Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 65899 (KAR)
SACHIN AND ORS v. SUNITA BAI AND ORS
RSA/200024/2025 · 2025-12-05
M G S Kamal
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 65899 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 65899 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "
##
$%
&
! "
""
#"" $ %
&
Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
% '
!(
! "
%
" (
()
" ! %
*
"
"" "
! (
%
%
" %"
%
* *! ! - 3 -
'
% '
!(
#"
$
+ ! ( '
"
&
+
+
"
"
% ! ! ! )"% * *! !(" % ! ! ! +
""
""
"" + %
,%
- 4 -
" $" ,%
&
-./011203./45627286089 :/9:0;;<.2=2645 9-2 >?6;@289 086 62A<22 60926 * *! !( 10//26 .8 : ! ! ! :8 9-2 7.32 :7 66.9.:803 ./9<.A9 B 2//.:8/ :?<9 .99.8; 09 0/0=0C03508 $7:< /-:<9 D+.</9 11233092:?<9E&45F-.A-9-2+.</911233092:?<9F-.32 033:F.8; 9-2 011203 7.326 45 9-2 130.89.77/ <2/1:86289/ -2<2.8?862<<62<(?32<206F.9-2A9.:8*':7" -0//290/.629-2>?6;@28908662A<2260926 ! ! 10//26 .8 : ! )
-2 +.</9 11233092 :?<9 -0/ 7?<9-2<-2369-099-232;03<21<2/28909.=2/:79-2130.89.77/ 0<2 9-2 04/:3?92 :F82</ 086 1: :</ :7 9-2 /?.9 1<:12<95086-0/7?<9-2<6.<2A9269-2011233089/-2<2.89:
=0A092 086 -086 :=2< 1: .:8 :7 ! ;?890/ :7 3086 420<.8;5 :!! :?9:70A<2/:7/?.91<:12<95F.9-.8 9F:@:89-/7<:@9-26092:79-2>?6;@289 ! -24<.2770A9/:79-2A0/20<29-09G
- 5 -
! -204:=2/?.9.8 : ! )./7.326459-2 :<.;.803 130.89.770>286<0 / : 0H@08 0:
-0F03C0< /22C.8; <23.27 :7 62A30<09.:8 :7 -./ 9.932 086 A:8/2I?289.03 <23.27 :7 12<@08289 .8>?8A9.:8 .8 <2/12A9 :7 3086 420<.8; 5 :!! $:36& 5 :!! "! $82F& @20/?<.8;
0A<2/ $7:< /-:<9 D9-2 /?.9 1<:12<95E&/.9?092609033?<=.330;20867?<9-2< 6.<2A9.:8 9: <2@:=2 9-2 A:8A<292 086 9<0A9:< .332;0335 C219 :=2< 08 2H9289 :7 ! ;?890/ :7 3086 9:F0<6/ /:?9-2<8 /.62 086 9: -086 :=2< 9-2=0A0891: .:89:9-2130.89.77 !! -09 /?.9 1<:12<95 F0/ :<.;.80335 0AI?.<26 45 :82 2/-@0 0?< .8 92<@/ :7 6226 :7 /032 60926!) )**2H2A?92645:8208.C0110 -2/0.62/-@00?<.892<@/:76226:7/032 60926 **) /:36 9-2 /?.9 1<:12<95 .8 70=:?<:79-2130.89.77
-280@2:79-2130.89.77 -0/4228@?90926.89-2<2=28?2<2A:<6/=2<
- 6 -
/.8A2 9-28 -2 ./ .8 1: .:8 086 28>:5@289 :7 9-2 3086 0/ 04/:3?92 :F82< 9-2<20792< 27286089/ 8:9 -0=.8; 085 <.;-9 9.932 086 .892<2/9 :=2< 9-2 1<:12<95 -0=2 4228 A0?/.8;
.892<72<28A2 ?<.8; -./ 04/28A2 627286089/ -06 6?@126 F0/92 @092<.03/ .8 9-2 /?.9 1<:12<95 ! -09 6?<.8; 9-2 128628A5 /?.9 086 F-.32 9-2 .892<.@:<62< :7 /905F0/ .87:<A2 627286089/ .8 A:33?/.:8 F.9- :9-2</ -06 :8 * )! * 6?@1264:?362</"30.89.77.8.9.09261<:A226.8;/ .8 ./A233082:?/ : !
