- 1 - !" #$%$$ $ & '&()* ' &)) + ! " # $ " % " $ $ % $ & " # $ ' $ " % ! % $ " ( % " Digitally signed by NIJAMUDDIN JAMKHANDI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - $ $ % $ % (!&! % &!&!" % % )$ ' '% % %% $ & & ( " % $ ( % $ % *$ ' *$ ' " +,-./0123,4/,0101231567.--85,432!920+,:13 ;.< 2= 0+, 4,-,.5,4 5,,>13? .301-1/.02:7 6.1; 834,: ,-0123!2=$+.:.017..?.:1>8:.>5+..3+10.!&!( 13 2(!&! .:1513? 280 2= :19, 2&!&! :,?150,:,4 67 8001 2;1-, 0.0123 =2: 0+, 2==,3-, /8315+.6;, 834,: ,-01235 & & :,.4 <10+ ,-0123 ( "2=$+.:.017.7.7..3+10.!&!(.34,-01235(.34 2= 2<:7 :2+1610123 -0 @A /,3413? 23 0+, =1;, 2= ;,.:3,4,312:1B1;'84?,.34'%13?.58?8: - 3 - ! +, ?150 2= 0+, -29/;.130 15 0+.0 .--85,4 2 +.4 4,B,;2/,4 .-C8.130.3-, <10+ 0+, 4,-,.5,4 0+:28?+ 0+, 52-1.; 9,41. /;.0=2:9 350.?:.9 <+1-+ ,B,308.;;7 -8;913.0,4 13 0+,1: 9.::1.?, .6280 =28: 7,.:5 .?2 0 15 .;;,?,4 0+.0 .0 0+, 019, 2= 9.::1.?, 0+, /.:,305 2= 0+, 4,-,.5,4+.4/.14.42<:72= 5&&&&13-.5+.34.;52 /:,5,30,4 ?2;4 2:3.9,305 02 0+,1: 4.8?+0,: /:12: 02 (&&!&! +,-29/;.130 =8:0+,:415-;25,5 0+.0.--85,4 2 48:13? +15 B15105 02 0+, +285, 2= 0+, -29/;.13.30 90 3D.99. +.4 /+751-.;;7 .55.8;0,4 0+, 4,-,.5,4<+1;,9.>13?4,9.345=2:.4410123.;42<:7015 =8:0+,:.;;,?,40+.0.3.4410123.;5892= 5!&&&<.5 5865,C8,30;7 /.14 02 .--85,4 2 +, .;;,?.01235 .;52 1341-.0, 0+.0 .--85,4 2 +856.34" .--85,4 2! 920+,:13;.<" .34 .--85,4 2( 5150,:13;.<" <,:, /,:5150,30;7 4,9.3413? . =8:0+,: 42<:7 2= 5!&&&&& .34 & ?:.95 2= ?2;4 0+,:,67 586D,-013? 0+, 4,-,.5,4 90.7.3.+.95.02-230138285+.:.559,30015=8:0+,: .;;,?,40+.00+,4,-,.5,4+.458==,:,4.915-.::1.?,48, - 4 - 020+,.55.8;067.--85,42<+1-+8;019.0,;74:2B,+,: 02 0.>, 0+, ,E0:,9, 50,/ 2= -29910013? 581-14, 23 !@&!&! ( /23:,-,1B13?0+,13=2:9.0123230+,=2;;2<13? 4.71,(&&!&!.-29/;.130<.5;24?,4;,.413?02 :,?150:.01232=:19,2&!&!67 80012;1-,0.0123 +, /:,5,30 /,010123,: <+2 15 0+, 920+,:13;.< 2= 0+, 4,-,.5,4 15 32< .//:,+,3413? .::,50 13 -233,-0123 <10+ 0+, 5.14 -.5, .34 +.5 0+,:,=2:, .//:2.-+,4 0+15 28:0 5,,>13?:,;1,=2=.301-1/.02:76.1; +, ;,.:3,4 1?+ 28:0 2B,:39,30 ;,.4,: 2//2513?0+,/,010123-230,34,40+.00+,:,,E15058==1-1,30 13-:1913.013? 9.0,:1.;5 23 :,-2:4 1341-.013? 