Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 65839 (KAR)
THE CHAIRMAN AND ORS v. SHARANAPPA S/O BHIMARAYA NAIKODI
WA/200046/2022 · 2025-09-04
H P Sandesh, T M Nadaf
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 65839 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 65839 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"!#$
#! % $&!#!! % $&!$ ##
'!!(
! "
! #
"
! $
%
&
'
&"
' (
$ %
Digitally signed by SACHIN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
" ) !)
"
''& ' ' '
" "
)
)
*' '
)
+ ) ,
)"
-
- )
)&$ $ - %
./012/3455647/08/769524:/;<3=06340/963.6=2962 94369 ' ' 540069 >: 3.6 7642;69 /;<76 ?9<6 /;
"= ''& '4;93=477=13.612/3563/3/=;
)4@3?47 A432/B =8 3.6 @406 =8 3.6 2605=;96;3 >68=26 3.6 9?@43/=;47 55677436 2/>?;47
/C45?2 $8=2 0.=23
+3.6 2/>?;47,% 1./76 /;D=E/;< 6@3/=; *!$% =8 3.6 42;434E49?@43/=;@3
*#
/;55647=& '! /03.43
.61401=2E/;<406=;4;9140455=/;369/;3.6 :642 **! /6
=; !'**! 8362 @=A5763/=; =8 ./0 52=>43/=;42:562/=9
.626F?603698=226<?742/G43/=;=8./0
- 3 -
062D/@60 3 /0 470= ./0 @406 3.43 3.6 4556774;30 400?269 4552=D47=8./0455=/;3A6;382=A3.6@=A5636;34?3.=2/3: 4;9./026F?603140E653/;4>6:4;@6=;=;6=23.6=3.62 52636B3 3/0470=./0@4063.43
/;3.6:642 '#
/6
=;
' '#
.6 140 26824/;69 >: 3.6 4556774;30 82=A 9/0@.42</;< ./0 9?3/60 6;@6
.6 /;D=E69 3.6 4>=D6 52=D/0/=;>:8/7/;<4;455647
# ;2605=;063=3.64D62A6;30A496/;3.604/9 455647 A6A=24;9?A
3.6 4556774;30 8/769 =>C6@3/=;0 @=;36;9/;< 3.43 3.6 455=/;3A6;3 =8 3.6 2605=;96;3 140 06;3 8=2 4552=D47 >: 3.6 @=A5636;3 4?3.=2/3:
>?3 3.6 @=A5636;3 4?3.=2/3: 9/9 ;=3 4552=D6 3.6 04A6 >: </D/;< 2640=; 3.43 3.626 140 4 >4; =; 4/9 3= 3.6 ;=;H364@./;< 03488 3 140 470= @=;36;9693.43 3.62605=;96;3<=3./0 @623/8/@43604;976833.6C=>/;3.6:642**/30678 3140 @=;36;9693.433.=?<.3.652=5=04714006;38=24552=D47 3.6 04A6 140 ;=3 4@@65369 ?3
3.6 2/>?;47 D/96 =2962 94369'I '5400694;=29629/26@3/;<3.64556774;30 3= 26/;03436 3.6 2605=;96;3 1/3./; =;6 A=;3. 1/3. - 4 -
@=;3/;?/3: =8 062D/@6 4;9 'J >4@E 14<60 82=A ' '! 3/77 3.6 9436 =8 ./0 26/;03436A6;3 40 562 ;;6B?26H 3= 3.6 12/3 563/3/=; 4;9 @=5: =8 3.6 =2962 /0 574@69 =; 26@=29 47=;< 1/3. 3./0 455647 40 ;;6B?26H .6 04/9 =2962 140 F?603/=;69 >68=26 3.6 7642;69 /;<76 ?9<6/;"= ''& '.67642;69/;<76?9<6 .4D/;< @=;0/96269 3.6 A4362/47 4D4/74>76 =; 26@=29
D/96 =296294369 ' ' 9/0A/00693.612/3563/3/=;@=A/;< 3=3.6@=;@7?0/=;3.433.62/>?;47.40;=3@=AA/33694;: 622=2
! 6/;<4<<2/6D69>:3.6=2962=83.62/>?;4740 1677403.6=2962=83.67642;69/;<76?9<6540069/;3.6 12/3563/3/=;
3.652606;312/3455647/08/769
.6A4/;@=;36;3/=;=83.67642;69@=?;0678=2 4556774;30 >68=26 3./0 =?23 /0 3.43 >=3.