) 7:< 6./:426.28A2 :79-2.892<.@:<62< !( 27286089/ -06 0;0.8 4<:C2 :128 9-2 3:AC :7 9-2;:6:F8423:8;.8;9:130.89.77086-06C219 9-2.<9<0A9:<0862@19540<<23/9-2<2.8"30.89.77 9-2<27:<2 /:?;-9 <23.27 :7 <2@:=03 :7 28A<:0A-@289459-2627286089/
- 7 -
27286089/ 7.326 F<.9928 /9092@289 086 066.9.:803/9092@2896285.8;9-2A0/2:79-2130.89.77 9./06@.99269-092/-@00?<F0/9-220<3.2< :F82< :7 9-2 /?.9 1<:12<95
-09 9-2 /0.6 2/-@0 0?< -06 /:36 9-2 /?.9 1<:12<95 .8 70=:?< :7 709-2< :7 9-2 627286089/ 80@235 0@2/--0F03C0<.80/@?A-0/9-2289.<2/032 A:8/.62<09.:8 :8 9-2 /?.9 1<:12<95 F0/ 10.6 9: /0.6 2/-@0 0?< 45 9-2 709-2< :7 9-2 627286089/
-2/0.62/-@00?<-061?99-2 709-2< :7 9-2 627286089/ .8 1: .:8 :7 9-2 1<:12<95:F2=2<9-2/0326226F0/8:@.80335 2H2A?926 .8 9-2 80@2 :7 130.89.77 F.9- 08 .89289.:8 9: C221 1:<9.:8 :7 9-2 3086 ?862< A092;:<5 :7 /@033 086 @0<;.803 70<@2</
"30.89.77 9-2 5:?8;2< 4<:9-2< :7 0@2/- -0F03C0< 9-2 709-2< :7 9-2 627286089/ F0/ /2<=.8; ?862< -.@ 0/ 0 A:89<0A9:< 086 4?/.82//@08
- 8 -
! -09 709-2< :7 9-2 627286089/ -06 03/: 1?<A-0/26 /:?9-2<8 1:<9.:8 :7 3086 .8 5 :!! !@20/?<.8;'0A<2/!;?890/7<:@ :82 0<60< 034.< .8;- -?/4086 :7 2/-@0 0?< :7 F-.A- ! ;?890/ ./ A:8=2<926 7<:@ 0;<.A?39?<039:8:80;<.A?39?<031?<1:/2/
-090 /9:82 A<?/-.8; ?8.9 13089 086 @0A-.82<5 086 :9-2< /9<?A9?<2/ F2<2 2H./9.8; 09 9-2 9.@2 :7 1?<A-0/2:79-2/0.61<:12<95F-.329-2/?.93086 F0/=0A089086?8A?39.=0432
-2/?.93086F0/ 1?<A-0/26 45 /0.6 0@2/- -0F03C0< 7:< 9-2 1?<1:/2 :7 /9:<.8; 9-2 /9:82/ 086 :9-2< @092<.03/ <2I?.<26 7:< 9-2 /9:82 A<?/-.8; @0A-.82<5 -2130.89.7762/1.92-0=.8;9-2C8:F326;2:7-2 42.8; 0 8:@.803 :F82< 7.326 9-2 /?.9 :835 9: -0<0//9-2627286089/?909.:8:79-23086./.8 9-280@2:79-2130.89.77:F2=2<709-2<:79-2 627286089/F0/?/.8;9-2/0.63086086-2F0/
- 9 -
.81: .:808628>:5@289:79-2/0@29.33-./ 62@./2 792< -./ 6209- 627286089/ 0<2 .8 1: .:8 086 28>:5@289 :7 9-2 /?.9 1<:12<95 0/:F82</ (
