Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 65850 (KAR)

MOHAMAD GAUSE v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA

CRL.A/200092/2025 · 2025-08-06

M G Uma

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - !"!! !## $%& '(#)* +'), - !! " # $ % ! ! !! &&' ( ! ! !# ) ! " ! !* $ !! % &"$ % ! # !! + , ! "! $ -- % + % "! $ Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - % %% ! -&"$---'"$".$! %! % ) !! # !! % % % !! % % + # / + "! "! / + $ 01 2331442.5 617.8 501 299:;1< 7. 319724 2;1 "! $=--=.501>741=>501412?.1<<<757=.24 7;5?7952.< 1;;7=.;+:<81% "! $25 2426:?287 "7.=-=>2802@1.<?2282?!=4791 5257=.$7; 7A3:8.7.8 501 B:<8A1.5 => 9=.@7957=. 2.< =?<1? => ;1.51.91 <251< ,50 =@1A61? 9=.@7957.8 07A >=? 501=>>1.91;3:.7;02641:.<1? 1957=.;-&"$---- => 501 .<72. !1.24 =<1 ">=? ;0=?5 C501 !D$ 2.< 1957=. => 501 !?=51957=. => 074<?1. >?=A 1E:24 >>1.91; 95 F>=? ;0=?5 C501 ! 95DG 2.< ;1.51.97.8 07A 5= :.<1?8= ?78=?=:; 7A3?7;=.A1.5 >=? 2 - 3 - 31?7=< => -& H12?; >=? 501 =>>1.91 3:.7;02641 :.<1? 1957=. => 501 ! 95 I750 >7.1 => ;*5=:.<1?8=7A3?7;=.A1.5>=?H12?;>=?501 =>>1.913:.7;02641:.<1? 1957=.-&"$=>!I750>7.1 =>;*5=:.<1?8=7A3?7;=.A1.5>=?&H12?;>=?501 =>>1.91 3:.7;02641 :.<1? 1957=. -- => ! I750 >7.1 => ;* 2.< 5= :.<1?8= 7A3?7;=.A1.5 >=? H12? >=? 501=>>1.913:.7;02641:.<1? 1957=.--=>!I750>7.1 =>;I750<1>2:45;1.51.91; %295; => 501 92;1 7. 6?71> 2?1 5025 =. -501>2501?=>501@7957A87?44=<81<501A7;;7.8 9=A3427.5 ;:;31957.8 5025 299:;1< 02; J7<.2331< 501 @7957A % 92A1 5= 61 ?187;51?1< .@1;578257=. I2; :.<1?52J1..-501299:;1<2.<@7957AI1?1 >=:.<5=81501?01@7957AI2;?1;9:1<2.<299:;1<I2; 233?101.<1< 7957A I2; ;:6B1951< 5= A1<7924 1E2A7.257=.>51?7.@1;578257=.902?81;011592A15=61 >741< 99=?<7.8 5= 501 92;1 => 501 3?=;19:57=. 501 299:;1<9=AA7551<501=>>1.913:.7;02641:.<1? 1957=.; - 4 - -&"$ -- -' "$ ".$ 2.< -- => ! 2.< :.<1? 1957=.=>501! 95 - 12?.1< 287;5?251 5==J 9=8.7K2.91 => 501 =>>1.91 2.< ;:AA=.1< 501 299:;1< 01 299:;1< 23312?1< 61>=?1 501 ?724 =:?5 3412<1< .=5 8:745H 2.< 9427A1< 5= 61 5?71< !?=;19:57=. 1E2A7.1< !#; 5= 8=5A2?J1< E;!5=!&2.<7<1.57>71<;5=7. ;:33=?5 => 75; 9=.51.57=. 01299:;1< 02;<1.71<244 501 7.9?7A7.257.8 A251?724; 2@2742641 =. ?19=?< 2.< 1E2A7.1< #; 2.<7.;:33=?5=> 07;<1>1.91 01 ?724 =:?5 2>51? 52J7.8 7.5= 9=.;7<1?257=. 244 501;1 A251?724; =. ?19=?< 92A1 5= 501 9=.94:;7=. 5025 501 3?=;19:57=. 7; ;:991;;>:4 7. 3?=@7.8 8:745 => 501 299:;1< >=? =>>1.91; 3:.7;02641 :.<1? 1957=.; -&"$ -- -' "$ ".$ 2.< -- => ! 2.< 1957=. => 501 ! 95 2.< 299=?<7.84H ;1.51.91< 07A 2; ;5251< 26=@1 17.8 288?71@1<6H501;2A1501299:;1<7;61>=?1507;=:?5 - 5 - 12?