Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 65619 (KAR)

SAGAR S/O GORAKH KADAM v. KHATALSAB AND ANR

MFA/202277/2018 · 2025-10-16

H T Narendra Prasad, Tyagaraja N Inavally

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - ! " #! $ %!#! $ %!"%& " ! !## '&( ) ! " # " $ " % &% " """ % Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ' " " " "( (" ! " # " " " )" $ " (" ( " * #$ ( " " ) " (" " ) (" " " " " " ' %' " ( " ") " + " " + " " - 3 - % # + " " $ ",-. /001/2 34516 178-94 *#$ 9: 9896 1,-721. 78 ; #,161-4/:816 61:16615 89 /. <8,1 78=$ ,/. >114 :-215 >? 8,1 72/-@/48 >1-4A /AA6-1B15 >? 8,1 C35A@148 5/815 ' 0/..15 >? 55-8-94/2 14-96 -B-2 35A1/45"8-C/?/036/-49%' ' (/78. A-B-4A 6-.1 89 8,1 :-2-4A 9: 8,1 /001/2 >6-1:2?.8/815/618,/894 ' /8/>938 41/6/D/6./21.-@-815961A/94-22/A1018-8-9416D/. 56-B-4A ,-. 98967?721 >1/6-4A 1A9 E; A9-4A 89D/65. 961A/94 .-51 /45 -8 D/. 56-B14 -4 .29D /45 7/38-93. @/4416 /8 8,/8 8-@1 / "637F >1/6-4A 1A9 * 7/@1 :69@ -C/?/036 .-51 -4 ,-A, .0115/45-46/.,/4541A2-A148@/44168,156-B16>1-4A 34/>21897948692-87/@194D694A.-51/455/.,158,1 ./-5@98967?721./61.3289:8,1/:961./-5/77-51488,1 72/-@/48.3.8/-415A6-1B93.-4C36-1./45D/.,9.0-8/2-G15 - 4 - ",172/-@/48:-215/018-8-9434516178-94 9:8,178.11F-4A79@014./8-948D/.021/5158,/8,1 .0148 ,3A1 /@9348 89D/65. @15-7/2 861/8@148 8 D/. :368,16 021/515 8,/8 8,1 /77-5148 97736615 03612? 94 /7793489:8,16/.,/4541A2-A14856-B-4A9:8,19::145-4A B1,-721>?-8.56-B16 % 4 .16B-71 9: 498-71 8,1 61.0945148 9' /001/615 8,693A, 7934.12 /45 :-215 D6-8814 .8/81@148 514?-4A8,1/B16@148.@/51-48,172/-@018-8-94 ",161.094514895-5498/001/6>1:9618,1 "6->34/2 -4 .0-81 9: .16B-71 9: 498-71 /45 D/. 02/715 1H 0/681 48,1>/.-.9:8,1021/5-4A.9:8,10/68-1.8,1 2/-@."6->34/2:6/@158,1-..31./458,161/:81661796515 8,11B-51471",172/-@/48,-@.12:D/.1H/@-415/.) /45 941 D-841.. -. 1H/@-415 /. )' /45 A98 1H,->-815 5973@148. 4/@12? H 89 H% 4 >1,/2: 9: 8,1 61.0945148 9' ,/. A98 /553715 8,1 1B-51471 9: - 5 - ..-.8/48 9: 8,1-6 79@0/4? /. ) /45 A98 1H,->-815 5973@148.4/@12? H89 H%",12/-@."6->34/2 >? 8,1 -@03A415 C35A@148 -4816 /2-/ ,125 8,/8 8,1 /77-5148 899F 02/71 94 /779348 9: 6/., /45 41A2-A148 56-B-4A9:8,19::145-4AB1,-721>?-8.56-B16/./61.3289: D,-7, 8,1 72/-@/48 .3.8/-415 -4C36-1. ",1 "6->34/2 :368,16,1258,/88,172/-@/48-.148-821589/79@014./8-94 9:. /294AD-8,-48161.8/88,16/819:;I0/ /45 5-617815 8,1 61.0945148. 