3.6 2/>?;47 40 1677 40 3.6 7642;69 /;<76 ?9<6 .40 ;=3 @=;0/96269 3.6 A4362/47 =; 26@=29 /; 52=562 562056@3/D6 .6 @=?;067 D6.6A6;37: @=;36;969 3.43 3.6 688=230 A496 >: 3.6
- 5 -
4556774;30 3= 4552=D6 3.6 2605=;96;3,0 5=03 82=A 3.6 @=A5636;34?3.=2/3:/;3.6:642**4;9/;3.6:642 '' 16;3/;D4/;
0/;@63.6261404<=D62;A6;3>4;=;3.64/9 =8 ;=;H364@./;< 03488 3 /0 470= @=;36;969 3.43 3.6 2605=;96;3D=7?;342/7:76833.6C=>7=;<>4@E.67642;69 /;<76?9<684/7693=@=;0/9623.433.62/>?;4726@=29694 8/;9/;< 3.43 3.6 2605=;96;3 062D69 /; 3.6 /;03/3?3/=; 3/77 '# 268622/;< 3= 3.6 =247 6D/96;@6 =8
" 4;9 540069 3.6 /A5?<;69 =2962 .6 7642;69 @=?;067 470= @=;36;969 3.43 /; 3.6 /;034;3 @406
49A/33697:
3.6 2605=;96;3 140 ;=39/0A/0069
26A=D69=2269?@69/;24;E;=23.626/04;
=2962 =8 5?;/0.A6;3 .=?<. 3.6 455647 /30678 /0 ;=3 A4/;34/;4>76
3.6 2/>?;47 A/02649 3.6 52=D/0/=;0 4;9 6;36234/;69 3.6 455647 .6 7642;69 /;<76 ?9<6 .40 84/7693=34E6;=36=83.604/984@3/;3=@=;0/96243/=;.6 8/;9/;<=83.62/>?;473.43.6140@=;3/;?69/;062D/@63/77 '#/0622=;6=?04;9>=3.3.6=?230/6
3.62/>?;4740 1677 40 7642;69 /;<76 ?9<6 =8 3./0 =?23 @=AA/3369 4;
- 6 -
622=2/;5400/;<3.6/A5?<;69=296204;9.6;@6
3.604A6 26F?/26/;3628626;@6=83./0=?23
7642;69 @=?;067 455642/;< 8=2 3.6 2605=;96;3 /; ./0 42<?A6;30 D6.6A6;37: @=;36;969 3.43 1.6; 3.6 2605=;96;3 140 26824/;69 82=A 4336;9/;< 3.6 C=>
4;4556471408/769>68=263.62/>?;47.62/>?;47 43 76;<3. 9/0@?0069 3.6 A4362/47 =; 26@=29 4;9 824A69 /00?60403=1.63.623.62605=;96;3140455=/;369/;3.6 :642**!4;91.63.62.614012=;<8?77:362A/;436982=A 062D/@6/;3.6:642 '#4;934E6;;=36=83.6@=;36;3/=;
=8 3.6 4556774;30 3.43 3.6 2605=;96;3 D=7?;342/7: 7683 3.6 C=> /; 3.6 :642 ** 4;9 6D6; 6B4A/;69 3.6 /00?6 =8 7/A/343/=; 4D/;< @=;0/96269 3.6 A4362/47 =; 26@=29 5423/@?7427:
9=@?A6;343B03=*4;9B0 3= 3.6 2/>?;47 4;016269 /00?6 =0 4;9 /; 488/2A43/D6 /00?6 =0# 4;9 ! /; ;6<43/D6 4;9 /00?6 = 5423: /; 488/2A43/D64;92/<.37:9/26@3693.64556774;303=26/;03436 3.6 2605=;96;3 1/3. @=;3/;?/3: =8 062D/@6 4;9 'J >4@E14<60 82=A ' '! 4;9 =2962 =8 966A69
- 7 -
362A/;43/=; =8 3.6 2605=;96;3 94369 ' '! /0 063 40/96.6@=?;067470=@=;36;9693.433.67642;69/;<76 ?9<6
1./76 @=;0/962/;< 3.6 A4362/47 =; 26@=29
34E6; ;=36=83.684@3?474056@30/;5424<245.H#=83.6/A5?<;69 =2962 4;9 34E6; ;=36 =8 3.6 <2=?;90 1./@.
