- 1 - !" # $ % %% &%' ( ! " ! ! # $ % & $ % "" Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - " ! $ & % ' ' ! # $ ()% "( ( * $+% %( "! ( ( & % " !!! ( & "! , ( " ( ( ( !!- !! !!- " " (& ( & " '!! " ( ." ( & "/ ( 0 "0 1"& - 3 - "$ 2324"256744897:;5:!25<247=8>8295++?7 =25@25584 :A=7A 29 :!!- =8+7= !! 85 2+ B85=25@2557=<:A=7<8;4+ ?7 8CC74489+ :5 89= 8A7 =8;>?+7A5 :< 8CC74489+ : 89= +?7D 8A7 +?7 47>84 A7CA7579+8+2375 :< ?238A;=A8CC875C:9=79+:589=8A7+?7=8;>?+7A5:< ;9=842E8CC8 89= 25+7A5 :< ?238A;=A8CC8 ;9=842E8CC8 ?85+B:5:9589=+B:=8;>?+7A5CC74489+:25+?7B2<7 :< ?238A;=A8CC8 27 D:;9>7A 5:9 :< ;9=842E8CC8 ?7 8CC74489+5 ?837 5+8+7= +?8+ +?7D ?837 A767237= 5 ''<A:@+?7:37A9@79++:B8A=557A3267F797<2+5 :<?238A;=8CC8B?:B85B:AE29>85"898>7A297+7A298AD 6:447>7 89= =27= :9 ! 89= 5:;>?+ <:A 255;8967 :< ;667552:9 7A+2<268+7 29 A75C76+ :< +?7 58@7 75C:9=79+ :589=8=@2++7=+?72AA748+2:95?2CF;+5+8+7=+?8++?72A <8+?7A ?85 9:+ A767237= 57A3267 F797<2+5 :< ?238A;=A8CC8 89=:;A+=762=7=+?8+844:<+?7@8A779+2+47+:A=5?8A7 29 5 '' 29 +?7 &;=>@79+ =8+7= !!- - 4 - >>A2737= FD +?7 582= &;=>@79+ +?7 8CC74489+5 ?7A729 CA7<7AA7=8CC78429:!!-F;+2+B85=25@2557=<:A =7<8;4+:9!!?7DA7G;75+7=+:A75+:A7+?758@7 89=6:9+79=7=+?8++?7&;=>@79+:<+?7+A284:;A+259:+:9 CA:C7A 8CCA7628+2:9 :< <86+5 ?7 6:;9574 79>8>7= FD +?7@ 7HC2A7=9A7672C+:<9:+267+?7D79>8>7=89:+?7A6:;9574 F;+=;7+:486E:<6:@@;9268+2:9+?7D=2=9:+8CC78AF7<:A7 +?7 :;A+ 89= 2+ B85 =25@2557= <:A =7<8;4+ :9 !! ?79 +?7D 68@7 +: E9:B 8F:;+ +?7 582= :A=7A +?7D 8CCA:86?7=+?7:;A+<:AA75+:A8+2:9?78CC74489+:258 B2=:B 89= 5?7 25 @829+82929> +?7 79+2A7 <8@24D ?7 84:9> B2+? ?7A 6?24=A79 8A7 79+2+47= <:A 57A3267 F797<2+5 :< ?7A ?;5F89= +?;5 A7G;75+7= +?25 :;A+ +: 57+ 852=7 +?7 :A=7A =8+7=!!! 78A= +?7 8A>;@79+5 :< F:+? 52=75 89= C7A;57= +?7A76:A=5 5+8+7= F7<:A7 +?7 +A284 :;A+ +?8+ ?7A 6:;9574:9A76:A=7HC2A7=89=+?7&;92:A6:;9574=2=9:+4::E 29+:+?76857855;6?2+B85=25@2557=:9!!?7 - 5 - 258:37A9@79+@C4:D7789=5?7B85F;5DB2+?+?7B:AE 89= 5?7 6:;4= 9:+ 6:9+86+ +?7 &;92:A :;9574 8+7A 5?7 :F+8297=67A+2<27=6:CD:<+?7:A=7A5?77+=8+7=!! 89=@8AE7=2+85H?7+A284:;A+:F57A37=+?8+5?7 A767237= :;A+ 9:+267 89= @7+ +?7 &;92:A 6:;9574 ?7 ?85 5+8+7=+?8+5?7?85=:9789==89=5?725B:AE29> 85 89= ?7A =8;>?+7A5 8A7 9>2977A5 <+7A A7672329> +?7:;A+9:+267<:;AD78A5+2@7B85>A89+7=F;++?7D=2= 9:+ 8CC78A 89= 6:9+75+ +?7 @8++7A 89= 866:A=29>4D 2+ B85 =25@2557= ):! 25<247=FD+?78CC74489+5?7A729 <:A255;8967:<+?7;667552:97A+2<268+7A7>8A=29>+?7<2H7= =7C:52+55+89=29>29+?798@7:<;9=842E8CC889=?25B2<7 ?7:;A+292+5&;=>@79+=8+7=!!-6:952=7A29>+?7 79+2A7732=7967:9A76:A=:A=7A7=<:A255;8967:<;667552:9 7A+2<268+7 F;+ 5+8+7= +?8+ +?7 C7+2+2:97A :5 +: 8CC74489+5 ?7A729 8A7 79+2+47= <:A A= 5?8A7 29 +?7 <2H7= =7C:52+55+89=29>29+?798@7:<;9=842E8CC8+:897H+79+ :<5 !89=A75C:9=79+:589=8A779+2+47=<:A - 6 - A=5?8A7786?>>A2737=FD+?7582=:A=7A+?7DCA7<7AA7= 8CC784;+=;A29>+?7C79=796D:<+?78CC78485+?7D6:;4= 9:+C;A5;7+?78CC784+?758@7B85=25@2557=<:A=7<8;4+ ?7 8CC784 B85 <247= 29 +?7 D78A !- F;+ +?7D E7C+ G;2+7 B2+?:;+ @8E29> CA:C7A A7CA7579+8+2:9 +244 !! 85 5;6?8<+7A>2329>=;7:CC:A+;92+D2+B85=25@2557=>8295+ +?758@7+?7DCA7<7AA7=2324"256744897:;5:!89= 2+B85=25@2557=:9!!!>8295++?7582=:A=7A+?25 8CC784 25 <247= ?7 8CC74489+5 ?7A729 ?837 <247= :!-8>8295++?7:A=7A:<+?7+A284:;A+29) :! =8+7=!!-F;++?7D?8379:+C;A5;7=+?7 42+2>8+2:9B2+?=;7=242>7967<+7A+?7=78+?:<+?72A6:;9574 +?7D A767237= :;A+ 9:+267 89= +?7D 845: @7+ +?7 &;92:A 6:;9574 ?7 :;A+ >A89+7= 5;<<26279+ :CC:A+;92+D :< <:;A D78A5 89= A2>?+4D =25@2557= +?7 8CC4268+2:9 :9 !! 89= +?7D <247= A75+:A8+2:9 + B85 845: =25@2557= :9 !!! - 7 - ' D6:952=7A29>844+?785C76+5+?25:;A+<29=5+?8+ +?7A78A79:@7A2+529+?78CC78489=+?78CC78425=73:2=:< @7A2+589=25 )*+ &% ' $ 25+:04:0