Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 65851 (KAR)
ALAMGIR MASJID AND SARKARI v. STATE OF KARNATAKA
WP/203338/2025 · 2025-11-05
M G S Kamal
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 65851 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 65851 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"#
$#% # #
&#'
! "
#
$
%& %
!!! '
& (
!!! Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
)
%&
%&
! "
#
*
'* &
)$
%
''
''+ $ %&
) !'!'
! ''
'
(* $ %
') !'!' %
(
'
(*
$
%
,
, -
#,-
$
./0/012.3452560261770//..3.83.9.2/.:;<0/9 3.90:.2/09;.=13./>091?3/9..@026=1AA1B0263.A0.=9,
!"#$#"%"&'(")%
- 3 -
*
+
! , )!-
* . ! , )
. /
. + ! , )#-
0
' .532.: .2013 1?29.A 588.53026 =13 />. C1?29.A =13 />. 8./0/012.3 /5@026 />09 1?3/ />31?6> />. 3.C13:9 713. 853/0C?A53A< /1 22.D?3. B>0C> 09 5 C177?20C5/012 :5/.: +!)'!' 099?.: ;< />. 09/30C/ %5E===0C.30F5<58?355::3.99.:/1/>.>0.=D.C?/0G. ==0C.3 5325/5@5 /5/. 153: 1= ?E5=
.265A?3? 9?;70/9/>5/5=/.3C178A052C.B0/>/>.3.E?03.:831G090129 1= A5B 52: />. 3?A.9 52: 02 =?3/>.352C. /1 />. 1:.A C>.7. 1= :70209/35/012 257.9 1= 7.7;.39 /1 />. 5256026 1770//..1= %5@=29/0/?/012 257.A< A57603 59F0: 52: 53@530 .6?7 1?H5 5?;56 15:
0F5<58?35 5A?@ 52:
09/30C/ B59 =025A0H.: >5/ ;< />. 950: C177?20C5/012
09/30C/ %5E= ==0C.3 >5:
- 4 -
3.C177.2:.: /1 C1290:.3 />. 8318195A /1 C129/0/?/. 8./0/012.35256026 1770//.. 52: >5: 91?6>/ =13 2.C.9953< 13:.39 02 />5/ ;.>5A= >5/ 3.9812:.2/ 1' 4 %5E=
153: B0/>1?/ /5@026 52< 5C/012 13 8599026 52< 13:.39 />.3.12 099?.: ==0C. 3:.3 :5/.: ) !'!' 59 8.322.D?3.831819026/1588102/%5E===0C.3 09/30C/ %5E= :G0913< 1770//.. 0F5<58?35 09/30C/ 59 5 C53./5@.3 /1/>. 9?;F.C/ %5E= 29/0/?/012 >5/ 12C. />. 09/30C/ %5E= ==0C.3 3.C177.2:.: =13 C129/0/?/012 1= C1770//..C12909/0261= 7.7;.39/>.3.9812:.2/1' %5E=
153:C1?A:21/>5G.1802.:/>5//>.3.09G5C??7 02 61G.3252C. 52: 5:70209/35/012 1= />. 5==5039 1= />. 9?;F.C/B5E=029/0/?/012B53352/026588102/7.2/1=5%5E= ==0C.3595C53./5@.3>?9>.9?;70/9/>5//>.078?62.: 13:.3098.3G.39.52:53;0/353<
) 2 3.98129. 30 5A085/0A A.532.: C1?29.A 588.53026 =13 3.9812:.2/ 1' 4 %5E=
153: />31?6> G0:.1 C12=.3.2C. 9?;70/9 />5/ />1?6> 9?C> 5 3.C177.2:5/012 B59 75:. ;< />. 09/30C/ %5E= ==0C.3
- 5 -
2113:.3>59;..28599.:/0AA:5/.>090902G0.B1=/>. =5C/ />5/ C.3/502 5AA.65/0129 B.3. 75:. 565029/ />. .7;.39 1= />. 831819.: C1770//.. B>0C> 3.E?03.: =?3/>.35C/012025CC13:52C.B0/>A5B>5/902C./>.950: 831C.99 B1?A:
;. /07. C129?7026 />. 13:.3 5/ 22.D?3. C57. /1 ;. 8599.: 588102/026 />. %5@= ==0C.3 59 />. C53./5@.3 B>0C> 09 02 =?3/>.352C. /1 ?;
3?A.#$1=?A.I1=/>.5325/5@5%5@=?A.9'! +. 9?;70/9/>5//>.8./0/012.309/>.3.=13.>5921. /17502/502/>.8./0/012
I 30 0<5E5/ 53..: 9/5: A.532.: C1?29.A 588.53026=13/>.3.9812:.2/1)4 09/30C/%5E===0C.3 9?;70//026/>.9/5/.7.2/1=1;F.C/012952:/>..2CA19?3. />.3./1 9?;70/9 />5/ 8?39?52/ /1 />. 5AA.65/0129 1= 709588318305/012 75:. 565029/ />. .39/B>0A. 7.7;.39 1= />.52560261770//..521/0C.>595A3.5:<;..2099?.:
C5AA026?812 />.7 /1 =?3209> />. .D8A525/012 . 9?;70/9 />5/ />. 950: 831C.99 09 ?2:.3B5< 52: />.3.=13. 02 />. C03C?79/52C.9 />. %5E= ==0C.3 09/30C/ 0F5<58?35 >59
- 6 -
;..2 588102/.: 59 />.
