Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 65853 (KAR)
SMT. NIRMALA AND ORS v. ARUNKUMAR J. BAHL PATIL CHAWL AND ANR
MFA/200126/2021 · 2025-11-19
H T Narendra Prasad, Tyagaraja N Inavally
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 65853 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 65853 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"#
$ %& $
%& "&#" $$
'#( )* $$ +
)
*
Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
! "
#
$
%
&
'
"
#
(
() %
&
"
"
$ *
+ , '
$ $ +&' $
$ "
) $
"
+
$ $" #
- 3 -
+)
*
-
%
&
'
! ! - 4 -
$
"
#
()
! "
#
(
%
&
$ !*
* '
$ $ +&' $
"
)
"
+
$ $" #
$ .$
"
/ "
/ "
"
- 5 -
& & / "
'
$ 0 ! 12 31456 78 9:5 ;4<1=<>92 ?:5@5<2 $ 0 )
12 31456 78 9:5 >2A@<>;5 0=B<>8A>65@5;910>+&'039:5090@5:1;452 ;9 ,)) &:5@51><395@ @535@@56 90 <2 C9:5 ;9. 30@ 2:0@9' ;:<445>D1>D 9:5 EA6D=5>9 <>6 <?<@6 6<956 ) B<225678 6645>10@1F14"A6D5<>6 16<@1> 02
+
$<;92 D1F1>D @125 90 9:5 3141>D 03 9:5 <BB5<42 7@15348 29<956 <@5 9:<9 0> ) ! 9:5 65;5<256 <16<BB< <40>D ?19: :12 ?135 <>6 09:5@ B5@20>2 ?<2 B@0;5561>D 1> <A90@1;G2:<?75<@1>D@5D129@<910>0 H,
!++90?<@62 <>><HG:5441 F144<D5 :5> 9:58 @5<;:56 >5<@ 1@>< @022 <9 9:<9 91=5 < D0062 F<> 75<@1>D @5D129@<910> 0H
$"H!) ?:1;: ?<2 751>D 6@1F5> 1> < @<2: <>6 >5D41D5>9 =<>>5@ ;<=5 3@0= 0BB02195 2165 <>6 6<2:56 <D<1>29 9:5 <A90 @1;G2:<? 2 < @52A49 03 9:5 <30@52<16
- 6 -
<;;165>9 9:5 65;5<256 <16<BB< 2A29<1>56 D@15F0A2 1>EA@152<>62A;;A=756909:51>EA@152
:5 ;4<1=<>92 31456 < B591910> A>65@ 5;910> !! 03 9:5 ;9 255G1>D ;0=B5>2<910> 30@ 9:5 65<9: 03 9:5 65;5<256<40>D?19:1>95@529
B0> 25@F1;5 03 >091;5 9:5 @52B0>65>9 0 <BB5<@56 9:@0AD: ;0A>254 <>6 31456 ?@1995> 29<95=5>9 65>81>D 9:5 <F5@=5>92 =<65 1> 9:5 ;4<1= B591910> :5 @52B0>65>90652B19525@F1;503>091;5616>09<BB5<@ 7530@59:5@17A><4<>6?<2B4<;565IHB<@95
> 9:5 7<212 03 9:5 B45<61>D2 03 9:5 B<@9152 9:5 4<1=2@17A><43@<=569:5122A52<>69:5@5<395@@5;0@656 9:5 5F165>;5 :5 @17A><4 78 1=BAD>56 EA6D=5>9 <>6 <?<@6:<2B<@948<440?569:5;4<1=B591910><>6:5469:<9 9:5 ;4<1=<>92 <@5 5>919456 90 < ;0=B5>2<910> 03 2 ,)
H<40>D?19:1>95@529<99:5@<9503,JB< <>6 61@5;956 9:5 @52B0>65>9 0 90 65B0219 9:5 ;0=B5>2<910> <=0A>9 <40>D ?19: 1>95@529 51>D <DD@15F569:5B@525>9<BB5<4:<2755>31456
- 7 -
! :545<@>56;0A>25430@9:5;4<1=<>92:<2@<12569:5 30440?1>D;0>95>910>2 <' $1@2948 9:5 ;4<1=<>92 <225@9 9:<9 9:5 65;5<256 ?<2 <D56<70A985<@2<99:591=5039:5<;;165>9<>6:<6< =0>9:481>;0=503 2
H78?0@G1>D<2<D@1;A49A@129 <>66@1F5@0?5F5@9:5<22522=5>903=0>9:481>;0=503 9:5 65;5<256 <9 2+
H 78 9:5 @17A><4 12 A>EA2913156 <>65@@0>50A2 7' 5;0>648 <2 B5@ 9:5 EA6D=5>9 03 9:5 0>.745 AB@5=5 0A@9 1> 9:5 ;<25 03 ,# - &
.5<;:039:5;4<1=<>92125>91945690;0=B5>2<910> 03 2
HA>65@9:5:5<603C40220340F5<>6<335;910> <>6;0>20@91A=. ;' :1@6481>@52B5;90341<71419812;0>;5@>569:120A@9 1> $ 0 ;
?
