- 1 - ! "!# $%!&!&"%% ' ( ! " # " "" $ %&'(#)# * "" "" " %&'(#)# "" !! %&'(#)# ( %&'(#)# " # + ( Digitally signed by VARSHA N RASALKAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - , " ** **- " " " , " ./ 01234045 467840 97:6;2< 76 =284<> 7> 011?2;8 4@1A4< >70 ?82 B2?1?17620 46@ 01 26C4?2;8 4<<4=4@1 97:6;2<>7002;B76@26?;#?784324BB2402@16B20;76 7?192?702;B76@26?7(D4;70@202@76#*)(*)* B20:;4< 7> ?82 7>>192 67?2 @2B19?; ?84? 02;B76@26? 7( 1; ;2032@ 46@ :602B02;26?2@ 2;B76@26? 7( 621?820 26E4E2@ ?82;203192;7>464@3794?2670976@:9?2@?8294;24;4B40?A 16B20;76 * 82;870?>49?;402?82;2 82 B2?1?17620 D4; 4BB716?2@ 4; 4 77C 76 @41<A D4E2 =4;1; 16 *))* 16 1E820 01F40A 9877< 22<4E4< 4<:C 16E4;:E:0 1;?019? 4198:0 >70 ?82 34946? B7;? 7> 77C >70 B02B404?1767>F1@@4AF24<?7?82;?:@26?;?1;;41@?84??82 B2?1?17620;2032@?7?82;4?1;>49?1767>?8202;B76@26?;D1?84<< - 3 - 8762;?A46@<7A4<?A7D2320?8202;B76@26?;?20F164?2@820 ;203192704<<A>07F*()#*))-D1?87:?>7<<7D16E?82B0792@:02 4; 976?2FB<4?2@ :6@20 29?176; *& " 46@ *& 7> ?82 6@:;?014< 1;B:?2; 9? #G(- ?87:E8 ;82 84; ;:992;;>:<<A 97FB<2?2@*()@4A;976?16:7:;;20319216?82B0292@16EA240 76?26@16E ?84? 820 ?20F164?176 1; 1<<2E4< ?82 B2?1?17620 4BB074982@?827691<14?176 >>1920=:??8297691<14?176>41<2@ ; ?82 F4??20 ;?77@ ?8:; 4>?20 4 <4B;2 7> 4<F7;? 6162 A240; ?82 B2?1?17620 041;2@ 4 @1;B:?2 46@ ?82 ;4F2 D4; 02>2002@ ?7 ?82 4=70 7:0? 4198:0 16 2> 7#( *)# 82 4=70 7:0? 31@2 D40@ @4?2@ #(#**)** 02529?2@ ?82 02>202692 ? 1; ?81; 4D40@ ?84? 1; 94<<2@ 16?7 H:2;?176 16 ?81; ,01?2?1?17676;23204<E07:6@;4;;2?%7:?16?822F7046@:F 7>,01?2?1?176 7:6;2<01234045467840>70?82B2?1?1762016 B02;26?16E81;40E:F26?;;:=F1?;?84??8270@207>@1;F1;;4<1; 16 :??20 317<4?176 7> 29?176; *&" 46@ *& 7> 6@:;?014< 1;B:?2;9?#G(- 2I? 82 ;:=F1?; ?84? ?82 4=70 7:0? 84; 2002@ 16 F4C16E?8294<9:<4?1767>976?16:7:;;2031924;@2>162@:6@20 - 4 - 29?176*&17>?829?2;:=F1?;84??8297692B?7> *() @4A; 7> 976?16:7:; ;203192 @72; 67? 4BB<A 6 ?82 7?820 846@ ;:=%;29?176 # 7> 29?176 *& 7> ?82 9? D1<< =2 4BB<194=<2?7?82>49?;46@9109:F;?4692;7>?82B02;26?94;2 4;?<A 82 ;:=F1?; ?84? ?82 4=70 7:0? 