-099-2130.89.779<2/10//26.89:9-2/?.9308609 9-2.8/908A2 :7 9-2 A2<90.8 12</:8/0792< ;06. .8 ** +09-2< :7 9-2 627286089/ -06 .@@26.09235 6<.=28 9-2 130.89.77 :?9 :7 9-2 /?.9 3086 628.26 -./ 9.932 :=2< 9-2 1<:12<95 .8A2 9-28 627286089/ -0=2 <2@0.826 .8 06=2</2 1: .:8:79-2/?.930869.33-./6209-:12835 9: 9-2 C8:F326;2 :7 9-2 130.89.77 086 9: 033 /?<<:?86.8; 3086:F82</ / :8 9-2 6092 :7 -./ 6209- .2 :8 ! 627286089/ 0<2 .8 06=2</2 1: .:8 9: 9-2 C8:F326;2 :7 130.89.770//?A-9-25-0=212<72A9269-2.<9.932 :8 /?.9 1<:12<95 7:< 06=2</2 1: .:8
-2 0332;09.:8:7=.:309.:8:7.892<.@:<62<./628.26 /:03/:9-20332;09.:8:7.332;0328A<:0A-@289:7
- 10 -
! ;?890/ :7 3086 :8 9-2 :?9-2<8 /.62 :7 9-2 /?.9 1<:12<95 6./1: .8; :7 9-2 130.89.77 ./ 03/:628.26 ( 0/26:89-213206.8;/9-2
<.03:?<97<0@26 9-27:33:F.8;.//?2/
! "
- 11 -
"30.89.772H0@.826-.@/2370/"0862H-.4.926 !( 6:A?@289/ 0/ H/" 9: !( "30.89.77 6.26 6?<.8; 9-2 128628A5:79-2/?.9:82:79-232;03<21<2/28909.=2F0/ 2H0@.8260/"!27286089 :!2H0@.8260/086 2H-.4.9266:A?@289@0<C260/H ' 8 011<2A.09.:8 :7 2=.628A2 9-2
<.03 :?<9 08/F2<26.//?2 :10<935.89-2077.<@09.=2G.//?2 :/!
9: 086 066.9.:803 .//?2 : .8 9-2 82;09.=2 086 066.9.:803.//?2 :!.89-2077.<@09.=2:8/2I?289359-2 <.03 :?<9 6./@.//26 9-2 /?.9 2.8; 0;;<.2=26 130.89.77 1<272<<26 9-2 011203 .8 : ! ! ! :8 9-2 7.32 :7 +.</9 11233092 :?<9 27286089/ 7.326 9-2 A<:// 011203 8 )! ! /22C.8; /299.8; 0/.62 :7 9-2 7.86.8;/ :8 .//?2 :/086.89-2>?6;@28908662A<22 ! ! 10//26459-2
<.03:?<9086/.8A29-2<2F0/062305.8 7.3.8; 9-2 A<:// 011203 08 0113.A09.:8 ?862< 2A9.:8 :7 .@.909.:8 A9 ./ 03/: 7.326 /22C.8; A:86:809.:8 :7 9-2 62305
- 12 -
) -2 +.</9 11233092 :?<9 7<0@26 9-2 7:33:F.8; 1:.897:<.9/A:8/.62<09.:8
# $ %! %
& # $
-2 +.</9 11233092 :?<9 45 9-2 .@1?;826 >?6;@289086:<62<033:F269-2011203086/290/.629-2 >?6;@289 086 62A<22 10//26 45 9-2
<.03 :?<9 2.8; 0;;<.2=26 45 9-2 /0@2 9-2 627286089/ 0<2 427:<2 9-./ :?<9 * 20<826 A:?8/23 7:< 9-2 011233089/627286089/ 09 9-2 :?9/29 /?4@.9/ 9-09 F-28 06@.992635 627286089/ 1<272<<26 A<:// 011203 03:8; F.9- 08 0113.A09.:8 .8 :! /22C.8; A:86:809.:8 :7 62305 .8 7.3.8; 9-2 A<:// 0112039-2+.</911233092:?<9F.9-:?96./1:/.8;:79-2 /0.6 .892<.@ 0113.A09.:8 A:?36 8:9 -0=2 1<:A22626 9:
06>?6.A092 9-2 @0992< :8 @2<.9/ 2 7?<9-2< /?4@.9/ 9-09