C53./5@.3 >5/ 9>1?A: />. 8./0/012.39>5G.52<630.G52C./>.<75<>5G./1.D>5?9/ />.03 3.7.:< 5G50A5;A. ?2:.3 />. A5B 257.A< >5G026 3.C1?39./1/>.831G0901291=/>.%5E=C/;.=13./>.%5E= 30;?25A.2C.9..@9=13:0970995A1=/>.8./0/012
.53:.3?9.:/>.3.C13:9
22.D?3. />. C177?20C5/012 099?.: ;< />. 09/30C/%5E===0C.3:5/.: +!)'!'3.5:959?2:.3, 1234"&'("#$#"55"5)"52 67""
# 8,
/ 4
+
! !19!:4(8
;
6 #
$
#
!. $ <
+
(= ; 1
( ; &< * ; $
* !. $ < # 1 /
$ ( ;&< *
( 6
> #. 1 3"!2$"8" #("5")2 6
> #. 1 3"!2$"#("57" )2 6??%
> #. 1 3"!2$"#("@" )2 657
- 7 -
;!. $ <
+
(= ; 1
( ; &< *
= 1 3
A
* & 9 = 1
13""!!"?752 65?75 .17@
#*
9 =
1 . $
#
/ !"#$#"5?"&'(")2 655
, 55 * > 4 . B
; ! / *
/ !"4!""&'(") 2 67
$ . ! 9 . * $
3
.. %5 *
/ ' A *
$
B
C5' *
/ . 8. / C
.*
3
9 . * ( . 2 6%5
.. /
B . / 234"&'("#$#" 55"5)" 2 6
=
.. <
"
1 <
"
/
.. *DE
3 #
.. (
1@ 2 6553 +#
A ..); ! 6")/ ..* ; E
* +.*
. $
#
* . ! .* . +*;
F ..*;
") 2
3 4 2
3 4 &< *
0
- 8 -
+ .3?95A 1= />. 5=13.950: C177?20C5/012 B1?A:
02:0C5/. />5/ 5 A09/ 1= 7.7;.39 8?3813/.:A< .A.C/.:
?252071?9A< >59 ;..2 =13B53:.: ;< />. 09/30C/ %5E= ==0C.3 /1 />. >0.= D.C?/0G. ==0C.3 5325/5@5 /5/. 153:1=%5E==13C1290:.35/0121=/>.8318195A>.950: C177?20C5/012>5921/3.9?A/.:0252<A160C5AC12CA?9012 .0/>.3020/95CC.8/52C.13020/93.F.C/0122/0A52:?2A.99 />. 957. 09 .0/>.3 5CC.8/.: 13 3.F.C/.: 8./0/012.3 1770//.. C5221/ CA507 59 5 75//.3 1= 306>/ /1 ;. 588102/.: 59 />. 5256026 1770//.. 1= />. 9?;F.C/ 1770//.. / 9/52:9 12A< 5/ />. 9/56. 1= 8318195A 21/ ;.<12:
>1?6> 22.D?3. B>0C> 09 52 ==0C. 3:.3 :5/.: ) !'!' 099?.: ;< />. 3.9812:.2/ 1' 4%5E= 153:831819.9/1588102//>.%5E===0C.31=/>. 09/30C/ %5E= :G0913< 1770//..
59 5 C53./5@.3 1= />. 9?;F.C/ 029/0/?/012 02 =?3/>.352C. /1 81B.3 C12=.33.: ?2:.3 ?;
3?A.#$1=?A.I1=/>.5325/5@5%5E=?A.9'! +/>. 957.831C..:912/>.83.709.1=/>.3.;.026215256026
- 9 -
1770//..902C.!I!I'!'/>.3.09213.=.3.2C.02/>. 950: 13:.3 /1 />. 5=13.950: C177?20C5/012 :5/.:
+!)'!' 5/ 22.D?3. 3.C177.2:026 />. 257.9 1= 7.7;.39 /1 ;. 588102/.: 59 5256026 1770//.. A.53A<22.D?3.3.5:02/>.A06>/1=22.D?3.B1?A:
02:0C5/. />5/ />. 3.9812:.2/ 1' 4 %5E=
153: >59 21/ /5@.2 52< :.C09012 12 />. 3.C177.2:5/012 75:. ;< />. 09/30C/%5E===0C.3
J >1?6>A.532.:C1?29.A=13/>.3.9812:.2/1' 4 %5E=
153: 52: />. 09/30C/ :G0913< 1770//.. G.>.7.2/A< 9?;70/ />5/ />. 3.5912 =13 21/ /5@026 52< :.C09012 12 22.D?3. 09 />. 5AA.65/012 1= 709588318305/01275:.565029//>.7.7;.391=8./0/012.3 452560261770//../>.957.09A.=//1/>.:09C3./012 1=/>. 153:/1831C..:025CC13:52C.B0/>A5B
! %0/>1?/ 5:G.3/026 /1 />. 957. />. 83.9.2/ 8./0/012 09 :03.C/026 />. 3.9812:.2/ 1' 4 %5E=
153: /1 C1290:.3 />. C177?20C5/012 =13B53:.: ;<
- 10 -
/>. 09/30C/ %5E= ==0C.3 5/ 22.D?3. 52: 8599 588318305/. 13:.3 12. B5< 13 />. 1/>.3 B0/>02 52 1?/.3 A070/1=)!:5<9=317/>.:5/.1=/>.3.C.08/1=C18<1=/>09 13:.3
/ 09 75:. CA.53 />5/ />. 3.9812:.2/ 1' 4 %5E=
153: 9>5AA 5A91 8.39125AA< >.53 />. 09/30C/ %5E= ==0C.3;.=13./5@02652<:.C0901202/>.75//.3
() &# #' %
% 09/1, A1, ,