Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 65883 (KAR)
THE MANAGER LEGAL v. BASVARAJ GURUMURTHYAYYA MATH AND ORS
MFA/201549/2022 · 2025-11-06
P Sree Sudha
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 65883 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 65883 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"#
$ % &
&&
'( )* && +
)
*
! " #
"
$ %
"
$
&
' "" (("
)
Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
'" (&&
!)
'
" ! )
'" (&&
*
"" '
" )
'" (&&
!)
""
"
! ))
""""
" '" (&&
!)
"" &)" )" %
"
+ &, - + *- - $
++ )* &$+
"
! " '! *
&
& &)&"
'
+
" '"
+
'
"
- 3 -
++
"
+)
*
&
' "" ("
)
'" (&&
!) ' &" ! )
'" (&& %
" $
&
"" '
" )
'" (&&
*
!)"" *" ! ))
""
""
- 4 -
" '" (&&
)""
" )
* %
"
+ &-
+ - * - $
++ )
* .$+
"
+"
'
! *
&
&
&)& + +
' +
" '" + &)
"
"
+
+
"'! /
/ 0 '
%
& 12 344235 .6 + 7
&) .8 9: ;12 68<=36>2 7?436: 36@ ;12 344235 .6 + 7
) .8 9: ;12 >53.?36;8 3A3.68; ;12 83?2 B<@A?26; 36@ 3C3=@ @3;2@ *
&
& 43882@9: ;12 @@.;.7635 26.7= .D.5 '<@A2 36@ 7??.88.762= E7=
- 5 -
?457:228 7?42683;.76 >; .B3:34<=3 FE7= 817=;
G7??.88.762=HI.67
&)& 129=.2EE3>;87E;12>3823=2;13;762363::3 3A2@ :23=8 ?2; C.;1 36 3>>.@26; 76
& 36@ @.2@@<=.6A;12>7<=827E2?457:?26;
26>21.843=26;8 E.52@ >53.? 42;.;.76 92E7=2 ;12 7??.88.762= >53.?.6A >7?42683;.767E 8
)
28476@26;78
*36@ 3=2 ;12 C.E2 36@ @3<A1;2= 7E ;12 @2>2382@
12 7??.88.762=>768.@2=.6A;1226;.=2?3;2=.3583D3.5395276 =2>7=@3C3=@2@38<?7E 8
&()C.;1.6;2=28;3;
&J 42= 366<? E=7? ;12 @3;2 7E 3>>.@26; ;.55 =235.K3;.76 36@ @.=2>;2@ =28476@26; 7
68<=36>2 7?436: ;7 83;.8E: ;12 3C3=@ 3?7<6;
AA=.2D2@ 9: ;12 83.@ B<@A?26;;128234423583=2E.52@ * 12 ?3.6 >76;26;.76 .6 + 7
&) E.52@ 9: ;12 68<=36>2 7?436: .8 ;13; ;12=2 .8 67 2?457:22 36@ 2?457:2= =253;.7681.4 92;C226 ;12 @2>2382@ 36@ =28476@26; 7
&
; .8 ;12 E<=;12= >76;26;.76 7E ;12 68<=36>2 7?436: ;13; <6@2= 2>;.76
- 6 -
&$7E?457:228H7?42683;.76>;3842=67;.E.>3;.76 @3;2@ *&
& ?3L.?<? C3A2 >36 92 >768.@2=2@ .8 8
)42=?76;19<;;127??.88.762=.A67=.6A;12 83?2 138 ;3M26 ;12 .6>7?2 3; 8
&&) 42= ?76;1 C1.>1 .8 2==7627<8
6 ;1.8 344235 ;12 E7557C.6A 8<98;36;.35 N<28;.768 7E 53C 3=2 =3.82@ 9: ;12 68<=36>2 7?436:/
! " ! # $
" ! # %
&
%
'()*) ()+ ,-!