- 13 -
8:9-.8; ./ 2@0809.8; 7<:@ 9-2 .@1?;826 >?6;@289 086 62A<22 10//26 45 9-2 +.</9 11233092 :?<9 <2;0<6.8; 9-2 /909?/:79-2A<://011203.2F-29-2<9-2A<://011203./ 6./1:/26:<8:9./8:9A320<7<:@9-2.@1?;826>?6;@289
2<272</9:9-260.35:<62</-229@0.890.826.8 +.</9 11233092:?<9 @:<210<9.A?30<3560.35 :<62< /-229 60926' !! !(9:9.33! *! !(9:1:.89:?99-099-2 :!7.326459-2011233089/627286089/-2<2.8/22C.8;
A:86:809.:8 :7 62305 -0/ 82=2< 4228 6./1:/26 :7 086 ?832//086?89.39-2/0.60113.A09.:8F0/06=2<9269:086 :<62< .8 9-2 @0882<C8:F8 9: 30F F0/ 10//26 .9 A088:9 421<2/?@269-09A<://0112037.326459-2011233089/F0/ .86226 -20<6 086 06>?6.A0926 ?1:8
-09 9-2 +.</9 11233092 :?<9 -0/ 1<:A22626 9: 10// 9-2 :<62</ :8 @2<.9/2=28F.9-:?9-20<.8;9-2627286089/ 011233089/:8 9-2 @2<.9/ :7 9-2 A0/2
-2<27:<2 -2 /?4@.9/ 9-09 /?4/9089.03 I?2/9.:8 :7 30F F:?36 0<./2 7:< A:8/.62<09.:8 086 A:8/2I?289 <2@086 :7 9-2 @0992< 7:< 7<2/- A:8/.62<09.:8 45 9-2 +.</9 11233092 :?<9 2 /?4@.9/
- 14 -
0859-.8; 32// 9-08 9-09 F:?36 621<.=2 9-2 /909?9:<5<.;-9 :7 011203 F-.A- 9-2 627286089/ 011233089/ 0<2 289.9326 ?862<30F
8/?11:<9:7-./A:89289.:8/-2<23.2/?1:89-2 >?6;@289/:79-212H:?<9086:79-./:?<9G
& '
( % )
"*")+,'$,-. /%'
01+ *")+ ,,! 0"+2 . $'
$%
( *33 ")/$43- 28A2/22C/7:<033:F.8;9-2011203
!
20<826 A:?8/23 01120<.8; 7:< 9-2 130.89.77 <2/1:86289/ :8 9-2 :9-2< -086 90C.8; 9-./ :?<9 9-<:?;- 9-2.@1?;826:<62<@:<210<9.A?30<3510<0;<01- :/ 086 ' /?4@.9/ 9-099-2+.</9 11233092 :?<9-0/ .86226 06=2<926 9: 20A- 086 2=2<5 ;<:?86 ?<;26 45 9-2 627286089/ 011233089/ .8 9-2.< A<:// 011203 2 03/:
/?4@.9/ 2=28 9-2 0113.A09.:8 .8 :! 7.326 ?862< 2A9.:8 :7 .@.909.:8 A9 -0/ 03/: 4228 6./1:/26 :7
- 15 -
-2<27:<2 9-2 A:89289.:8 ?<;26 45 9-2 011233089/ ./ ?89280432
2 7?<9-2< /?4@.9/ 9-09 9-2
<.03 :?<9 -0/ .86226 ?1-236 9-2 A:89289.:8 :7 9-2 130.89.77 42.8; 9-2 04/:3?92:F82< :7 9-2 1<:12<95:F2=2<.9 -06 2<<26 .8 6./@.//.8;9-2/?.9@2<23542A0?/20AA:<6.8;9:
<.03:?<9 627286089/ F2<2 .8 1: .:8 F-.A- 08:@035 -0/ 4228 /2909<.;-9459-2+.</911233092:?<9
