Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 65657 (KAR)
MOHAMMED GOUSE v. SHARANA BASAPPA AND ANR
MFA/201228/2018 · 2025-10-10
H T Narendra Prasad, Tyagaraja N Inavally
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 65657 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 65657 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"
#! $ %!#! $ %!"%& "
! !##
'&(
)
!"
#
$
%
%&
% '
%
(
!"
Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
%
)
%
)
#
$ (
%)*
&
)
)
$& ) %
)
' ! )
'
% +"+
)
'
%
,'
,' '
%
- 3 -
%
$,'
&
-./ 011203 45627 289.:5 $& :; :9:7 %2-.832/ 89 !! $-272.50;927 72;27726 9: 0/ <9-2 89=& -0/ >225 ;.326 >? 9-2 830.@059 >2.5A 0AA7.2B26 >? 9-2 C46A@259 60926!10//26>? 663./97.89056 2//.:5/ '46A2D663090.8-47.5%:+"+
)089/ A.B.5A 7./2 9: 9-2 ;.3.5A :; 9-2 011203 >7.2;3?/909260729-09:5!+090>:49 0@ 5207:;;.820.8-47:50.8-470597030?07:069-2 67.B27:;807>207.5A72A./9709.:5:"67:B2 9-2 /0@2 ;7:@ 0.3E0? /909.:5 0.8-47 9:E076/ 0597030?09::F 947552078.78329-272>?60/-269:
9-2 >.F2 8:@.5A ;7:@ :11:/.92 6.7289.:5 056 804/26 9-2 088.6259 / 0 72/439 :; 9-2 0;:72/0.6 088.6259 9-2 830.@059/4/90.526A7.2B:4/.5C47.2/056E0/-:/1.903.G26
-2830.@059;.3260129.9.:545627 289.:5++ :;9-289/22F.5A8:@125/09.:5
9E0/13206269-09-2
- 4 -
/1259 -4A2 0@:459 9:E076/ @26.803 2H125/2/
9 E0/ ;479-27 1320626 9-09 9-2 088.6259 :8847726 14723? :5 088:459:;9-270/-05652A3.A25967.B.5A:;9-2:;;256.5A B2-.832>?.9/67.B27
" 5/27B.82:;5:9.829-272/1:56259:/056 01120726 9-7:4A- 8:45/23 056 ;.326 E7.9925 /9092@259 625?.5A9-20B27@259/@062.59-2830.@129.9.:5
59-2>0/./:;9-213206.5A/:;9-21079.2/9-2 30.@/7.>4503;70@269-2.//42/0569-2720;927728:7626 9-2 2B.62582 -2 830.@059 -.@/23; E0/ 2H0@.526 0/
0/-.F0590 74/9? E0/ 2H0@.526 0/ 056 707./-@479-?E0/2H0@.5260/056A:92H-.>.926 6:84@259/ 50@23? H 9: H 5 >2-03; :; 9-2 72/1:56259/ A:9 @07F26 2H-.>.926 6:84@259 50@23? H
+ -2 30.@/ 7.>4503 >? 9-2 .@14A526 C46A@259-2369-099-2088.62599::F13082:5 088:459 :; 70/- 056 52A3.A259 67.B.5A :; 9-2 :;;256.5A
- 5 -
B2-.832 >? .9/ 67.B27 0/ 0 72/439 :; E-.8- 9-2 830.@059 /4/90.526 .5C47.2/ -2 7.>4503 ;479-27 -236 9-09 9-2 830.@059 ./ 259.9326 9: 0 8:@125/09.:5 :; /!" 03:5AE.9-.59272/9099-27092:;+I100566.7289269-2 72/1:56259 :/ 056 9: 621:/.9 9-2 8:@125/09.:5 0@:45903:5AE.9-.59272/92.5A0AA7.2B269-2172/259 011203-0/>225;.326
7. -07050A:460%09.39-232075268:45/23 ;:79-2830.@059-0/70./269-2;:33:E.5A8:59259.:5/
0& ).7/93?2B259-:4A-9-2830.@059830.@/9-09-2E0/ 6:.5A@28-05.8E:7F0562075.5A/127@:59- >499-27.>4503-0/90F259-25:9.:503.58:@20/@2723? 0/ / 1@ E-.8- ./:5 9-2 3:E27 /.622 ;479-27 8:59256/ 9-09 .5 B.2E :; 9-2 C46A@259 :; 12H :479 .5 80/2 :;
B
""" -2 830.@059 ./ 03/: 259.9326 ;:7 ;4947217:/12894/
- 6 -
>&
28:563? 9-2 830.@059 -0/ 2H0@.526 9-2 6:89:7 0/ -2 6:89:7 .5 -./ 2B.62582 -0/ /90926 9-09 9-2 830.@059-0//4;;27266./0>.3.9?:;! I9:9-2E-:32>:6? 642 9: 0@14909.:5 :; 7.A-9 3:E27 3.@> 49 9-2 7.>4503 -0/ 90F25 9-2 E-:32 >:6? 6./0>.3.9? 09 "I E-.8- ./ :5 9-23:E27/.62
8& -.763? -2 8:59256/ 9-09 9-2 7.A-9 0>:B2 F522 -0/ >2250@1490926-2830.@05972J4.726079.;.8.0332A056.9 8:/9/ @:72 9-05 / 49 9-2 7.>4503 -0/ 0E07626 :53? / 2582 -2 /:4A-9 ;:7 25-0582@259:;8:@125/09.:5
6& 0/93?
