- 1 - !!"!#$ % "&"'""! ""'' ($) * ! " ! # $ % # # %&' ## # !# &%( " #&&)$!"&# # # Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - #& # % * %%+ & # # +)*%* # & # #, #, -# &! ./0 122314 /0 253635537 89 :.3 ;41/<1=: 1>1/=0: :.3 ?7><3=: 1=7 1@157 71:37 % * %%+ 210037 /= # A +)*%* 89 :.3 77/:/A=14 3=/A5 /B/4 ?7>3 1=7 # 1: /C1912?51 !6A5 0.A5: D:.3 :5/8?=14E" 033F/=> 3=.1=;3<3=:A6:.3;A<23=01:/A= % .3 /=C?537 ;41/<1=: 1>37 $ 93150 @A5F/=> 10 ;431=35<3:@/:.1;;/73=:A=% % %*1=7.36/437;41/< 23:/:/A= 033F/=> ;A<23=01:/A= A6 0 .3 :5/8?=14 ;A=0/735/=> :.3 3=:/53 3B/73=;3 A= 53;A57 1@15737 ;A<23=01:/A= A6 0 $)$ @/:. /=:3530: 1: :.3 51:3 A6 G2351==?<65A<:.371:3A623:/:/A=:/441@157 >>5/3B37 89 :.3 01/7 A5735 :./0 122314 /0 253635537 /= @./;. /: /0 ;A=:3=737 :.1: :.3 ;41/<1=: @10 315=/=> 1 0?< A6 - 3 - 0 235 <A=:. 1=7 :.3 :5/8?=14 .10 :1F3= 0 $% 235 <A=:. $ :.3 A;:A5 10030037 :.3 7/018/4/:9G8?::.3:5/8?=14.10:1F3=G106?=;:/A=14 7/018/4/:9 1=7 /: /0 :A 83 3=.1=;37 &?5:.35 .3 53H?30:0 :A 3=.1=;3:.351:3A6/=:3530::A%G/=0:317A6G $ 3157 :.3 15>?<3=:0 A6 :.3 4315=37 ;A?=0340 65A<8A:.0/730 + .3 A;:A5 $ .10 10030037 :.3 7/018/4/:9 1: G $57 A6 :.3 G ;A<30 :A G 3=;3 :.3 7/018/4/:9 :1F3= 89 :.3 :5/8?=14 1: G /0 25A235 1=7 ;A553;: 315=37 ;A?=0346A5:.3;41/<1=:1223441=:;A=:3=737:.1::.31>3A6 :.323:/:/A=35@100.A@=10+93150/=I )1=7/=A:.35 <37/;1453;A5708?:/=I ./01>3/00.A@=1093150 .3:5/8?=14534/37?2A=I 1=7;A=0/73537:.31>3A6:.3 ;41/<1=:1093150 A=0/735/=>:.31>3<3=:/A=37/=:.3 I ) 1=7 A:.35 <37/;14 53;A570 :./0 A?5: 6/=70 /: 5310A=1843:A;A=0/735:.31>3A6:.3;41/<1=:10+93150 6A5@./;.:.3<?4:/24/35@A?4783DE - 4 - .3 ;41/<1=: 0?0:1/=37 ;A<<?=/:37 7/0241;37 651;:?53 A6 C?=;:/A= A6 </7743 1=7 4A@35 $57 0.16: A6 .?<35?0@./;./0>5/3BA?0/==1:?53 %/00?377/018/4/:9 ;35:/6/;1:3 1: I % /= ./0 ;5A00 3I1</=1:/A= 732A037 :.1: :.3 ;41/<1=: 0?663537 .31437 0?5>/;14 0;15 <15FAB35:.32A0:35/A51023;:436:15<<310?5/=>18A?: ;< 3 .10 140A 732A037 18A?: :.3 530:5/;:/A= A6 348A@ <AB3<3=: 1=7 51>3 A6 <AB3<3=: A6 0.A?4735 /= B/3@ A6 1;;/73=:14 /=C?5/30 3=;3 :.3 :5/8?