< ?7 0?702?;022?I24412?.1<9=:.;14 >=? 501 2331442.5 2.< ?7 =324J7?;0.2 2<2@ 412?.1< 780 =:?5 =@1?.A1.5 !412<1? >=? ?1;3=.<1.5 = 52511;3=.<1.5=50=:80;1?@1<02;?1A27.1<:. ?13?1;1.51< & . @71I => 501 ?7@24 9=.51.57=.; :?81< 6H 412?.1<9=:.;14>=?6=5050132?571;5013=7.55025I=:4< 2?7;1>=?AH9=.;7<1?257=.7; H2.;I1?5=50126=@13=7.57;7.501CD >=?501>=44=I7.8 99=?<7.8 5= 501 92;1 A2<1 =:5 6H 501 3?=;19:57=. 501 @7957A !# I2; 281< 'L H12?; 99:;1< 02< ;524J1< 501 @7957A 87?4 I750 ;1E:24 7.51.5 7.<:91< 01? 5= 02@1 ;1E:24 7.51?9=:?;1 J7<.2331< 01? - 6 - >?=A42I>:48:2?<72.;0739=AA7551<?231?131251<4H>?=A ,-5744- 01I2;;:6B1951<5=I?=.8>:4 9=.>7.1A1.5 2.< 501?16H 01 02; 9=AA7551< 501 =>>1.91; 3:.7;02641:.<1? 1957=.;-&"$---'"$".$-- =>!2.< 1957=.=>501! 95 ' !# 7. 01? 1@7<1.91 ;5251< 61>=?1 501 ?724 =:?55025299:;1<7;01??14257@12.<01:;1<5=9=A15= 01? 0=:;1 2.< I2; >?71.<4H I750 01? 99:;1< 9=AA7551< ?231 =. 01? I750 2 3?=A7;1 5= A2??H 01? 01 92441< 299:;1<=.-2.<299:;1<2;J1<01?5=9=A15= :A627 1 ;1.5 ; 2.< 299=?<7.84H ;01 ?12901< :A6272.<;52H1<7.07;0=:;1I01?1019=AA7551<?231 ?131251<4H E! 7; 501 ;5251A1.5 => 501 @7957A ?19=?<1< :.<1? 1957=. => ?! 6H 501 412?.1< 287;5?251 I01?1 ;01 02; ;5251< 5025 ;01 I2; 7. 4=@1 I750 501 299:;1<2.<;01I2;I7447.85=A2??H07A=I1@1?01? 32?1.5; 02@1 ?1>:;1< 5= 815 01? A2??71< 5= 501 299:;1< - 7 - =;0102<92441<501299:;1<2.<2;J1<07A5=2??2.81 >=?A=.1H012??2.81<>=?;2.<299=?<7.84H;01 41>55010=:;12.<8=.1I750501299:;1< , !# 7; 501 >2501? => 501 9=A3427.2.5 1 <13=;1<50252;501@7957AI2;A7;;7.8014=<81<501>7?;5 7.>=?A257=. 2.< 4251? 501 @7957A 2.< 299:;1< I1?1 >=:.< 5=81501?!#7;501=95=?I0=1E2A7.1<501@7957A2.< 7;;:1< 501 A1<7924 91?57>79251 2; 31? E! 01 >7.24 =37.7=.I2;J13531.<7.82I2757.8% ?13=?5 E!7; 501 % ?13=?5 299=?<7.8 5= I0790 ;1A7.24 ;527.; 2.< ;31?A25=K=2I1?1.=5<151951<7.2.H=>501;2A341;; 31? 501 >7.24 =37.7=. E!- 501?1 7; .= 1@7<1.91 => ?191.5;1E:247.51?9=:?;1 57;501<1>1.9152J1.6H501299:;1<5025501 @7957A I2; .=5 2 A7.=? 6:5 ;01 I2; 2 A2B=? 281< A=?1 502.H12?;2.<75I2;29=.;1.;:24295.5025?182?< 299:;1< 1E2A7.1< # I0= 7; .=.1 =501? 502. 501 A=501?=>501@7957A2.<#5016?=501?=>501@7957A - 8 - 01 3?=;19:57=. ?1471< =. 501 1@7<1.91 => !# 501 12<A2;51? => 501 =@1?.A1.5 ?<: 780 90==4 2.< 91?57>79251 E! ; 31? E! 501 @7957A ;5:<71< ,50 2.< 50 ;52.<2?< 7. 501 780 90==4 2.< 2; 31? ;90==4 ?19=?<;01?<251=>67?507; ;31? 1957=.,=>501+:@1.741+:;5791"2?1 2.<!?=51957=.=>074<?1.$95&501281=>B:@1.741 =>>1.<1?7;5=61<151?A7.1<6H>=44=I7.85013?=91<:?12; ;5251<501?17.57;501;15541<3=;757=.=>42I50251@1. 7.92;1=>@7957A7.501! 