- 1 - !"! #$"% $ & !"# $!!! ! % & $ '# $!!! % & # $!!! ( % & ) Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - *)) $" ! ! ' !$ ( %)+ )!& ) ! ) %& ' ) " !$! ,-! !$! ) )) ,. ! $, / $- , ) )#$!$!) %& / ) $! * )) ) * %* & 0123 24 154 1647 7012803 9:;8<07 =:2 6>0 ?06464:802<241@1312>1>1A;334870128034B>:;26 - 3 - :5028@086701302=:220<?:83086:183241C1 70128039:;8<07=:220<?:83086:! ! 06464:8;83020964:8!:=!$!D46> 6>0=:77:D48B?21E02 !" # !$%&' ((' ! ) " # (! * + , ( + ** & - ./.01).23 4+ 5 67+ ' 8 9 )196< 48 8;6<>077 D>49> 120 ;6@:<6 8090<<12E =:234<?:<17:=6>0?20<086?06464:81201<;8302 0<?:83086 :! >02048 =4703 1 9:@?71486 D46> 171A;21B4 :@08 :7490 6164:8 :8 $!$! D>49> D1< 20B4<60203 48 24@0 :" !$! =:2 6>0 :==0890< - 4 - ?;84<>1A70 ;8302 0964:8< ,. ! $, 183 $- 2013 D46>0964:8,:=834180817:30 ! 4<6 := 6>0 9:@?71486 1502@086< D:;73 205017 6>1620<?:83086:!B:6@1224036::80248451<18@17 :8 $!$! 16 >181<>200 54771B0 1=602 @00648B 6>0 30@183< @130 AE 6>0 =1@47E := 248451< 18@17 >0201=60220<?:83086:!F:48036>0@1624@:8417>:@0 183<>0<61260320<4348BD46>>;<A183183?12086< 48 71D ):2 1A:;6 :80 @:86> 6>0 @124617 74=0 D1< >1??E 183 6>0201=602>02>;<A183;<036:?49C;?G;12207:8=74@<E 6>48B< ;8302 6>0 48=7;0890 := 74G;:2 183 ;<03 6: 1A;<0 20<?:83086:!48=476>E718B;1B0 64<1770B036>16?20<086?06464:802<17<:F:4803 6>0>;<A183481A;<48B6>09:@?7148186 20<?:83086:! 489020<?:83086:!D1<;81A706:A0126>06:26;20<>0 4864@16036>0<1@06:>02?12086<02?12086<17:8BD46> 07302< 54<4603 6>0 @1624@:8417 >:@0 := 20<?:83086 :! 183>073?189>1E16>0E20G;0<6036>0=1@47E@0@A02< - 5 - := >;<A183 := 20<?:83086 :! 6: 7::C 1=602 >02 48 1 ?2:?02@18802 , 0<?460 <;9> 20G;0<6 :8 !$!$! 16 1A:;6 $$$ 1@ >02 >;<A183 183 @:6>02 48 71D ?49C03 ;? G;12207183=:294A7E?;<>0320<?:83086:!:;6=2:@6>0 @1624@:8417>:@01836>020=:20<>0<:;B>6=:21964:8 ;24<34964:817 ?:7490 1=602 20B4<60248B 6>0 91<0 6>:2:;B>7E4850<64B16036>0@16602183=47039>12B0<>006 , ;248B 6>0 9:;2<0 := 12B;@086< 7012803 9:;8<07 =:2 6>0 ?06464:802< =470< 1 @0@: 0H?20<<48B >4< 30<4206:B066>0?06464:834<@4<<034820<?096:=?06464:802 : 199;<03 :! D>: 4< 6>0 @:6>02 48 71D := 20<?:83086 :! >020=:20 ?20<086 ?06464:8 4< 8:D 20<62496036:?06464:802:<!183D>:120<4<602< 48 71D :=20<?:83086:! 012803 9:;8<07 =:2 6>0 ?06464:802< D:;73 9:860836>16?06464:802:!4<6>020<43086:=:?181?1774 - 6 - #1421A13617;C118B12033E34<62496183?06464:802:4< 6>0 20<43086 := >181<>200 54771B0 #1>421A13 617;C1 18B12033E 34<62496 183 6>020=:20 6>0E 343 8:6 ?126494?186<486>01770B03924@0183<:;B>6=:234<@4<<17 :=6>04@?;B803924@481791<01<1B148<66>0@ - 7012803 4B> :;26 :5028@086 701302 =:2 20<?:83086 : 183 7012803 9:;8<07 =:2 20<?:83086 :! D:;73 9:86083 6>16 6>0 9:@?71486 1502@086< 46<07= <>:D< 6>16 ?06464:802 :<! 183 >150 17<: F:4803 6>0 >;<A183 := 20<?:83086 :! 48 >121<<48B 6>09:@?7148186 20<?:83086:!183<:;B>6=:234<@4<<17 :=6>0?06464:8 " 1548B>01236>012B;@086<:=A:6><430<6>4< :;26?02;<036>0@1602417:8209:23@0649;7:;<7E 8<;9>?02;<17:=6>0@1602417:8209:23464< 92E<617 97012 6>16 ?06464:802 :<! 183 120 20<4348B <0?121607E1836>0E3438:6<>1206>09:@@:82::= - 7 - . H90?6 :@84A;< 183 B080217 1770B164:8< 8: <?094=49 :5026 196< D020 <?076 :;6 48<:=12 1< ?06464:802 :<!1831209:8902803486>09:@?7148646<07= $ 1C48B8:60:=6>0=1966>16?06464:802:<!183 120 @122403 <4<602< := 6>0 >;<A183 := 20<?:83086:! 183 120 20<4348B <0?121607E =:77:D48B 6>0 3496;@ := 6>0 :8IA70?0H:;26486>091<0:= 20?:2603 48 6>4< :;26 4< := 6>0 9:8<430203 :?484:8 6>16 ?08348B 924@4817 ?2:900348B< 1< 1B148<6 ?06464:802 :<! 1838003<6:A0G;1<>03 0890=:77:D48B:23024<?1<<03 1& 24@4817?06464:84<177:D0348?126 A& 71948B6>0@0@:=4703AE70128039:;8<07 =:2 6>0 ?06464:802< ?06464:8 1< 1B148<6 ?06464:802 : D>: 4< 199;<03 :! <6183<34<@4<<031<8:6?20<<03 - 8 - 9& 24@4817 ?06464:8 4< 177:D03 48 20<?096 := ?06464:802 :<! 183 D>: 120 199;<03 :< 183 , :8<0G;0867E ?08348B 924@4817 ?2:900348B< 48 :,-! !$! :8 6>0 =470 := 33464:817 4547 ;3B0 %28&183)171A;21B44820<?096:= ?06464:802:<!183<6183<G;1<>03 3& 6 4< @130 97012 6>16 6>4< :;26 >1< 8:6 0H?20<<03 18E :?484:8 :8 @0246< := 6>0 @16602 '( )%* " 4<6:7:!!