=14 .10 ;A=0/73537 G 7/018/4/:9 1=7 /: =3370 =A /=:356353=;3 /=;3 .3 <3: @/:. 1;;/73=:/=:.39315%*./0/=;A<310235:.3>?/734/=30 A6:.315=1:1F1:1:33>1435B/;30@A?47830 $% .3:5/8?=14.105/>.:49:1F3=:.3/=;A<3A60 $%1=7 :.34A00A66?:?53/010?=735, 0 $%J%JJGK0 +*+ .3 :5/8?=14 .10 1@15737 1 0?< A6 0 )$ :A@1570 <37/;14 3I23=030 @./;. =3370 =A /=:356353=;3 89 :./0A?5: .3;41/<1=:@10.A02/:14/L376A51235/A7A6* 719010235I ./0A?5:6/=70/:5310A=1843:A>51=:1= - 5 - 1<A?=: A6 0 :A@1570 21/= 1=7 0?6635/=> 0 %:A@15704A00A61<3=/:/300 $:A@1570 :51=02A5:1:/A= 3I:51 =A?5/0.<3=: 1=7 1::3=71=: ;.15>30 .3;41/<1=:</>.:=A:.1B31::3=7371=9@A5F6A51:4310: 6A?5<A=:.0 .3536A5310?<A60 $!0 $%J +<A=:.0"/01@15737:A@15704A00A6/=;A<37?5/=>41/7?2 235/A7 .3:A:14;A<23=01:/A=@A?478310?=735, 4 A 3170A6;A<23=01:/A= <A?=:0 A00A66?:?53/=;A<3 0 +*+ % 1/=1=70?6635/=>0 0 $ A00A61<3=/:/30 0 % + 51=02A5:1:/A= 3I:51 =A?5/0.<3=: 1=7 1::3=71=: ;.15>30 0 $ A00 A6 /=;A<3 7?5/=> 41/7 ?2235/A7 0 $ #37/;143I23=030 0 )$ A:14 0 $$$$ ) .3;41/<1=:/03=:/:4376A5:A:14;A<23=01:/A=A6 0 $$$$ 14A=> @/:. /=:3530: 1: :.3 51:3 A6 G 235 1==?< 65A< :.3 71:3 A6 23:/:/A= :/44 5314/L1:/A= 10 1>1/=0: 0 $)$1@1573789:.3:5/8?=14 315=37 ;A?=034 6A5 :.3 =0?51=;3 ;A<21=9 0?8</:0 :.1: :.3 ;A<23=01:/A= 1<A?=: 1@15737 89 :.3 :5/8?=14.10833=732A0/:37836A53:.3:5/8?=14 - 6 - * ;;A57/=>49:.36A44A@/=>A5735, ! !/" .3122314/0144A@37/=215:( !//" .3 ;41/<1=: /0 3=:/:437 6A5 :A:14 ;A<23=01:/A=A60 $$$$14A=>@/:./=:3530: 1: :.3 51:3 A6 G 235 1==?< 65A< :.3 71:3 A6 23:/:/A= :/44 5314/L1:/A= 10 1>1/=0: 0 $)$ 1@1573789:.3:5/8?=14( !///" .3 =0?51=;3 ;A<21=9 /0 7/53;:37 :A 732A0/: :.3 3=.1=;37 ;A<23=01:/A= A6 0 *%+14A=>@/:./=:3530:@/:./=A=3<A=:. 65A<:.371:3A6:./0A5735( !/B" =0?;.732A0/::.3;41/<1=:/0235</::37 :A @/:.751@ :.3 3=:/53 1<A?=: 14A=> @/:. /=:3530: 1;;5?37A=/: !B" .3 ;41/<1=: /0 =A: 3=:/:437 6A5 /=:3530: 6A5:.37341937235/A7A6%)7190 +,- ('""!) &! /0:A ,4A ,)*