479;>:4=5>??785>C@7874>@5D=I ?=F8H@:=9D975<97F745;>:<F8=:7B=46<FAA9<7G7BCD 567 :><B =9B79 567 875<5<=479 I<@7B >88@<?>5<=4 C7I=97 567 9<CH4>@ 9><:<4A G>9<=H: A9=H4B: =;7G79 567 9<CH4>@ CD567<F8HA47B=9B7997L7?57B567>88@<?>5<=4 7>9B 567 @7>947B ?=H4:7@ >887>9<4A I=9 567 8>95<7:>4B879H:7B567F>579<>@=497?=9B - 5 - 67@7>947B?=H4:7@>887>9<4AI=9567875<5<=479 :HCF<5: 56>5 567 ?=F8@><45 <4 MH7:5<=4 8795><4: 5= >4 >@@7A7B>?5=IC<A>FD;6<?6;=H@BI>@@H4B79567>FC<5=I 7?5<=4/=I5674B<>4 74>@=B7$* ' (;6<?6<: ;<56<4 567 LH9<:B<?5<=4 =I 9<F<4>@ =H95 5 <: ?=4574B7B 56>547<5679567 =E>DHE5>4=9567B<:?<8@<4>9D>H56=9<5D<: ?=F8757455=>BLHB<?>57H8=4567<::H7=IC<A>FD569=HA6 B78>95F745>@89=?77B<4A:>::H?6F>5579:@<77N?@H:<G7@D ;<56<4567LH9<:B<?5<=4=I5679<F<4>@=H95:5<:>9AH7B 56>5567<F8=:<5<=4=I>874>@5D=I?=F8H@:=9D975<97F745 <: @7A>@@D H4:H:5><4>C@7 ;6<?6 >:87?5 ;>: I><@7B 5= C7 ?=4:<B797BCD5679<CH4>@ * 5<:IH95679>9AH7B56>5567<F8HA47B=9B79=I <F8=:<4A 567 874>@5D =I ?=F8H@:=9D 975<97F745 <: I@>;7B 7<567956774MH<9D978=954=956797?=FF74B>5<=4=I567 =E>DHE56> 4=9 567 9<CH4>@ <4 <5: =9B79 6>: ?6>9>?579<O7B 567 >@@7A7B ?=4BH?5 >: !9>G7 <:?=4BH?5" ;6<?6 <: > 47?7::>9D 897?=4B<5<=4 I=9 ;<566=@B<4A 567 874:<=4>9D C747I<5: 4 :H88=95 =I 6<: :HCF<::<=4: - 6 - 97@<>4?7<:8@>?7B=4567B7?<:<=4=I56787N=H95<4567 ?>:7 =I ;6797<4 <5 ;>: 67@B 56>5 <4 567 >C:74?7 =I > !9>G7 <:?=4BH?5" =G794F745 7F8@=D77 :6=H@BC7879F<557B5=975<97G=@H45>9<@D;<56=H5I>?<4A>4D :5<AF> =9 I=9I7<5H97 =I :79G<?7 C747I<5: 5 ;>: :HCF<557B 56>5 567 874>@5D =I ?=F8H@:=9D 975<97F745 >F=H45: 5= :5<AF> >4B B789<G7: 567 875<5<=479 =I 6<: 9<A65IH@ :79G<?7 C747I<5: - 7>947B?=H4:7@>887>9<4AI=956797:8=4B745: 5>57 >4B 567 =E>DHE5> ;=H@B :HCF<5 56>5 567 B78>95F745>@ 74MH<9D <4<5<>57B <: <4 >??=9B>4?7 ;<56 @>; ;6<?6 9><:7B :79<=H: >@@7A>5<=4 =I F<:?=4BH?5 >A><4:5 567 875<5<=479 5 <: ?=4574B7B 56>5 74579<4A <45= 567 :7?=4B F>99<>A7BH9<4A567:HC:<:574?7=I567I<9:5F>99<>A77G74 <I <5 9><:7: <::H7 H4B79 567 ?9<F<4>@ @>; >@:= >F=H45 5= F<:?=4BH?5H4B79567:79G<?7@>;F=978>95<?H@>9@DH4B79 H@7 % =I 567 >94>5>E> <G<@ 79G<?7: '=4BH?5( H@7: 1 - 7 - $/**'J=4BH?5H@7:$/**KI=9:6=95(5<:>9AH7B56>5 567 4MH<9D II<?79 >I579 >8897?<>5<4A 567 F>579<>@ =4 97?=9B I=H4B 567 875<5<=479 AH<@5D =I F<:?=4BH?5 67 <F8=:<5<=4=I874>@5D=I?=F8H@:=9D975<97F745<:LH:5>4B 89=8795=567F<:?=4BH?57:5>C@<:67B>4BB=7:4=5:HII79 I9=F>4D@7A>@<4I<9F<5D >G<4A67>9B567@7>947B?=H4:7@>887>9<4AI=9 5678>95<7:5678=<4556>5>9<:7:I=9?