- 7 -
& . ,-! '() ,-!$
/
"
*0+(1 +02++)345 !$6
23=@3=A<?26;87E97;1;128.@2836@42=<82@ ;12?3;2=.353D3.5395276=2>7=@
12 ?3.6 >76;26;.76 7E ;12 >53.?36;8 .8 ;13;
;12 @2>2382@ C38 C7=M.6A <6@2= ;12 2?457:?26; 7E =28476@26; 7
& 38 3 =.D2= 76 ;12 ;=<>M 923=.6A =2A.8;=3;.76 7
)** 36@ A2;;.6A 8353=: 7E 8
&)42=?76;1343=;E=7?@3.5:93;;37E 8
&) 36@12@.2@@<=.6A;12>7<=827E;122?457:?26;9<;;12 7??.88.762= 2==2@ .6 388288.6A ;12 .6>7?2 7E ;12 @2>2382@3; 8
&&)42=?76;136@3C3=@2@?23A=2 >7?42683;.76
; .8 3587 >76;26@2@ ;13; ;12 7??.88.762= 2==2@ .6 3C3=@.6A 765: &J 7E ;12 3C3=@
- 8 -
3?7<6; ;7 ;12 &8; >53.?36;)E3;12= 7E ;12 @2>2382@ 36@ 35872==2@.63C3=@.6A>7?42683;.76;7=28476@26;7
*O C.E27E@2>2382@C173E;2=;12@23;17E;12@2>2382@138 =2?3==.2@
26>2.;.88<9?.;;2@;13;;12>7?42683;.76 3C3=@2@ ;7 C.E2 7E ;12 @2>2382@ >76;=3=: ;7 53C
12 E7557C.6A 8<98;36;.35 N<28;.768 7E 53C 3=2 =3.82@ 9: ;12 >53.?36;8/ 35
" & 70+++(1
! 8 09 0: ; <+ # !9*2$ 3
5
" !$ 35 =
$6
- 9 -
(
23=62@ >7<6825 E7= ;12 >53.?36;8 8<9?.;;2@ ;13; ;12 @2>2382@ C38 <6@2= ;12 2?457:?26; 7E =28476@26;7
&38=.D2=761.8;=<>M923=.6A=2A.8;=3;.76 7
)** 36@ 23=6.6A 8
&) 42= ?76;1 3576AC.;1913;;37E 8
&)42=@3:
235878;3;28;13;
;12 @2>2382@ C38 3A2@ ( :23=8 3; ;12 ;.?2 7E 3>>.@26; 36@ =28476@26; 7
& 3@?.;;2@ ;12 =253;.7681.4 7E 2?457:2= 36@ 2?457:22 92;C226 1.?825E 36@ ;12 @2>2382@
6 D.2C 7E ;12 3@?.88.76 9: =28476@26; 7
& ;13; @2>2382@ C38 C7=M.6A <6@2= 1.? ;12 3=A<?26; 7E 68<=36>2 7?436: ;13; ;12=2 .8 67 =253;.7681.4 7E 2?457:2=36@2?457:2292;C226;127C62=7E;12D21.>52 36@;12@2>2382@>3667;923>>24;2@
12=.9<635138;3M26.6>7?27E;12@2>2382@ 38 8
&&) 42= ?76;1
12 @2>2382@ ?2; C.;1 36 3>>.@26;76
&
12=2E7=21.8?76;15:C3A2838 42=;1267;.E.>3;.76 @3;2@*&
& .8 ;792 8
) 42=?76;1
+<=;12=.6=.D.6A .>2682;12@3;27E9.=;17E @2>2382@.8817C638(
&&36@;12@3;27E3>>.@26;
- 10 -
92.6A
& @2>2382@ C38 3A2@ :23=8 3; ;12 ;.?27E3>>.@26;36@;12=252D36;E3>;7=.8;792;3M2638 &*
>>7=@.6A5:57887E@2426@26>:>7?2838<6@2=/ J7E 8
))L&*
P 8
)
1.8 7<=; E.6@8 .; =238763952 ;7 3C3=@ 36 3?7<6; 8
) E7= E<62=35 2L426828
1<8 ;7;35 >7?42683;.76>7?28;7 8
)
12>7?42683;.763C3=@2@9:;12=.9<635C38 8
&()36@.;.8=2@<>2@;7 8
)
1<8 ;12 >53.?36;8 3=2 26;.;52@ ;7 8
) 3576A C.;1 .6;2=28; 3; ;12 =3;2 7E &J 42= 366<? E=7?
E=7? ;12 @3;2 7E 3>>.@26;;7;.55.;8=235.K3;.76
&
12 26;.=2 >7?42683;.76 3C3=@2@ 9: ;12 =.9<635 .8 35=23@: @2478.;2@ 9: ;1268<=36>2 7?436:
12=2E7=2 ;12 68<=36>2 7?436: .8 26;.;52@ E7= ;12 =2E<6@7E2L>2883?7<6;36@;12>53.?36;83=226;.;52@;7 8
)3576AC.;1.6;2=28;3>>=<2@76.;
- 11 -
&&
<; 7E ;12 83.@ 3?7<6; 8
&) 23>1 .8 3447=;.762@ ;7 43=26;8 7E ;12 @2>2382@ 36@ ;12: 3=2 42=?.;;2@;7C.;1@=3C;1283.@3?7<6;3576AC.;1.6;2=28;
&
;.88;3;2@;13;C.E27E;12@2>2382@=2?3==.2@ 12=2E7=2 93536>2 3?7<6; .8 ;7 92 M24; .6 + .6 ;12 63?2 7E ?.67= @3<A1;2= ;.55 812 3;;3.68 3A2 7E ?3B7=.;: 7;12=7E;12>1.5@.842=?.;;2@;7C.;1@=3C.6;2=28;76>2 .6;1=22?76;1;7?22;7<;12=2L426828 &*
?7<6; @2478.;2@ 9: ;12 68<=36>2 7?436: 92E7=2;1.87<=;.8;=368?.;;2@;7;12>76>2=62@7<=;
&
6 D.2C 7E ;12 397D2 ;12 344235 E.52@ 9: ;12 68<=36>27?436:.6+7
&).83557C2@.6 43=; 36@ ;12 344235 E.52@ 9: ;12 >53.?36;8 .6 + 7
&).8@.8?.882@ 8@) '& ( %
.8;7
/&57
/ / '