- 1 - !!"!#$ % "&"'""! ""'' ($) * ! " # $ ! % & & " % %% # '(')$ ' * ' '' ! " # %+ # ('' ' $ % % ,*"$ % # Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - % ' ' # ')' # % )&*( )- &(( '- % # . &! /012/ 3/4 566457 89 78934: ;0< 5:=89980> ?83/ 3/4 @0>94>3 0; 745<>4: @01>947 ;0< 3/4 65<3849 83 89 35A4> 16 ;0<;8>57:8960957 ' /89 566457 89 ;874: 5258>93 3/4 B1:2=4>3 5>: 5?5<::534:' ' 65994:CD3/44>80<8E871:24 5>:::7/5/561<8>#0')0;' * /4 @758=5>3 524: * D45<9 =43 ?83/ 5> 5@@8:4>3 0> ' *' 5>: 919358>4: 2<84E019 8>B1<49 /4<4;0<4 /89 =03/4< 59 >531<57 215<:85> ;874: 5 @758= 6438380> C4;0<4 3/4 <8C1>57 @758=8>2 @0=64>95380> 0; 9' - 3 - & /4<8C1>57@0>98:4<8>23/44>38<44E8:4>@40> <4@0<: 2<5>34: @0=64>95380> 0; 9)&*( ?83/ 8>34<49353)-65;<0=3/4:5340;6438380>3877<457895380> 5>: :8<4@34: <4960>:4>3 0'>91<5>@4 0=65>D 30 :4609833/495=4 22<84E4:CD3/4958:B1:2=4>35>:5?5<:3/4 8>B1<4: @758=5>3 /59 6<4;4<<4: 3/89 566457 8> ?/8@/ 83 89 @0>34>:4:3/533/4:0@30<5994994:3/4:895C8783D53, - 30 3/4 70?4< 78=C 5>: * - 30 3/4 ?/074 C0:D C13 3/4 <8C1>57/5935A4>3/4:895C8783D0>7D53* -/4<8C1>57 2<5>34: 9* 30?5<:9 7099 0; ;131<4 8>@0=4 ?/8@/890>3/470?4<98:4057903/45=01>395?5<:4: 1>:4< 03/4< /45:9 5<4 =452<4 5>: 8>34<493 89 30 C4 2<5>34: 53 (- 65 /19 <4F14934: ;0< 4>/5>@4=4>3 0; @0=64>95380> ) 45<>4:@01>947;0<<4960>:4>30'>91<5>@4 0=65>D @0>34>:4: 3/53 3/4 5664775>3 ?59 =8>0< 524: *D45<9964<3/4218:478>49758::0?>CD3/4 0>GC74 64H 01<3 8> - 4 - 5>:5790@0>98:4<8>23/4=4:8@574E8:4>@4 3/4<8C1>57/59<82/37D2<5>34:B193@0=64>95380>5>:83 >44:9>08>34<;4<4>@4 , 45<:3/45<21=4>390;C03/98:49 45<>4:@01>947 ;0<3/4 5664775>3/59 ;874: 3/4 =4:8@574E8:4>@40;'?/093534:3/533/45664775>3 /59 919358>4: @0=601>: ;<5@31<4 0; 3/4 <82/3 38C85 5>: ;8C175 =8::74 3/8<: 5>: 3<4534: /8= 91<28@577D 0> '( *' ?83/6<8=5<D:4C<8:4=4>3?83/4H34<>57;8H530< 5>:9A8>2<5;38>2:0>4?83/2593<0>54=19978:49;756?83/ 2<5;38>2:534: & &' 5>::89@/5<24:0>', &' 5>: 5258> 203 5:=8334: 8> 3/4 95=4 /0968357 0> ') ' 5>: 91<24<D :0>4 ;0< ;<5@31<4 <82/3 38C85 5>: ;8C175 ?83/ % ?83/ 0> ', ' 5>: 5258> 203 5:=8334: 8> 95=4 /0968357 0> *' ) ?83/ /8930<D 0; <4@1<<4>3 8>;4@380> 5>: :89@/5<24: 0> *' ) 4 ;1<3/4< 93534: 3/53 3/4<4 ?59 658> 5>: ?45A>499 8> 3/4 1 AIR 2014 SC 736 - 5 - ?/074 <82/3 70?4< 78=C 5>: :89@/5<28>2 ?01>: 0E4< 3/4 <82/3 742 9/0<34>8>2 0; 3/4 <82/3 742 53 5C013 I @= @0=65<4 30 3/4 74;3 742 5>: 07: /4574: ;<5@31<4 0; 3/4 =8::74 38C85 5>: ;8C175 <82/3 ?83/ 09340=D478389 @/5>249 5>:5994994:3/4:895C8783D53, -303/4<82/370?4<78=C 5>:3/4?