=4:<B79>5<=4<: 675679567B<:?<8@<4>9D 89=?77B<4A:<4<5<>57B >A><4:5567875<5<=479?H@F<4>5<4A<4567<F8=:<5<=4 =I874>@5D=I?=F8H@:=9D975<97F745C>:7B=4567 >@@7A>5<=4 =I C<A>FD >4B ?>:57 F<:97897:745>5<=4 ;=H@B ?=4:5<5H57 !A9>G7 F<:?=4BH?5" H4B79 567 >88@<?>C@7 79G<?7H@7:P / 67?6>9A7:@7G7@7B>A><4:5567875<5<=479;797 5;=I=@B <( 56>5 BH9<4A 567 :HC:<:574?7 =I 567 F>99<>A7 ;<56 567 ?=F8@><4>45 567 875<5<=479 ?=459>?57B > :7?=4B F>99<>A7 ;<56 =47 9 1>D>B7G< ><E;>B 56797CD - 8 - G<=@>5<4AH@7%=I567=4BH?5H@7:$/**<<(;6<@7567 875<5<=479C7@=4A:5=567!H9HC>"?=FFH4<5D567:?6==@ 97?=9B: =I 567 ?6<@B974 C=94 =H5 =I 567 :7?=4B F>99<>A7 97I@7?5 567<9 ?>:57 >: !=@7D>" ':?67BH@7 ?>:57( ;6<?6 >F=H45:5=IH94<:6<4AI>@:7<4I=9F>5<=45=567=G794F745 I=9:7?H9<4AC747I<5:6774MH<9D?=4BH?57B67@B56>5567 875<5<=479 6>: ?=FF<557B F<:?=4BH?5 CD ?=459>?5<4A > :7?=4BF>99<>A7BH9<4A567:HC:<:574?7=I567I<9:5>4BCD F<:97897:745>5<4A?>:57B75><@:<4567=II<?<>@97?=9BH@7 %=I=4BH?5H@7:$/**97>B:>:H4B79 ! " " ! # $! %! #" #$&# ! $ #% $! "$ ' $ = 567 >9AHF745 >BG>4?7B CD 567 @7>947B ?=H4:7@ I=9 567 875<5<=479 56>5 567 =E>DHE5> >4B 567 - 9 - B<:?<8@<4>9D >H56=9<5D @>?E 567 LH9<:B<?5<=4 5= >BLHB<?>57 H8=4 567 MH7:5<=4 =I $!( <4 > B78>95F745>@ 89=?77B<4A:<5;=H@BC797@7G>455=8@>?7567B7?<:<=4=I 56787N=H95<4567?>:7=I ) ;6797<4 567 87N=H95=C:79G7B56>5!% ( ( %$ % )! *# +, %#"*# - ..-" $% (! " % # ">4B! # *# +,-#" " % % # % " " $!(#% " /0( $!-$" (">4B 567 ?=45745<=4 =I ?6>9A7 =I C<A>FD ?>44=5 C7 :HCL7?5 5= B78>95F745>@ >BLHB<?>5<=4 ;>: 97L7?57B >4B <4G=?>5<=4 =I H@7 % =I 567 =4BH?5 H@7: $/** CD 567 <:?<8@<4>9D H56=9<5D ;>: H867@B >4B 67@B G>@<B >4B 879F<::<C@7 <4 @>;67>:87?5=IC<A>FD6>:C7749<A65@D?=4:<B797BCD 5679<CH4>@<4@<47;<56567>88@<?>C@7 79G<?7H@7:>4B 2 ( ..11 - 10 - 567 B7?<:<=4 =I 567 87N =H95 <4 567 ?>:7 =I :5>57B# $$ 67=5679?=45745<=49><:7BCD567875<5<=479<: 56>5567F<:?=4BH?5I=9;6<?6567875<5<=479<:I=H4BAH<@5D B=7: 4=5 >F=H45 5= A9>G7 F<:?=4BH?5 >: B7I<47B H4B79 H@7%$=I567>94>5>E><G<@ 79G<?7:H@7:'I=9:6=95 J H@7:K(>4B56>567<:56797I=97745<5@7B5=97?7<G7IH@@ :79G<?7C747I<5:<4?@HB<4A874:<=4879H:>@=I56774MH<9D 978=95 567 97?=FF74B>5<=4 =I 567 =E>DHE5> >4B 567 <F8HA47B=9B798>::7BCD5679<CH4>@97G7>@:56>556797 <:4=7N897::I<4B<4AB7?@>9<4A567875<5<=479K:?=4BH?5>: !A9>G7F<:?=4BH?5" $% 67 !A9>G7 F<:?=4BH?5" <: B7I<47B <4 N8@>4>5<=4 >8874B7B 5= H@7 %$ =I H@7: ;6<?6 97>B:>:H4B79 !222222 "#$ 3 / # - 2 4 #" 4" #%" ! " #% 5" " 6"- + 6" +-%2 - 11 - 4 %%4 " #% " #" %" # ( " " " % % ()"- - % - " - -% "# #" %" 1 % 6" " $% %! " #% 7#%" ( " ! #$ " "# ( ' $ 5 <: 7G<B745 I9=F 567 N8@>4>5<=4 H4B79 H@7 %$ =I H@7: 56>5 567 579F !A9>G7 F<:?