- 1 - !"# $"%"" "!! & '(')!*&'** + !"#"$% & ' ' !"#"$% & Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ' () ' ' ' '' (* $#$$% $$$% $*% ' ' + %" + ,- .//01-2 34 5$*% 54 6,- 738- 57 6,- 8-.94-2 2236354.8 -113541 02:- .8.;09.:3 31 3<=0:434: 6,- >02:<-46 57 /54?3/6354 2.6-2 $#$$% .42 592-9 57 1-46-4/- 2.6-2 $$$% /54?3/634: ,3< 759 6,- 577-4/- =0431,.;8- 042-9 -/6354 (* 57 423.4 -4.8 52- @759 1,596 A93.8 5096BC 1-46-4/34: ,3< 65 042-9:5 93:59501 3<=93154<-46 759 $% D-.91 .42 65 =.D 734-571"%%%%!E36,2-7.0861-46-4/- - 3 - ,-7./61576,-/.1-34;93-7.9-6,.66,-?3/63< $,.1852:-26,-7391634759<.6354.1=-9F$.:.3416 6,-.//01-2.88-:34:/5<<311354576,-577-4/-=0431,.;8- 042-9 -/6354 (* 57 6 31 ,-9 /546-46354 6,.6 1,- .854: E36, ,-9 ,01;.42 ! .42 ,-9 1316-9 ! .42 ,-9 9-8.63?- ! # .854: 56,-9 9-8.63?-1 ,.2 ;--4 65 .31,4.?3 .;. 54 %%% ,.2 6,- 2344-9 .42 18-=6 6,-9- 4 6,- -.98D ,5091 57 $%%* .6 )%% .< E,-4 6,- ?3/63< E.1 18--=34: .854: E36, ,-9 ,01;.42 1316-9.426,-9-8.63?-16,-.//01-2/.<-.42/5<<366-2 9.=- 54 ,-9 ,-4 6,- ?3/63< 1/9-.<-2 ,-9 ,01;.42 /.0:,6 ,582 57 6,- .//01-2 .88 6,- 56,-9 =-91541 /.<- 6,-9- .42 6,-D 3463<.6-2 6,- 583/- ,- 583/- /.<- 65 6,- 1=56 .42 655G 6,- .//01-2 65 6,- 583/- 6.6354 3/63< E.1 10;>-/6-2 65 <-23/.8 -F.<34.6354 76-9 34?-163:.63546,-734.89-=596/.<-65;-738-2,013631 6,- /546-46354 57 6,- =951-/06354 6,.6 6,- .//01-2 ,.1 /5<<366-2 6,- 577-4/- =0431,.;8- 042-9 -/6354 (* 57 - 4 - -.94-2 .:3169.6- 655G /5:43H.4/- 57 6,- 577-4/-.42/5<<366-26,-<.66-9656,--1135415096 ,-.//01-2.==-.9-2;-759-6,-93.85096=8-.2-2456 :0386D.42/8.3<-265;-693-2,-=951-/06354-F.<34-2 1$65$*:56<.9G-2F1$65.4232-46373-2 $65$$,-16.6-<-46576,-?3/63<042-9-/6354$*)57 9 E.1 32-46373-2 .1 F$ //01-2 2-43-2 .88 6,- 34/93<34.634:<.6-93.81.?.38.;8-549-/592;06,.14568-2 .4D -?32-4/- 34 10==596 57 ,31 2-7-4/- ,- 93.85096 6.G34: 3465 /54132-9.6354 .88 6,-1- <.6-93.81 54 9-/592 /.<-656,-/54/8013546,.66,-=951-/063543110//-11708 34 =95?34: 6,- :0386 57 6,- .//01-2 ;-D542 9-.154.;8- 250;6.42.//59234:8D=.11-26,-3<=0:4-2>02:<-4657 /54?3/6354.42592-9571-46-4/--34:.::93-?-2;D6,- 1.<-6,-.//01-231;-759-6,315096 ) -.92 311 .31,4.?3 .4:.4- 8-.94-2 /5041-87596,-.==-88.46.//01-2.42935=.8G931,4. .2.? 8-.94-2 3:, 5096 5?-94<-46 8-.2-9 759 6,- - 5 - 9-1=542-46 ! 6.6- -901-2 6,- <.6-93.81 54 9-/592 34/80234:6,-93.850969-/5921 " 4 ?3-E 57 6,- 93?.8 /546-463541 09:-2 ;D 8-.94-2/5041-817596,-=.963-16,-=53466,.6E5082.931- 759<D/54132-9.635431 D.41E-9656,-.;5?-=534631346,-A B 7596,-75885E34: * 6316,-/546-46354576,-=951-/063546,.654 %%%6,-?3/63<.854:E36,,-9,01;.421316-9.42 6,-9-8.63?-1E.118--=34:34.31,4.?3.;..76-9,.?34: 2344-9 4 $%% .6 )%% .< .//01-2 /.<- .42 /5<<366-29.=-546,-?3/63<4363.88D1,-6,50:,636E.1 ,-9 ,01;.42 ;06 54 9-.83H34: 6,.6 ,- 31 . 169.4:-9 1,- 16.96-21/9-.<34: -9,01;.42/.0:,6,582576,-=-9154 - 6 - .42 9-.83H-2 6,.6 36 E.1 6,- .