/074C0:D:895C8783D59* - ( 45<>4: @01>947 ;0< 3/4 5664775>3 <4784: 160> 3/4 B1:2=4>3 0; 3/4 0>GC74 16<4=4 01<3 8> !" "#"$#%"&#%"#""'$()) (*# + ,"($' 5>: 93534: 3/53 8> 3/4 958: @594 3/4 @758=5>39 919358>4: * - 5>: ' - :895C8783D <4964@38E47D 5>: 3/4 64H 01<3 /59 2<5>34: 9* 30?5<:9 64<=5>4>3:895C8783D5>:57902<5>34:<4590>5C745=01>39 1>:4< 3/4 03/4< /45:9 5>: 3/19 <4F14934: ;0< 4>/5>@4=4>30;3/4@0=64>95380>C598>20>3/4<5380758: :0?>8>3/4958:B1:2=4>3 45<>4: @01>947 ;0< 3/4 5664775>3 5790 <4784: 160>3/4B1:2=4>30;3/4 0>GC7416<4=401<38> 2 2014 AIAR (Civil) 1009 - 6 - $) *5>:@0>34>:4:3/538> 3/4 958: @594 @758=5>3 ?59 524: ' D45<9 5>: 3/4 =8>8=1= ?5249 ?59 35A4> ;0< 3/4 @57@175380> 0; 3/4 5=01>3570>2?83/;131<46<0964@395>:3/45=01>39?59 2<5>34:1>:4<<474E5>3/45:9 G9@594 ?595790<4;4<<4:8>65<50')0;3/4958:B1:2=4>35>: 591=0;9* ?592<5>34:;0<70990;=5<<8524 6<0964@395>:;131<4=4:8@574H64>949?5957902<5>34: > 3/4 6<494>3 @594 3/4 8>B1<4: ?59 524: * D45<9389;1<3/4<93534:3/533/4@758=5>3?595:=8334: 8> 3/4 /0968357 ;0< ) :5D9 5>: /89 3<453=4>3 ?59 @0>38>14:;0<0>4D45</4<4;0<4@0>98:4<8>23/4=4:8@57 4E8:4>@4 5>: 5790 3/4 <5380 758: :0?> 8> 3/4 5C0E4@594 3/89 01<3 ;8>:9 83 <4590>5C74 30 2<5>3 5> 5=01>3 0; 9 ;0<658>5>:91;;4<8>29' ;0<7099 0; 5=4>83849 5>: 9& ;0< 3<5>960<35380> 4H3<5 >01<89/=4>35>:5334>:5>3@/5<249 *' ' 5>3&("$ - 7 - ' /4 <8C1>57 /59 2<5>34: 5> 5=01>3 0; 9* 30?5<:9 64<=5>4>3 :895C8783D 5>: 9'* 30?5<:9 =4:8@57 4H64>949 5>: 3/4 95=4 >44:9>08>34<;4<4>@4 * /89 01<3 5790 ;8>:9 83 <4590>5C74 30 2<5>3 5> 5=01>30;9' ;0<70990;=5<<85246<0964@39 & 4>@43/45664775>3894>38374:;0<3/4=0:8;84: @0=64>95380>1>:4<:8;;4<4>3/45:959C470? 4<=5>4>3:895C8783D 9* 58>5>:91;;4<8>2 9 4:8@574H64>949 9'* 0990;=5<<85246<0964@39 9' <5>960<35380>4H3<5>01<89/=4>35>: 5334>:5>3@/5<249 9& 0990;5=4>83849 9' 0357 4995?5<:4:CD<8C1>57 >/5>@4=4>3 9(& 9)&*( + ,, /4 >91<5>@4 0=65>D /59 57<45:D :4609834: 3/4 5=01>3 5?5<:4: CD 3/4 <8C1>57 /19 3/4 5664775>3 89 4>38374:;0<4>/5>@4:@0=64>95380>0;9'(&&(?83/ 8>34<493 53 )- 64< 5>>1= 5>: 3/4<4;0<4 3/4 566457 :494<E4930C45770?4:8>65<3 - 8 - >3/4<491733/4;0770?8>20<:4<8965994: "8$ 66457895770?4:8>65<3 "88$ /4 5664775>3@758=5>3 89 4>38374: ;0< 3/4 4>/5>@4: @0=64>95380> 0; 9'(&&( ?83/ 8>34<493 53 )- 64< 5>>1= ;<0= 3/4 :534 0; 6438380> 3877 3/4 :534 0; <4578J5380> "888$ 4960>:4>3 0'>91<5>@4 0=65>D 89 :8<4@34: 30 :460983 3/4 5;0<4958: @0=64>95380> 5=01>3 ?83/8>0>4=0>3/;<0=3/4:5340;3/89B1:2=4>3 "8E$ > 91@/ :460983 3/4 5664775>3 89 64<=8334: 30 ?83/:<5? 3/4 4>38<4 5=01>3 570>2 ?83/ 8>34<493 5@@<14: 0>83 +-. ('""!) &! 893070*