642 9: 9-2 088.6259 9-2 830.@059 -0/ /4/90.526A7.2B:4/.5C47.2/2E0/97209260/.5109.259;:7 0 127.:6 :; 60?/ B25 0;927 6./8-07A2 ;7:@ 9-2 -:/1.903-2E0/5:9.501:/.9.:59:6./8-07A2-./72A4307 E:7F2-0//4;;27263:9:;10.5647.5A97209@259056-0/ 9:/4;;279-26./0>.3.9?9-7:4A-:49-./3.;2:5/.627.5A9-2 /0@2 9-2 8:@125/09.:5 0E07626 >? 9-2 7.>4503 45627
- 7 -
9-2-206/:;,3://:;0@25.9.2/,,10.5056/4;;27.5A/,056 :9-27 .58.625903 2H125/2/ 072 :5 9-2 3:E27 /.62 2582 -2/:4A-9;:7033:E.5A9-2011203
! 5 9-2 :9-27 -056 @9 7229. 09.3 23F456. 3207526 8:45/23 ;:7 72/1:56259 :
5/470582 :@105? -0/70./26;:33:E.5A8:459278:59259.:5/
0& ).7/93?2B259-:4A-9-2830.@059830.@/9-09-2E0/ 2075.5A/127@:59--2-0/5:917:6482605? 6:84@259/9:2/90>3./--./.58:@2
59-20>/2582:;17::;
:; .58:@2 9-2 7.>4503 -0/7.A-93?0 26 9-2 @:59-3? .58:@2:;9-2830.@0590//1@
>&
28:563? 2B25 9-:4A- 6:89:7 -0/ 621:/26 9-09 830.@059 -0/ /4;;2726 ! I 6./0>.3.9? 9: 9-2 E-:32 >:6? 642 9: 9-2 0@14909.:5 :; 7.A-9 3:E27 3.@> -2 -0/ 5:9 0 26 9-2 6./0>.3.9? 9: 9-2 1079.84307 3.@> >2;:72 0 .5A9-2E-:32>:6?-272;:727.>4503-0/7.A-93? 8:5/.62726 9-2 E-:32 >:6? 6./0>.3.9? 0/ "I ./ C4/9 056 720/:50>32
- 8 -
8& -.763? 8:5/.627.5A 9-2 .5C47.2/ /4/90.526 >? 9-2 830.@059 056 8:5/.627.5A 9-2 2B.62582 :; 6:89:7 0A2 056 0B:809.:5 :; 9-2 830.@059 9-2 8:@125/09.:5 0E07626 >? 9-2 7.>4503 45627 9-2 -206/ :; ,3:// :; 0@25.9.2/, ,10.5 056/4;;27.5A/,056:9-27.58.6259032H125/2/072C4/9056 720/:50>32
6& 0/93?9-2830.@059-0/2H0@.5269-26:89:70/ 056-2-0/621:/2672A076.5A9-28:/9:;079.;.8.0332A 7.>4503 -0/ C4/9.;.26 .5 A7059.5A / ;:7 05 079.;.8.03 32A ./ C4/9 056 720/:50>32 2582 -2 /:4A-9 ;:7 6./@.//03:;9-2011203
2076 9-2 3207526 8:45/23 ;:7 9-2 1079.2/ 056 1274/269-2C46A@2590560E076:;9-27.>4503
9 ./ 5:9 .5 6./1492 9-09 9-2 830.@059 -0/ /4/90.526.5C47.2/.59-27:06970;;.8088.6259:8847726:5 !+ 642 9: 70/- 056 52A3.A259 67.B.5A :; 9-2 807
- 9 -
>207.5A72A./9709.:5:"429:9-20>:B2 088.62599-2830.@059-0//4;;27269-2;:33:E.5A.5C47.2/
! -2 830.@059 830.@/ 9-09 -2 E0/ 2075.5A / 127 @:59- 2 -0/ 5:9 17:64826 05? 6:84@259/9:17:B2-./.58:@2-272;:72.59-20>/2582 :; 17::; :; .58:@2 5:9.:503 .58:@2 -0/ 9: >2 0 26 :5/.627.5A9-20A2:;9-2830.@059056-2E0/E:7F.5A0/ @28-05.8 9-2 7.>4503 -0/ C4/9.;.26 .5 8:5/.627.5A 9-09 @:59-3?.58:@2:;9-2830.@05909/1@
-2 830.@059 -0/ 2H0@.526 0/
707./-@479-? 79-:126.8
47A2:5 0.8-47 -0/ 621:/26 9-09 9-2 830.@059 -0/ /4;;2726 6./0>.3.9? :; ! I 9:9-2E-:32>:6?6429:0@14909.:5:;7.A-93:E273.@> :.5A 9-7:4A- 9-2 @26.803 728:76/ 056 2B.62582 :; 9-2 6:89:7 .9 ./ B27?