=4BH?5" <: 97:79G7BI=9=II74?7:=I>:79<=H:4>5H97:H?6>:C97>?67: =I ?=4I<B745<>@<5D H4B79 567 II<?<>@ 7?975: ?5 $/% =9 7MH<G>@745 F<:?=4BH?5 <4G=@G<4A B<:6=47:5D =9 :7?H9<5D 9<:E: $ H@7 %$ =I 567 H@7: IH95679 :5>57: >: H4B79 8 6 " # ( % " ( ( $ ! % $( # ( " #" (- % % % # % %$ % " # ( - 12 - &' ( 9 - ( " # ( % # % % ( $ ! % # % % "#* #(-(-%$ % " # ( : - - " "#" "# " - # (- " ( " # ( - ( #$7" % *! 6# (- ) #" %#" ( $ " $%- ( ) 6 %#" ($% "#* #( 0 $ ;9 %#" $% $ # (< &')(0 ($ # =% % ( " # ( %#% # - %!- -* % #%<' $ 6H: H4B79 H@7 %$ 567 ?=4B<5<=4 897?7B745 I=9 ;<566=@B<4A =9 97BH?<4A 874:<=4 <: 56>5 567 =G794F745:79G>45FH:56>G7C774I=H4BAH<@5D=IA9>G7 F<:?=4BH?5 =9 ?=4G<?57B =I > :79<=H: ?9<F7 BH9<4A 6<: :79G<?7 F8=95>45@D <4 567 897:745 ?>:7 56797 <: 4= I<4B<4A7<5679<456774MH<9D978=9556797?=FF74B>5<=4=I - 13 - 567 =E>DHE5>=95679<CH4>@2:B7?<:<=47N897::@D6=@B<4A 56>5567F<:?=4BH?5=I567875<5<=479;>:A9>G7<44>5H97 $* 67 87N =H95 <4 567 ?>:7 =I :5>57B # 6>: ?>57A=9<?>@@D 67@B 56>5 567 ?=4B<5<=4 897?7B745 I=9 B74D<4A 874:<=4>9D C747I<5: <: 56>5 > ?@7>9 I<4B<4A FH:5 C7 97?=9B7B 7<5679 <4 567 B78>95F745>@ 74MH<9D=9<4567 LHB<?<>@89=?77B<4A:56>5567874:<=479 ;>:AH<@5D=I!A9>G7F<:?=4BH?5"=9!A9=::47A@<A74?7"<4 B<:?6>9A7 =I 6<: =II<?<>@ BH5<7: 4 567 >C:74?7 =I :H?6 I<4B<4A 567 >H56=9<5D 6>: 4= LH9<:B<?5<=4 5= ;<566=@B =9 ;<56B9>; 874:<=4 47<5679 ;6=@@D =9 8>95<>@@D ;675679 879F>4745@D=9I=9>:87?<I<7B879<=B $- 4@<A65=I567>C=G7@7A>@8=:<5<=4>@56=HA6567 ?6>9A7: =I F<:?=4BH?5 ;797 I=H4B 5= C7 89=G7B >A><4:5 567 875<5<=479 ;7 I<4B 56>5 47<5679 567 B78>95F745>@ 74MH<9D978=954=956797?=FF74B>5<=4=I567 =E>DHE5> 4=9 567 <F8HA47B =9B79 =I 567 9<CH4>@ ?=45><4: >4D I<4B<4A 56>5 567 875<5<=479 ;>: AH<@5D =I F<:?=4BH?5 >: - 14 - ?=457F8@>57B H4B79 H@7 %$ 97>B ;<56 H@7 %$ =I 567 H@7: ??=9B<4A@D ;6<@7 I<4B<4A 567 F<:?=4BH?5 >A><4:5 567 875<5<=479 F>D =5679;<:7 C7 @7A>@@D :H:5><4>C@7 567 >C:74?7 =I > I<4B<4A 97A>9B<4A !A9>G7 F<:?=4BH?5" B<:745<5@7: 567 97:8=4B745: I9=F ;<566=@B<4A =9?H95><@<4A567875<5<=4792:874:<=4>9DC747I<5:::H?6 567 875<5<=479 ;=H@B C7 745<5@7B I=9 567 :79G<?7 >4B 874:<=4>9DC747I<5:>:879567H@7:>88@<?>C@75=6<F<4 >??=9B>4?7 ;<56 @>; >4B >??=9B<4A@D 8=<45 9><:7B I=9 ?=4:<B79>5<=4 <: >4:;797B >4B 567 ;9<5 875<5<=4 :5>4B: "23 (&&&') $ "23 ("&!) $ <:5=$ @=