$
0 612B02560> , <@121>D0A9039:52<=5<;;165>9 :<2 :546 9:<9 9:5 >2A@<>;5 0=B<>8 12 41<745 90 B<8
- 8 -
;0=B5>2<910> ?19: 9:5 4175@98 90 @5;0F5@ 9:5 2<=5 3@0= 9:50?>5@039:50335>61>DF5:1;45 19: 9:5 <70F5 ;0>95>910>2 9:5 45<@>56 ;0A>254 20AD:990<440?9:5<BB5<4 + > 9:5 09:5@ :<>6 9:5 45<@>56 ;0A>254 30@ 9:5 >2A@<>;5 0=B<>8 :<2 @<1256 9:5 30440?1>D ;0A>95@H ;0>95>910>2 <' $1@2948 <49:0AD: 9:5 ;4<1=<>92 ;4<1= 9:<9 9:5 65;5<256 ?<2 5<@>1>D 2
H B5@ =0>9: 5I;5B9 B@06A;1>D 9:5 6@1F1>D 41;5>25 03 9:5 65;5<256 9:58 :<F5 >09 B@06A;56 <>8 09:5@ 60;A=5>9 90 2A729<>91<95 9:51@ ;4<1= 0>25KA5>948 9:5 @17A><4 :<2 ;0@@5;948 <2252256 9:51>;0=5039:565;5<256>0910><448 7' 5;0>648 0> <BB@5;1<910> 03 0@<4 <>6 60;A=5>9<@8 5F165>;5 <>6 ;0>2165@1>D 9:5 <D5 <>6 <F0;<910> 03 9:5 65;5<256 9:5 0F5@<44 ;0=B5>2<910> <?<@656 78 9:5 @17A><412EA29<>6@5<20><745 ;' :1@6481>41D:9039:51F1210>5>;:65;1210>039:12 0A@91>9:5;<2503 &" ,
- 9 -
# # # ' !)
$
+
(9:5@<95031>95@529<?<@656789:5@17A><4 <9,JB<0>9:5;0=B5>2<910><=0A>9120>9:5:1D:5@ 2165 6' <2948>@52B5;90341<71419812;0>;5@>56<20>9:5 6<95 03 9:5 <;;165>9 9:5 6@1F5@ 03 9:5 0335>61>D F5:1;45 ?<2>09:0461>D<F<416<>65335;91F56@1F1>D41;5>;51>;5 9:5 1>2A@56 :<2 F104<956 9:5 B041;8 ;0>61910>2 9:5 >2A@<>;50=B<>812>0941<74590B<8;0=B5>2<910>A9 9:5 @17A><4 :<2 5@@56 1> 3<295>1>D 41<714198 0> 9:5 >2A@<>;50=B<>8 19: 9:5 <70F5 ;0>95>910>2 9:5 45<@>56 ;0A>254 20AD:990612=1229:5<BB5<4
) 5<@6 9:5 45<@>56 ;0A>254 30@ 9:5 B<@9152 <>6 B5@A2569:5EA6D=5>9<>6<?<@6039:5@17A><4 , 9 12 >09 1> 612BA95 9:<9 <16<BB< 6156 1> 9:5 @0<6 9@<331; <;;165>9 0;;A@@56 0> ) ! 6A5 90 @<2: <>6 >5D41D5>96@1F1>D039:50335>61>DF5:1;45781926@1F5@
- 10 -
:5 ;4<1=<>92 ;4<1= 9:<9 65;5<256 ?<2 5<@>1>D 2
H B5@ =0>9: 7A9 3<1456 90 B@06A;5 2ABB0@91>D 60;A=5>92 5I;5B9 6@1F1>D 41;5>25 90 2A729<>91<95 9:51@ ;4<1= 0>2165@1>D 9:5 @1F1>D 41;5>25HI <D5 <>6 <F0;<910>039:565;5<256?5<@5039:50B1>10>9:<99:5 =0>9:48 1>;0=5 03 65;5<256 :<2 90 75 <2252256 <2 2
HB5@=0>9:09:5<30@52<161>;0=5@17A><4 :<2 @1D:948 <6656 J 0> <;;0A>9 03 3A9A@5 B@02B5;92 1> F15?039:54<?4<1660?>789:50>2919A910>5>;:039:5 AB@5=5 0A@9 1> 9:5 ;<25 03
! "# $# %&
' " (
(')*:A29:5=0>9:481>;0=5;0=5290 2
H 1>;5 9:5@5 <@5 31F5 65B5>65>92 @17A><4 :<2 @1D:948 656A;956
9: 03 9:5 1>;0=5 03 9:5 65;5<256 90?<@62 B5@20><45IB5>252<>6@5=<1>1>D<=0A>9:<290759<G5> <2:12;0>9@17A910>909:53<=148:565;5<256?<2<D56 <70A985<@2<99:591=5039:5<;;165>9<>6=A491B415@ <BB41;<74590:12<D5D@0AB12C.:A29:5;4<1=<>92<@5 5>919456 90 ;0=B5>2<910> 03 /
)
- 11 -
& 2 LLL
' 0> <;;0A>9 03 C4022 03 65B5>65>;8. > <661910> 9:5 ;4<1=<>92 <@5 5>919456 90 ;0=B5>2<910> 03 /) 0> <;;0A>9 03 C4022 03 529<95.