-098:1<2>?6.A2 -0/ 4228 A0?/26 9: 9-2 011233089/ .8 9-2 +.</9 11233092 :?<9 8:9 /12A.7.A0335 <272<<.8; 9: 9-2 A<://011203 .8 .9/ :<62< .8A2 70A9?0335 086 32;0335 9-2
<.03 :?<9 086 9-2 +.</9 11233092 :?<9 -0=2 -236 9-2 011233089/ 9: 42 9-2 04/:3?92:F82<:79-21<:12<950869-22<<:82:?/7.86.8;
:7 9-2
<.03 :?<9 F.9- <2;0<6 9: 9-2 1: .:8 -0=.8; 4228<2=2</26459-2+.</911233092:?<98:/?4/9089.03 I?2/9.:8 :7 30F 0<./2 7:< A:8/.62<09.:8 28A2 /22C/ 7:< 6./@.//03:79-2011203 ( 20<6"2<?/269-2<2A:<6/
- 16 -
-2 1<.@0<5 ;<:?86 =2-2@28935 ?<;26 45 9-2 A:?8/23 7:< 9-2 011233089/ ./ 8:8A:8/.62<09.:8 :7 9-2 0113.A09.:8 .8 :! 7.326 ?862< 2A9.:8 :7 9-2 .@.909.:8 A9 45 9-2 +.</9 11233092 :?<9 F-.A- 0AA:<6.8; 9: -.@ ./ 0 /2<.:?/ 2<<:< .80/@?A- 0/ F.9-:?9 A:8/.62<.8; 9-2 0113.A09.:8 :8 3.@.909.:8 9-2 +.</9 11233092:?<9A:?368:9-0=2=289?<26:89:9-2@2<.9/:7 9-2A0/2
-2 <272<28A2 @06245320<826 A:?8/23 7:< 9-2 011233089 .8 >?/9.7.A09.:8 :7 9-./ /?4@.//.:8 ./ 9: 9-2 >?6;@289 :7 9-2 ::<6.8092 28A- :7 9-./ :?<9 .8 9-2 A0/2 :7 $/?1<0& .8 F-.A- 9-2 ::<6.8092 28A- -0/ -236 9-09 62305 /-:?36 42 A:86:826 7.</9 086 011203/-:?364206@.99269-2<20792< ' : 6:?49 9-2 60.35 :<62< /-229 @0.890.826 45 9-2 +.</9 11233092 :?<9 2HA219 <272<<.8; 9: :! -0=.8;42287.326459-2627286089/011233089/-2<2.8086 28I?.<5 -0=.8; 4228 A:86?A926 9-2<2:8 6:2/ 8:9 /120C 04:?9 085 :<62< -0=.8; 4228 10//26 :8 9-2 /0.6 0113.A09.:8:F2=2<0910<0;<01- :!0910;2 :/! - 17 -
9:!:79-2.@1?;826:<62<9-2+.</911233092:?<9-0/ 2H928/.=235 06=2<926 9: 9-2 A:89289/ :7 0113.A09.:8 .8 :!0860910<0;<01- :!1<:A226269:6./@.//9-2 /0.6 0113.A09.:8
-2<27:<2 @2<235 42A0?/2 9-2<2 ./ 8: @289.:8 .8 9-2 60.35 :<62< /-229 04:?9 9-2 /909?/ :7 9-2 0113.A09.:8.9A088:942/0.69-099-2+.</911233092:?<9 -0/ 8:9 06>?6.A0926 ?1:8 9-2 0113.A09.:8 :!
7.326 ?862<2A9.:8:79-2.@.909.:8A9 ) .@.30<35 @2<2 @289.:8.8; :7 <20/:8/ 086 9-2 A:8A3?/.:80<<.=2609:89-20113.A09.:8099-2286:79-2 >?6;@289A088:903/:420;<:?869:/059-099-262305 0113.A09.:8 -0/ 8:9 4228 A:8/.62<26
-2 0<;?@289 ./ 9-2<27:<28:90AA21926