.4D6 >66; ?2<69>68=263.62/>?;474;93.6@=;36;3/=;34E6;>:3.6 4556774;30 4;9 @=;0/962/;< 3.6 A4362/47 =; 26@=29 3.43 04742: 140 54/9 3/77 '#
3.6 2/>?;47 9/0>67/6D69 3.6 D620/=; =8 3.6 4556774;30 4;9 >67/6D69 3.6 @=;36;3/=; =8 3.6 2605=;96;3 4;9 =>062D69 /; 5424<245.0HI 4;93.43 3.6 2/>?;47 .40 ;=3 @=AA/3369 4;: 622=2 4;9 .6;@6
/3 9=60;=326F?/26/;3628626;@6=83./0=?23.6268=26
.6 @=;36;90 3.433.6 /A5?<;69 =2962540069>:3.67642;69 /;<76 ?9<6 /0 C?03 4;9 52=562 6;@6
.6 0=?<.3 3= 9/0A/003.6455647
I 4D/;< .6429 3.6 7642;69 @=?;067 8=2 3.6 4556774;304;93.67642;69@=?;0678=23.62605=;96;3
3.6 5=/;303.431=?7942/068=2=?2@=;0/96243/=;426
- 8 -
4D/;<@=;0/962693.657649/;<0=83.65423/60 /3 /0 ;=3 /; 9/05?36 3.43 3.6 4556774;3 = /0 3.6
6</036269 =@/63: 26</036269 ?;962 3.6 42;434E4 =@/63/60 6</03243/=; @3
*' 556774;3 = /0 3.6 2/;@/547 =8 .2/ .40<4360.142 =A5=0/36 ?;/=2 =776<6 4;9 4556774;3 =# /0 3.6 649 40362 =8 .2/ .40<4360.142 /270 /<. @.==7 3 /0 470= ;=3/;9/05?363.433.606/;03/3?3/=;04262?;>:4556774;3 =H=@/63: 3/0470=;=3/;9/05?363.433.62605=;96;3 140455=/;369/;3.6:642**!/6
=;!'**!0=470= 3.6 A4362/47 9/0@7=060 3.43 =; @=A5763/=; =8 52=>43/=; =8 3.6 2605=;96;3
4 52=5=047 140 06;3 3= 3.6 @=A5636;3 4?3.=2/3: 8=2 26<?742/G43/=; =8 ./0 455=/;3A6;3
>?3 3.6 04A6 140 ;=3 4552=D69 .6 84@3 3.43 .6 062D69 /; 3.6
- 9 -
/;03/3?3/=;82=A **! /0 470=;=3/; 9/05?36 ?33.6 D62: @=;36;3/=;=83.64556774;30/03.433.62605=;96;376833.6 C=>D=7?;342/7:/;3.6:642**/0;=30?>034;3/4369.6 2/>?;47401677403.67642;69/;<76?9<634E6;;=36=8 3.6 84@3 3.43 .6 140 @=;3/;?69 /; 062D/@6 3/77 .6 140 26824/;69 82=A 4336;9/;< 3.6 1=2E .6 7642;69 /;<76 ?9<6
.4D/;< 34E6; ;=36 =8 3.6 =247 4;9 9=@?A6;342:
6D/96;@6
/;5424<524.HI=83.6/A5?<;69=2962=>062D69 3.433.62605=;96;3 140@=;3/;?69/; 062D/@6 4;9 .6 .40 >66; 54/9 04742: 3/77 '# 4;9 .6 140 362A/;4369 82=A 062D/@6 =; ' '! 0/;@6 /3 /0 6A62<69 9?2/;< 3.6 @=?206=83.66D/96;@63.43.61=2E694;904742:14054/9 3/77 '#
