Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 65835 (KAR)
PARASHURAM S/O GOOLAPPA HIREKURUBAR v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
CRL.A/200043/2021 · 2025-07-10
V Srishananda
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 65835 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 65835 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "# $
#%%
&
'&(%)*&))
+
!"# $ % &
'
' ! #" % (
!"#& $
% &
Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
'
)*%+& '
'
' ++#+#
, +#, '
''
*,!%&#) '
' ' (
-
# % -
&
./01 02 324/5/51 /66/573.662 8./05.1 9:;57.8 <:0 63. /==.88/56/99;7.1 /51 02 ..0/5/>:;1/ /82=/628 8./05.1 2>3 :;06 :4.05?.56 8./1.0 <:0 63. 0.7=:51.566/6. + ==.88/56 3/7 @..5 9:54296.1 25
:, +#,:5++#+#@A63. 11262:5/82760296/51 .772:57 ;1>. 2B/A/=;0/ %<:0 73:06 C02/8 :;06D& <:0
63. :<<.59.7 =;5273/@8. ;51.0 .962:57 *,! /51 #) :< /517.56.59.1/7;51.0
- 3 -
! !" #$%&' ! (
)*** &+, ! ' ) ! ! ! ' +!! ! - !" *. ' ! (
/*)*** &+ ! ' ) ! ! ! ' 0! 1 2 (
/*)*** &!"
. 1,!34
5 65
,
6
#% !" !7 +
- 4 -
8 ! ! 3! 81
/ " ! 0 ,! '
,
-!! !7 !!,! 9
'/967 25 @02.< E3293 /0. ;6?:76 5.9.77/0A <:0 127=:7/8:<63.=0.7.56/==./8/0./7;51.0
3. 93/0>.73..6 ?/6.02/8 E:;81 0.4./8 63/6 (/A/730..27E2<.:<63./==.88/56/5163.20?/002/>. 6::F=8/9./5163.AE.0.82425>3/==28A<:07:?.62?./51 /7:5@A5/?.0..63/?E/7@:056:63.? +
6279:56.51.163/663.0./<6.0/99;7.1/11296.1 6: 82G;:0 /51 E/7 5:6 8::F25>/<6.0 63. ( /51 3.0 7:5 /51 ;51.0 63. 25<8;.59. :< 82G;:0 3. ;7.1 6: =29F.1 ;=
- 5 -
G;/00.8E26363.(=0/9629/88A/51;7.16:=3A729/88A/51 ?.56/88A 3/0/77 3.0
6 E/7 /87: /88.>.1 63/6 3. 5.4.0 9/?. 6: 9:5602@;6. <:0 63. 3:;7.3:81 .H=.57.7 /51 @A 1:25>9::82.E:0F63.(E/7?/256/2525>63.</?28A
(3.563.?/66.076::163;72627/88.>.163/625
63. 256.04.525> 52>36 :< + # +#, 6: +"# +#, ( E/7 78..=25> 6 63/6 62?. /99;7.1 E263 /5 256.562:5 6:
?;01.0 327 E2<. E263 63. 3.8= :< =288:E % & 602.1 6: 7?::63.03.0/51/87:=0.77.13.05.9F(3.563.7/21 /66.?=6E/70.7276.1@A(3.08.>6:;93.163.4.77.87 /5126<.881:E5/51:53./025>63.7:;5163.4.77.873.0 7:5 0..63/? 9/?. /51 :=.5.1 63. 1::0 6 63/6 B;596;0. 73. 6:81 3.0 7:5 63/6 /==.88/56 602.1 6: ?;01.0 3.0
??.12/6.8A3.0/27.1/8/0?/515.2>3@:;079/?. /51:57..25>63.?63./==.88/560/5/E/A<0:?63.7=:6
*
??.12/6.8A 73. E/7 6/F.5 6:63.3:7=26/8 @A
63. ?:63.0 :< 63. ( /51 :63.07
5 63. 3:7=26/8 73. 3/7 @..5 .H/?25.1 ( 27 63. :96:0 E3: .H/?25.1
- 6 -
( 277;.1(:;51.062<29/6. /7=.0 H E3.0.25 5: <0/96;0.E/77..5.263.02563.7=25.:0:563.73:;81.0:0 25 5/7/8 @:5. 5:0 /5A 82>/6;0. ?/0F E/7 5:629.1 :5 63. 5.9F
* /7.1:563.9:?=8/25663.=:829.254.762>/6.1
63. ?/66.0 /51 <28.1 93/0>.73..6 <:0 63. :<<.59.7 =;5273/@8.;51.0.962:57*,!/51#):<
99;7.1 E/7/00.76.1/518/6.0:5.58/0>.1:5@/28
3.0./<6.0 93/0>.7 E.0. <0/?.1 <:0
63. /<:0.7/21:<<.59.7/51/99;7.13/425>=8./1.15:6>;286A 602/8E/73.81
" 5:01.06:@025>3:?.63.>;286:<63./99;7.1
63. =0:7.9;62:5 .H/?25.1 72H E265.77.7 9:?=02725> :< 9:?=8/25/56 /7 ( /51 / 9209;?76/562/8 E265.77 E3: 3./01 8:;1 3;. /51 90A /51 0./93.1 63. 3:;7. :< 63. 9:?=8/25/56 @A 5/?.