9 /45 ' C9-482? /45 .1B16/22? 2-/>21 89 0/? 79@014./8-94 /@9348 /294A D-8, -48161.8 1-4A /AA6-1B15 8,1 061.148 /001/2 ,/. >114 :-215 * B14 8,93A, 8,1 72/-@/48 72/-@. 8,/8 ,1 D/. 59-4A /A6-7328361 D96F /45 1/64-4A . 016 @948,>388,1"6->34/2,/.A6/4815A29>/279@014./8-94 9: .% D-8, #J$ 15-7/2 -22. 89 8,1 6341 9: .% ' 1/64157934.12:968,172/-@/48,/.794814515 8,/8 531 89 /77-5148 8,1 72/-@/48 ,/. .3::1615 A6-1B93. - 6 - -4C36? ,-. 6-A,8 21A D/. /@038/815 /45 ,1 D/. -40/8-148 :96 / 016-95 9: @948,. 1 ,/. .3::1615 298 9: 0/-4 536-4A 8,1 861/8@148 1 ,/. .3::1615 5-./>-2-8? /45 34,/00-41..8,693A,938,-.2-:1",186->34/2,/.A6/4815 /A29>/279@014./8-949:. -.29D16.-51 ; 16 9486/ 21/6415 7934.12 /001/6-4A :96 -4.36/47179@0/4-1.,/.7948145158,/81H7108018-8-9416 .8/8-4A 8,/8 ,-. 6-A,8 21A ,/. /@038/815 1 ,/. 498 1H/@-4158,1597896/45495-./>-2-8?7168-:-7/81,/.>114 0695371 /45 8,1 861/815 597896 ,/. 498 >114 1H/@-415 ",161:961 "6->34/2 ,/. 6-A,82? 498 A6/4815 /4? 79@014./8-94345168,1,1/59:0/-4/45.3::16-4A29..9: /@14-8-1.94.-516-4A8,15973@148./B/-2/>2194617965 ,/.A6/481579@014./8-949:. 1/65 8,1 21/6415 7934.12 :96 8,1 0/68-1. /45 0163.158,1C35A@148/45/D/659:8,1"6->34/2 8 -. 498 -4 5-.0381 72/-@/48 9: .3::1615 /4 -4C36? -4 / 69/5 86/::-7 /77-5148 94 ' ' 31 89 - 7 - 6/., /45 41A2-A148 56-B-4A 9: 56-B16 9: "637F >1/6-4A 1A * 31898,/8/77-514872/-@/486-A,821A D/. /@038/815 /45 ,1 D/. -40/8-148 :96 / 016-95 9: @948,. 1 -. 498 1H/@-415 8,1 861/815 597896 ",1 -B-.-94 147, 9: 8,-. 9368 -4 8,1 7/.1 9: !" # $ %& B14 8,1 0/68-1. /61 498 1H/@-41 8,1 597896. 8,1 "6->34/2 ,/. / 09D16 89 .3@@94 8,1 861/815 597896 /45 1H/@-41 :96 /..1..-4A :/-6 79@014./8-94 ",1 6121B/48 0/6/A6/0, 9. /45 ; 9: 8,1 C35A@148 9: K>/2/,/@15 7/.1 61/5. 8,3. L ",-. 7/.1 -. / 72/..-7 1H/@021 9: 8,1 2/7F/5/-.-7/2 016:96@/471 9: @/4? "6->34/2. 51/2-4A D-8, @9896 /77-5148 72/-@. D,-21 5-.7,/6A-4A 8,1-6 C35-7-/2 538? 101/8152? -8 ,/. 79@1 89 8,1 498-71 9: 8,-. 9368 8,/8 -4 2/6A1 43@>169:72/-@018-8-94.8,172/-@/48./6134/>21 8906953711-8,168,1861/8-4A 97896968,1 97896 D,9 ,/. -..315 8,1 5-./>-2-8? 168-:-7/81 /. / D-841.. ",1 72/-@/48. @/? >1 061B14815 :69@ 069537-4A .37, D-841.. 1-8,16 >17/3.1 9: 8,1-6 09B168? -A496/471 -22-816/7? 96 >17/3.1 .37, - 8 - D-841..>1-4A 97896./61-4B/6-/>2?899>3.? 89 /001/6 >1:961 8,1 "6->34/2. 