83207 9-09 7.A-9 3:E27 3.@> -0/ >225 0@1490926 0>:B2 F522 >23:E 9-2 -.1 :5/.627.5A 9-2
- 10 -
/8-26432 .5 @13:?22/ :@125/09.:5 89 /27.03 :;:7@14909.:5>23:E-.1E.9-/94@15:92H8226.5A @/ .5 325A9- @20/4726 ;7:@ 9.1 :; A7209 97258-05927./!I -272;:72 90F.5A .59: 8:5/.62709.:5 9-22B.62582:;9-26:89:7056@26.803728:76/E2072:;
9-2:1.5.:59-09E-:32>:6?6./0>.3.9?-0/9:>20 26 !I
-2 830.@059 ./ 0A26 0>:49 " ?207/ 09 9-2 9.@2:;9-2088.6259
5B.2E:;9-2C46A@259:;:5=>32 12H :479 .5 80/2 :;
"I:;9-2.58:@2:; 9-2 830.@059 -0/ 9: >2 8:5/.62726 ;49472 17:/1289/ -2 @439.13.27 0113.80>32 9: -./ 0A2 A7:41 ./ <!= -4/ 9-2 830.@059 ./ 259.9326 ;:7 8:@125/09.:5 :; /! :5088:459:;,3://:;;49472.58:@2,-0/>225720 26 0/;:33:E/
/+HH!H!K/! - 11 -
" 42 9: 9-2 088.62599-2 830.@059 -0/ /4;;2726 9-20>:B2/0.6.5C47.2/056E0/97209260/.5109.259;:70 127.:6:; 60?/.59-2-:/1.9032-0/9:/4;;27E.9-9-2 6./0>.3.9? /90926 >? 9-2 6:89:7 9-7:4A-:49 -./ 3.;2 :5/.627.5A9-22B.62582:;6:89:7056.5C47.2//4;;2726>? 9-2 830.@059 E2 .583.526 9: 25-0582 9-2 8:@125/09.:5 0E07626 >? 9-2 7.>4503 45627 9-2 -206 :; ,10.5 056 /4;;27.5A/,;7:@/ 9:/+056456279-2 -206:;,3://:;0@25.9.2/,;7:@/ 9:/
5 72/1289 :; 079.;.8.03 32A ./ 8:5827526 8:5/.627.5A9-092B.62582:;6:89:79-26./0>.3.9?/4;;2726 >?9-2830.@059./! I0569-272./050@14909.:5:77.A-9 3:E27 3.@> E2 072 :; 9-2 :1.5.:5 9-09 8:@125/09.:5 0E07626 >? 9-2 7.>4503 ;:7 079.;.8.03 32A -0/ 9: >2 25-05826;7:@/ 9:/
+ :5/.627.5A 9-2 509472 :; .5C47.2/ 9-2 8:@125/09.:50E07626>?9-27.>450345627:9-27-206/ ./C4/9056720/:50>32
- 12 -
-4/ 9-2 830.@059 ./ 259.9326 9: 9-2 ;:33:E.5A 8:@125/09.:5 :@125/09.:5 456276.;;27259 206/ /0E07626>? 9-27.>4503 $/& /0E07626>? 9-./:479 $/& 705/1:7909.:5 / / )::6099256059 D5:47./-@259 8-07A2 / / 26.8032H125/2/ / / 79.;.8.0332A / / 0.5056 /4;;27.5A / /+ ://:;0@25.9.2/ / / ://:;;49472 2075.5A/ /! /! *+, -../ - . ./ 01+023430* -5.5/
! 59-272/4399-2;:33:E.5A:7627./10//26
0& -2011203./
>& -2C46A@259:;9-230.@/7.>4503./@:6.;.26 8& -2 830.@059 ./ 259.9326 9: 0 9:903 8:@125/09.:5 :;
/ 0/ 0A0.5/9 /!!" 0E07626 >? 9-2 7.>4503 056 25-05826 8:@125/09.:5 :;
- 13 -
/""++03:5AE.9-.59272/9099-27092:;+I 1270554@ 6& -22/1:56259:
5/470582:@105?./6.728926 9:621:/.99-225-058268:@125/09.:50@:45903:5A E.9- .59272/9 ;7:@ 9-2 6092 :; ;.3.5A :; 9-2 830.@ 129.9.:59.339-26092:;7203.G09.:5E.9-.50127.:6:; /.HE22F/;7:@9-26092:;7282.19:;08:1?:;9-./ C46A@259 2& -2 011:79.:5@259 621:/.9 056 72320/2 :; 0@:459 /-033>2@062.5927@/:;9-20E076:;9-27.>4503
!6/ '#!( %
!6/ '"%& "( %
./9: 3:+