0+, .-01B, 13B2;B,9,30 2= 0+, /,010123,: 13 0+, .;;,?,4 2==,3-, 0 15 5869100,40+.00+,9.0,:1.;5-2;;,-0,448:13?13B,501?.0123 :,B,.; 0+.0 0+, /,010123,: .;23? <10+ 20+,: .--85,4 +.4 586D,-0,4 0+, 4,-,.5,4 02 -:8,;07 23 .--2830 2= 42<:7 4,9.345<+1-+;,402+,:-29910013?581-14, ,3-,1015 - 5 - .:?8,4 0+.0 0+15 15 320 . =10 -.5, =2: 0+, ,E,:-15, 2= 415-:,012313=.B28:2=0+,/,010123,: /23 -.:,=8; -23514,:.0123 2= 0+, :,-2:45 0+15 28:0 =1345 0+.0 0+, -+.:?, 5+,,0 +.5 .;:,.47 6,,3 ;.14 .34 0+.0 0+, /:25,-80123 -.5, 105,;= 1341-.0,5 0+.0 0+, 4,-,.5,4 <.5 13 . ;2B, :,;.01235+1/ <10+ .--85,4 2 /:12:020+,1:9.::1.?,+28?+0+,4,.0+2=0+,4,-,.5,4 90.7.3.+.95. .//,.:5 02 +.B, 2--8::,4 834,: 585/1-1285-1:-8950.3-,5-28/;,4<10+.;;,?.012352=42<:7 +.:.559,30 0+, :2;, 2= 0+, /:,5,30 /,010123,: .34 +,: 41:,-0 3,E85 02 0+, 4,-,.5,4)5 .-0 2= -29910013? 581-14, .:,9.00,:50+.0-.36,,==,-01B,;7.4D841-.0,423;748:13? . =8;;=;,4?,4 0:1.; .>13? 1302 .--2830 0+, .?, 2= 0+, /,010123,:<+2157,.:5.34.<142<.34-23514,:13? 0+.00+,13B,501?.012315-29/;,0,0+1528:0152=0+,B1,< 0+.0 -850241.; 130,::2?.0123 15 320 <.::.30,4 ,3-, 0+, /,010123,: 15 ,3010;,4 02 6, ,3;.:?,4 23 .301-1/.02:7 6.1; 586D,-0 02 50:13?,30 -234101235 --2:413?;7 0+15 28:0 /:2-,,4502/.550+,=2;;2<13? - 6 - +,/,01012315.;;2<,4 ,010123,:.--85,4 2! 13 2(!&! .:1513? 280 2= :19, 2&!&! :,?150,:,4 67 8001 2;1-, 0.0123 =2: 0+, 2==,3-,5 /8315+.6;, 834,: ,-01235 & .34 & :,.4 <10+ ,-0123 ( " 2= 0+, $+.:.017. 7.7..3+10.!&!(.34,-01235(.342=0+,2<:7 :2+1610123-0@A/,3413?230+,=1;,2=;,.:3,4,312: 1B1;'84?,.34'%13?.58?8:5+.;;6,:,;,.5,4130+, ,B,302=+,:.::,50586D,-002=2;;2<13?-234101235 . +,/,010123,:5+.;;.//,.:6,=2:,0+,:1.;28:0 <10+13 4.75 =:29 0+, 4.0, 2= :,-,1/0 2= . -,:01=1,4 -2/7 2= 0+15 2:4,: .34 ,E,-80, . /,:523.; 6234 =2: . 589 2= 5&&&&& 8/,,5 3,.>+23;7"<10+0<258:,01,5=2:0+, ;1>,589020+,5.015=.-01232=0+,:1.;28:0 - 7 - 6 +,/,010123,:5+.;;.//,.:6,=2:,0+,:1.;28:0 23.;;4.0,52=+,.:13?83;,55,E,9/0,4=2:B.;14 :,.5235 - +, /,010123,: 5+.;; 320 0.9/,: <10+ 0+, /:25,-80123<103,55,52:,B14,3-,,10+,:41:,-0;7 2:1341:,-0;7 4 +, /,010123,: 5+.;; 320 13B2;B, +,:5,;= 13 .37 2==,3-,2=.5191;.:3.08:,13=808:, ,* &$$) % ' 1502;2(