38 -4 8,1.1 7-673@.8/471.D,-7,/61>1?9458,179486929:8,1 72/-@/48-4B/6-/>2?-8-.8,172/-@/48D,9.3::16. :9649:/3289:,-.96,1694.-516-4A8,1:/788,/8 8,1861/8-4A 97896/458,1 97896D,9,/.-..315 8,1 -./>-2-8?168-:-7/81/61@/816-/2D-841..1.-4/ 72/-@018-8-94-8-.1..148-/28,/88,1-6061.1471>1 14.3615>?8,161.-5-4A::-716.9:8,1"6->34/2>? -4B9F-4A 8,1 09D16 34516 178-94 9: 8,1 B-5147178 ; 4 8,1 7/.1 9: #.306/$ 8,1 94=>213061@19368,/.61@-45158,161.-5-4A ::-716. 9: 8,1 "6->34/2. 51/2-4A D-8, 72/-@ 018-8-94. 8,/8 8,1? .,9325 :3478-94 41-8,16 /. / 41386/23@0-61496/./.-2148.0178/8964:/78/ 069/78-B169214115.89>102/?15>?8,161.-5-4A ::-716. 9: 8,1 "6->34/2. -471 8,1 "6->34/2 ,/. /@021 09D16. 34516 178-94 9: 8,1 B-51471 78 89 .3@@94 / 9368 D-841.. 8,1 1/6415 "6->34/2./611H017815891H167-.1.37,09D16.-4 :/B936 9: 8,1 72/-@/48. ",1 61.-5-4A ::-716. 7/4498.,?/D/?:69@1H167-.-4A8,1./-509D1694 8,1:2-@.?A693458,/8-47/.1.37,/09D16D161 89 >1 1H167-.15 8,1 1/6415 1@>16. 9: 8,1 /6 A18 /A-8/815 98, 8,1 1/6415 1@>16. 9: 8,1 /6 /45 8,1 61.-5-4A ::-716. @3.8 61/2-G1 8,/8 8,1 538? 9: 8,1 /6 /45 8,1 147, -. 498 942? 89 - 9 - 5-.79B16 8638, >38 -. /2.9 89 59 C3.8-71 89 8,1 0/68-1. : 8,1 61.-5-4A::-716. D161 89 7/22 /4? 016.94 /. 9368 D-841..1. 8,1 61.-5-4A ::-716. /61@1612?/5908-4A/@1/4.895-.79B168,18638, ?49.86187,9:-@/A-4/8-94-87/4>1./-58,/8>? 7/22-4A / 9368 D-841.. 8,1 61.-5-4A ::-716 -. 61B1/2-4A ,-. 0/68-/2-8? -4 :/B936 9: 8,1 72/-@/48 ",161:96149B/2-5 9>C178-947/4>18/F14>? 8,1 1/6415 1@>16. 9: 8,1 /6 D,14 8,1 09D16 B1.815-48,161.-5-4A::-71634516178-949: 8,1 B-51471 78 -. -4B9F15 -4 :/B936 9: 8,1 72/-@/48M ' 4B-1D9:8,1/>9B18,1@/881661K3-6189>1 61@-8>/7F898,1"6->34/289A-B1/490096834-8?89,-@ /68?891H/@-418,1861/815597896 1471D10697115 89:9229D-4A /$ ",1/001/2-.*+,-./+..012 >$ ",1 C35A@148 5/815 ' 0/..15 >? 55-8-94/2 14-96 -B-2 35A1 /45 " -C/?/036/ -4 9 %' -..18/.-51 - 10 - 7$ ",1 @/8816 -. 61@-8815 >/7F 89 8,1 "6->34/2 89 794.-516 8,1 @/8816 /:61., 61.16B-4A 2->168? 89 1H/@-41 8,1 861/815 597896 -: 8,1 861/815 597896 D/. 498 /B/-2/>218,172/-@/48.7/4/2.91H/@-41 /4?98,1659789689069B1,-.7/.1 5$ /68-1. /61 5-617815 89 >1 /001/6 >1:961 8,1 "6->34/2 94 '' ' D-8,938 /4? 498-71.-4718,1/77-51489:8,1?1/6' 1$ ",1"6->34/2-.5-617815895-.09.19:8,1 72/-@018-8-94D-8,-4.-H@948,.:69@8,1 5/819:/001/6/4719:8,10/68-1. !23 '#!( % !23 '"%& "( % -.8929%% "