<>6 ;0=B5>2<910> 03 /) 0> <;;0A>9 03 C3A>5@<45IB5>252. >F15?039:54<?4<1660?>789:5AB@5=50A@91> 9:5 ;<25 03 0 1 &2AB@<' ;4<1=<>9 0 ?135 03 9:5 65;5<256 12 5>919456 30@ ;0=B5>2<910> 03/+) A>65@9:5 :5<603 /402203 2B0A2<4;0>20@91A=/;4<1=<>902<>6H;:146@5>03 9:5 65;5<256 <@5 5>919456 30@ ;0=B5>2<910> 03 /+) 5<;: A>65@ 9:5 :5<6 03 C4022 03 B<@5>9<4 ;0>20@91A=.<>6;4<1=<>90H=09:5@039:565;5<25612 5>91945630@;0=B5>2<910>03/+)5<;:A>65@9:5 :5<603C4022033141<4;0>20@91A=. :5 ;0=B5>2<910> 03 2+
H <?<@656 78 9:5 @17A><4A>65@9:5:5<603C=561;<45IB5>252.127<2560>
- 12 -
9:5=561;<471442B@06A;56789:5;4<1=<>92<>612655=56 EA29<>6@5<20><745
> @52B5;9 03 41<714198 12 ;0>;5@>56 9:12 0A@9 1> $ 0
;
? $ 0
612B0256 0> , <@121>D0A9039:52<=5<;;165>9:<2:546 9:<99:5>2A@<>;50=B<>81241<74590B<8;0=B5>2<910> ?19:9:54175@9890@5;0F5@9:52<=53@0=9:50?>5@039:5 0335>61>DF5:1;45
:A2 9:5 ;4<1=<>92 <@5 5>919456 90 9:5 30440?1>D ;0=B5>2<910> 2345/678595:4; :84;45746:/ <;8=956> / <7?8/ 9;7 / 0220365B5>65>;8
+ $A>5@<45IB5>252
02203529<95
022032B0A2<4;0>20@91A=
02203<@5>9<4;0>20@91A= H
02203$141<4;0>20@91A= H
- 13 -
561;<41442 + + 76>
!+@ + @+@
! >9:5@52A499:530440?1>D0@65@12B<2256
<' :5<BB5<42<@56>>A4:8536;7 7' :5EA6D=5>9039:54<1=2@17A><412=0613156 ;' :5 ;4<1=<>92 <@5 5>919456 90 < 909<4 ;0=B5>2<910> 03 /+ @+@) <2 <D<1>29 2 ,)
H<?<@656789:5@17A><4 6' $0440?1>D9:5EA6D=5>9039:51F1210>5>;:03 9:12 0A@9 1> 9:5 ;<25 03 C &" . &2AB@<' 9:5 5>91@5 ;0=B5>2<910> 2:<44 ;<@@8 1>95@529<9!JB< 5' :5 >2A@<>;5 0=B<>8 12 61@5;956 90 65B0219 9:5;0=B5>2<910><=0A>9<40>D?19:1>95@529<9 !J B< 3@0= 9:5 6<95 03 3141>D 03 9:5 ;4<1= B591910> 9144 9:5 6<95 03 @5<41M<910> ?19:1> < B5@1060321I?55G23@0=9:56<9503@5;51B903<
- 14 -
;0B8 03 9:12 EA6D=5>9 0?5F5@ 4175@98 12 @525@F56 90 9:5 >2A@<>;5 0=B<>8 90 @5;0F5@ 9:5 2<=5 3@0= 9:5 0?>5@ 03 9:5 0335>61>D F5:1;45 3' :5 <BB0@910>=5>9 65B0219 <>6 @545<25 03 <=0A>9 2:<44 75 =<65 1> <;;0@6<>;5 ?19: 9:5 95@=2039:5<?<@6039:5@17A><4 D' :5 <=0A>9 1> 65B0219 12 0@65@56 90 75 9@<>235@@56909:5@17A><4
:) '$ ( &
:) '"&#"( &
129040