;1F/==/ /7 (+ ..8/44/ /8/==/ /7 63. 9209;?76/562/8 E265.77.7 63. :96:0 /7 ( /5163. 54.762>/625> <<29.0/7("
- 7 -
) 0:7.9;62:5 =8/9.1 :5 0.9:01 72H 1:9;?.567 E3293 E.0. .H32@26.1 /51 ?/0F.1 /7 H7 6: " 9:?=02725> :< :?=8/256 /3/I/0 3:6:>0/=37 (:;51 .062<29/6./51'
! 3. =288:E E3293 E/7 /88.>.18A ;7.1 25 63. 25921.56E/77.2I.1;51.0H+E/7?/0F.1/7 +
, <6.0 9:598;72:5 :< 0.9:0125> :< .421.59. 63. 8./05.1 02/8 ;1>. 0.9:01.1 /99;7.1 76/6.?.56 /7 27 9:56.?=8/6.1 ;51.0 .962:5 :< 0 E3.0.25 /99;7.13/71.52.163.25902?25/625>?/6.02/8;63.121 5:6:<<.0/5AE0266.57;@?2772:5763:;>33.3/7/1?266.1 6: .H/?25. E265.77.7 :5 327 @.3/8< 3. 121 5:6 .H/?25. /5AE265.77.7
# 3.0./<6.0 8./05.1 02/8 ;1>. 3./01 63. /0>;?.567:<63.=/062.7/51:59;?;8/624.9:5721.0/62:5 :<63.:0/8/511:9;?.56/0A.421.59.:50.9:019:54296.1
63. /99;7.1 <:0 63. :<<.59.7 =;5273/@8. ;51.0 .962:57 *,!/51#):<
/517.56.59.1/70.<.00.16:7;=0/
- 8 -
.25> />>02.4.1 @A 63. 7/?. /==.88/56 27 @.<:0.6327:;06256327/==./8:563.<:88:E25>>0:;517 +!) ! 5 :
" ! 5 !!) :!, +!) ! 7 ! ! ,! ! ! +!) ; <0
&/ ! ,&*&*/$
"/=*
>,, ! ! &*& */$ " $=/ >
) ! ! )!!! ! >) !!! +!) ; ! ?& / ) ! 0 ! !! - 9 -
! ! "@ ! ! ! ! ! , ! ) " ; ! <0
&/
) ,! ! ! , ! >)!! ! !! "" +!);!0?& /!,!; ! ,)"! ,;! ! ) " ! ) ! " ! ! >) 5
"" +!)!! !!!,!!! ," ! " !) " ! 3
?& !) ! 5
" ,! ,! ! - 10 -
" "5
) ! " ! "" +!) ; ! " ! " ! ! #$% '
+ ! #$% ' ! ! " ,! , ,!!!; ! , 5 ) " !! ,!! ! ! , ! ! , ,! ! ! ,! , ! ! , "
" ! ! ! >) ! ! @!!; ! #$%' +!);!?&/)) : # " ! ,! &
! ! - 11 -
! ) " !! #$%:*.' +!) ! ,! ! ! ! , !! , ! )! ! !
