- 1 - !"#"" "$$ %& %'$() *%(( + ! " " " #$%$&$ ' ! " () *!" " ' &**&& &%&*& * Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - " ' + #" + ! ,,-./01*23 1&%&*&1345/627/1645/ 7/893/00024213872.492,4830 /..213.-0:/-7;89:8 2. 2<=-:323: 45/ >-0:</34 16 ,13?2,4213 830 190/9 16 ./34/3,/084/0&**&&,13?2,423:52<61945/166/3,/. -30/9 /,4213*$$)$@830(9/80A245 /,4213) 16 30283 /387 10/ B619 .5194 CDE 830 ./34/3,23: 41 -30/9:1.2<=7/2<=92.13</346198=/921016F/89.830 41=8F623/16.#61945/166/3,/=-32.58;7/-30/9 /,4213 *$ 16 G -30/9:1 .2<=7/ 2<=92.13</34 619 8 =/9210 16 <1345. 830 =8F 623/ 16 .$# 619 45/ 166/3,/ =-32.58;7/ -30/9 /,4213 $) 16 G -30/9:1 .2<=7/2<=92.13</346198=/921016&F/8983041=8F623/ 16.&$#61945/166/3,/=-32.58;7/-30/9 /,4213$@ 16G83041-30/9:1.2<=7/2<=92.13</346198=/9210 - 3 - 16F/89.83041=8F623/16.*#61945/166/3,/ =-32.58;7/ -30/9 /,4213 ( 16 A245 0/68-74 ./34/3,/. * "8,4.1645/,8./23;92/689/458445/",8</ 41 ;/ 9/:2.4/9/0 13 45/ ;8.2. 16 45/ 629.4 23619<84213 710:/0 ;F .48423: 4584 45/ 8==/778348,,-./0 1* ;/23:A26/1645/23>-9/0H$5802772,249/784213.52=A245 8,,-./0 1& 3 **& 0-923: <2032:54 84 * 8<8,,-./01&,8</4145/51-./16$-30/945/ :-2./ 16 .//I23: 0923I23: A84/9 830 .48;;/0 52< A245 8 I326/A24583234/3421341,8-./52.0/845,,-./01* ;/23:45/A26/1645/23>-9/087.18..2.4/08,,-./01&23 ,1<<2..213 16 45/ 166/3,/ 5/ 8,,-./0 58?/ ,92<23877F 2342<2084/0 45/ 23>-9/0 23.42:84/0 41 ,1<<24 ;9/8,5 16 =/8,/83045/9/;F,1<<244/045/8;1?/.820166/3,/. 64/9 23?/.42:84213 ,589:/#.5//4 ,8</ 41 ;/ 627/0 5/ 7/893/0 8:2.4984/ 411I ,1:32J83,/ 619 45/ 8;1?/ .820 166/3,/ 830 ,1<<244/0 45/ <844/9 41 45/ - 4 - /..213. 1-94 5/ 9287 1-94 .-<<13/0 45/ 8,,-./0 ,,-./0 1.& 830 * 58?/ 8==/89/0 ;/619/ 45/ 9287 1-94=7/80/0314:-274F830,782</041;/492/0 ) 1 =91?/ 45/ :-274 16 45/ 8,,-./0 45/ =91./,-4213/K8<23/023877&A243/../.8..&41& :14 <89I/0 45/ 01,-</34. 8. =/9 K.& 41 &$ 830 20/34262/0&23.-==1941624.,134/34213 5/8,,-./0 0/32/0 877 45/ 23,92<238423: <84/9287. 8?8278;7/ 13 9/,190 23 45/29 .484/</34 -30/9 /,4213 & 16 9 830 :14 /K8<23/0&23.-==1941645/290/6/3,/ $ 64/948I23:2341,13.20/98421387745/<84/9287. 139/,19045/ 92871-94,8</4145/,13,7-.213458445/ =91./,-4213 2. .