Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 65631 (KAR)
MADHAV CONTRACTOR v. THE JOINT COMMISSIONER (APPEALS)
WP/203321/2025 · 2025-11-04
M G S Kamal
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 65631 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 65631 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!" #$%
&%'!%!%
(!)
!
"
#
$
!
% #
$
&#
$ '(! ) !
*
& &
Digitally signed by KHAJAAMEEN MALAGHAN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
!
* !
"
# $
+
**, **(
#$
! (#$
* !(
!)#!$#-$ *
!) . $ +
/
* ,* *
*) *!))(, !
&
/
* * * 0*) * *+ &
+
% . $
+
1%
#
1% $
23434'52647829'623:47';638245-<--642=2>8?3:2 '6>26 '9 @<5@2AA<34'5 '9 62-4736<34'5 45 '6B !)
- 3 -
><32> * * * '5 3:2 C62B472 '9 3:2 C23434'526 5'3 627C'5>45-3'3:27:'D@<;725'34@2
*
:2 C23434'526 :<> <CC<6253A? C6292662> <5 <CC2<A 829'62 3:2 627C'5>253 '* D:4@: :<7 <A7' 8225 62E2@32> '5 3:2 C62B472 '9 7<B2 8245- 8<662> 8? 34B2 245- <--642=2> C23434'526 47 829'62 3:47 ';63 722F45- 9'AA'D45-62A4297
!"#
# $
%& '
%()
" * +
, &
-.- (
"
&
- / %' (%%.' "#
# 0
12! &
"#
, #
"# '
-- '
"
&
3- 4 % '' 5'6 0
1 &
" # +
7 )
8
-9
2<652> @';572A 9'6 3:2 C23434'526 >6<D45- <332534'5 '9 3:47 ';63 3' 3:2 '6>26 '9 3:2 ''6>45<32
- 4 -
25@: '9 3:47 ';63 ><32> * * * C<772> 45 +
'*!(** * ;5>26 4>2534@<A 9<@37 743;<34'5 '9 3:2 B<33267;8B4373:<3745@23:2C23434'52647743;<32>74B4A<6 3' 3:<3 '9 3:2 C23434'526 45 3:2 7<4> D643 C23434'5 '5 3:2 C645@4CA2'9C<643?C627253C23434'582<AA'D2>'53:2A4527 '93:2'6>26C<772>3:26245
2<652> @';572A <CC2<645- 9'6 627C'5>2537 3:6';-:=4>2'@'592625@45->'275'3>47C;323:2<9'627<4> 9<@3;<A<5>A2-<A<7C2@37'93:2B<3326
2<6>
26;72>3:262@'6>7 ,
:2 ''6>45<32 25@: '9 3:47 ';63 ;5>26 4>2534@<A 9<@37 743;<34'5 '9 3:2 B<3326 :<> G;<7:2> 3:2 '6>26 '9 @<5@2AA<34'5 '9 62-4736<34'5 <7 D2AA <7 3:2 '6>26 C<772> 8? 3:2 <CC2AA<32 <;3:'643? <5> :<> >462@32> 3:2 <;3:'643427 3' 624573<32 3:2 62-4736<34'5 '9 3:2 C23434'526 3:26245 :2 C23434'526 45 3:2 4573<53 @<72 74B4A<6A? 743;<32> 45 3:2 @'574>262> =42D '9 3:47 ';63 47 <A7'25343A2>9'674B4A<662A429 ( 53:<3=42D'93:2B<33263:29'AA'D45-
- 5 -
#4$
:2D643C23434'547
#44$
:2 4BC;-52> '6>26 <3 552H;62 ><32> * ,* *C<772>8?627C'5>253 '!<5> 4BC;-52> '6>26 <3 552H;62 ><32> * * *C<772>8?627C'5>253 '<62 G;<7:2>
#444$ :2627C'5>2537<;3:'643427<62>462@32>3' 624573<326273'623:2 62-4736<34'5'93:2 C23434'526 D43:45 9';6 D22F7 96'B 3:2 ><32 '9 62@24C3 '9 @2634942> @'C? '9 3:47 '6>26 7;8E2@33'C23434'52694A45- 623;657<5> C<?45- ;C 3' ><32 3<H D43:45 3:2 <9'627<4> C264'> '9 9';6 D22F7 96'B 3'><? 3'-23:26 D43:4532627349<5?
!*+ (%!%) '
+ 473 '!A '*