; ! @ ! +!) ! ! ,!! +!" " ! +!)"; ! " ",)! ! " A ! "
" ! +!) ! " ! ,
- 12 -
! ) ! !"&&, +!) ,! ! ! ) ! " ! !! +!) ! @
! : ! ,! !/ +!) ", ! ! " ! , ,! ! ! +!) " !) ! 7 ! ! ! ! !!""!! ! +!" ! +! ! 5! + 02324/5/51/66/573.6628./05.19:;57.8<:0
63. /==.88/560.26.0/625> 63.>0:;517 ;0>.1 2563./==./8
- 13 -
?.?:0/51;? 9:56.51.1 63/6 63. =0:7.9;62:5 9/7. 27 5:6325>@;6/76:0AE:4.5:58AE263/5256.562:56:7:?. 3:E =;6 63. /==.88/56 @.3251 63. @/07 /51 63. 8./05.1 02/8 :;06 3/7 5:6 =0:=.08A /==0.92/6.1 63. ?/6.02/8 .421.59.:50.9:010.7;8625>25?279/002/>.:<B;7629./51 7:;>36<:0/88:E25>63./==./8
. E:;81 =:256 :;6 63/6 /88.>.1 .A.E265.77 6:
63. 25921.56 25 6.0?7 :< .962:5 " :< 63. 421.59. 96 5/?.8A0..63/?E3:2763.7:5:<63./==.88/56/5163. (@.25>5:6.H/?25.1@A63.=0:7.9;62:5.H=:7.763. 3:88:E5.77 25 63. 9/7. :< 63. =0:7.9;62:5 /51 7:;>36 <:0 /88:E25>63./==./8
* 86.05/624.8A02324/5/51/66/573.662E:;81 9:56.5163/62563./@7.59.:</5A<0/96;0.:<5/7/8@:5. 63.:0A:<7?::63.525>9/55:6@.9:;56.5/59.1258/EJ/6 @.7663.?/6.02/8:50.9:01E:;817;==:06:58A/5:<<.59. ;51.0.962:5*,!:<
- 14 -
3.0.<:0. 63. 9;76:1A =.02:1 /80./1A ;51.0>:5.@A63./==.88/56?/A@.60./6.1/7/=.02:1:< 2?=027:5?.56 /51 7:;>36 <:0 /88:E25> 63. /==./8 6: 63/6 .H6.56
" 02..0/5/>:;1//82=/6288./05.1 2>3 :;06 :4.05?.56 8./1.0 7;==:067 63. 2?=;>5.1 B;1>?.56
) . E:;81 <;063.0 9:56.51 63/6 63. </96 :< 63. 8:1>25> 9:?=8/256 2??.12/6.8A /<6.0 63. 25921.56 /51 .H/?25/62:5:<63.42962?(2563.:4.05?.56:7=26/8 :5 63. 7/?. 1/A @A 63. :96:0 E3: .H/?25.1 63. ( /51 277;.1 (:;51 .062<29/6. 421. H 73:E7 63/6 63. 25921.56 /7 27 =0:=:;51.1 @A 63. =0:7.9;62:5 121 :99;0 E3293 3/7 @..5 02>368A /==0.92/6.1 @A 63. 8./05.1 02/8 ;1>./517:;>36<:0127?277/8:<63./==./8
! .E:;81<;063.0=:256:;663/6?.0./@7.59.:< <0/96;0. :< 5/7/8 @:5. E:;81 5:6 @. 7;<<292.56 .5:;>3 6: 127@.82.4.63.63.:0A:<63.=0:7.9;62:563/663.0.E/7/5
- 15 -
/66.?=66:6/F./E/A63.82<.:<(@A7?::63.525>/51 63;77:;>36<:0127?277/8:<63./==./8
, /425>3./0163./0>;?.567:<@:63721.76327 :;06=.0;7.163.?/6.02/8:50.9:01?.629;8:;78A
+# 57;93=.0;7/8:<63.?/6.02/8:50.9:0163. <:88:E25> =:2567 E:;81 /027. <:0 9:5721.0/62:5 25 6327 /==./8
& (3.63.0 63. ?/6.02/8 .421.59. =8/9.1 :5 0.9:01 @A 63. =0:7.9;62:5 E:;81 @. 7;<<292.56 .5:;>3 6: ?/256/25 63. :01.0 :< 9:542962:5 :< 63. /==.88/56 <:0 63. :<<.59. =;5273/@8. ;51.0 .962:57 *,! /51 #) :< K
+& (3.63.0 63.