-,,/..6-7 23 =91?23: 45/ :-274 16 8,,-./0 1.& 830 * 619 45/ 8;1?/ .820 166/3,/. 830 8,,19023:7F =8../045/2<=-:3/0>-0:</3416,13?2,4213830190/916 ./34/3,/ /23: 8::92/?/0 ;F 45/ .8</ 8,,-./0 1* 2. ;/619/452.1-94 - 5 - @ /890 92 980//= -<89 7/893/0 <2,-. -928/ 619 45/ 8==/77834 830 92 1=87 92.538 808? 7/893/0 2:5 1-94 1?/93</34 7/80/9 619 45/ 9/.=130/34# 484//9-./045/<84/9287.23,7-023:45/ 9287 1-949/,190. ( 3 ?2/A 16 45/ 92?87 ,134/34213. -9:/0 ;F 7/893/0,1-3./7619;14545/=8942/.45/=12344584A1-70 892./619<F,13.20/9842132. % F83.A/94145/8;1?/=12342. 61945/61771A23: L 4 2. 45/ ,134/34213 16 45/ =91./,-4213 4584 8,,-./0 1& A8. 58?23: 2772,24 9/784213.52= A245 8,,-./0 1*A512.45/A26/1623>-9/0$ 5/9/619/45/9/A8. - 6 - 8 M-899/7 ;/4A//3 45/< 3 45/ 084/ 16 45/ 23,20/34 23 45/<2032:54848;1-4*8<8,,-./01&A/344145/ 51-./ 16 23>-9/0 $ A51 A8. .48F23: 8713: A245 8,,-./01*-30/945/:-2./168.I23:6190923I23:A84/9 89</0A2458I326/<</0284/7F$1=/3/045/0119 5/ 492/0 41 .48; 52< A245 45/ I326/ .1 8. 41 ,8-./ 52. 0/845 1A/?/9 5/ .-.4823/0 23>-92/. ,,-./0 1& 8;-./0 52< A245 62745F 783:-8:/ ,92<23877F 2342<2084/0 83023.42:84/041,1<<24;9/8,516=/8,/ & 1 =91?/ 24. ,134/34213 45/ =91./,-4213 /K8<23/0 &#45/ 01,419 A51 49/84/0 45/ 23>-9/0 830 2..-/045/A1-30,/94262,84/8.=/9K&K&02.,71./. 45841345/084/1645/23,20/3445/23>-9/0A8.49/84/0;F &A24545/52.419F168..8-748305/580.-.4823/04A1 ,-478,/984/0A1-30.A52,5A/9/:92/?1-.23384-9/* 2. 45/ 3:23//9 A51 58. 098A3 45/ .=14 .I/4,5 8. =/9 K* 2. 45/ ;9145/9 16 45/ 23>-9/0 A51 627/0 45/ 629.4 23619<84213 8. =/9 K ) 2. 45/ <858J89 A243/..4145/.=14<858J8984K)$2.45/23>-9/0 - 7 - /F/#A243/.. A51 58. 6-77F .-==194/0 45/ ,8./ 16 45/ =91./,-4213 830 0/=1./0 9/:89023: 45/ 1?/94 8,4 ,1<<244/0 ;F 8,,-./0 1.& 830 * .@ 41 % 89/ 45/ /F/#A243/../. 41 45/ 23,20/34 A51 58?/ 87.1 .-==194/0 45/ ,8./ 16 45/ =91./,-4213 .L 830 & 89/ 45/ <858J89A243/../.4145/./2J-9/<858J8984K(-30/9 A52,5 &#45/ I326/ -./0 23 45/ ,1<<2..213 16 166/3,/ A8. ./2J/0 84 45/ 23.483,/ 16 8,,-./0 1& .&& 830 &*89/45/=172,/1662,287.A519/:2.4/9/045/"830627/0 45/,589:/.5//4&2.45/1662,287691<45/A51 2..-/045/7/44/98.=/9K&$41,13629<458445/9/A8. =1A/9 .