- 1 - !! ""# ""$"! ! %! #&#'##" # #'' ()* !+ ! " # $ " % & '! (( # $(!!)! & && ! " Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - # & * !)! $ & & +,#$ & & - & % !+!,! % + !( )!! &. &% & % / / 0 % &" 123 455647 23 82769 :; <16 =742>4?< 4@42?3< <16 %A9@>6?< 4?9 4B4C9 94<69 !+!,! 543369 2? D + !( :; <16 D<DC ==296?< 742>3 C2:A?47 4?9 992<2D?47 6?2DC 2E27 %A9@6 474:AC4@2 #8DC 31DC< F<16 <C2:A?47G$366H2?@6?14?=6>6?<D8<16=D>56?34<2D? 16 =742>4?< >6< B2<1 4==296?< D? !!+ 4?93A886C69@C26EDA32?IAC263682769=742>56<2<2D?:68DC6 <16 <C2:A?47 366H2?@ =D>56?34<2D? D8 3 !!!! 16 <C2:A?47 48<6C =D?3296C2?@ <16 6?<2C6 6E296?=6 D? C6=DC9 - 3 - 4B4C969 4 3A> D8 3 ,!! 47D?@ B2<1 2?<6C63< 4< <16 C4<6 D8 ). 56C 4??A> 8CD> <16 94<6 D8 56<2<2D? <277 C6472J4<2D? 62?@ 4@@C26E69 :; <16 3429 %A9@>6?< 4?9 4B4C9 <16 =742>4?< 143 5C686CC69 <16 5C636?< 455647 4?9 >42?7;=D?<6?969<14<16B4364C?2?@43A>D8 3!!! 56C >D?<1 4?9 3!! 56C 94; 43 :4<<4 4?9 16 2?=ACC69 >692=47 6K56?363 D8 3( !!!! :A< <16 <C2:A?47 B2<1DA< =D?3296C2?@ <16 34>6 143 4B4C969 >64@6C =D>56?34<2D? 4?9C6LA63<38DC6?14?=6>6?<D8<16=D>56?34<2D? , 64C9<164C@A>6?<38CD>:D<132963 ( 16 =742>4?< 143 ?D< 82769 4?; 2?=D>6 5CDD8 <D 31DB 123 2?=D>6 6 >6< B2<1 4==296?< D? !!+ 6?=6 <16 <C2:A?47 143 C2@1<7; <4H6? <16 2?=D>6 D8 <16 =742>4?< 4< 3! ! 16 =742>4?< B43 4@69 ;64C3 4?9 <16 >A7<25726C23 FG 16 =742>4?< 3A3<42?698DAC574<6 B2<1 <6? 3=C6B3 A369 8DC D56? C69A=<2D? 2?<6C?47 82K4<2D? # &$D88C4=<AC6D8CDD8>692=474?95D3<6CD74<6C47B477D8 C2@1<DC:2<4?<6C2DC>692474?95D3<6CD74<6C47B477D8:274<6C47 >4K2774C; 32?A3 :274<6C47 5<6C;@D29 574<63 C2@1< J;@D>4<2= - 4 - 4C=1C2@1<5D3<6C2DCB477 D8 =D?9;74C 8D34 4?9 87DDC D8 C2@1< DC:2< 3 56C <16 923=14C@6 3A>>4C; <16 =742>4?< B43 1D352<472J69 8DC , 94;3 <16 D=<DC 233A69 9234:272<; =6C<282=4<6 A?96C K 6 43363369 <16 56C>4?6?< 9234:272<;D8<16=742>4?<4<.<D>4K277D84=247C6@2D?6 8AC<16C 3<4<69 <14< <16 455CDK2>4<6 6K56?92<AC6 <D C63<DC6 <16>47D==7A32D?4?9C6574=6>6?<4?9<DC63<DC6<164886=<69 <66<1 BDA79 :6 3 ,!! 16 <C2:A?47 143 =D?3296C69 <169234:272<;D8<16=742>4?<4< .D?3296C2?@<16?4<AC6 D8 2?IAC; 4?9 56C2D9 D8 1D352<472J4<2D? <123 DAC< 82?93 ?D C643D?<D2?<6C86C6B2<1<163429DC96C 16 <C2:A?47 473D 49969 (!. D8 <16 2?=D>6 <DB4C93 8A<AC6 5CD356=<3 4?9 43363369 <16 7D33 D8 8A<AC6 2?=D>6 4< 3 ,!! 4?9 2< 23 =D?82C>69 16 <C2:A?47 473D 4B4C969 4 3A> D8 3!!!! <DB4C93 >692=47 6K56?3634?92<?6693?D2?<6C86C6?=6 ) 2?=6<164>DA?<3@C4?<69:;<16<C2:A?47A?96C 92886C6?< 16493 4C6 =DCC6=< 4?9 C643D?4:76 <123 DAC< 82?93 ?DC643D?<D2?<6C86C62?<163429DC96C - 5 - + < 23 3A:>2<<69 <14< <16 =D>56?34<2D? 4>DA?< 4B4C969 :; <16 <C2:A?47 23 47C649; 965D32<69 :68DC6 <16 <C2:A?47 16 =742>4?< 23 56C>2<<69 <D B2<19C4B <16 4>DA?< 47D?@B2<12?<6C63<4==CA69D?2< ? <16 C63A7< <16455647 23 923>23369 =D?82C>2?@ <16%A9@>6?<4?9DC96CD8<16<C2:A?47 ,-. ('##"* &" 23<D/ 7D/+ / %