2?=;>5.1 B;1>?.56 27 7;<<.025><0:?/5A8.>/825<20?26A:0=.04.0726A /5163;79/887<:0256.0<.0.59.@A6327:;06K
& (3.63.063.7.56.59.27.H9.7724.K
*& (3/6:01.0K
- 16 -
,-.(/01-20134.1/
+ 5 63. 9/7. :5 3/51 63. 0.8/62:5732= :< 63. /==.88/56E26363.(/5163.7:5@A5/?.0..63/?27 @:052563.E.18:9F275:625127=;6. ++
6 27 /87: <:;51 <0:? 63. ?/6.02/8 .421.59. =8/9.1 :5 0.9:01 63/6 63. 0.8/62:5732= @.6E..5 63. /==.88/56 /51 63. ( E/7 5:6 9:012/8 ! /7 /==.88/56;7.16:9:57;?.82G;:0/51;7.16:3/0/7763. (.4.0A1/A@A5:6:58A/@;725>3.0@;6/87:/77/;8625> 3.0 /6.02/8 .421.59. /87: 12798:7.7 63/6 63. /==.88/56 E/7 5:6 9:5602@;625> /5A ?:5.A <:0 63. 3:;7.3:81 .H=.57.7 /51 ;7.1 6: /@;7. 63. ( =3A729/88A /51 ?.56/88A
+ 3.7. /7=.967 :< 63. ?/66.0 /0. 7;<<292.56 .5:;>3 6: ?/256/25 9:542962:5 :< 63. /==.88/56 <:0 63. :<<.59.=;5273/@8.;51.0.962:5*,!:<
- 17 -
+* H9.=61.5A25>63.25902?25/625>9209;?76/59.7 63:;>3 /99;7.1 3/7 />0..1 6: .H/?25. .421.59. @;6 3. </28.16:1:7:
+ ' /7 93/0>. ;51.0 .962:5 #) :<
27 9:59.05.1 26 27 63. 7=.92<29 9/7. :< 63. =0:7.9;62:5 63/6 E26363./21:< L=288:E/99;7.1:563.256.04.525> 52>36@.6E..5+ # +#,/51+"# +#,/6/@:;6+# /?602.16:7?::63.063.(/5125:01.06:6/F./E/A 63.82<.:<63.(
627<:;51<0:?63.0.9:01763/6( 0/27.1/8/0?/510.7276.163./66.?=6:<63./99;7.13.0 8.>6:;93.1 4.77.87/51 26<.88 1:E5 ::5/<6.0 3./025> 63.7:;51:<4.77.87</8825>1:E57:5:<63./==.88/56/51
63. ( 5/?.8A 0..63/? 9/?. 63.0. /51 3. 7/E 63. 25921.56/510.=:06.163.7/?.6:63.:63.07/51E3.0.@A
63. 5.2>3@:;07 /51 ?:63.0 9/?. 6: 63. 3:;7. :< 63. /==.88/56 /51 0.79;.1 63. ( /51 :5 7..25> 63.? /==.88/560/A/E/A<0:?63.7=:6:.76/@827363.7/?. 63.=0:7.9;62:5</28.16:.H/?25.63.7:5:<63.(/7/ E265.77
- 18 -
+" ';063.0 /99:0125> 6: 63. 4.072:5 :< 63. ( 6E:?:0..A.E265.77.76:63.25921.565/?.8A211/??/ 20.?/63 /51 3/56/@/2 /5>. E3: =/92<2.1 63. G;/00.8 /510.79;.163.(
+) .0625.568A 5.263.0 211/??/ 20.?/63 5:0 3/56/@/2 /5>. 3/4. @..5 926.1 /7 E265.77.7 @A 63. =0:7.9;62:5/51.H/?25.63.?6:7;==:0663.9/7.:<63. =0:7.9;62:5
+! /F25> 5:6. :< /88 63.7. /7=.967 :< 63. ?/66.0 /51 /87: 6/F25> 5:6. :< 63. 72I. :< /7 27 7..5 25 =3:6:>0/=37 E3293 27 7/21 6: 3/4. @..5 7.2I.1 ;51.0 H+ /3/I/0 63.:0A 63/6 27 =;6 <:0E/01 @A 63. =0:7.9;62:563/6E26363.3.8=:< /==.88/56602.16: 7?::63.063.(9/55:6@.9:;56.5/59.1258/E
+, ';063.0 63.0. 27 5: <0/96;0. :< 63. 5/7/8 @:5. /51(3.07.8<76/6.1/51 E/7;7.16:7?::63.0 63.?:;63/515:663.5:7.';063.063.0.275:<0/96;0. - 19 -
:563.73:;81.0@:5.:063.9:88/0@:5.:05:<0/96;0.25 63.7=25. # /F25> 5:6. /88 63.7. /7=.967 6327 :;06 27 :<
63. 9:5721.0.1 :=252:5 63/6 63. ?/6.02/8 .421.59. 27 5:6 7;<<292.56 .5:;>3 6: ?/256/25 63. 9:542962:5 :< 63. /==.88/56<:063.:<<.59.=;5273/@8.;51.0.962:5#):<
563./@7.59.:</5A@8::125B;0A63./88.>.1 /967 :< 63. /==.88/56 73:;81 @. 79/8.1 1:E5 <0:? 63.