* .62/>?;47
1./76@=;0/962/;<3.6@406=83.6 2605=;96;3
34E6; ;=36 3.43 .6 140 455=/;369 /; 3.6 /;03/3?3/=; =8 3.6 4556774;30 4;9 3.43 .6 140 362A/;4369 4;9 9/9 ;=3 >67/6D6 3.6 @=;36;3/=; =8 3.6 4556774;30 3.43 3.6 2605=;96;3 D=7?;342/7: 7683 3.6 C=> /; 3.6 :642 ** 1./764;0162/;</00?6=04;9 /;488/2A43/D64;9/00?6
- 10 -
=0# 4;9 ! /; ;6<43/D6 ".6; >=3. 3.6 =247 4;9 9=@?A6;342: 6D/96;@6 9/0@7=06 3.43 .6 140 455=/;369 /;
3.6:642**!4;9.614054/904742:3/77 '#
3.6D62: @=;36;3/=;=83.64556774;30,@=?;0673.43>=3.3.62/>?;47 40 1677 40 7642;69 /;<76 ?9<6 @=AA/3369 4; 622=2 /; 5400/;<3.6/A5?<;69=29620@4;;=3>64@@65369.626/0 ;= 9/05?36 1/3. 26<429 3= ./0 455=/;3A6;3 >?3 @=;3/;?43/=;=8062D/@63/77 '#/09/05?369
>?33.604A6 .40 >66; 52=D69 .=?<. /3 /0 @=;36;969 3.43 3.6 2605=;96;3D=7?;342/7:76833.6C=>/;3.6:642**
3.626 /0;=52=5626B574;43/=;>:3.64556774;3026<429/;<1.43 A4963.64556774;303=A4E654:A6;3=804742:3/77 '#
".6; 0?@.
>6/;< 3.6 @406
3.6 2/>?;47 9/26@369 3.6 4556774;30 3= 54: >4@E14<60 43 'J 1/3. @=;3/;?/3: =8 062D/@6 .6 7642;69 /;<76 ?9<6 470= @4A6 3= 3.6 @=;@7?0/=;3.433.62/>?;47.40;=3@=AA/33694;:622=2 4;9=>062D693.43/3/0;=33.6@406=83.64556774;303.43 3.62/>?;47.404557/69741622=;6=?07:.6268=26
169= ;=38/;94;:8=2@6/;3.6@=;36;3/=;=83.67642;69@=?;067
- 11 -
8=2 4556774;30 3.43 3./0 =?23 .40 3= /;3628626 1/3. 3.6 8/;9/;<=83.62/>?;47401677403.67642;69/;<76?9<6 6;@6
164;01625=/;3=/;;6<43/D6".6;3.626426 ;= /;8/2A/3/60 /; 3.6 /A5?<;69 =29620 540069 >: 3.6 2/>?;47401677403.67642;69/;<76?9<6
3.6F?603/=; =86;36234/;/;<3.612/34556479=60;=342/06
' ;D/61=83.64>=D69/0@?00/=;
1652=@6693= 54003.68=77=1/;<
.6"2/355647/09/0A/0069
; D/61 =8 9/05=047 =8 3.6 A4/; 455647
56;9/;< 4557/@43/=;
/84;:
9=;=30?2D/D68=2@=;0/96243/=;
!*+ '#!!( &
!*+ '$( &
/03=7=!&