- 1 - ! " # $!%& $! ## '() *% ## '() ## % !" # $ % &&' ! $ & (! ")% Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - && (*( !) & !" # $ ( & + & % & & )$%& & & * !' , & & & - ## * % * ( '! )! " & .!" # $ % - 3 - &&' ! $ & (! ")% && (*( !) & !" # $ ) & % & & )$% & & & * !! , & & & - & / 0 / ( ( - 4 - ! $ / ( (% 1232 4552463 472 572827729 :; <12 =64>?4@<3 4334>6>@A <12 BC9A?2@< 4@9 4D479 94<29 543329 >@ E3!' , 4@9 !! , E@ <12 8>62 E8 <12 E<E7 ==>92@< 64>?3 7>:C@46.* >B4;45C74 $1272>@48<27 72827729 <E 43 F7>:C@46G 8E7 31E7<% 322H>@A 2@14@=2?2@<E8=E?52@34<>E@ 2479 <12 6247@29 =EC@326 455247>@A 8E7 <12 4552664@<3 =64>?4@<3 4@9 <12 6247@29 =EC@326 455247>@A 8E7<12@3C74@=2E?54@; ) E455246143:22@572827729:;<12@3C74@=2 E?54@; 2><127 E@ <12 A7EC@9 E8 6>4:>6><; E7 E@ <12 IC4@<C?E8=E?52@34<>E@:2>@A2J=233>K2 ' 1C3 C@9>35C<29 84=<3 72?4>@3 <14< <12 4==>92@< E==C7729 E@ D1>62 =64>?4@<3 D272 <74K26>@A87E?>B4;45C74<E2@A46C7C>@ C3:247>@A E(! ") 9C2 <E 7431 4@9 @2A6>A2@< 97>K>@A E8 - 5 - <1297>K27E8<12C3D1E6E3<1>3=E@<7E64@9=E66>929D><1 4 4@H27 :247>@A E) ) 87E? :21>@9 3 4 723C6< E8 <12 >?54=< <12 =64>?4@<3 3C3<4>@29 A7>2KEC3 >@BC7>23 ! 1C3 <12 E@6; 5E>@< <14< @ED 72?4>@3 8E7 =E@3>9274<>E@ :28E72 <1>3 EC7< >3 <14< D12<127 <12 =E?52@34<>E@4D47929:;<127>:C@46>3BC3<4@957E527 4@9D12<127><D4774@<32@14@=2?2@<43=64>?29:;<12 4552664@<3 =64>?4@<3 " 247@29 =EC@326 8E7 <12 4552664@<3 E<127 <14@ 3<4<>@A<14<<12=E?52@34<>E@4D47929C@927<12K47>EC3 12493 :2>@A ?24A27 57>?47>6; =E@<2@93 <14< ' <12 9E=<E7>33C29<129>34:>6><;=27<>8>=4<23?47H2943J 4@9 J) D1>=1 3<4<2 <14< :E<1 <12 =64>?4@<3 14K2 3C882729 527?4@2@< 9>34:>6><; <E <12 2J<2@< E8 'L >@ 72352=<E87>A1<4@9628<6ED276>?:ED2K27<127>:C@46 143277E@2EC36;=E@3>92729<12527?4@2@<9>34:>6><;<E<12 2J<2@<E8)L4@91269L9>34:>6><;<E<12D1E62:E9; - 6 - D1>62 4D479>@A =E?52@34<>E@ C@927 <12 1249 E8 F6E33 E8 247@>@A =454=><; E@ 4==EC@< E8 527?4@2@< 51;3>=46 9>34:>6><;G 4@9 <1C3 DEC69 =E@<2@9 <14< <12 =E?52@34<>E@ 477>K29:;<127>:C@46>3E@<126ED273>924@99E23@E< =E??2@3C74<2D><1<124=<C469>34:>6><;3C3<4>@29 6247@29 =EC@326 455247>@A 8E7 <12 @3C74@=2 E?54@; =E@<2@93 <14< <12 =E?52@34<>E@ 4D47929:;<127>:C@46>3BC3<4@957E5274@934?29E23 @E<D4774@<4@;>@<278272@=2 12 9E=<E7 143 43323329 <12 527?4@2@< 9>34:>6><;4<'L>@7264<>E@<E<127>A1<4@9628<6ED276>?: 43>32K>92@<87E?J34@9)4K>@A72A479<E<12 @4<C72 E8 >@BC7>23 3C882729 :; <12 =64>?4@<3 <12 D1E62 :E9; 527?4@2@< 9>34:>6><; =4@ :2 43323329 4< !L 43 4A4>@3<L431269:;<127>:C@46 , 12 4D479 E8 =E?52@34<>E@ C@927 <12 1249 E8 54>@ 4@9 3C8827>@A 4<<2@94@< 4@9 =E@K2;4@=2 =147A23 6E33E84?2@><>236E33E8>@=E?29C7>@A64>9527>E9:;<12 - 7 - 7>:C@46>3463EE@<126ED273>923<12=64>?4@<39>9@E< 57E9C=2 4@; ?4<27>46 <E 31ED <12 4=<C46 >@=E?2 <12 7>:C@461437>A1<6;<4H2@@E<>E@46>@=E?2E8 3! 