:<<.59.;51.0.962:5#):<
6:+:<
+ 99:0125>8A 25 42.E :<
63. <:0.>:25> 1279;772:57=:256:7/51+/0./57E.0.1=/068A2563. /<<20?/624. ,-.(/01-2013
5 42.E :< 63. <:0.>:25> 1279;772:5 E3.5 6327 :;0679/8.11:E563.:<<.59.<0:?#):<
6:+:<
- 20 -
/51 ?/256/2525> 9:542962:5 :< 63. /==.88/56 <:0 63. :<<.59.=;5273/@8.;51.0.962:5*,!:<
63.9;76:1A =.02:1 /80./1A ;51.0>:5. @A 63. /==.88/56 2< 60./6.1 /7 =.02:1:<2?=027:5?.56@A.53/5925>63.<25./?:;5625/ 7;? 7 #### :< E3293 / 7;? :< 7* ### 9/5 @. =/21 /7 9:?=.57/62:5 6: ( .517 :< B;7629. E:;81 @. ?.62563.=.9;82/0</967/519209;?76/59.7:<63.9/7. * 99:0125>8A =:256 : 27 /57E.0.1 =/068A 25 63./<<20?/624. ,-.(/01-2013
5 42.E :< 63. <25125> :< 6327 :;06 0.>/0125> =:256:76:/7/@:4.63.<:88:E25>
2& 3./==./827/88:E.125=/06 22& (328. ?/256/2525> 63. 9:542962:5 :< 63. /==.88/56 <:0 63. :<<.59. =;5273/@8. ;51.0 .962:5 *,! :<
/==.88/56 /99;7.1 27
- 21 -
/9G;266.1 :< 63. :<<.59. =;5273/@8. ;51.0 .962:5 #) :<
2576./1 3. 3/7 @..5 9:54296.1 <:063. :<<.59. =;5273/@8. ;51.0 .962:5+:< 222& ;76:1A =.02:1 /80./1A ;51.0>:5. @A 63. /==.88/56/99;7.1 E:;81 @. 60./6.1 /7 =.02:1 :< 2?=027:5?.56 <:0 63. =0:4.1 :<<.59.7 ;51.0 .962:57 *,! /51 + :< @A 120.9625> 63. /==.88/56 6: =/A .53/59.1<25.:<7 #### 24& ==.88/56 27 >0/56.1 6: =/A 63. .53/59.1 <25. /?:;56 6288 #!+#+ </28;0. 6: =/A 63.<25.E26325#!+#+ /==.88/5673/88 ;51.0>: 2?=027:5?.56 <:0 / =.02:1 :< 6E: A./07 4&
;6 :<
63. <25. /?:;56 0.9:4.0.1 7* ### 27 :01.0.1 6: @. =/21 /7 9:?=.57/62:5 6: 63. ( ;51.0 1;. 21.562<29/62:5
- 22 -
<<29. 27 120.96.1 6: 0.6;05 63. 02/8 :;06 .9:017 E2639:=A:<6327B;1>?.56<:063E263<:0277;.:<?:12<2.1 9:542962:5E/00/56
/* &$)
276:8:*)