//01-2 ! .1.?.9.> E,5 1-9?-27552656,-<546,-=9-?350143:,6<<-23.6-8D 6,-D/.88-26,-583/-.42,.42-25?-96,-.//01-2,-D ,.?- .815 :54- 65 6,- 583/- 6.6354 .42 738-2 6,- 73916 34759<.6354.1=-9F$ ( ,- ' /.<- 65 ;- 9-:316-9-2 .1 F$ ,- ?3/63< E.1 -F.<34-2 .1 $ ;-759- 6,- 93.8 5096 ,-16.6-29-:.9234:6,-34/32-46346,-/,3-7!-F.<34.6354 ,- .815 16.6-2 6,.6 ,-9 ,01;.42 /.0:,6 ,582 57 6,- .//01-2.42,-E.1,.42-25?-9656,-583/-88576,-< E-46656,-583/-6.6354659-:316-96,-';-34: 6,-,01;.42576,-?3/63<.8152-=51-213<38.98D#31 54- 57 6,- -D-E364-11-1 .//59234: 65 6,- /.1- 57 6,- =951-/06354E,5.81510==596-210/,/546-46354 # $* ! 6,- 583/- 773/-9 2-=51-2 6,.6 ,- .==9-,-42-2 6,- .//01-2 54 %% 795< 2316.46 =8./- .1 =-9 6,- 239-/63541 :3?-4 ;D 6,- 4?-163:.634: 773/-9$"I4?-163:.634: 773/-9.8152-=51-2;-759- 6,- 5096 6,.6 .76-9 9-:3169.6354 57 6,- ' .:.3416 6,- - 7 - .//01-2 ,- E.1 /.0:,6 ;D $* ,31 34/541316-4/D 34 6,--?32-4/-576,-=951-/06354E364-11-1:5-1656,-9556 57 6,- <.66-9 34 /544-/634: .//01-2 65 6,- 577-4/- 34 J0-16354 K ,- =951-/06354 ,.1 -F.<34-2 6,- 5/659 .1 $) E,5 -F.<34-2 6,- ?3/63< .42 =9520/-2 F1$* $(.42$#=95?31354.8.42734.8-23/.8-96373/.6-1 .42 6,- ' -96373/.6- 65 =95?- 6,- /546-46354 6,.6 1,- E.110;>-/6-2659.=-066,-=951-/06354,.1<31-9.;8D 7.38-2 65 /544-/6 6,- .//01-2 65 6,- 577-4/- 34 J0-16354 ,--?32-4/-576,-4?-163:.634: 773/-9.42$*:565 1,5E 6,.6 6,- .//01-2 E.1 456 /.0:,6 9-2 ,.42-2 .1 /8.3<-2;D6,-?3/63<.4256,-9-D-E364-11-1;06,-E.1 .==9-,-42-2 <0/, 8.6-9 ,- 34/541316-4/D 34 6,- /.1- <.2- 506 ;D 6,- =951-/06354 :5-1 65 6,- 9556 57 6,- <.66-942-910/,/39/0<16.4/-16,-;-4-73657250;631 65 ;- -F6-42-2 65 6,- .//01-2 .42 ,- 31 -46368-2 65 ;- ./J0366-2 - 8 - $% ,.?-:54-6,950:,6,-3<=0:4-2>02:<-4657 /54?3/6354.42592-9571-46-4/-=.11-2;D6,-93.85096 ,- 93.8 5096 656.88D 3:459-2 6,31 34/541316-4/D 34 32-4637D34:6,-.//01-2346,--?32-4/-571$.42# .1/5<=.9-2E36,$".42$*.42=95/--2-265/54?3/6 6,- .//01-2 ,-9-759- .< 57 6,- 5=34354 6,.6 6,- 3<=0:4-2>02:<-4657/54?3/6354.42592-9571-46-4/-31 388-:.8=-9?-91-.42.:.34166,-<.6-93.816,.6,.?-;--4 =8./-2;-759-6,-5096 -4/-.<576,-5=343546,.6 6,-1.<-3183.;8-65;-1-6.132- $$ 4?3-E576,-.;5?-.41E-96,-.;5?-=5346 346,- .42=95/--265=.116,-75885E34: 3 ,-93<34.8==-.831 33 ,- 3<=0:4-2 >02:<-46 57 /54?3/6354 $#$$% .42 592-9 57 -46-4/- 2.6-2 $$$% =.11-2 34 -113541 .1- 5$*%546,-738-578-.94-22236354.8 31693/6 .42 -113541 02:- .8.;09.:3 31 ,-9-;D 1-6 .132- 541-J0-468D 6,- - 9 - .==-88.46.//01-2 31 ./J0366-2 759 6,- 577-4/- =0431,.;8-042-9-/6354(*57 333 .38 ;542 57 6,- .==-88.46.//01-2 .42 6,.6 57 6,-39109-63-11,.8816.42/.4/-88-2 3? '34- .<5046 37 .4D 2-=5136-2 ;D 6,- .==-88.46.//01-2 31 592-9-2 65;-9-7042-265 ,3<.76-9.==-.8=-9352315?-9 ,-7--157<3/01093.-3173F-2.61$%%%%! -:3169D 65 1-42 ;./G 6,- 93.8 5096 9-/5921 .854: E36,/5=D576,31>02:<-4675934759<.6354.427594--2708 ./6354 ,& '""* % 3165$85)