-==7F 84 45/ .,/3/ 16 1,,-99/3,/ 84 45/ 42</ 16 23,20/34 && 5/ /?20/3,/ 16 $ ;/23: 45/ 23>-9/0 /F/# A243/.. 830 .@ 41 % ;/23: 45/ /F/#A243/../. 41 45/ 23,20/348..-</.2<=19483,/23,13.20/923:45/,134/34213 48I/3 ;F 45/ 8==/77834 5/9/23 5/./ A243/../. 58?/ ,13.2.4/347F0/=1./09/:89023:45/,1<<2..21316166/3,/ ;F 8,,-./0 1.& 830 * ?/3 451-:5 45/./ A243/../. - 8 - A/9/,91..#/K8<23/0847/3:45314523:58.;//3/72,24/0 691<45/<4102.;/72/?/45/29?/9.213 &* 5/ 8,,-./0 :14 /K8<23/0 & A51 2. 45/ 08-:54/9 16 45/ 23>-9/0 $ 830 8,,-./0 1* 5/ 0/6/3,/ 48I/3 ;F 45/ 8,,-./0 2. 4584 45/ 23>-9/0 $ A8.8002,4/0410923I23:87,1517830-30/945/2367-/3,/16 87,15175/<-.458?/6877/3830.-.4823/023>-92/.K& 02.,71./.458445/23>-9/058..-.4823/04A1,-478,/984/0 A1-30. &#45/ 01,419 A51 49/84/0 45/ 23>-9/0 830 2..-/0 45/ A1-30 ,/94262,84/ .=/,262,877F .484/0 4584 45/ 23>-92/.</34213/023K&,1-70;/,8-./0268=/9.132. .48;;/0A24545/I326/#&-923:,91..#/K8<238421324 2. .-::/.4/0 4145/ A243/.. 4584 26 8 =/9.13 6877. 691< 8 <1?23:?/52,7/5/<8F.-.4823.-,523>-92/.83045/.820 .-::/.4213 2. 67847F 0/32/0 ;F 45/ A243/.. 4 2. 87.1 .-::/.4/0 41 45/ A243/.. 4584 26 8 =/9.13 6877. 13 45/ .589=/0:/0A/8=13..-,523>-92/.,1-70;/,8-./0 5/ A243/..80<244/0452..-::/.4213 1A/?/9242.=/9423/34 41 314/ 4584 8. =/9 K& 45/9/ 89/ 4A1 ,-4 78,/984/0 - 9 - A1-30.24,83314;/.82045848=/9.13A27768774A2,/13 45/ .589= /0:/0 A/8=13 41 .-.4823 4A1 .-,5 23>-92/. 5/9/619/ 8< 16 45/ 1=23213 4584 45/ =91./,-4213 2. .-,,/..6-7 23 =91?23: 45/ :-274 16 45/ 8,,-./0 ;/F130 9/8.138;7/ 01-;4 1A/?/9 45/ 8,,-./0 6827/0 41 =91;8;782J/45/0/6/3,/48I/3;F45/< & 4 2. 45/ ,134/34213 16 45/ =91./,-4213 4584 8,,-./0 1& 580 ,8</ A245 8 I326/ 830 .48;;/0 45/ 23>-9/0 24 2. 87.1 45/ ,134/34213 16 45/ =91./,-4213 4584 8,,-./01*;/23:45/A26/1645/23>-9/0A8.A24552< 8445/42</1623,20/34830.5/8..2.4/08,,-./01&;F 517023:45/23>-9/041,8-./45/23>-92/. 5/23>-9/0830 45//F/#A243/../.58?/.=/,262,877F0/=1./09/:89023:45/ .8</01314623083F9/8.134102.;/72/?/45/29?/9.213 30/9 .-,5 ,29,-<.483,/. 8< 16 45/ 1=23213 4584 45/ =91./,-4213 2. .