95;2A13?=91<:?17;5=61 >=44=I1< 2; 3?=@7<1< :.<1? +:@1.741 +:;5791 "2?1 2.< !?=51957=.=>074<?1.$95%=?<151?A7.7.8501281=>501 A7.=?61752@7957A=?29074<7.9=.>4795I75042I501<251 => 67?50 91?57>79251 >?=A 501 ;90==4 => A25?79:4257=. =? 1M:7@241.5 91?57>79251 >?=A 501 9=.91?.1< E2A7.257=. =2?< 9=:4< 61 52J1. 2; 1@7<1.91 5= 3?=@1 501 <251 => 67?50 01 67?50 91?57>79251 7;;:1< 6H 2 =?3=?257=. =? 2 :.797324:50=?75H=?2!2.902H2592.24;=61?1471<=. .50126;1.91=>2.H=>501;1<=9:A1.5;=;;7>79257=.51;5 - 9 - I=:4< 61 9=.<:951< 5= <151?A7.1 501 281 :5 7. 501 3?1;1.5 92;1 E! <=1; .=5 >244 :.<1? 2.H => 501;1 92518=?71; 01 67?50 91?57>79251 => 501 2:50=?75H 7; .=5 3?=<:91< 01 A25?79:4257=. =? 1M:7@241.5 91?57>79251 7; 24;=.=53?=<:91<.<1?;:9097?9:A;52.91;2A=>501 =37.7=. 5025 501 3?=;19:57=. 7; .=5 ;:991;;>:4 7. 3?=@7.8 501281=>501@7957AI7503?197;7=.#01.5013?=;19:57=. 02;.=53?=@1<5025501@7957AI2;2A7.=?5013?=@7;7=.; =>! 9592..=561255?2951< #01. 75 7; .=5 3?=@1< 5025 501 @7957A I2; 2 A7.=? 501 ;5251A1.5 => 501 @7957A :.<1? 1957=. ?! ?19=?<1< 6H 501 412?.1< 287;5?251 2;;:A1; 7A3=?52.912;501@7957A;5251<5025;01I2;7.4=@1I750 501 299:;1< 2.< I1.5 I750 07A @=4:.52?74H I750 2. 7.51.57=. 5= A2??H 07A 01 A1<7924 91?57>79251 <7;94=;1; .= 1@7<1.91 => ?191.5 ;1E:24 7.51?9=:?;1 .<1? ;:90 97?9:A;52.91; 501 61.1>75 => <=:65 I744 02@1 5= 61 1E51.<1<5=501299:;1<2.<017;1.57541<>=?29M:75524 - 10 - - 02@18=.150?=:805017A3:8.1<B:<8A1.5=> 9=.@7957=. 2.< =?<1? => ;1.51.91 7. 501 47805 => 501 <7;9:;;7=.; 014< 26=@1 01 ?724 =:?5 3?=911<1< 5= 9=.@795501299:;1<I750=:5501?1617.82.H62;7;5=>=?A ;:90 2. =37.7=. 01?1>=?1 2A => 501 =37.7=. 5025 501 7A3:8.1< B:<8A1.5 => 9=.@7957=. 2.< =?<1? => ;1.51.91 9244;>=?7.51?>1?1.91 .@71I=>50126=@12A=>501=37.7=.5025 501 7A3:8.1< B:<8A1.5 => 9=.@7957=. 2.< =?<1? => ;1.51.9132;;1<6H501?724=:?57;4726415=61;152;7<1 99=?<7.84H 2.;I1? 501 26=@1 3=7.5 7. 501 2>>7?A257@1 2.<3?=911<5=32;;501>=44=I7.8 "7$ ?7A7.242331247; "77$ 01 7A3:8.1< B:<8A1.5 => 9=.@7957=. 2.< =?<1?=>;1.51.91<251<,32;;1< 7. 3197242;1"! $=--6H501 <<757=.24 7;5?795 2.< 1;;7=.; +:<81 % "! $25 2426:?2877; - 11 - "777$ 012331442.5299:;1<7;29M:7551<=>501 =>>1.91; 3:.7;02641 :.<1? 1957=.; -& "$ -- -- => ! 2.< 1957=. => 501 ! 95 "7@$ %7.1 2A=:.5 <13=;751< 7> 2.H ;0244 61 ?15:?.1< 5= 501 299:;1< =. <:1 7<1.57>79257=. 187;5?H7;<7?1951<5=9=AA:.79251507;=?<1?5=501 9=.91?.1<+274:50=?7571; . @71I => <7;3=;24 => 501 233124 = => & ;52.<; 187;5?H 7; <7?1951< 5= ;1.< 629J 501 ?724 =:?5 ?19=?<; 24=.8 I750 9=3H => 507; B:<8A1.5 >=? 7.>=?A257=. 2.<>=?.191;;2?H2957=. .* '!!) " # 7;5= 4=-- !