84; 2002@ 16 02529?16E?8202>20269276?82E07:6@;7>@2<4A46@<4982;2 ;:=F1?; ?84? ?8202 402 94?264 7> @291;176; 7> ?82 B2I 7:0? ?84? ?82 @2<4A ;84<< 67? 97F2 16 ?82 D4A ?7 4@5:@194?2 ?82 @1;B:?2;;:F16E4D81<2?84??82021;4@2<4A?824=707:0? 946 F7:<@ ?82 02<12> 46@ E046? 4BB07B014?2 02<12> 7:6;2< ?8202>702;:=F1?;?84??82,01?2?1?176F4A=24<<7D2@ 7:6;2<01 26C4?2;84<<4=4@1>7002;B76@26?;#?7 5:;?1>12@ ?82 4D40@ B4;;2@ =A ?82 4=70 7:0? 7:6;2< ;:=F1?;?84??82021;461670@164?2@2<4A7>4<F7;?6162A240;16 4BB0749816E?824=707:0?269282;:=F1?;?84??82,01? 2?1?176F4A=2@1;F1;;2@ 240@ ?82 40E:F26?; 46@ B20:;2@ ?82 ,01? B4B20; D1?8 9402 - 5 - ( 82 ;870? B716? ?84? 401;2; >70 976;1@204?176 1; D82?820?824D40@7>?824=7:07:0?02H:102;16?20>202692 & 82 >49?; 402 ;:>>19126?<A ;41@ 46@ @7 67? 02H:102 021?204?176 :>>192 1? ?7 67?2 ?84? ?82 70@20 7> @1;F1;;4< D4; F4@2 16 *))- 76?26@16E ?84? 820 ?20F164?176 1; 1<<2E4< ?82 B2?1?17620 ;7:E8? 02>202692 16 *)# 8202 1; 46 1670@164?2 @2<4A7>4<F7;?6162A240; 82B2?1?17620976?26@2@?84?@:2 ?7 B4:91?A 7> >:6@; 46@ >7092@ :62FB<7AF26? ;82 97:<@ 67? 041;2?82@1;B:?216?1F2 82024;76;>70?82@2<4A94667?=2 4992B?2@ > ?82 B2?1?17620 D4; ;?0:EE<16E @:016E ?82 ?1F2 7> :62FB<7AF26? 4 B07FB? 49?176 ;87:<@ 8432 =226 ?4C26 1FF2@14?2<A :? ?8202 1; 4 @2<4A 16 ;22C16E 4 02>202692 22@<2;; ?7 ;4A ?82 D70CF46 1; 02H:102@ ?7 976?2;? ?82 @1;F1;;4<70@20D1?87:?@2<4A 821;;:20237<32;407:6@@2<4A46@<4982;?1;B137?4< ?7 67?2 ?84? ?82 B2I 7:0? 16 02B70?2@16 84;82<@?84?D826?82021;67 4E1?4?176=A?82D70CF464E416;??8270@207>B:61;8F26?46@ ?82 @1;B:?2 1; 041;2@ =2<4?2@<A 46@ ?82 @2<4A 46@ <4982; - 6 - 02F4162@ :62IB<4162@ 1? ;87:<@ =2 B02;:F2@ ?84? 82 84@ D4132@81;01E8??1;4<;77=;2032@?84?4??82?1F2D826?82 @1;B:?2D4;041;2@1?84@=297F2;?4<246@D4;67?462I1;?16E @1;B:?232616?82B02;26?94;2D826?82@1;B:?2D4;041;2@ =A ?82 D70CF46 1? 84@ 310?:4<<A =297F2 4 ;?4<2 @1;B:?2 82 4=70 7:0? 2I?26;7 02>2002@ ?7 ?82 F4?2014< 76 02970@ 46@ 01E8?<A 02529?2@ ?82 02>202692 >16@ 67 E07:6@; ?7 16?20>202 D1?8?824D40@B4;;2@=A?824=707:0? 82,01?2?1?1761; <14=<2?7=2@1;F1;;2@ 2;:<?46?<A?82,01?2?1?1761; ! " 294:;2 7> @1;F1;;4< 7> ?82 ,01? 2?1?176 16?201F 70@20 E046?2@1>46A;?46@;@1;9840E2@ !)* '&"%%( & 1;?7#<7