-,,/..6-7 23 =91?23: 45/ :-274 16 8,,-./0 1*45/8==/778345/9/23;/F1309/8.138;7/01-;4 - 10 - &) 4 2. ;91-:54 41 45/ 3142,/ 16 45/ 1-94 4584 8,,-./0 1& A51 A8. ,13?2,4/0 ;F 45/ 9287 1-94 580 =9/6/99/045/8==/872392<2387==/871@(@*&*830 45/ .820 8==/87 ,8</ 41 ;/ 02.<2../0 ;F 452. 1-94 ?20/ >-0:</34084/0*%&*&1345/M-/.42131672<2484213 5/.820>-0:</3458.9/8,5/06238724F83045/9/619/45/ >-0:</34 16 ,13?2,4213 830 190/9 16 ./34/3,/ =8../0 8:823.48,,-./01&A8.,13629</0 &$ 58?/:13/4591-:545/2<=-:3/0>-0:</3416 ,13?2,4213830190/916./34/3,/=8../0;F45/ 92871-94 8:823.4 45/ 8==/77834 5/9/23 01 314 6230 83F 9/8.13 41 234/96/9/ A245 45/ >-0:</34 16 ,13?2,4213 =8../0 ;F 45/ 92871-94 &@ 4 452. .48:/ 7/893/0 <2,-. -928/ 619 45/ 8==/77834 .-;<24. 4584 8,,-./0 1* 2. 8 780F 58?23: ,52709/3 41 .-==194 830 45/9/619/ =98F. 619 .51A23: <8K2<-<7/32/3,F235/968?1-9 - 11 - &( 13.20/923: .-,5 .-;<2..213 830 87.1 45/ 68,4 4584 45/ 8,,-./0 1* ;/23: 45/ A26/ 16 45/ 23>-9/0 580 314 ,8-./0 83F 23>-92/. A245 83F A/8=13 8< 16 45/ 1=23213 4584 45/ 190/9 16 ./34/3,/ =8../0 8:823.4 5/9 ,1-70 ;/ <10262/0 ,,19023:7F 83.A/9 45/8;1?/=1234 C 830 =91,//0 41 =8.. 45/ 61771A23: 2! 5/92<2387==/872. 22! 5/ 2<=-:3/0 >-0:</34 16 ,13?2,4213 084/0 &**&& =8../0 23 1&%&*& 13 45/ 627/ 16 7/893/0 002421387 2.492,4 830 /..213. -0:/ -7;89:8 2. 5/9/;F ,13629</0 222! 5/ 190/9 16 ./34/3,/ =8../0 8:823.4 8==/77834#8,,-./01*;F45/ 92871-94619 45/ 166/3,/ -30/9 /,4213. $) 830 $@ 9A )162.,13629</0 5/190/916./34/3,/ =8../0;F45/ 92871-9441=8F623/8<1-34 2.87.1,13629</0 - 12 - 2?! 1A/?/945/190/916./34/3,/=8../0;F45/ 9287 1-94 619 45/ 166/3,/ =-32.58;7/ -30/9 /,4213. *$ 830 ( 16 2. <10262/0 8. -30/9G 8! 5/ 8==/77834#8,,-./0 1* 2. ./34/3,/0 41 -30/9:1 .2<=7/ 2<=92.13</34 619 8 =/9210 16 13/ F/89 /8,5 619 45/ 166/3,/ -30/9 /,4213. *$ 830(16 ?! 5/ .-;.48342?/ ./34/3,/. .5877 9-3 ,13,-99/347F ?2! ==/77834,,-./0 1* 2. /34247/0 619 ./4 166 8.=/9 /,4213)*%169 ?22! 5/190/99/:89023:,1<=/3.84213=8../0;F 45/ 92871-942.,13629</0 /:2.49F 41 ./30;8,I 45/ 92871-94 /,190. 8713: A245,1=F16452.>-0:</3461923619<842138306193//06-7 8,4213 - 13 - 5/6//.16<2,-.-928/2.62K/084.&# 5/ 7/893/0 002421387 /:2.4989 /3/987 2. 029/,4/0 41<8I/3/,/..89F89983:/</34.619=8F</341645/6//. 4145/<2,-.-928/ ,) %""( # 2.41& 71*(