-2 :9-2< 0<;?@289 :7 9-2 320<826 A:?8/23 7:< 9-2 011233089/ ./ 9-09 9-2 A<:// 011203 -0/ 8:9 4228 A:8/.62<269./82A2//0<5099-./>?8A9?<29:06=2<99:9-2 ;<:?86/?<;26.89-2A<://0112037.326459-2011233089/ 627286089/
-2 ;<:?86/ .8 9-2 A<:// 011203 0<2 8:9-.8;
4?9 <2.92<09.:8 :7 9-2 A:89289.:8 90C28 .8 9-2 F<.9928
- 18 -
/9092@289.23086@20/?<.8;'0A<2/!;?890/086/?.9 3086 @20/?<.8; 0A<2/ F2<2 1?<A-0/26 45 62A20/26 0@2/- -0F03C0< :8 9-2 /0@2 605 7<:@ -./ 2</9F-.32 :F82< 034.< .8;- 086 -./ F.72 2/-@0 0?< .86.A09.8;
0@2/- -0F03C0< 9: 42 9-2 :F82< :7 9-2 3086 086 130.89.77 F0/ 0 8:@.803 :F82<
-09 9-2
<.03 :?<9 F-.32 08/F2<.8;.//?2 :/0860AA:<6.8;9:9-2011233089/ -062<<26.88:9A:8/.62<.8;9-2@092<.03130A26:8<2A:<6 .89-./<2;0<6 * -2 7?<9-2< ;<:?86 ?<;26 .8 9-2 /0.6 A<:// 011203 ./ F.9- <2;0<6 9:1?<1:<926 06@.//.:8 45 " :7 627286089/ A0<<5.8; :8 /9:82 A<?/-.8; ?8.9 .8 9-2 3086 @20/?<.8; ' 0A<2/ 086 ! ;?890/ F-.A- F0/ 2H./9.8; .8 9-23086/.8A2**)0869-09/?A-06@.//.:8A:?1326F.9- 9-2 <2=28?2 <2A:<6/ F:?36 .86.A092 627286089/ 42.8; .8 1: .:8 :7 9-2 1<:12<95 086 12<72A9.8; 9-2.< 9.932 45 06=2</21: .:8 ! / /228 09 10<0;<01- :) :7 9-2 .@1?;826 >?6;@289 086 :<62< :7 9-2 +.</9 11233092 :?<9 .9
- 19 -
/12A.7.A0335 <272</ 9: 9-2 70A9 :7 +.</9 11233092 :?<9 -0=.8; -20<6 9-2 0<;?@289/ :7 9-2 A:?8/23 7:< 9-2 011233089/ 086 9-2 <2/1:86289 :8 @2<.9/ 9 10<0;<01- :/086'9-2+.</911233092:?<9-0/A?3326:?99-2 ;<:?86/?<;26459-2627286089/ 011233089/.89-2.<A<:// 011203 9 10<0;<01- :! 09 10;2 :! 9-2 +.</9 11233092 :?<9 -0/ /12A.7.A0335 <272<<26 9: 9-2 A<:// 0112037.326459-2011233089/.89-27:33:F.8;F:<6/ 5 6
)"%
'
7
"6 ,
8
6 &
$9
! -?/ 9-2 6./A?//.:8 086 9-2 <20/:8.8; :7 9-2 +.</911233092:?<90/7:?86.810<0;<01- :/)9:! 320=2 8: 6:?49 9-09 033 9-2 ;<:?86/ ?<;26 .8 9-2 A<:// 0112030869-20<;?@289066<2//26459-2A:?8/237:<9-2 011233089/ 427:<2 9-2 +.</9 11233092 :?<9 -0=2 4228
- 20 -
2H928/.=235 066<2//26 06=2<926 9: 45 9-2 +.</9 11233092 :?<9 !! -2<27:<29-2<23.08A2130A26:8459-2320<826 A:?8/237:<9-2011233089/:89:9-2>?6;@289:79-212H :?<9 .8 9-2 A0/2 :7 $/?1<0& 086 :7 9-2 >?6;@289 :7 9-2 ::<6.8092 28A- :7 9-./ :?<9 .8 9-2 A0/2:7 $/?1<0&0<2:78:0=0.3 !