527?E@<143527AC>926>@23>33C29:;<12(47@4<4H4 <4<2 2A46 27K>=23C<1E7><;8E7<124==>92@<<14<E==C7729E@ @ 72433233>@A <12 =E?52@34<>E@ <12 =E?52@34<>E@ <E :2 4D47929 >@ :E<1 <12 4552463 D><1 728272@=2 <E <12 =E?52@34<>E@ 4D47929 :; <12 7>:C@46 47243C@927 &E" $E!' ,% 6 E 2493 D479:;<12 7>:C@46 D47929:;<12 >A1EC7< E33E88C<C72247@>@A ;7>:C@46 $!JJJL% ;>A1EC7< $!JJJ!L% 3!) 3) 4>@4@93C8827>@A 3) 3' ) 29>=462J52@323 3))') 3))') ' &C<C72 ?29>=46 2J52@32 3' 3' ! <<2@94@< 8EE9 4@9 @EC7>31?2@< 3! 3 " E33E84?2@><>23 3 3) - 8 - &E! $E!! ,% 477>4A257E5E346 3 3 <<2@94@< 4@9 =E@K2;4@=2=147A23 3)! , E33E8>@=E?29C7>@A 64>9C5527>E9 3)! 3)!! E<46 3!,') 3,) +,-.- /"0"* /1"10"* @14@=29 =E?52@34<>E@ /""* 6 E 2493 D479:;<12 7>:C@46 D47929:;<12 >A1EC7< E33E88C<C72247@>@A ;7>:C@46 $!JJ'JL% ;>A1EC7< $!JJ'J!L% 3,' 3," 4>@4@93C8827>@A 3) 3' ) 29>=462J52@323 3))) 3))) ' &C<C72 ?29>=46 2J52@32 3' 3' ! <<2@94@< 8EE9 4@9 @EC7>31?2@< 3! 3 " E33E84?2@><>23 3 3) <<2@94@< 4@9 =E@K2;4@=2=147A23 3)! E33E8>@=E?29C7>@A 64>9C5527>E9 3)! 3)!! E<46 3'),) 3!," +,-.- /2"2"* /"0"1* @14@=29 =E?52@34<>E@ /""1* - 9 - 12 =64>?4@< >@ & E" >3 2@<><629 8E7 <E<46 =E?52@34<>E@ E8 3,! 43 4A4>@3< 3!,! 4D47929 :; <12 7>:C@46 4@9 2@14@=29 =E?52@34<>E@E8 3 12 =64>?4@< >@ & E! >3 2@<><629 8E7 <E<46 =E?52@34<>E@ E8 3!, 43 4A4>@3< 3'' 4D47929 :; <12 7>:C@46 4@9 2@14@=29 =E?52@34<>E@E8 3! ==E79>@A6;D25433<128E66ED>@A > E<1<124552463472 >> 12 4552664@< =64>?4@< >@ & E" $ E!' ,% >3 2@<><629 8E7 4 <E<46 =E?52@34<>E@ E8 3,! 43 4A4>@3< 3!,! 4D47929:;<127>:C@46D><1>@<2723<4<"L 527 4@@C? 87E? <12 94<2 E8 52<><>E@ <>66 7246>M4<>E@ - 10 - >>> 12 4552664@< =64>?4@< >@ & E! $ E!! ,% >3 2@<><629 8E7 4 <E<46 =E?52@34<>E@ E8 3!, 43 4A4>@3< 3'' 4D47929:;<127>:C@46D><1>@<2723<4<"L 527 4@@C? 87E? <12 94<2 E8 52<><>E@ <>66 7246>M4<>E@ >K 12 2@14@=29 =E?52@34<>E@ 31466 :2 925E3><29 :; @9 7235E@92@< . @3C74@=2 =E?54@; D><1>@ <DE ?E@<13 84>6>@A D1>=1 <12 4?EC@< 31466 =477; 9284C6< >@<2723< 4< ,L5274@@C? K 12925E3><4@97262432DEC69:243527<12 E7927E8<127>:C@46 -* '%&) ! -* ') ! >3<E 6E