8 085 2=289 F-09 ./ <2I?.<26 9: 42 /228 ./ 9-099-2A<://0112032=280AA:<6.8;9:9-2011233089/F0/ :835F.9-<2;0<69:9-27.86.8;/<2A:<626459-2
<.03:?<9 :8 .//?2 :/ 086 /9<.A935 /120C.8; 9-2 /0@2 A:?36 -0=24228066<2//262=28.89-204/28A2:7A<://011203 0/ 1<:=.626 ?862< <62< J ?32 !! :7 "
-2 A<:// 011203 7.326 45 9-2 011233089/ ./ 42.8; 7:<@03 086 .8 9-2 04/28A2 :7 085 ;<:?86 @062 :?9 45 9-2 011233089/ :7 /?4/9089.03 1<2>?6.A2 086 .8>?/9.A2 -0=.8; A0?/26 .8 =.2F :71?<1:<9268:8/12A.7.A:<62<10//26:8 :!086:8 A<://0112039-./:?<96:8:97.86.9011<:1<.0929:0AA219 9-2 A:89289.:8 086 <2I?2/9 7:<<2@086 :7 9-2 @0992< /
- 21 -
9-./92A-8.A03<2I?.<2@289:71<:A26?<2.89-2A:8/.62<26 =.2F :7 9-./ :?<9 -0/ 8:9 0772A926 .8 085 @0882< F-09/:2=2< 9-2 <.;-9/ :7 9-2 011233089/ 627286089/ -2<27:<29-2/0.6<2I?2/90860<;?@289./<2>2A926 !( -2<20/:8.8;0869-2A:8A3?/.:80<<.=260945 9-2 +.</9 11233092 :?<9 /-033 42 9: <206 9: @208 9-2 A<://011203-0=.8;42286./@.//26 ! / <2;0<6/ 9-2 @2<.9/ :7 9-2 A0/2 9-2<2 ./ 8: 6./1?92:79-270A99-099-2/?.91<:12<95F0/1?<A-0/26.8 92<@/:79-26092:7/03260926 **)459-2:<.;.803 130.89.77
-2
<.03:?<90869-2+.</911233092:?<9-0=2 A:8A?<<28935A:@29:9-2A:8A3?/.:8:89-./0/12A9:79-2 @0992<
-2
<.03:?<9086+.</911233092:?<9-0=203/:
A:@2 9: 9-2 A:8A3?/.:8 :7 9-2 70A9 9-09 <2=28?2 <2A:<6/ 1<:6?A26 09 H/"( 9: "! 42.8;
2H9<0A9/ 086 9-2 @?909.:8 A:1.2/ A320<35 .86.A092 130.89.77 9: 42 9-2 04/:3?92:F82<.81: .:8:79-2/?.93086
-:?;-9-2 <.03 :?<9-06 -236 9-09 9-2 130.89.77 -06 70.3269: 1<:=2 9-21: .:89-2+.</911233092:?<906=2<9.8;9:9-2
- 22 -
@092<.03 :<03 086 6:A?@2890<5 2=.628A2 09 10<0;<01- :/ * 086 ! -0/ A:@2 9: 9-2 A:8A3?/.:8 9-09 9-2 130.89.77 0792< -./ 62@./2 -./ 32;03 <21<2/28909.=2/ A:89.8?26 9: 42 .8 1: .:8 086 28>:5@289 :7 9-2 1<:12<950/04/:3?92:F82</9-2<2:7 !' 8 9-2 I?2/9.:8 :7 A30.@ @062 45 9-2 627286089/ :8 06=2</2 1: .:8 9-2 +.</9 11233092 :?<9-0/<.;-93506=2<9269:9-2<2I?.<2@289:7232@289/ :706=2</21: .:8.89-09.9-0/A:@29:9-2A:8A3?/.:8 9-09 9-2 627286089/ -0=2 8:9 ;.=28 9-2 6092/ :8 F-.A- 9-2.<1: .:842A0@206=2</29:<.;-99.932086.892<2/9 :7 9-2 130.89.77 9-2 9<?2 :F82< 086 9-25 03/: -0=2 8:9 1<:=26 9-2 328;9- :7 9-2.< 0332;26 :128 086 ?86./9?<426 1: .:8 F-.A- 0<2
8
7:< 9-2 1?<1:/2 :7 A:8/.62<09.:8:7 9-2 1<052< 7:<9-25 -0=.8; 12<72A926 9-2 9.9324506=2</21: .:8 !) -?/4:9-70A9?033508632;03359-2
<.03:?<9 0869-2+.</911233092:?<90/<2;0<69.9320869-2+.</9
- 23 -
11233092:?<90/<2;0<61: .:8-0=2A:@@.99268: 2<<:< ! : /?4/9089.03 I?2/9.:8 :7 30F 9-2<27:<2 F:?36 0<./27:<A:8/.62<09.:811203./9-2<27:<26./@.//26 !* -2 >?6;@289 086 62A<22 10//26 45 9-2 +.</9 11233092:?<9./A:87.<@26
'( $ %
"
"